The French Revolution was inspired by the American Revolution in its principles of liberty and equality instead of a monarchy. However, the humanistic ideas of the Enlightenment which inspired French revolutionaries made them rebel against all traditions, including religion and time-honored wisdom. An article in The Epoch Times called “Happy Bastille Day? Not for Many French Then or Now” describes how the French Revolution differed from the American Revolution by putting the general cause of freedom above the liberty and safety of the individual.
Cherishing personal liberty is not a good thing if it comes at the price of sacrificing all tradition and wisdom from the past. In his essay "Self-Reliance," Ralph Waldo Emerson talks about the importance of individualism and being true to oneself, as opposed to following a group or going along with the popular thing to do. Although there is a lot of truth in what he wrote, his idea that each person should follow only his own will is dangerous without a higher law of morality. This problem is similar to an issue we're facing today with advancing AI technology. The rights and autonomy of the individual human being are being threatened by the lack of guidelines or restrictions on AI. #mentalhealth#mind#bodyhealth#health#healthcare#healthandwellness#bodyhealthy#wellbeing#wellness#show#talkshow#traditional#american#america#healthbenefits
Welcome to Epoch Insights with Tiffany. My name is Tiffany Brannan.
A friend of mine recently was asking about the difference between the French Revolution and the
American Revolution. Was the French Revolution a good thing, he asked? It was more of a philosophical
question than an actual wanting to know about history, sort of, what was my opinion on it.
And I had a few thoughts, but it struck me as rather an interesting coincidence when in,
I don't think the next, but a very soon issue of the Epoch Times, there was an article about this
issue. It's called Happy Bastille Day? Not for many French then or now. It talks about the fact
that the French Revolution has been glamorized in some ways. It seems like it was standing for
something good. As Americans, we should be very happy about the French Revolution. After all,
they were imitating our revolution in trying to overthrow a monarchy and establish a democracy,
a society where all men could be equal. However, the biggest difference between
the French Revolution and the American Revolution was the spirit and the philosophical idea
behind these. The end result, or rather the goal, may have been the same, but there were some
different underlying beliefs, and the circumstances were rather different. America was a colony
miles a different continent away from our ruler, our king, whereas the French had to overthrow
the monarchs right there in their own country. And they were overturning customs, traditions,
and institutions which had existed for centuries, whereas the United States, or rather the American
colonies at that time, had no real traditions to overthrow. That was the whole spirit of the thing.
America was a new land, a new country, so it called out for a new kind of government.
The fact that the French Revolution was overthrowing something old and long-established
was one of its core problems. The article describes that July 14th is the National Day in France,
it's their Independence Day, known as Fête Nationale Francaise in French, and it's similar to our
Fourth of July. It's called Bastille Day, not in France, but in English-speaking countries,
in recognition of the breaking of the Bastille prison tower in Paris in 1789.
That was really just the beginning, more of a symbol, just as July 4th for the United States was
just the beginning of the fight for independence with the Declaration of Independence.
The breaking of the Bastille was similar to the Boston Tea Party, a sign of that the people
wanted change more than something which had a huge impact or a big actual cause and effect.
One of the reasons for this French Revolution was the great deal of unrest which was arising
in the country at the time. It was because of poor politics. A king who was greatly in debt and just
didn't care about the problems of his people or even understand, he just cared about throwing
lavish parties at Versailles. There were also crippling debt problems which were especially
bad for the peasants and the poor working class. This article points out that these class divisions,
inequality of wealth, and the tax exemptions of the rich were things which caused a great
deal of unrest amongst the common people, and that just led to the sort of situation
which can breed a revolution. Nevertheless, the revolution wasn't just seeking to reform the
lower taxes, get rid of the monarchy, and equalize the citizens. It was a purpose to create an
entirely new social order, different from traditions which had existed in Western Europe
for generations and centuries, really since the beginning of the Christianization of that region.
Three traditional French social foundations were overthrown during the French Revolution.
The monarchy, of course, aristocracy, but also church authority. And that doesn't mean that the
country turned Protestant by overthrowing Catholicism. It was rebelling against Christianity,
morality, and the tradition which had lasted and sustained that country for years.
Whereas the colonies in America wanted to break away from England, first in founding
those colonies and then in becoming a sovereign nation, to worship God, to have freedom of
worship, to not be controlled, because many of those original founders were either Puritans
or Pilgrims, which were distinct Protestant religious groups which were different Christian
denominations from the Church of England. And at that time in England, you could be greatly
persecuted for worshipping in any other form of Christianity besides the established Church
of England. In France, this call for freedom and independence was similar to the rebellion of a
teenager who's going against all the traditions that his parents have had.
Rather than a mature, wise, thoughtful choice to give up certain ideas, it was a reckless,
impassioned move away from traditions which perhaps were good, because some of the things
happening in the country were bad, like the tax situation and the debt, the wanton spending of
the rich and their vain lifestyle. The people began to feel that all these customs were bad.
The French Revolution was closely aligned with the Enlightenment movement.
The word Enlightenment doesn't seem like a horrible thing, it means that you're becoming
more aware of things, you're becoming more conscious of good versus evil. Unfortunately,
Enlightened was just the 18th century version of what we would call woke now. Both of them mean
to have a brightening, being more awake and aware, yet they also tend to mean giving up
traditions of the past and thinking only of the current modern thing, because it's believed that
some evils which exist in society were closely connected to those traditions.
One of the great influencers in that revolution was Alexis de Tocqueville. Alexis de Tocqueville
wrote, in France, the spirit of religion and the spirit of freedom marched in opposite directions.
Because it was believed that the church must also be abandoned, Christianity was persecuted during
the French Revolution. The clergymen were stripped of their property and even the beautiful cathedral
Notre-Dame in Paris was desecrated. The Christian altar was dismantled and replaced by an
altar to the secular and ideal of Enlightenment and liberty, its doorway dedicated to philosophy.
This was around the same time that people were saying, I think, therefore I am,
as opposed to the Christian idea, God made me, therefore I am. The whole idea of the
French Revolution was that each man would have freedom. This was based on Rousseau's teaching.
The motto of the French Revolution was liberté, égalité, fraternité, which means liberty, equality,
and fraternity or brotherhood. But this is actually very similar to Marxism, which would
develop with Karl Marx in the next century. In the cause for equality and fraternity,
liberty is often sacrificed, that is, personal liberty. The article describes that Rousseauian
contract of the revolutionary France often required the individual to sacrifice his personal liberty
and his own will for his life to the greater good, to force him to be free.
In the Life and Tradition section, there's an article with a related topic. It's called
Privileging the Individual Over the Collective. This article is talking about an essay by Ralph
Waldo Emerson, written in 1841. It's called Self-Reliance. I remember reading it and other
writings of Emerson in school. This article gives a very similar conclusion and summary of his work
as my curriculum did, which was a Christian curriculum, talking about the conflicting
ideas which Mr. Emerson portrayed. Some of his ideas are very sound and encouraging,
but like the French Revolution, there's a dangerous aversion to tradition in his ideas.
Now, as opposed to the French Revolution, he was absolutely opposed to conforming to any kind of
group, hence the title Self-Reliance. In this 10,000-word essay, he described all the different
ways that conforming to the ideas of the day, the public good, the popular trends for how to behave,
were just the most horrible thing you could do. As a matter of fact, the only way, he said, that you
could live according to any kind of decency or happiness was to follow the only will or guide
any man can have, his own conscience and his own idea of self, his own truth. I think that you
could say his whole work is just an elaboration on Shakespeare's very popular saying,
and this above all, to thine own self be true. He goes on to describe that it's
fallacy to try to adopt every kind of good that's out there, every charity, every kindness, to always
agree with people and smile, because, he says, your goodness must have some edge to it, else it is
none. It's better to have a true feeling and express it about people you know than the example he gives
of pretending like you have great sympathy for natives in a far-off country. He said oftentimes
this is just a cover-up for bigotry, and it's very insincere. It's better to be honest about
bigotry or about the fact that you're indifferent to people who live in some far-off country.
In the essay, he laments that the charities are always trying to get people to give dollars here
and there to causes which they say should be your greatest concern, when they have absolutely no
bearing on an individual person's life, whether it's for missionaries or poverty, the college of
foolish men, as he says, and he admits that he himself has given an occasional dollar here and
there to such causes only because he didn't have the inner strength. I agree with him on
almost all of those points. He was talking about not being a victim, not letting people convince
you to act a certain way. However, I have to disagree with him on the point that he goes a
little too far in saying that we must each be a god to ourselves and the idea that there is an
internal immutable truth in each person that is good. It's true that each person has his own nature
and we do all have a conscience, but there is something to be learned from the traditions and
the wisdom of the past. We need to have our own nature and our own wisdom to be able to determine
whether we believe something, but it's also important to have a strong moral compass that's
outside of just what do I feel like doing, because if you take his idea of doing what you want and
being true to yourself too far, you can end up in the situation we have now, where people are
always talking about follow your own truth and live your own truth. The idea that truth
is something personal rather than an eternal truth upon which all can agree.
It would also be the beginning of anarchy if you go along with his idea, because each person's
truth may not agree with any kind of morality. One person might say that it is completely
following his own nature to be a murderer or to be a thief. If his natural inclination is to steal
his neighbor's property, it would be wrong for him to go against it. One person's nature might go
against someone else, as we see in the nature of animals. Although there are certain laws of the
pack, there also are animals which wantonly kill each other. And to have any kind of civilization,
there must be some kind of higher truth, some higher morality, something upon which we can agree.
Although depending on the state or one individual, one group of public opinion to tell you everything
you should do is just as wrong as thinking it's fine to kill people or or rob people.
We need to make our own decisions, but measure them against the wisdom of the ages and of a
higher being and of faith and tradition to know what we need to do. Being self-reliant without
some kind of a higher purpose can often lead to folly. In that same school book, I remember that
after the works by Emerson, there were some works by Henry David Thoreau, who was
almost an apprentice of his. Emerson mentored the younger Thoreau. Thoreau's most famous work
is Walden, which he wrote by the Walden Pond. He too wrote about self-reliance and
getting away from civilization, rebelling, being independent, and not going along with conformity.
Nevertheless, he wrote that while he was living in the house that belonged to Emerson
on Walden Pond. So that wasn't particularly self-reliant. If he hadn't had that situation,
he couldn't have just been sitting around writing a book. He was in a situation where someone
was basically supporting him, so he didn't have to be in part of the workaday world.
Just as Emerson couldn't have had many of his ideas if he hadn't read the works of others,
and the French Revolution wouldn't have had the infrastructure that it had if the country
hadn't already been built. A lot of that work having been done by the aristocracy
and the monarchy and the church, which they were so eager to overthrow.
This article about Emerson mentions the Luddites. That's a term we hear tossed around a lot
nowadays. Either Ludditism or Neo-Ludditism. What is it? I wasn't really sure, so I decided
to look them up and see what they really are. The article mentions that Emerson's essay also
speaks to techno-authoritarianism. Contemporaries of his, the Luddites, weren't, as it is widely
believed, against technology, but against its mindless use. Like Emerson, they were proud and
protective of man's empathy, critical thinking, and ethical intelligence. To outsource that was
to surrender a critical part of humanity. The Luddites were actually a little bit before
Emerson wrote this. They were mainly in the very late 18th century, and the whole Luddite
movement came to a head around 1816 in England. They were textile workers who were basically
rebelling against what you could call the automation of the day. The use of frames to
create stockings and other woollen wear. If we saw such a frame now, it would seem like an
exceptionally old-fashioned kind of handiwork to be able to make something on this old frame.
Yet before that, these textile workers made stockings without any kind of frame, and it took
much longer and a lot more skill. With the introduction of these frames, they were
rather concerned that they wouldn't be paid as much, or they wouldn't have as much work,
less skilled workers would be brought in, so that they could do it faster and with less pay.
So it really was a form of a union strike, if you would. But these workers were spread out
across the countryside, so they didn't really have any kind of union or other way to come
together. So what they did was break these frames. They would communicate with each other,
sometimes by letters, or they would meet out in the middle of the night in the fields or in the
bogs, and they would oftentimes, one of them would write a letter to the owner of the works,
or sometimes a factory, but it often was smaller than a factory, and it would be signed,
Ned Ludd. This was a fictional character, but there's an old story among textile workers
that there was this young man who was making some textiles, and he was being criticized
for his work, and he grew so angry that he broke the frame in a burst of anger. So whenever a frame
or something would go wrong in textile works, it was a joke at the time to say, oh, Ned Ludd's at
it again. So they were saying it was Ned Ludd who was going around and breaking all these frames.
It was quite effective because it was the one way that workers could strike back before unions,
and it happened in many different situations where workers didn't like that machines were
being brought in to, they thought, replace them or at least lessen their handiwork,
and they were certain that this would make the goods of a lesser quality, and it was disrespectful
to their very trade. So they would write these letters and sign them and say we're going to keep
breaking these things until you get rid of them. It was somewhat effective. As a matter of fact,
it made such a big impact that the government ended up sending in thousands of military troops
to tell them to stop, and eventually it escalated to some killing. For the most part, the Luddites
just went after the machinery, but there were a couple of instances of times where they actually
shot some of the employees, or rather their employers, who were the owners of the factory,
mainly this one man who said that he was going to stop this revolution until he was up to his
saddle in Luddite blood, so he ended up getting shot. And the punishment for the people who were
involved, 60 people were rounded up, many of whom weren't even involved, and 30 of them were found
guilty and were given very severe punishment. This was enough to convince the Luddites to stop
for then. But their idea and the spirit behind their movement has continued, and it's become
just a phrase for someone who rejects technology. It's more appropriate to use it as a phrase for
someone who rejects automation or who fears that automation could replace important jobs,
thus leaving the goods with less quality and making human beings have less meaningful work to do.
The Neo-Luddite movement sprung up in the late 20th century, particularly in the 1990s,
and it goes much further than the original Luddites. Rather than just about work, it
is different in different cases, but the main idea is to be against any kind of electromagnetic
technology, electronic technology. You could consider the Amish and Mennonites a form of
Luddites, but they do it for religious reasons, whereas Neo-Luddites often do it either for
the desire for a return for a simpler life, some of them do it for environmental reasons.
But the founder of this new movement has wrote a manifesto on it in 1990,
and has encouraged people to abandon dangerous technology and sort of trying to encourage
governments to realize that there is a wanton use and development of technology beyond what is
Now, some people in this movement are extremists who do wish to return to an era from a few
centuries ago, which works very well in some small communities. It's not likely to happen
on a large scale in a whole country, but many Amish communities are very successful and happy.
But these people often say to have no communications, that would be no telephones,
no internet, no refrigeration, no chemical development, most of medicines wouldn't be used,
no bioengineering of foods. I think a lot of people would agree that many of those things
wouldn't be a bad idea to abolish, or at least control. But the idea behind it,
in its simplest form and its most practical, is to not introduce technology to the world,
whether that's a form of medicine or a form of computer technology, without being completely
sure of its safety. And one must acknowledge that especially with the rapid development of
internet technology in the last couple of decades, there has been little to no testing to see what
effect this is going to have on people. As we're seeing a generation or two dealing with the
effects, we're beginning to realize, oh, this causes brain damage, this causes cancer,
this causes developmental defects. I guess we've just maimed a whole generation, but we didn't
stop to think about it, or to consider what kind of effects this could have, not only physically,
but psychologically, emotionally, spiritually, and environmentally. And I don't mean the
environment of the earth, although that is something to consider. I mean the environment
of society. What are certain things doing to the world? I think the issue on which the most people
are neoluddites is AI, artificial intelligence, to the point that Hollywood has had a couple of
major strikes which have crippled the entertainment industry for months on end,
because actors, writers, and other people who do real work in the industry are extremely concerned
that computer-generated imagery, which has always been around, is now going to be coupled with
artificial intelligence to basically put them all out of work. As we see, chat GPT can write,
it's not Shakespeare, but it can come up with sentences, and that same artificial intelligence
can create deep fake videos which look exactly like politicians, actors, even just your friends
and family if you just want to mess around with it. If that kind of technology is available,
yeah, you could have Tom Hanks continuing to act in movie after movie with scripts that
computers have written. When Tom Hanks wasn't there, no writers were used, and basically it's
just a completely computer-generated film. This is of concern to actors. It's also of concern to
writers, because they don't want to be put out of work. As usual, the film industry in Hollywood
has a much bigger mouth than a lot of the smaller industries which have already been wiped out,
or at least greatly threatened by artificial intelligence. As far back as 1957, we see movies
like Desk Set, starring Spencer Tracy and Catherine Hepburn, their second to last film together.
Although we don't think of computers as being the force that they are now, this movie is all about
a research department at a big television broadcasting network where the four women who
work in that research department are afraid that their jobs are going to be taken away
when a new electromagnetic computer moves in. They've already seen how accounting has been
replaced by this huge calculator, basically. Dozens of jobs disappeared as one huge machine moved in.
This is a computer which can translate Russian to Chinese and can come up with all this information
in a few seconds, whereas it would take days or weeks for people to do the research in the books.
Nevertheless, this film shows the fallacy of thinking you can replace all human beings with
machines, because as Spencer Tracy's character, who is the computer genius who developed it,
says, the computer can only repeat information that was put into it. It can't reason. Now,
people say AI can reason, but that's only because it can come up with creatively phrased answers,
which it has gleaned from all over the internet. It really is plagiarism software. It's just
gleaning from all over the internet, and that's why you can tell it doesn't have the originality
that human writing would have. The other day, I was trying to find out about a song that I knew
from the 1920s with the title Hello. I tried searching it in the regular Bing search engine,
nothing really came up. Then I tried searching it in Copilot, which is sort of the AI partner that
goes along with the Bing search engine, and it came up with the answer. And I thought to myself,
oh, it's funny. When I watched the old Arthur cartoons and they show people at the library
on the computer, they typed in a question and it came up with the answer instantly.
Now, I wasn't alive then, so I don't know if that's what computers were like, but
I think that before there was more introduction of search engine optimization and advertising,
really just weaponizing the internet, you used to be able to find information more.
Now, we've all forgotten that that's what the computer was supposed to be. Back in 1957,
in Desk Set, you type in a question, it gives you the answer. Now, it's nothing but ads,
so it gives you an answer and you say, oh, it's something brand new, artificial intelligence.
That's what computers were supposed to be. You ask it a question, it looks through all
its archives and gives you the answer. But, as Spencer Tracy's character points out,
it's the human element which can make it wrong. It's only repeating information
that people put into it. This article describes that people are saying computers may have a higher
moral level than people because they don't have the emotions and the jealousies which
make people so devious at times, as we mentioned, following your own truth
or someone else's higher truth. But that's the problem here. Who determines this higher truth,
this higher sense of morality to which computers are going to be holding us?
If the people who program it don't have any morality, how are the people who are getting
information from it going to glean some kind of wisdom from it? Computers can be a useful tool,
just like a frame to make a stocking can, but they must be held under control and they shouldn't
be used to replace people, only to help. And they should never be allowed to replace
artistic things because that's our tradition, that's our culture. There's something so beautiful
about doing something yourself, even if it's more imperfect, whether that's baking a cake,
writing a poem, making a painting. The naturalness is what makes it real.
Right after this argument I was having with the same friend who was asking about the French
Revolution, about artificial intelligence, saying he likes to use ChatGPT to write descriptions of
opera concerts for Facebook. And I said, oh, I can tell when you've done that. He said, oh, I know,
you know, everyone can, but it's so much easier. It saves me time. Just a few days after that,
I was listening to two photographer friends of mine discussing why they like using real
film sometimes as opposed to digital, because it has a different look. It's real. Just like
they like to use a real drummer for background music in a movie as opposed to something
synthesized. It's more expensive, but you've given an artist work and he got pleasure from it,
and there's a spontaneity to it. The desired order that artificial intelligence seems to be
trying to impose on us isn't something we have to just lie down and allow. Emerson was trying
to remind us years ago to not blindly go along with every technological advance that comes along.
It is a choice, and we can all decide that we don't want to use technology that isn't helping
us. If enough of us say that's not the technology we want or that's not how we want to use it,
a few technological geniuses won't be able to control the whole humanity if we all are
listening to that inner voice that tells us that we need to have our personal liberty and not
sacrifice that individual liberty for some perceived greater good. Thank you for spending
this time with me. I hope you enjoyed this discussion of liberty, self-reliance, and the
dangers of blindly allowing technology to run our world. If you enjoyed this episode, I hope that
you'll leave a comment letting me know what you'd like me to cover in the future, like this video,
subscribe to our channel, and share it with your friends. Have a wonderful day!