The Rise of New Conservatism [APUSH Review]

Cultures Uncovered
10 followers
3 Video Views·Apr 3, 2026
In this video, Heimler walks you through everything you need to know about APUSH Unit 8 Topic 14 (8.14) which is all about how a new movement of political, economic, and social conservatives rejected the ideals of modern liberalism that had been so dominant in the New Deal and Great Society eras by emphasizing a return to traditional social values and a transfer of power from the federal government to state governments.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Well, by conservative reckoning in the 1960s, it was high time to bag up the stupid liberalism of
the New Deal and Great Society era, put it by the curb, and let a guy in a jumpsuit take it
to the dump where it would be a last return from the stanky chasm from whence it came.
So it's time to talk about it, and if you're ready to get them brain cows milked, let's get to it.
Okay, so hopefully I've established in the last few videos that the multitudinous policies that
made up the Great Society represented the golden age of modern American liberalism.
Like, you couldn't go anywhere in the 1960s without bumping into a liberal policy.
And then in addition to that, the 1960s was a decade of enormous cultural upheaval that
included the civil rights movement and the discarding of social norms that came with
the youth counterculture movement, to name only a few developments.
And as it happened, the very rapidity of those changes unsettled many conservative
Americans who seemed to perceive all the change not as progress but as an existential threat.
And therefore, in the 1960s, a new conservatism began to stir and its members desired to take
back what they believed had been taken from them in the throes of civil rights and liberalism.
And that take back essentially had three prongs of attack.
First, new conservatives wanted to prevent what they perceived to be moral and cultural decline.
For example, conservatives were deeply dismayed by the discarding of sexual
norms that they witnessed in the counterculture movement and they feared that the emphasis on
casual free love would unravel the most fundamental institution of American culture, the family.
And then related to that, the growing feminist movement challenged the conservative narrative
that society thrives best when men and women embrace their natural gender roles.
And here were all these saucy women getting abortions and throwing their bras into trash
cans and letting their armpit hair grow out and worst of all, demanding social equality with men.
Or to put it another way, these conservatives felt like the civil rights movements and the
anti-war movements amounted to little more than social chaos and they aimed to bring back a sense
of normalcy to Americans. And then second, conservatives sought to limit the role of
the federal government in American society. And look, they weren't just making this up.
Recall that the New Deal greatly expanded the power of the federal government and that liberal
tide just kept rising with the flurry of federal civil rights policies and culminated in LBJ's
Great Society. And whereas liberals interpreted this stretch of 30 years as long-overdue progress
toward a more just and equitable society, conservatives interpreted it as a profound
violation of the United States' federalist structure since power had gradually shifted
away from the states and toward the national government. Therefore, a hallmark of the new
conservatism would be a strong emphasis on states' rights. And then the third emphasis
of this conservative movement was to enact a more aggressive foreign policy.
And if you've been paying attention throughout this whole unit, you might be like,
And your confusion would be justified because the Korean War, the Vietnam War,
and all the other proxy wars that were launched in the name of containing the spread of communism
really makes it seem like Americans didn't really have problems with acting aggressively
in their foreign policy. But even so, some of these new conservatives believed that the
United States needed to make full use of its power on the world stage. For example,
they attacked the gradual escalation strategy of the Vietnam War and acted mostly under a
string of liberal presidents which ultimately ended in national disgrace. And therefore,
Okay, so those are the big ideas that animated conservatives in this period. But here's where
I tell you that at the beginning of the 1960s, new conservatives were a somewhat isolated and
disjointed bunch. But at least three developments brought them together and helped give form to
their movement to give American liberalism a proper smack bottom. First was the publication
and growth of a conservative magazine called The National Review. It first emerged in 1955
as the brainchild of conservative activist William F. Buckley. And as it grew in popularity,
the publication served to unify the various strands of conservative thought,
namely the cultural traditionists, the free market libertarians, and anti-communists.
And as such, Buckley helped provide the new conservative movement with a consistent
ideological foundation to fight against what they perceived as the morally corrosive and
economically destructive effects of liberalism. And then the second development that focused the
new conservatism was the campaign of Barry Goldwater. So in the 1964 election, Goldwater
ran against Lyndon B. Johnson and in doing so became the face of this new conservative movement.
In this campaign, Goldwater attacked New Deal liberalism and advocated for the abolishment of
Social Security benefits and the progressive income tax and other policies that he believed
represented federal overreach. And in these attacks, Goldwater clearly articulated what
would become a staple of conservative politics from then on, namely an emphasis on states' rights
against the intrusion of the federal government. For example, by that reasoning, Goldwater condemned
the Brown v. Board of Education ruling as well as the Civil Rights Act of 1964 because they
represented an unconstitutional infringement of the rights of states to enact policies that
suited their own constituencies. However, as would be the case with many conservatives that
followed in Goldwater's steps, his emphasis on the reduction of federal spending was mainly
limited to liberal safety net programs like food stamps or Social Security. But when it
came to federal spending on the military, Goldwater was all for it. Anyway, ultimately,
Goldwater lost in a landslide to Johnson, but in the next election, conservatives would finally
have their moment. And that leads us to the third big development in this rise of new conservatism,
the election of Richard Nixon to the presidency. So Nixon was a conservative who won the election
of 1968 and in doing so brought many of the principles of the new conservatism onto the
national stage. For example, Nixon declared himself the Law and Order candidate, which
actually was a thinly-veiled code for cracking down on minority crime in urban areas. He also
pledged to restrain the federal government from regulating and enforcing civil rights legislation,
not least the laws mandating integration through school busing programs. And all this taken
together made up what became known as Nixon's Southern Strategy, through which he appealed to
white Southern voters who had reliably voted Democrat. Like Nixon wasn't dumb enough to come
right out and say that racial inequality and segregation was, now that he thought about it,
a pretty good idea. But by using the coded language of states' rights and law and order,
he was able to appeal to Southern voters who had become deeply unsettled by the rapid pace
of social change over the previous decade or two. And so Nixon claimed that there was a large and
disgruntled silent majority of Americans who were fed up with all the cultural upheaval and would
show themselves in great numbers to vote for a candidate that promised to calm the waters and
make life more comfortable for the white middle class. And as it turned out, he was right because
he won that election handily. And in his first term, he got busy dismantling many great society
programs and stacking the Supreme Court with conservative judges. Okay, so as conservatives
gained more political power in the 1970s, they continued to clash with liberals on a metric
buttload of issues, only two of which I'm going to tell you about. First of all, liberals and
conservatives clashed over the issue of women's rights. So on the left, second-wave feminists
called for greater and greater social equality with men, and that amounted to a threat to
First, the 1973 Supreme Court decision in Roe v. Wade legalized a woman's right to abortion in all
50 states. And women's rights activists cheered this decision as a significant step in recognizing
a woman's right to make decisions regarding her own body. But conservatives grew uncomfortable
with the women's liberation movement and sought to limit access to abortion by emphasizing that
what a woman carried in her womb was not merely a collection of cells but rather a human being
that possessed, even in that fetal state, the right to exist. And then second, women's rights
pushed for an Equal Rights Amendment that would formally enshrine women's equality into the
Constitution. And while women's rights activists were able to muster significant support for this
amendment, conservative women like Phyllis Schlafly organized a mass movement to kill
the amendment and it ultimately fell two votes short of ratification. And then the second
prominent clash between liberals and conservatives was a disagreement concerning the appropriate
amount of power for the federal government. So liberals of the New Deal and Great Society
varieties wanted more involvement from the federal government in order to expand access
to civil liberties and intervene in the economy to avoid a crisis. But conservatives rejected
strongly to both of these points. So as champions of states' rights, the New Right of the 1970s
argued that the civil rights policies of the Great Society era amounted to federal coercion.
And to support this argument, they invoked the 10th Amendment which says that any power
not explicitly granted to the federal government is reserved for the states. And so to conservatives,
the federal imposition of school busing and forced racial integration amounted to a constitutional
crisis with respect to the guaranteed constitutional power of the states.
Additionally, conservatives scorned the high tax rates required to fund all of these liberal
policies. For example, in the 1970s, the wealthiest Americans were taxed at a 70% rate. And to correct
this, conservatives championed supply-side economics, which was a system that would lower
taxes to bare minimum levels and deregulate businesses. And the idea was that if America's
businesses and entrepreneurs paid less in taxes, then they would invest that money into
their businesses and thus create more jobs. And in that way, wealth would trickle down
from the richest Americans to the rest of society.
Okay, now the next thing you need to know about this conservative movement is that their
intensity got turned up to 11 once they got the good Lord Jesus involved. What I mean is,
the 1970s marked an inflection point for the melding of conservative new right politics
with the growing evangelical Christian movement. As a result, the Christian right emerged as a
powerful political force that opposed abortion and condemned the secularization of American
society and supported a return to traditional gender roles just as God intended.
Several high-profile evangelical leaders played a big role in blessing this union,
and I'll introduce you to two of them.
First was James Dobson, who hosted an enormously popular Christian radio broadcast called Focus
on the Family. Here, Dobson taught his listeners that the Bible required women to submit to their
husbands and commanded parents to enact strong physical discipline on their children in order
to save them from turning to secularism. In other words, women could drink a tall
glass of shut the heck up and children could get a butt cheek full of the spanking spoon.
Anyway, in these and many other ways, Dobson galvanized the Christian right to embrace
traditional gender roles and thus save God's greatest gift to the cultural fabric of Western
culture, namely the family. And then the second influential leader here was Jerry Falwell,
whose skillful use of television evangelism gained him a wide audience among the Christian right.
So in 1979, Falwell founded the Moral Majority, which was an organization that endorsed and
supported political candidates who promised to uphold in advance what Falwell called family
values. And since Falwell's audience was becoming massive, new right politicians started falling
all over themselves to partner with the likes of Falwell and Dobson in order to receive their
endorsement. And so in this way, millions of American evangelicals were convinced over time
that a vote for the Republican Party was a vote for Jesus. And that, my dear pupil,
is a potent combination. And finally, I need to finish up by telling you about the most salacious
and juicy political failures of the 1970s, which all had the effect of plunging public trust in
their government to new lows. And there were three categories of failure that you're going
to need to know. First, political scandals seriously damaged public trust, and none was
more corrosive than Richard Nixon's Watergate scandal. So Nixon yet again tickled the fancies
of his beloved silent majority in order to win a second term in 1972. But at that very same moment,
Nixon was embroiled in a scandal that would unravel many of the gains that he had secured
for the new conservative movement. So right after the election, news broke that five men on Nixon's
reelection committee had broken into the Watergate Hotel in Washington, D.C. in order to steal
documents that belonged to the Democratic Party and bug their offices with listening devices.
Now Nixon denied knowing anything about the burglary, and that may have been true,
but what was beyond doubt is that once Nixon did find out about it, he authorized an elaborate
cover-up for the crime. And even worse, Nixon ordered federal investigators to turn their
attention elsewhere so as not to incriminate the president. And so in light of all this,
Congress formed an investigative committee and ultimately found that despite Nixon's
repeated claims that he was innocent, he was, in fact, a real guilty and deeply complicit in
making plans to steal the election. And therefore, when it became clear to Nixon that Congress
intended to impeach and remove him, Nixon resigned the presidency in disgrace in 1974.
And all this had the effect of convincing the American people that they could not trust their
government officials, since Nixon turned out to be not so much a president but more like a
damp fart in the shape of a president. And then the second development that eroded public trust
in their government was an economic crisis in the 70s known as stagflation. And I talked about this
in my last video, so I'll keep it short here. Basically, the group of Middle Eastern states
that made up the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries cut off their oil exports
to the United States, and that resulted in stagflation in which inflation and unemployment
was rising at the very same time. And because this was an economic situation that had never
experienced before, no federal policy seemed to help it, and that made the government look
weak and ineffective. And finally, third, public trust in government eroded because
of foreign policy crises, the most notable of which was the Iran hostage crisis in 1979.
So way back in 1953, the CIA had participated in a coup in Iran that resulted in the overthrow of
their democratically elected leader and installed the US-friendly Mohammad Reza Pahlavi in his place.
And not surprisingly, certain factions within Iran were deeply resentful of this foreign meddling in
their affairs. And so in 1979, the disaffected Iranians sparked a revolution that resulted in
the overthrow of Pahlavi. And in his place, Ayatollah Khamenei assumed power and represented
a fundamentalist Islamic regime that sought to erase the American influence in Iran.
Now pretty soon thereafter, Pahlavi was diagnosed with terminal cancer and President Jimmy Carter,
humanitarian that he was, invited him to the United States in order to receive treatment.
But Khamenei warned Carter that if he allowed Pahlavi into the United States, he would interpret
that as a hostile act from the United States. Well, long story short, Carter went ahead and
in response, Khamenei ordered Iranian troops to invade the US embassy in Tehran,
and the result was that 52 Americans in the embassy were held hostage by the Iranians.
And that's no good, so Carter authorized a covert operation to rescue the hostages,
which failed miserably. As a result, Iran held the American hostages for over a year,
a move that made Carter look weak and ineffective, thus contributing all the
more to Americans' growing perception that their government was not worthy of their trust.
And that, combined with the burgeoning conservatism that I mentioned earlier,
is going to pave the way for the election of the brightest star of the conservative
universe, Ronald Reagan. And that is where we're going to pick up in Unit 9.
Well, okay, you can click here to watch my other Unit 8 videos, or you can click here to grab my
A-Push Heimler Review Guide, which has everything you need to study as fast as possible. I'm glad
you came around, and I'll catch you on the flip-flop. Heimler out.
