Japanese History: The Heian Period, Pt. 3 (The Birth of the Samurai)

Ancient Asia - China
17 followers
There are few things more synonymous with Japanese history than the iconic warriors
known to us today as the samurai. But what does that word really mean? How did these warriors
emerge onto the historical stage, and what set them apart from the countless military men who
came before them? Today, we will explore the answers to those questions and more when we
follow the footsteps of some of Japan's most infamous samurai forefathers as they plunge
into the conflicts that will, for better or worse, leave their names forever etched into
the annals of history. Leave your poetry books and courtly formal wear at home, because we're
about to venture into the wild backcountry of ancient Japan to witness the birth of the bushi
on this 10th episode of Japanese History The Textbook on the Buyuden Japanese History Channel.
Hello everyone, and welcome back to Japanese History The Textbook, the series where we make
our way chronologically through Japanese history, primarily using Japanese language educational
sources as our guide. The main sources that I use for every episode, as well as my more specific
secondary sources that tend to vary from episode to episode, are listed down in the description,
so feel free to check those out if you're curious. With today's episode, which happens to be episode
10, we have finally reached the double digits, so I'd just like to take a moment to thank everyone
who's watched, liked, and followed thus far for giving me the motivation to make it to this point.
We've still, of course, got a very long way to go, but I still feel like episode 10 is a
milestone worth celebrating. Anyway, on today's episode, we will finally begin discussing a topic
I'm sure a lot of people, myself included, have been really looking forward to getting into,
the birth of the samurai. Now, my goal with this series is to try to reflect the general structure
and content of what I see as the mainstream narrative of Japanese history as it's presented
in the actual country of Japan, and so with that in mind, I need to be honest with you. Textbook
style materials in Japan do not actually spend that much time on the birth of the samurai.
They certainly don't gloss over it at all, but they don't tend to really do any particular deep
dive on it either. These books are, after all, written mostly for kids and teens who would
prefer to be at home watching K-pop videos, rather than for rabid foreign fans of Shogun Total War,
so it's not really all that surprising if you think about it. Luckily for you guys though,
I am much closer to being in the latter category, so for this episode, I have decided to focus on
all the main points of my educational sources, but also inject them with a little extra detail
for those who are interested. Of course, I'm sure there are plenty of people out there for whom a
single 40-minute video is not going to be nearly detailed enough, but I'm hoping I can strike
something of a balance here. Feel free to let me know in the comments whether you think I've
succeeded or not. Anyway, without further ado, let's get right into it. Japanese History The
Part 3. There are a number of important things we need to discuss before we get into the birth of
the samurai, so let's begin by rewinding a few centuries and reviewing what we've learned so far
about the development of Japan's provincial land situation. As you may recall, way back in 743,
in the first half of the Nara period, the Konden Einen Shizai no Hou law was passed,
which permitted the permanent possession of land for those who went out and reclaimed that
land themselves from the wilderness. This law was primarily taken advantage of by those who
actually had the power to engage in large-scale land reclamation projects, aristocrats, and
religious establishments. They often employed runaway farmers in these new cultivation endeavors,
and they ended up creating large personal estates called shouen. Specifically, the estates of this
time are referred to in history scholarship as shokishouen or early shouen, as they were
somewhat primitive in comparison to the personal estates that would be created in later centuries.
Most importantly, these early shouen were taxed just like anywhere else, and as such did not
present a major threat to the state's income stream. However, they did pave the way for a
much more insidious type of estate, which would emerge during the mid-to-late Heian period.
As we saw in our last episode, Emperor Daigo issued his Engi no Shouen Seirire or the Engi
Era Shouen Reorganization Order in 902, and during the course of its implementation,
the final redistribution of Japan's public farmland to its peasant cultivators was carried
out. Or at least, the government attempted to carry it out. In the course of implementing the
order, the government was rather bluntly confronted with the fact that they no longer had a good grasp
on the makeup of their own peasant population. In particular, census fraud for the sake of tax
evasion was running extremely rampant at this time, a fact exemplified by a village in Awa Province,
which claimed to be home to 376 female residents but only 59 males. The reality of the country's
villages, of course, did not match these harem anime-style numbers, but without an accurate
census to go by, the government simply could not hope to distribute its farmland correctly,
and as such, they were finally forced to give up on the old ailing ritsuryo tax system.
From this point on, the government would base its tax strategy not around its people but around
its land, and it began to group the country's rice fields into taxable units known as myou.
The management of these myou field groups was entrusted to particularly powerful local farmers
called tato, and these tato would in turn now answer directly to the province's kokushi governor.
Prior to this change, the kokushi governors had collected taxes via resident local bureaucrats
called gunji, aka district managers, men who typically had no personal ties with the governor.
Being able to now directly collect taxes without having to go through these neutral middlemen
resulted in a substantial increase in the kokushi's power. Kokushi governors of this era
are referred to as zuryou kokushi, or simply zuryou, a word whose original meaning was
the act of taking over a post from one's predecessor, but which eventually came to
serve as a byword for the position itself. The zuryou governors were notorious for the
unbridled greed with which they taxed the residents of their provinces, a side effect
of their newfound power. Under the new system, they had a fixed amount of tax which they needed
to collect and forward on to the capital, but it was not particularly difficult for them to
collect beyond that initial amount and generously line their own pockets. A particularly famous
example of this era's brutally greedy zuryou kokushi is the case of Fujiwara no Motonaga,
who was governor of Owari province during the 980s. The province's district managers and powerful
farmers banded together to implore the central government to have Motonaga removed from office
for his gross misconduct, sending a petition known as the Owari no Kuni Gunji Hyakushoura no
Gebumi to the Grand Council of State in 988. The petition accused Motonaga of collecting large
amounts of illegal taxes, as well as of rarely ever actually being present at his government
headquarters, making it basically impossible for anyone who he didn't want to see to get in touch
with him. Additionally, it described how Motonaga had brought a large number of his own personal
followers with him from the capital, and was employing them to survey fields and collect
taxes in a public capacity, and it particularly lambasted Motonaga's son Yorikata for taking
advantage of his father's authority to high-handedly abuse and steal from the local populace.
The petition didn't fall on completely deaf ears, as Motonaga was indeed removed from office in its
wake, but he was allowed to continue to remain active in the political world, and his son would
go on to become governor of Iwami province a few decades later. One can only hope he mellowed
somewhat with age. Given how lucrative governorships in this era became, they began to be seen more and
more as an attractive career option for mid-level aristocrats who knew they had little chance of
advancement in the political world of the capital. In the latter half of the Heian period, it became
common for these sorts of individuals to dip into their own personal fortunes to finance things like
imperial ceremonies and temple construction, essentially bribing the powers-that-be into
rewarding them with lucrative governor positions out in the provinces. These are by no means words
that you need to remember by heart, but this act of buying one's governor position through bribery
is referred to with the term chōgō, and the act of doing the same thing yet again to buy a
reappointment to the same position is called chōnin. Finally, one more variety of zuryō kokushi
governor which emerged during this era was the type who never even deigned to go to the province
entrusted to him, instead sending a representative to govern in his place and remaining in the
capital to relax and enjoy his new income stream. This sort of situation is referred to as yōnin,
a term whose kanji characters literally mean fulfilling one's duty from afar.
The kokushi governors were not the only ones who prospered under the new land system,
and the powerful tato farm managers also found themselves gradually coming to hold
more and more authority and influence. Those operating on a particularly large scale came
to be called daimyō tato, with daimyō literally just meaning large myō, and they in turn began
to take on the role of prominent local authority figures. Many of them began to actually open up
and cultivate new land in addition to the government-owned fields with which they had
been entrusted. As their wealth and power grew, some of these daimyō tato began to butt heads
with their kokushi overlords over tax issues, a phenomenon only exacerbated by the greediness
characteristic of the zuryō kokushi of this era. In order to sidestep the authority of the kokushi
governors, some daimyō tato began to donate their lands to powerful figures and organizations in
the capital, with prime candidates being the Fujiwara regent family, various members of the
imperial family, and particularly large and influential temples or shrines. The land would
then become the personal shōen estate of the donation recipient, who could use their power
and connections to secure total tax exemption, a special right known as fuyu no ken. The tato who
had donated the land would carry on as the new shōen's manager, and in place of taxes they would
pay a slightly smaller sum directly into the personal coffers of the shōen's new owner.
Eventually, many of these shōen also obtained a second special right, the fuyu no ken, which
prohibited agents of the kokushi from even setting foot on their premises. A kokushi governor's word
was law out in the provinces, but they couldn't hope to contest the will of the Fujiwara regents
or the great temples of Nara, and so they could do little but sit by and watch as their taxable
land was gradually chipped away. This new style of shōen estate is known to history as the
kishinchikei shōen, or the donated land style shōen, and in many ways it is the ultimate
symbol of the collapse of the ritsuryō system and Japan's move toward a new, more feudalistic age
where land was something to be divided up and possessed. As the power of the tato farm managers
grew, they began to arm their family members and subordinates in order to protect the lands
they managed. Those who had become managers of donation-style shōen obviously wanted some muscle
to make sure no unwanted parties were setting foot on their turf, and those who had remained
on the public land side of things also needed to be armed in order to fend off brigands and
ambitious rivals. You will recall from episode 8 that the early decades of the Heian period had
seen the creation of the kōndei no sei, the stalwart youth system, wherein Japan's peasant
conscript army was scrapped and military duties were instead taken over by volunteer units composed
of the much more privileged and well-trained sons of wealthy local powerholders. The self-armament
of the tato farm managers was likely the natural extension of this new culture of influential local
individuals taking military matters into their own hands, and it is through this process that
we begin to see the foundations of bushidan, warrior bands, beginning to take shape. Bushidan
is also sometimes translated as samurai group, but we ought to note that the words bushi and samurai
are not exact synonyms, as we will see later when we examine the actual meaning of the word samurai.
The word bushi, in a nutshell, means warrior, and it is typically used as a general term for
describing the more militaristic elements of Japan's medieval society, often the same people
and groups that we would refer to in English as samurai. It is important to note that the word
bushi itself does not reference a fixed social class, but rather a way of life based around armed
self-sufficiency that was characteristic of the more powerful elements of provincial society.
Its definition is fluid, and the line between bushi and non-bushi would remain quite hazy up
until the beginning of the Edo period around the year 1600, when it did finally become a legal
class designation. Anyway, these bushidan, these groups of bushi, gradually grew larger and larger
and came to be united under the control of particularly wealthy and powerful provincial
landholders, typically either tato land managers who had become powerful enough to actually be
incorporated into the provincial government apparatus, or actual retired kokushi governors
who had chosen to put down roots in the provinces rather than return to the capital after their terms
had ended. These bushidan leaders were called toryo, and they are perhaps best represented by
two clans which rose to power in the 10th century, the Kanmuheishi and the Seiwa Genji,
better known to many as the Taira and the Minamoto. Both of these clans traced their
descendancy back to imperial princes, who gave up their status as royalty and descended down
to the status of nobility, receiving the names Taira and Minamoto when they did so. Taira and
Minamoto, by the way, are respectively read as he and gen when using the quote-unquote
Chinese pronunciation of their respective characters, and this is why the clans are
alternatively called heishi and genji, with the shi or ji being the character meaning clan,
the same one we studied back when we looked at the Kofun period's shisei system. I will try to
refer to the two warrior clans as the Kanmu Taira and the Seiwa Minamoto from here on to avoid any
confusion. As we saw with the case of Minamoto no Makoto in our last episode, there were quite
a lot of ex-royal individuals who received these surnames too, so it is important to remember that
just being a Minamoto or a Taira does not mean that someone was a warrior or even related to one.
As their names suggest, the Kanmu Taira were descended from a grandson of Emperor Kanmu
and the Seiwa Minamoto from a son of Emperor Seiwa. In the case of the Kanmu Taira,
their founder was Taira no Takamochi, formerly known as the Imperial Prince Takamochi, who,
after descending to the rank of nobility, made his way out to the Kanto region to serve as the
governor of Kazusa province in 898. Many textbooks posit that he left the capital because he was not
particularly favored by the ruling regime and had little chance of advancement there, but other
books suggest that he may have been looked to to help stabilize the wild Kanto region by means of
the majesty of his imperial blood. Either way, Takamochi's sons remained in Kanto and put down
roots there, and several decades later, a conflict would break out amongst them centered around one
of their second-generation members, Taira no Masakado. In the mid-930s, Masakado began to
feud with his other family members, possibly regarding land inheritance and possibly regarding
marriage issues, and he would ultimately end up killing his own uncle, Taira no Kunika, in the
conflict. Having established himself as one of the heavy hitters in the Kanto region,
other powerful landlords began to look to Masakado for help with their own squabbles,
and in 939, one such alliance led him into direct conflict with the governor of Hitachi province.
Perhaps it was his country upbringing, but Masakado was not one to back down from a fight,
and he ended up attacking Hitachi's provincial headquarters and seizing the governor's official
seal. Then, on the advice of an ally who suggested that the punishment for attacking
one provincial headquarters was probably hardly any different from that for attacking several,
Masakado set out to conquer the entire Kanto region. At the peak of his power, Masakado is
said to have proclaimed himself shinno, or new emperor, and begun appointing his own selections
for the governorships of the eight Kanto provinces. The veracity of this new emperor
anecdote has come into question in recent years, but like George Washington and the cherry tree,
it's one of those stories that will probably never really leave the public consciousness.
The imperial court would appoint a new shogun to lead an army against Masakado,
but before that plan could be put into action, Masakado would be defeated by a pair of local
rivals, Taira no Sadamori and Fujiwara no Hidesato. The former, Sadamori, was Masakado's
own cousin and the son of the uncle Kunika whom Masakado slew at the beginning of the conflict.
The latter, Fujiwara no Hidesato, was another powerful early bushi with a great deal of
influence in the Kanto region. His family claimed to have been a branch relation of the northern
house of the Fujiwara clan, but it is suspected that they may have actually just commandeered
the name out of convenience. Right around the same time as Masakado's rebellion, a similar
disturbance was breaking out in the western provinces of the country, the rebellion of
Fujiwara no Sumitomo. Sumitomo was a genuine member of the northern house of the Fujiwara,
but he came from one of its more peripheral bloodlines and thus had little chance of
advancement in the political world of the capital. He was sent out east in the mid-930s to become the
jō of Io province on the island of Shikoku, with jō being a direct subordinate position to the
Technically, the kokushi governor office consisted of four official positions,
with the highest, kami, being the actual governor himself, and the other three positions,
suke, jō, and sakan, being his deputies. As jō of Io province, Sumitomo distinguished himself
by subduing pirates ravaging the Seto inland sea, but he was rewarded for his services with
little more than a pat on the back, as his superiors in the kokushi governor office
reaped all the real, tangible rewards. A disillusioned Sumitomo put down roots in Shikoku
and began to organize his former enemies, the Seto inland sea pirates, into something of a
personal navy. It is worth noting that these quote-unquote pirates were typically made up
of frustrated peasant farmers who had fled their lands out of dissatisfaction with their greedy
zuryō kokushi governors. In 939, Sumitomo led his men in a sudden attack on the deputy governor
of Bizen province, who is suspected to have earned Sumitomo's ire by cracking down on his
cronies' pirate activities. The attack was a blatant act of treason, but the court was not
equipped to mount an offensive against Sumitomo, as they had their hands full with Taira no Masakado
in the east. There was even a rumor, albeit a false one, that Sumitomo was an ally of Masakado's,
and that his misbehavior out west was a ploy to take pressure off of Masakado in the east.
To buy themselves time, the court initially attempted to placate Sumitomo with a promotion
in court rank, which he accepted happily. However, his luck was not to last. Once Masakado was
defeated in the early months of 940, the court turned their full attention to the punishment
of Sumitomo and his pirate army, ordering a number of provincial officials and military
aristocrats to begin moving against him. Sumitomo, perhaps sensing that the walls were closing in,
began a spree of pillaging across southwestern Japan with his fleet of some 400 ships,
raiding a number of provinces and defeating an imperial force under the command of a Dazaifu
officer. In the fifth month of 941, Sumitomo occupied and burned the Dazaifu itself,
an attack which has actually been confirmed by recent archaeological excavation,
but this was effectively his last hurrah. The following day, his fleet was defeated in battle
at Hakata Bay, and Sumitomo fled back to Eo Province, where he was captured and killed
by the provincial police chief the next month. The rebellions of Fujiwara no Sumitomo and
Taira no Masakado are typically referred to in Japanese history scholarship as a single event,
the Jōhei Tengyō Disturbance or Jōhei Tengyō no Ran, a title referring to the fact that they
both occurred basically at the same time and spanned the Jōhei and Tengyō eras. The Jōhei
Tengyō Disturbance absolutely rocked the imperial government to its core, and thus the heroes of
the episode took on a special importance in the hearts and minds of the Japanese aristocracy,
almost as if they had some special power that others didn't possess. For this reason,
the particular importance of these rebellions is not so much in the men who started them,
Sumitomo and Masakado, but rather the men who ended them. With Masakado's rebellion in the east,
this would be the aforementioned Taira no Sadamori and Fujiwara no Hidesato. With Sumitomo's rebellion
in the west, one of the more decorated heroes of the incident was one Minamoto no Tsunemoto,
a grandson of the Emperor Seiwa, and the man remembered to history as the founder of the
Seiwa Minamoto. All three men were recognized for their service by the central government,
being rewarded with fairly high-level court ranks and going on to hold various governorships
throughout the country, but most importantly, they established themselves and their descendants
as being the military specialists of Heian aristocratic society. The arts of war, especially
horsemanship and archery, came to be greatly emphasized as the trademark skills of these
families, while other aristocratic clans began to actively discourage their members from practicing
such things. This hereditary monopoly that the Kanmu Taira, Seiwa Genji, and Hidesato Fujiwara
came to hold over matters of the sword set them apart from earlier clans like the Saka no Ue,
for example, who occasionally handled big military matters but never made that their
sole function and identity. The new top-tier bushi clans became defined in the public consciousness
as warriors, leading the imperial court to look to them to be the defenders of the capital
and the provinces, as both police and as soldiers. And the fact that they served in this capacity,
served being the key word here, is where we get the word samurai. Samurai originally comes from
an old Japanese verb, saburao, which means to serve one's master. Its kanji character is the
same one appearing in words such as jijo, meaning waiting maid, and jiko, meaning personal tutor.
In the Nara period, there was even something called a saburai bito, which was the job title
of those people assigned to take care of very elderly aristocrats. In the Heian period, the
word samurai, or rather its predecessor, saburahui, was used to refer to the members of lower-level
aristocratic families, who served the upper crust of the aristocracy as personal attendants or
assistants in some capacity. The descendants of Taira no Sadamori, Minamoto no Tsunemoto,
and Fujiwara no Hidesato were originally viewed as just being another part of this group,
and the word samurai referred to their servility rather than their specific job duties as military
specialists. The word's change in definition to something specifically limited to the bushi
occurred over the course of centuries, and it didn't actually become a colloquial catch-all
for all members of the warrior class until the Edo period. Many of the descendants of Sadamori,
Tsunemoto, and Hidesato undertook their service to Japan's ruling class in the capital itself.
Some joined the capital police, the kebiishi, while others served in the distinguished band
of warriors known as the takiguchi no musha, the official guardians of the imperial palace.
However, they all maintained their power bases out in the provinces, with many of their progeny
serving as kokushi governors or their deputies, or being appointed to various military or policing
positions such as Shinjuku Shogun, the head of the Tohoku region's pacification and defense
headquarters. On our last episode, we took a brief look at the Anna Incident of 969, wherein the
aristocrat and ex-imperial family member Minamoto no Takaakira was ousted from the halls of power
by his Fujiwara clan rivals, who feared he might become the next father-in-law of a sitting emperor.
This incident was significant not only in the history of Japan's aristocracy,
but also in the history of the bushi, as it marked the moment when the three great bushi
family lines established in the wake of the Jouhei Tengyo disturbance were reduced to only two.
As you will recall, Takaakira was exiled due to accusations of treason, but what I didn't mention
in the last episode is that these accusations originated with none other than Minamoto no
Mitsunaka, son of the aforementioned Minamoto no Tsunemoto and second-generation leader of the
Seiwa Minamoto. Mitsunaka also managed to get the son of Fujiwara no Hidesato wrapped up in
these allegations, and as a result, Hidesato's entire line fell from grace, permanently losing
their status as one of the preeminent warrior families of Heian Japan. From here on, it would
And thanks to Mitsunaka's earnest snitching efforts in the Anna incident, the Minamoto
in particular found themselves having secured a strong new ally in the Fujiwara regent family.
This was still a pre-feudal era in Japan's history, before lord-vassal relationships
based on land were the norm, and so these personal relationships with political superiors
who could secure one appointments to important government posts were extremely important.
It should thus go without saying that this alliance with the Fujiwara regent family
would pave the way for the Seiwa Minamoto's further success in the political and financial realms.
The next big step forward for the Seiwa Minamoto, as well as a bit of a step back for the Kanmu Taira,
occurred in 1028 with an incident known as the Rebellion of Taira no Tadatsune.
While the Minamoto had been cozying up to the Fujiwara regents in the capital,
the descendants of Taira no Sadamori and his uncles had been continuing to fortify their
position out in the backwoods of the east, and one of these descendants was Taira no Tadatsune.
Tadatsune, who had at one point served as the governor of Kazusa province,
controlled large swathes of territory in the Kanto region, much of which he had likely inherited
from his Taira forefathers, and the large amount of influence that he held there led to feuds
between him and other local power holders. The fact that he seems to have abstained from paying
any taxes on his vast holdings likely didn't win him any friends either, but it was his attack on
and murder of the governor of Awa province in 1028 that finally forced the imperial court to
call for his subjugation. They initially sent troops under the kebiishi officer Taira no Naokata
to deal with the issue, and Naokata, whose particular line of the Kanmu Taira had been
engaged in a multiple-generation feud with Tadatsune's, was more than eager to take on the
task. However, Naokata failed to accomplish anything other than ravaging the Kanto region
for three years with fruitless fighting and the ruthless requisition of food and supplies for his
army. At last, the central government relieved Naokata of his duties and instead turned to
third son of the Anna Incident's chief whistleblower Minamoto no Mitsunaka.
Yorinobu, who was at the time serving as the governor of Kai province, had made his name
serving under the late Fujiwara no Michinaga, the full-moon poem author and architect of the
Fujiwara clan's Golden Age, whom we met in our last episode. Yorinobu had been known as one of
the Michinaga shiten-no, a group of four particularly renowned military aristocrats
whom Michinaga had greatly favored and relied on heavily during his time at the top.
Shiten-no is the Japanese word for the four heavenly kings of Buddhism,
but it's often used in Japanese to refer to the top four people in any given field,
with a prime example being the Elite Four in Pokemon games, who are called the shiten-no in
the game's Japanese versions. In this way, I suppose we can think of Minamoto no Yorinobu
as one of Michinaga's Elite Four, and his reputation was in fact so impressive that
as soon as he made his way out to Kazusa province, Tadatsune chose to surrender to him without a
fight. Tadatsune would die of disease on his way to the capital to answer for his actions,
but Yorinobu dutifully beheaded the corpse and sent it along as a consolation prize for the court.
There were several significant consequences of the rebellion of Taira no Tadatsune.
The first was that the Kanto region was absolutely ravaged, and it would take several
generations and a lot of tax breaks for it to bounce back to its former production level.
The second was that it provided the Seiwa Minamoto an opportunity to begin building their
power base in the east, as prior to this incident they had primarily based themselves in more central
provinces closer to the capital. The third consequence, and one which provides some nice
foreshadowing for future episodes, is the issue of a particular parcel of land which Yorinobu came
into possession of via his success in this incident. The aforementioned Taira no Naokata,
Tadatsune's relative and bitter enemy who had failed to stamp out the rebellion in its early
stages, was so impressed with Yorinobu's performance here that he offered him his
daughter's hand in marriage. As part of her dowry, Naokata also gave Yorinobu a piece of land in
Kanto's Sagami province, which had been passed down through his family for generations, but which
would now become the hereditary property of the Minamoto. A little spot on Japan's pacific coast
called Kamakura. Before we move on to our final big event in the early history of the Bushi,
there is one more military incident to which we ought to briefly turn our attention.
This incident actually occurred about 10 years prior to the rebellion of Taira no Tadatsune in
1019, when a group of several thousand pirates from slightly northeast of the Korean peninsula
launched an attack on southern Japan. These pirates were members of an ethnic group known as
the Jurchen people, or Toi to the Japanese, and they spent roughly two weeks ravaging the provinces
of northern Kyushu. By the time that the attacks ended, more than 300 civilians were dead, more
than a thousand had been taken captive, and close to 400 cows and horses had been stolen or killed.
Without the military system of previous centuries, the Dazaifu had struggled to
scrape together the ships and soldiers needed to repel the invaders, and the day was instead
saved by the local Bushi warriors who stepped up to meet the pirates in battle. These warriors
consisted mostly of current or former Dazaifu bureaucrats who had settled in the northern Kyushu
region, including a number of members of the Kammu Taira, as well as various powerful local
landholders native to the area. The Mongol invasions of the 13th century are often brought
up as the first instance of Japan's samurai warriors engaging in battle with a foreign enemy,
but in reality such a clash had actually occurred more than 250 years prior with the Toi invasion.
The Jurchen pirates, by the way, would end up being destroyed by Goryeo Korean forces after
returning to the Asian mainland, and the Goryeo would graciously return several hundred civilian
captives to the Dazaifu, who thanked them with a gift of gold. And now we come to the final chapter
in our look at the history of Japan's provinces and the Bushi warriors in the middle Heian period,
the former Nine Years and later Three Years Wars. Both conflicts occurred in the untamed northern
lands of Japan's Tohoku region, which had been nominally under the control of the imperial court
for more than a century, but was in actuality ruled mostly by powerful local families tentatively
cooperating with the local Kokushi governors. One of these families was the Abe clan, who held
dominion over much of Tohoku's massive eastern province of Mutsu, the other main province in
the region being the equally large Dewa province in the west. The Abe clan were long held to have
been a powerful clan of Emishi, the native quote-unquote barbarians of the Tohoku region,
but recent scholarship has begun to question this narrative, suggesting that they may in fact have
been a family of central bureaucrats who simply put down roots in the north. Either way, the
traditional narrative goes that, in the middle of the 11th century, the Emishi warlord and Abe clan
leader Abe no Yoritoki began to shirk his duties of paying taxes and providing laborers to the
governor of Mutsu. This eventually led to a military clash with said governor in the year 1051,
but given that the man in question was a capital-born aristocrat with no military experience,
the battle ended in a decisive victory for the Abe clan army. This clash, called the Battle
of Onikiribe, officially marks the beginning of what later generations would call the former
Nine Years' War. The defeated governor of Mutsu fled back to the capital with his tail between
his legs, and the court chose to replace him with a man of significantly greater military renown,
Minamoto no Yoriyoshi, son of the hero of Taira no Taratsune's rebellion, Yorinobu.
With Yoriyoshi's appointment to the governorship of Mutsu, Abe no Yoritoki switched over to a much
more submissive attitude, and did his best to avoid any outright conflict with Yoriyoshi and
his followers. Yoritoki's original name actually was Yoriyoshi, and one of his tactics to appease
the new governor was changing it to Yoritoki, to avoid any awkwardness with the two of them
having the same name. The two men maintained an uneasy but peaceful coexistence for the next
four years, but just as Minamoto no Yoriyoshi's term as governor was about to end, an incident
occurred in which his subordinates were attacked by unknown Emishi assailants. Despite a lack of
any concrete proof, Yoriyoshi insisted that the attack had been the work of Abe no Yoritoki's son
and used it as a pretext to launch into a full-scale war with the Abe clan.
Yoritoki would die in battle the following year, but Sadato took over leadership of the clan
and put up a stiff resistance that was far more than anything the Minamoto had ever anticipated.
At the Battle of Kinomi in the snowy winter of 1057, the Abe army famously won so decisively
that the Minamoto army was reduced to only seven men, including Yoriyoshi and his teenage son
Yoshie. Admittedly, the Bushi armies of this era were typically in the neighborhood of a few hundred
to a few thousand at most, and this account is likely greatly colored by legend, but the fact
that Yoriyoshi was brought to the brink of total defeat is undeniable. After several more years of
being forced onto the defensive by the Abe, and having also failed to receive any reinforcements
from the imperial court despite repeated pleas, Yoriyoshi at last made a proverbial deal with
the devil in 1062. Just as the Abe clan existed as the local powerholders in Mutsu province,
another similar clan existed in Dewa province to the west, and it was to this clan, the Kiyohara,
that Minamoto no Yoriyoshi appealed for aid. The clan's leader, Kiyohara no Takenori,
answered Yoriyoshi's call, and marched east with an army of some 10,000 men, and the united
Kiyohara-Minamoto army, which was numerically mostly just a Kiyohara army, managed to destroy
the Abe once and for all. Counting from the 1051 clash between Abe no Yoritoki and the previous
governor of Mutsu, the war had spanned 11 years in total, and it is historically significant
because it provided the Seiwa-Minamoto with the opportunity to mobilize many of the Kanto
bushi to fight under them in an epic large-scale conflict. The bonds formed here between the
Minamoto and many of the lesser bushi clans of Kanto would prove instrumental a century and a
half later, when the descendants of Yoriyoshi and Yoshie worked to set up Japan's first warrior-centric
government, the Kamakura Bakufu, or the Kamakura Shogunate. An unintended side effect, however,
of Minamoto no Yoriyoshi's actions in the former Nine Years' War was that he had provided the
Kiyohara clan of Dewa province with a massive boost in power and influence. The Kiyohara had
not only absorbed all the old territory of the Abe clan, but their leader Takenori was appointed
by the imperial court. You will recall that this was the post given to the general in charge of the
Tohoku Pacification and Defense Headquarters, and the fact that it had been given to a man
viewed by aristocratic society as a barbarian emishi chieftain was groundbreaking, to say the
least. However, the Kiyohara clan's golden age was not destined to last long. Twenty years after
the end of the former Nine Years' War, an internecine conflict broke out between the
grandsons of Kiyohara no Takenori, Sanehira, Iehira, and Kiyohira. Sanehira was the eldest,
and was at this time serving as the leader of the Kiyohara clan. Iehira was his younger half-brother,
sharing with him the same father, but having a mother who was actually a member of the fallen
Abe clan. The third brother, Kiyohira, was actually biologically not a Kiyohara clan member
at all, with his mother being the same Abe clan woman who would later give birth to Iehira,
and his father being a descendant of our old friend Fujiwara no Hidesato, who had perished
during the former Nine Years' War after allying with his in-laws, the Abe clan. Kiyohira and his
mother had entered into the Kiyohara clan's protection as war refugees of a sort, with his
mother remarrying into the clan, and he himself thus becoming an adopted member of the Kiyohara.
Anyway, the conflict between Sanehira, Iehira, and Kiyohira is typically viewed by modern scholars
as the beginning of what we call the later Three Years' War. Right around the time that the
brothers' feud was beginning, the governorship of Mutsu province was assigned to none other than
Minamoto no Yoriyoshi's son and former Nine Years' War veteran, Minamoto no Yoshie, now in his early 40s.
Yoshie was just as eager as his father before him to get actively involved in local affairs,
and he immediately inserted himself into the middle of the Kiyohara clan conflict,
initially taking the side of clan leader Sanehira. Sanehira, however, would die suddenly shortly
thereafter while marching with his army, and with his death a tentative peace was restored
to the Tohoku region. From his position of authority as governor of Mutsu, Yoshie evenly
distributed the Kiyohara clan territories between the remaining two brothers, Iehira and Kiyohira,
but with their eldest brother and rival out of the picture, the two men were not inclined to play
nice with each other. Iehira in particular seems to have been upset that Kiyohira received the
same amount of territory as him despite not actually being a blood member of the Kiyohara clan.
This tension would finally boil over in 1085 when Iehira launched an attack on Kiyohira's residence,
killing his wife and child in the process. In response to this, Kiyohira managed to acquire
the support of governor Yoshie, who seems to have been all too happy to jump into the ring on his
behalf. It is speculated that Yoshie knew all along that the two brothers could not coexist
peacefully, and that he intentionally played them off of each other to start a war from which he
could expect to make some gains both financially and reputation-wise. Either way, Yoshie spent the
next two years mounting an offensive against Iehira, who put up a stalwart defense but was
eventually toppled after the long and grueling siege of his final stronghold, Kanezawa-no-saku.
In the aftermath of the conflict, Yoshie appealed to the imperial court for his reward for putting
down this local rebellion in the north, but to his dismay, the court refused, judging correctly
that the entire affair had been a personal war that Yoshie had waged mostly on his own behalf,
and even going so far as to remove him from the governorship of Mutsu.
In a way, however, this worked out in Yoshie's favor, because since he had no public funds with
which to reward his soldiers, he was forced to pay them all out of his own pocket. His reputation
as a war hero had already been cemented by his actions in these two northern wars, and now,
by paying his followers with his own personal fortune, he was able to further strengthen the
bonds between his line of the Seiwa Minamoto and the various lower-level bushi families who
had followed him into battle. Many of the bushi clans who would go on to become famous as vassals
of the Kamakura shogunate, such as the Oba, the Kajiwara, and the Miura, traced the origins of
their fealty to the Minamoto back to the later Three Years' War. In a sense, the real victor
of the later Three Years' War was Kiyohara-no-Kiyohira, the sole survivor out of the
brothers who had begun the conflict. Given Kiyohira's unique circumstances, having the
blood of the Kanto bushi on his father's side, the former lords of Mutsu, the Abe clan, on his
mother's side, and being the adopted son of the current lords of the north, the Kiyohara clan,
he was in almost a perfect position to finally unite the Tohoku region and bring about an era
of peace. After the war ended, he changed his family name back to that of his biological father,
becoming Fujiwara-no-Kiyohira, and establishing the century-long northern dynasty remembered to
history as the Ōshū Fujiwara, with Ōshū being an old-fashioned word for the Tohoku region.
He established his base in a place called Hiraizumi, and dedicated the remaining decades
of his life to attempting to build his vision of a holy Buddhist kingdom in northern Japan.
His experience losing his father in the former Nine Years' War and his wife and firstborn son
in the later Three Years' War, as well as witnessing so many others perish in the two
conflicts, left an indelible impact on Kiyohira, which pushed him deeply into the arms of the
Buddhist faith. In addition to rebuilding the ravaged Tohoku region, he spent the rest of his
life engaged in temple building and praying for the souls of all those lost in the two great northern
wars. One of the fruits of his labor, the temple complex of Chūsonji, is a UNESCO World Heritage
Site which can still be visited today, and is crowned by perhaps the most famous of Kiyohira's
construction projects, the Golden Temple known as the Konjiki-do, which houses the remains of
Kiyohira and three generations of his descendants, and stands as something of a monument to the
tragedy of Japan's Bushi Wars of the late Heian Period. And that, my friends, is a very brief
summary of how the people whom we know today as the samurai made their first appearance on the
pages of Japanese history. I'm sure few of you are surprised that we did not in fact make it to the
Insei Era, the era of cloistered government by retired emperors, but that will just have to be
something for us to look forward to in our next episode. In addition to that, sometime in the near
future, I'm hoping to do a couple deep dive episodes on some of the events we looked at in
this episode, particularly on the final two conflicts, the former Nine Years and later Three
Years Wars in northern Japan. These are events that don't seem to have really been covered much
at all in English on YouTube, and there are a ton of really fascinating details about them that I
couldn't even hope to squeeze into an overview video like this one. For example, I couldn't
really find a good place in today's script to explain why the former Nine Years and later Three
Years Wars were both longer than their names suggest. The short answer is that it was probably
a calculation error by later chroniclers, but if you want the long answer, well that's something I
would love to get into in a deep dive video. I haven't yet decided exactly when I'm going to do
this video, but please let me know in the comments if it's something you'd like to see.
If it seems like there's some interest, then I'll try to get on it sooner rather than later.
Anyway, as always, there will be a Japanese mnemonic for remembering one of the important
dates from this video at the end of the outro here, and if you enjoyed the video, please don't
forget to like, subscribe, and drop a comment. I really do appreciate you making it all the way
to the end here, so thanks for watching, have a great day, and HUUUM OINORUZU!
