Hagi- The Life of Yoshida Shoin - Japanology Plus

Japanese Culture
97 followers
2 Video Views·Apr 10, 2026
Looking back at the life of influential samurai and scholar Yoshida Shoin in his hometown of Hagi.
In 1868, the 16-year-old Emperor Meiji ascended the Japanese throne.
Western nations were shocked by the sudden opening of this previously isolated island
nation and its exceptionally young government.
With the sweeping reforms known as the Meiji Restoration, Japan began a rapid transformation
into a modern world power.
One of the men who planted the seeds of this major reform movement was Yoshida Shoin.
As an intellectual, Shoin helped lay the spiritual foundations for Japan's modernization.
During his short life of 29 years, he deeply influenced major figures of the Meiji Restoration,
including Japan's first Prime Minister, Ito Hirobumi.
His existence also became known abroad after the Scottish writer Robert Louis Stevenson,
known for his novel Treasure Island, was moved by Shoin's life and wrote a biography about him.
Yoshida Shoin was born in Hagi, Yamaguchi Prefecture.
With a landscape shaped by volcanic activity, Hagi is blessed with fertile soil and bountiful sea.
Much of its townscape has remained untouched since the 19th century.
The teachings of Yoshida Shoin, who set up a private school here, influenced many individuals.
The efforts of those who carried on his ideals toward modernization are now commemorated
as a series of five industrial heritage sites on UNESCO's World Heritage List.
Born and raised here in Hagi, his powerful influence can still be felt today.
What kind of person was he?
We trace the footsteps of Yoshida Shoin.
Hello and welcome to Japanology Plus. I'm Peter Barrakan.
I'm in Hagi in Yamaguchi Prefecture, the very western edge of Honshu, Japan's main island,
an area which used to be known as Choshu.
Hagi is the birthplace of Yoshida Shoin,
who helped to lay the foundations for Japan's modernization in the mid-19th century.
Yoshida Shoin was a rule-breaker and he paid a high price for that.
At the same time, he was a progressive educator,
and books embodying his ideas are still big sellers to this very day.
In this episode, which is the first of two programs about Hagi,
we'll take a closer look at Yoshida Shoin.
Nice to meet you.
Hello.
Yoroshiku onegaishimasu.
Nice to meet you.
Dosako Shingo is the curator of the Hagi Museum and a leading expert on Yoshida Shoin.
So is this where Yoshida Shoin was born?
Yes, it's the site of his birth.
OK. It's not that big, is it?
That's right.
When you look at the plot, it seems quite small.
And they were a relatively high-class family, too.
I mean, they were a samurai family.
The Sugi family, Shoin's birth family, actually had quite a low status as samurai.
During the mid-19th century,
it was social rank that determined the size of a family's house.
They could only have a living space this size.
So I think it was also due to that.
Ah, OK.
What would his early childhood have been like?
He was a diligent student.
Oh.
I think that's a very important point.
In fact, his father and his uncle were highly intelligent.
They had many books, and they were very knowledgeable.
They gave Shoin an incredibly rigorous education.
Was that unusual in the society at the time?
They had samurai status, but still had to supplement their income.
So they also engaged in farming to help support the family's finances.
They were what are known as half-samurai, half-farmers,
working hard at farming while also studying from books.
Interesting.
Yoshida Shoin was born in 1830 as the Sugi family's second son.
His father was a low-ranking retainer to the Choshu domain lord.
Although samurai had the highest social rank in the Edo period,
within themselves there were large differences of status.
The upper-ranking samurai were rulers,
while the lower-ranking samurai handled practical matters and served as guards.
The Sugi family's stipend was about 30 koku,
equivalent to around 3 million yen in today's money.
Many lower-ranking samurai were poor,
and it wasn't unusual for samurai to be deep in debt despite their class.
Nevertheless, samurai considered themselves superior to townspeople,
and to maintain their pride, they cultivated knowledge and refined their etiquette.
Study was encouraged at private temple schools and domain schools
that taught the sons of samurai.
The goal was for students to achieve success in life through education.
Within these studies, particular emphasis was placed on military science.
Military science was the systematic and theoretical study of warfare,
defense, military operations, tactics, and strategy.
Since the 8th century, it had been valued highly as an essential discipline for samurai.
Shōin studied military science under his uncle, Tamaki Bunnoshin,
and quickly distinguished himself.
By the age of seven, while continuing his studies at the domain school for children of samurai,
he also began giving lectures there as an apprentice.
A domain school known as Meirinkan was founded in 1718
and boasted some of the best facilities and curriculum in Japan.
The original gate still stands.
He spends several years at Meirinkan.
What's he doing during that time?
Essentially, this was a period when he devoted himself to academic study.
In fact, it was a crucial time for him.
The situation abroad, the environment surrounding Japan, was gradually changing.
Western nations that possessed economic, political, diplomatic, and military power,
they were coming closer to Japan.
Gradually, Shōin became aware of this and realized that Japan might be in danger.
He began to sense a turning point in history.
Despite Japan's over 200 years of national isolation,
an important book on world geography was translated into Japanese in the late Edo period.
This covered the militaries and industries of other countries.
Shōin came across this book and it had a huge influence on him.
So what does he do after he's read that book?
Japan's national defense, protecting Japan.
He spoke about the need for Japan to strengthen its sea defenses.
But first, it was the Chōshū domain.
He felt that the Chōshū domain had to be defended.
Then, eventually, he realized that Japan itself was in danger.
Gripped by a sense of urgency,
Shōin traveled to Kyūshū and Edo under the guise of studying military science
to learn about how Japan could be protected.
By surveying Japan's ports, highways, castles, armaments, and topography,
and by analyzing the terrain,
he intended to come up with a strategy to defend the nation.
Under the policy of national isolation,
it was considered an act of treason for a samurai to travel without his domain's permission.
But in 1851, when he heard Russian ships had appeared in the north,
he left without waiting for permission.
It was considered desertion of his domain and he lost his samurai status.
Then in 1853, the U.S. fleet led by Commodore Matthew Perry arrived in Japan
and, leveraging its formidable military power,
pressed Japan to open the country.
As the shogunate agreed to the United States' demands,
Shōin resorted to a reckless course of action.
When Perry returned to Japan the following year to sign a treaty,
Shōin boarded one of his ships without permission and tried to stow away.
Shōin saw the black ships and thought that Japan and the United States
would probably fight a war one day.
But in fact, the shogunate signed a Japan-U.S. Treaty of Peace and Amity with surprising ease.
So his thinking changed.
If there were no war, he would study.
He quickly grasped the situation.
He changed his mind.
Ah, interesting.
Later, in Edo, he encountered an outstanding scholar of Western studies called Sakuma Shōzan,
who suggested he go abroad to study.
So with that in mind, ultimately, Shōin decided to go to the United States.
Sakuma Shōzan was an intellectual who advocated opening Japan
and actively bringing in Western science and technology.
From Shōzan, Shōin learned the importance of knowledge and education.
He decided to stow away in order to see the world with his own eyes.
Shōin figured that even if he broke the law, as long as he returned,
he would still be useful to Japan.
That was his intention when he chose to go to the United States.
In the end, he failed, but his followers later put his ideas into action.
He had paved the way for them.
In that sense, I don't think that his failure was wasted at all.
However, because he had already broken his domain's law
and now violated the national law, Shōin was imprisoned in Hagi.
During his time in prison, Shōin wrote a book explaining the ideological rationale
for his attempt to stow away.
He continued to stress the importance of national defense based on Japan's geography.
He was released a year later, but was forced to live under house arrest in his family home.
He was allowed a space measuring only three and a half tatami mats.
This was the only room that he was allowed to be in?
Basically, he was told to stay here. That was his situation.
And did he have access to books?
During his time in prison and in this room, he read more than 600 books.
That's how much time he had to focus on reading.
So, in a sense, it was a good experience for him.
You know what this brings to mind? It's a bit of a digression, but
are you familiar with Malcolm X?
Malcolm X, yes.
Malcolm X was imprisoned for various crimes in Massachusetts,
and he was reading books all the time he was in prison,
and he became a very learned man as a result of that.
So they have something in common.
Shōin started a study group here, using the knowledge he had accumulated.
At first, it was for family members.
Because he wasn't allowed to have any communication with anybody else anyway.
Officially, he couldn't. But this is the interesting thing.
The local children came and begged him to let them listen to his lectures.
In this respect, things were a bit more relaxed than they are today.
So they started coming to his lessons.
Gradually, rumors of what was happening spread around town,
and it turned into something like a school.
It was the origin of what later became his school, Shōkason-juku.
In Shōin's head, an idea was starting to form about
how he could improve Japan even while under house arrest.
He gathered the local children and said,
let's start by making this area better.
Then the castle town of Hagi will improve.
Then the entire Chōshū domain will improve.
And then all of Japan will improve.
Think global, act local.
Exactly. That was Shōin's way of thinking.
Start from this place. This is the base.
The domain's leaders heard rumors about the growing popularity of Shōin's teachings,
and they turned a blind eye to his activities.
Thus was born Shōin's private school, Shōkason-juku.
How do you think teaching was conducted in this ordinary eight tatami mat room?
Presumably he would be in the middle with the students all around him.
You're quite close.
In a sense, Shōin's teaching was not a one-way lecture.
In an ordinary school, the teacher and the students face one another.
That's the usual style.
But in Shōin's case, he had the students line up desks and engage in debate.
Then, if they got stuck, he would offer a hint or make a suggestion.
Shōin did not put himself above his students and provided education in various ways,
including lectures, group readings, and discussions.
He generously imparted everything he had learned to his students.
So what kind of a school was it?
The easiest way to describe it is general knowledge.
It included Chinese philosophy as well as his original specialty of military science.
He also taught about world geography, history, things related to economics, agriculture.
He had read all kinds of books.
So it's practically like a university.
Almost like that.
There were no ranks here.
There was no curriculum.
Students attended when they wanted.
Shōin would teach at any hour, whenever someone came.
That was his style.
No timetable.
It was open 24 hours a day.
It seems that Shōin worked almost without sleep.
Amazing.
In the Japan of that time, it must have been revolutionary.
That wouldn't be an overstatement.
I believe that we can consider Shōin a true pioneer.
However, Shōin was only able to teach here for less than three years.
In 1858, without the emperor's consent,
the shogunate concluded a trade treaty with the United States.
One by one, objectors were purged.
As one of those who opposed the shogunate's actions,
Shōin was again imprisoned.
Then in 1859, he was sentenced to death.
Yoshida Shōin's short life ended at the age of 29.
In Hagi, there is a shrine dedicated to Shōin.
It was built in 1907 through the active efforts of his students.
Shōin's personal writings and other possessions
are stored in the shrine's treasure hall.
Among these is Shōin's will.
19 pages in length.
It was completed the day before his execution
and is addressed to his students.
In it, Shōin compares his life to the four seasons,
saying that he has planted sufficient seeds
and asking his students to ensure those seeds bloom.
He wants them to inherit and carry on his ideals.
Many of Shōin's students became key figures in Japan's modernization.
Not just in politics, but other fields too.
High-temperature reverberatory furnaces,
advanced shipbuilding technology, western-style education.
The students who inherited Shōin's ideals
promoted the introduction of many innovations.
Traces of these pioneers' innovative efforts
can still be found in Hagi today.
These were inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2015
as part of the Sites of Japan's Meiji Industrial Revolution.
Today, Hagi is seen as a symbol of Japan's modernization
during the late Edo period and the Meiji era.
Shōin, during his lifetime, I suppose, was seen as a criminal,
at least in some parts.
At the same time, he was a pioneer.
How is he viewed?
How's the balance between those two aspects?
He had some negative aspects, but even so, he was remarkable.
There are arguments in favor of and against Yoshida Shōin.
I think the debate will continue, but that is how he is seen.
How do you yourself see his contribution to history?
I believe that there's still so much that we can learn from him even today.
But he was a man of the Edo period,
so certain aspects of his way of thinking
don't quite align with present-day norms.
He traveled without permission from the domain lord,
deserting the domain.
I believe it's necessary to pass on to future generations
both his admirable qualities and his misdeeds.
It's interesting because in Japan, people follow rules,
and in the West, rules tend to be,
they're there to be bent or sometimes to be broken,
and people tend to take that for granted.
Shōin's thinking was probably closer to the Western perspective.
Of course, he knew the rules,
but if breaking them could ultimately result in a positive outcome,
he didn't feel that he had to strictly follow the rules.
That may have been the way he thought.
But you have to take the responsibility for your actions as well.
Taking responsibility for yourself, I see.
That's actually very close to Shōin's principles.
I hadn't thought of it that way.
That's a good point.
Today, an elementary school stands on the site of the domain school
where Shōin once taught.
Every morning, all the students recite Shōin's teachings.
Different sayings of Shōin are recited each trimester,
with the children reciting a total of 18 sayings
over their six years of elementary school.
The children recite Shōin's teachings over their six years of elementary school.
You recite Shōin's teachings every day, right?
Yes.
Do you understand what they mean?
At first, I didn't understand what they meant,
but I gradually learned them.
Now, I understand what they mean and what Shōin's teachings are.
Are they helpful?
Yes, they are very helpful.
I wanted to be mindful of how to be kind to others,
so I started to be mindful of how to be kind to others.
Thanks to that, I've made more friends.
Thank you.
Yes, thank you.
Much of Hagi's townscape remains unchanged from the time Shōin lived here.
Bordered by mountains and the sea,
the land was easy to defend and difficult to attack.
But in the late Edo period, foreign ships appeared even in these waters.
Such geographical factors influenced
Shōin's thinking about how Japan should be defended.
Hello.
Hello, pleased to meet you.
Shirai Takahaki researches the geology in and around Hagi.
He guides Peter around Shōin's hometown by sightseeing boat.
So where does this boat go to?
The town of Hagi is built on a triangular area of land known as a delta,
between two branches of a river.
As we go upstream, we can see the old area around the castle.
As you can see, the river is extremely wide,
which acts as a natural moat.
The castle town was built in the Edo period, right after a major war.
So, of course, they took precautions against attack from outside.
People couldn't possibly swim across this wide river,
and only the minimum number of bridges were constructed.
Also, the north side is surrounded by the sea and volcanic peaks.
It's known as a natural stronghold.
Difficult to attack, but easy to defend.
That's the environment where the castle and its town were built.
This was Yoshida Shōin's hometown.
I wonder how this landscape affected him living here, growing up here.
The place where Yoshida Shōin was born is a little outside this castle town area,
and on a small hill.
So that might have helped him develop a broad and insightful perspective
on people's lives and the surrounding geography.
There is a famous saying by Yoshida Shōin.
First, look to the geography.
He explained that without land, people cannot live,
and without people, there can be no daily life or politics.
Therefore, if you want to understand or discuss daily life,
culture, or political matters, you must first look to the geography.
That's what he said.
Yoshida Shōin's life was very short,
but he travelled around Japan observing each region with his own eyes.
One of the ideas that he cultivated then was to pay careful attention to geography.
Passing that idea onto many young people upon his return to Hagi was a major accomplishment.
There's another Shōin shrine in Tokyo.
It's actually not too far from where I live.
I was aware of the shrine, but had no idea that its name came from an individual.
In fact, in order to find out who Yoshida Shōin was,
I had to make this trip to Hagi, and I'm glad I did.
I can fully understand why his words are appreciated even now,
160-odd years after he died.
It's a shame that people didn't value them more when he was still around,
although perhaps that's the fate of a visionary thinker, both then and now.
