Environmental liability: Canada's new risk reality

Business Insurance
4 followers
4 Video Views·Apr 3, 2026
Canada’s environmental insurance market is facing a major shift as the federal government moves to classify PFAS as toxic under CEPA, raising urgent questions around exclusions, legacy contamination and coverage certainty.
In this 2026 Insurance Business TV panel, leaders from Gallagher, Willis and Aon explain how tightening regulation, rising contractor pollution requirements and broader definitions of “pollutant” are driving demand, reshaping underwriting and pushing environmental insurance firmly into the mainstream.
AI Generated·May contain errors
The biggest thing is figuring out what work needs to be done to quantify the historical piece.
Bottom line, it's everywhere.
If you do have a policy that is operational, that does not have a PFAS exclusion,
there is still potential that coverage is not there because the PFAS has been on site
for such a long time.
Hello everyone, and welcome to Insurance Business TV as we reunite our power panel
for the first environmental insurance discussion of 2026.
Let's meet our team, shall we?
We have Shauna Larvie, Senior Vice President, National Practice Leader, Environmental at
Gallagher.
Amanda Modica, Director, Head of Environmental and Professional Broking at Willis.
And Justin Perry, Senior Vice President, National Practice Leader, Environmental Resolutions
at Aon.
So welcome everyone, and to get the ball rolling, the federal government has concluded,
this is a big one, that the entire class of PFAS is toxic under CEPA
and is moving toward phased prohibitions on the manufacture, use, sale, and import,
starting with firefighting foams and then broader consumer and industrial applications.
So I want to find out from each of you, how is this evolving PFAS regime changing your
approach to site pollution, product pollution, and legacy contamination exposures in your
Canadian environmental policies?
Sean, do you want to start for us?
Sure, Paul.
Obviously, the PFAS discussion has been pretty prevalent in the last five to 10 years.
With us being in Canada, there is a renewed focus on the March 2025 investigation PFAS
report that was done by the federal government.
But when you're looking at PFAS, obviously the pain points around the insurability really
stand out, specifically around the historical contamination piece and uncharacterization
of what's in the current soil and groundwater, and potentially products that we're using
within Canada.
So if there is going to be some limitations or restrictions, I think that's going to only
be in the favor of the insured, where they're going to be able to probably protect themselves
from PFAS for future losses.
The biggest thing is figuring out what work needs to be done to quantify the historical
piece and whether it's actually attainable, given how expensive PFAS remediation is.
Bottom line, it's everywhere.
It's everywhere.
And just tell us as well, Amanda, how are insurers going about addressing this?
Like Sean said, PFAS is everywhere.
The underwriters and insurers are still excluding on a case-by-case basis in the pollution
space.
I would say we've seen an increase in added exclusions on some of the P&C lines.
And so we're having discussions on broader programs as well of what that looks like from
a PFAS coverage perspective.
The historical piece that Sean discussed is also super crucial to consider, because even
if you have an operational policy with no PFAS exclusion, the chances of that PFAS being
used historically on site, and we as the consumer not being able to quantify or qualify
how long that's actually been on site, is very challenging.
And so if you do have a policy that is operational, that does not have a PFAS exclusion, there
is still potential that coverage is not there because the PFAS has been on site for such
a long time.
And Justin, from your perspective, is this just another pollutant or not?
Yes, essentially from the environmental insurer's perspective, it is just another pollutant.
There are areas of concern, of course.
Is there knowledge of use at the premises?
Are there environmental investigations that actually review PFAS use or PFAS presence?
So those are some of the data gaps that would be treated no different than any other data
gap when we talk about coverage or exclusions.
But with adequate data, we're seeing this treated like any other pollutant.
Where there is a strong exclusionary consideration is with regards to products and casualty products,
where they're not just trying to exclude the pollutant, which is already a base exclusion
under a casualty policy with a giveback, but they're looking to exclude it from products
liability and your completed ops exposure as well.
So that's where we're seeing affirmative PFAS exclusions in the casualty world and
then bringing it back to an environmental policy, whether data exists or the client's
operations are consistent with the availability of coverage.
So data is key.
Do you know if it's present and how are you using it?
Perhaps some good news from the broker standpoint out there is that some Canadian market commentary
has been indicating that environmental insurance has kind of made a move recently from fringe
to the mainstream, particularly, of course, with regulators tightening their oversight
and in cleanup costs escalating.
So I'd love to know from your perspective over the past few quarters, what changes have
you seen in terms of demand limits, minimum standards, perhaps for CPL and premises pollution
among Canadian contractors and developers?
And indeed, how are you helping new entrants to understand what isn't covered?
What are you seeing out there, Amanda?
What we're seeing specifically from a contracting client standpoint is that previously not necessarily
high risk operations are now being asked to carry a CPL or a contractor's pollution
policy for upcoming projects and tenders.
What we have been doing with several of our clients in the last couple of months is really
educating around, should we be looking at a project specific placement for this particular
project or tender?
Or should we be contemplating a broader practice annual contractor's pollution policy to kind
of encompass all of their operations?
And then obviously the pros and cons between the two programs.
And really, when we are looking at that practice versus project, we can relieve some of the
administrative burden of placing one-off project policies as tenders come up.
So the education piece around those options is really important.
And Justin, just tell us about where you're seeing the conversations here.
Have you seen a similar spike in interest?
Oh, absolutely.
We've seen multiple factor increase in interest driven by third-party requirements primarily,
and then client curiosity.
So the conversation, as Amanda alluded to, the conversation also involves what is this
insurance going to do for me, not just how am I going to be compliant?
So if you're focusing on a product, especially a contractor's environmental liability product
or a premises product, you can extract more coverage out of it that is beneficial to
yourself as well as the contracted party that's requiring.
So we're getting just better risk transfers overall.
So if clients want to know what's in it for them, I guess there's a little bit of an education
piece here, Sean.
For sure.
And I think like Amanda and Justin already spoke very highly on this stuff.
It's like there's obviously the component around educating them around the requirement
and what they need from a compliance standpoint or a contract standpoint, but then it's also
like what do you also need to properly protect your business, right?
So there's a lot of forms, a lot of products out there, and there's a lot of ways to kind
of carve some risk transfer.
But what I've noticed, at least from the clients that we've been servicing, is that businesses
that typically have low exposure ratings are being asked to carry this kind of coverage.
And that approach is from businesses just trying to transfer liability wherever they
can, right?
So whether that's coming from the municipality or the lender, it's becoming increasingly
difficult for our clients to negotiate that out, which is obviously driving more opportunity
into the marketplace and allowing us to kind of educate people that are more interested
in hearing about it.
Well, perhaps in line with this concept of increased demand, we did see back in August
last year one top insurer launch an environmental protection insurance coverage product, which
combines general liability and environmental liability with what's described as full pollution
and product pollution coverages.
So alongside similar GL environmental forms in the market, I'd love to know, how is this
convergence influencing how you structure Canadian environmental programs, deciding
when to use integrated forms versus standard EIL?
And indeed, how can brokers explain residual pollution gaps on traditional GL policies?
Justin, any thoughts on this?
Certainly.
So these combined or integrated casualty and environmental products have been around for
a long time.
They go back 40, 45 years being the first ones that have come out, and they've evolved.
I think where we're seeing a significant shift is the casualty markets are starting to restrict
or limit specific contaminants such as PFAS across their policies, not relying on the
pollution exclusion that's built into the casualty policy, and therefore having a total
pollution exclusion for a specific chemical across the products and completed operations.
As a result, these integrated products remove that separation or that gap, if you want,
that exists of environmental product liability.
And they offer a solution where the casualty is not readily available.
The environmental product liability is available in the environmental marketplace as a standalone
or integrated into an environmental product already to augment an existing casualty product.
So you have two different themes that we're touching on, but I expect this will be a slow
uptick, but it will be an increasing area.
Interesting stuff.
And I imagine, Sean, as well, just from what Justin's described there, that choosing the
right policy is going to be very, very client specific.
Yeah, Paul, it's very much an approach by client by client, right?
So there's obviously multiple aspects to consider when you're looking at a combined solution
versus standalone is, part of it is like, what is the insurability piece or how can
the client benefit from a combined product?
Because there are obviously certain segments, at least from a product's liability side,
that could really use that additional coverage for the product's environmental coverage.
The other thing is the state of the market.
Obviously, as the market fluctuates, if we're able to get some pretty favorable pricing
at the same premiums that the clients are paying, why not look to kind of split out
those limits, have a dedicated limit?
And those dedicated products, usually those forms are broader.
So it requires less manuscripting from the carrier side and from us negotiating on the
broker side.
And I would say the last thing around these combined products is like the lead time and
the urgency around the requests.
Typically, these types of products require multiple input from multiple underwriters
or product heads.
And that holistic solution could take a lot of time to kind of put together from the information
gathering to the negotiating and the underwriting approach.
Definitely, as a place, as Justin mentioned, we are definitely seeing it uptake a little
bit.
But we'll see how it transpires over the next year or so.
And it seems, Amanda, like the butt here, if you want, is that there is the potential
for some gaps in coverage.
So how can they be avoided?
Absolutely.
Both of these gentlemen have spoken about there really is a sweet spot where the combined
form makes sense.
It's competitive and it's providing the right coverage extensions.
I think what we need to ensure we're doing for our clients' unique exposures is making
sure that the lines of business, pollution and casualty products, et cetera, are not
working in silos.
And we are, like Sean mentioned, working holistically to come up with that solution that best suits
our clients' exposures.
And that's the best way to avoid having gaps in coverage or potential blind spots in the
program, is working alongside our colleagues and the other lines of placement to ensure
that we are identifying and essentially covering off those exposures as they come up.
We are, of course, seeing regulatory expectations rise at federal, provincial, municipal levels.
So how are you seeing insurers update their underwriting guidelines, their policy forms
and indeed broker client training in order to keep Canadian contractors ahead of these
compliance-driven pollution liabilities?
Sean, what are you seeing the insurers do?
Yeah, I think that's kind of always a moving target, Paul.
I think depending on loss performance and history of that particular insurer, we might
see some limitations or restrictions.
But at least from what we can do from a broking standpoint is continue to have multiple touch
points with our markets on a daily and weekly basis.
Because if we know that something is going to change in terms of their position of risk
or it might impact the clients that they currently serve, then we need to kind of get ahead of
it.
Because as we've kind of already mentioned before, it's a pretty soft market.
There is a lot of capacity and appetite throughout it.
And we want to make sure that our clients are not limiting their coverages and only
looking to broaden where we can.
So I think it's just all about touch points and making sure that you have your ear on
the market.
Yeah, of course, you've got to think of what's important for the client.
But Amanda as well, I suppose you've got to think about what the underwriters want to
see here as well.
Well, that's the beauty of being a broker.
You're in between the insurers and the clients.
So having those off-cycle conversations is super important to have with both your market
partners and with your clients so that we can continue to educate as those regulatory
changes come into effect.
In terms of underwriting guidelines, I would say it's important for us as brokers to show
our insurers how our clients are, especially our contracting clients, are managing their
risk and operating within the regulatory framework.
And whether that's sharing additional QA, QC, spill response prevention, stormwater
or sediment control documentation, I think looking beyond just the initial scope of work
and actually taking into consideration what environmental controls and processes our
contracting clients have in place is really important to be showing our market partners.
And Justin as well, I mean, with these guidelines changing, is it actually a struggle now to
make clients fit these insurer guidelines?
I don't think it's necessarily a struggle due to the availability of capacity and the
soft market at the moment.
I think what happens is every insurer is trying to find an edge, why they can compete more
aggressively on a specific risk or to insure a specific client.
And so it's up to us to present the client in the best light and to show the insurers
what that edge is that the client has or what controls they have in place.
So getting more granular on the protections, the quality assurance, quality controls, as
Amanda mentioned, the competencies of the client, the practices they've been doing for
20, 30, 50 years that we've never had to express before.
These things make very small competitive changes in today's landscape where that wouldn't
have had a significant impact years ago.
I think that's one aspect.
The other aspect is that every insurer is trying to figure out where it can be the most
successful with the underwriters and the underwriting comprehensiveness that they have.
So even where the insurers choose to deploy their capacity, how much capacity they're
deploying is becoming much more siloed or fractured.
So before, a contractor's environmental liability for 80 different operations would
have been one price or one strategy in terms of limit insurability.
And now that can be broken down into 10, 20, 30 different approaches.
So it's trying to fit those boxes.
They're trying to understand where the client best fits an insurer's appetite.
While many things may be changing, one thing that definitely isn't is that Canadian
brokers, of course, will always highlight that even very common materials, which is
oil, salt, diesel, wastewater, can trigger environmental liability.
So I'd love to know from each of you in your recent portfolio experience, how are those
everyday contaminants shaping appetite, pricing, the way you position environmental liability
products to SMEs, property developers, lenders, anybody, I suppose, who might underestimate
the pollution exposure.
So yeah, how are you positioning them, Amanda?
I think that everybody here would agree the general client population really looks at
pollutants sometimes very narrowly.
And a pollutant can literally be anything.
One of my favourite examples that I like to share with clients and prospects is silt and
sedimentation.
So we've discussed our contracting clients a lot today.
And at a construction site, loose sand, clay, dirt that can potentially run off site after
a major rainstorm or a rain event could potentially be a pollutant if it is running into a nearby
waterway.
And these are things that we don't necessarily think of when your mind goes to pollutants.
But I think thinking more broadly about what a pollutant is provides us with an opening
to have those discussions with clients and prospects on their potential pollution exposure.
And one way if they are underestimating if they do in fact have an exposure, I think
is sharing claims examples, real life examples where there has been payouts under pollution
policies, potentially to our clients and prospects' peers in the industry.
To share that knowledge and those claims examples I think goes a long way in helping to explain
those potential exposures.
Yeah, and to Amanda's point there, Justin, you've really got to establish what a pollutant
is here, haven't you?
Absolutely.
As Amanda mentioned, some of the natural features or even augmented features that have occurred.
I've even seen drinking water be a pollutant.
I've seen water going from one lake to another area be a pollutant because there was a different
biological and chemical constitution.
So you have to look beyond just what is the product.
But is this product supposed to be in the area that it's found?
So are you moving something from one site to another or from one area to another where
it is no longer welcome in that receiving site?
That's really the key.
That is what we look at as a pollution.
What is a deleterious substance, a substance that shouldn't be present at this location
or that we have moved to this location?
So it's not just the puff of smoke that we see or the sheen of oil on water.
It goes far beyond that now.
It always has, but that's where the markets are getting at in their review.
Yeah, so obviously these pollutants can be found anywhere, Sean.
But explaining them sometimes, that's got to be highly technical, hasn't it?
Yeah, Paul.
It's really technical from a standpoint of being able to understand environmental
investigation or what a consultant is doing on site and why they're doing it and the rationale
behind it.
I think like Justin already alluded to this earlier in our call is the quality of information
is really important because obviously that speaks back to the insurability.
But it also can have a negative connotation around it because there might be some assumptions
made by the client for things that are covered that are not actually covered.
And that's why there's a cause and effect on everything that is done in the space.
If you're hiring a poor quality contractor or a consultant to do the work for you and
they're not really on their game and they haven't done it the right way, that's going
to affect you down the chain.
And our purpose as brokers is to obviously paint the best picture and the best light
for our clients.
And sometimes that becomes increasingly challenging if there's been no consideration around
environmental risk in what they're doing.
So don't think it's really affecting the price too much.
As Justin said, there's telemarkets available and there's a lot of capacity out there and
markets willing to take a risk.
It's just how we paint that picture and what's out there.
Thank you.
You've all done a wonderful job of painting a picture for us today.
Great thoughts indeed.
Huge thanks to everyone for their time.
Remember, this team will be back every quarter throughout 2026.
So keep it right here on Insurance Business TV.
