Michael Knowles on Why So Many Americans Are Becoming Conservatives | Real Talk | PragerU

PragerU
799 followers
39 Video Views·Nov 11, 2024
What does the future of the conservative movement look like? Why are so many classical liberals finding a new home on the right? @MichaelKnowles is a bestselling author, political commentator, and the host of the PragerU series “The Book Club.” Michael and PragerU CEO @realtalkwithmarissa discuss what it means to be a conservative and the pros and cons of “big tent” conservatism.
📲 Watch our content ad-free on our app: https://prageru.onelink.me/3bas/vgyxvm79
Follow PragerU on social media!
Instagram ➡️ (https://www.instagram.com/prageru/)
Twitter ➡️ (https://twitter.com/prageru)
Facebook ➡️ (https://www.facebook.com/prageru/)
what does it mean to be a conservative
who are we what are we all doing
together the left creates chaos what is
the framework for conservatism well I'll
let you know when we all decide I mean
we'll see who wins who gets to Define
what we should teach our children well
the first thing to lay out is somebody
will do that do you think the Bible
belongs in schools it's the most
important book ever composed that's the
one book we ban from schools today you
can't read the Bible in schools you can
in some cases must read pornography in
schools well I think had it right in the
' 50s actually maybe we should go back
to that standard conservatives are the
party of
normal Michael NS hello hello it's
excellent to be here you know how fun it
is to do these real talks with people
who I'm so close with it's like we're
gonna get into too much trouble I I did
wonder I said how long are we going to
be here you know this could we could go
on for five six we could go on forever I
am really pleased to see well my book my
book with words uh but these yeah yes
because you know conservatives now
things have realigned they've switched
and and it used to be it was the left
Wingers and the hippies were the ones
who were really into the health food and
the this and the no GMOs but now it's
the right the right like no sugar no
aluminum no anything but these are a
real guilty pleasure yes well we try to
find some balance here where we don't
only drink raw milk we don't only do I I
I don't know I mean this is really what
I wanted to talk to you about is what is
happening to us us because I think we're
getting real confused real fast so okay
but before that we're going down memory
lane I got to show you something that my
team dug up from I think I think this
just might be our 10-year anniversary I
think this is 10 years so look how you
haven't changed I've aged take a look at
this is your video from Prager Force
you're our first Prager Force m i was
the first I was the face of Prager Force
700 years ago when it began
729 I'm terrified to see PR three
children when I just looked so bright
young vibrant I'm terrified to see yeah
okay let's see what people think with
over 70 million views in 2015 prageru
has dominant I think I might found
conservative ideas online look at your
hair so what's next look at my hair
ining why did I age and you didn't the
cigar that's not it's the cig they're
preserving I'm going to start smoking
people don't understand the health
effects of cigars that is amazing to
look back and and think because when I
look at that I feel that I I look a
little more tired now with all the kids
fair I I feel a touch um I've expanded
just a touch I don't I don't know if I
maybe I would fit in the jacket I don't
know my hair is a little short that the
hair was an upgrade since then and but
maybe you're right maybe this maybe I'd
look much much worse if I had h a
stylist since then right I a stylist was
hired for me now I was kind of opposed
to this but daily wire in the early days
that was that was probably before I
started my show uh they decided they
wanted to make me hip and cool and and
that was a complete lost cause you know
that was never I don't know I feel like
you kind of wear the same stuff I mean I
literally may have that same shirt in my
closet I can't yeah I'm a conservative I
don't want to give things away you I
don't want conserving also conservatives
love the Earth why create extra piles of
clothes right that's great well at least
you haven't uh changed that much so
that's a really good thing what what did
you think you were going to be when you
grow up did you know you'll do the
troublemaking that you do
from my earliest memories I wanted to be
in Show Business and politics I wanted
to be an actor and I have been an actor
I've been an actor in different that's
why they don't let you on on any of the
daily wire films exactly I mean they
only daily wire only casts non-actors in
their film only real actor at the daily
wire and you're not in their films
classic the classic you know uh I did
have a a brief Cameo as a Native
American Indian in one of their recent
movies but of course they have you know
they they have to Zig when everyone zags
but I I did I was an actor for a bit and
then I always wanted to be in politics
from my my earliest age and so oddly
enough now I am in political Show
Business you know I'm doing both of
those things every day I as with all
things in life really I I probably
couldn't have plotted out the individual
steps the blank book I probably couldn't
have guessed or you know getting into
conservative politics through Hollywood
I probably couldn't have guessed that
but the main thrust of what I wanted to
do was there really from my earliest
memories I am I am doing basically
exactly what I've always wanted to do
the first time I heard about you was
when I called Jeremy boring this was
before the daily wire we're all in this
like crammy little place in Los Angeles
and I said I needed a Prager Force kid I
needed a Prager Force face for this
video and that's how it all started yeah
that I guess certainly that would have
been my first PR and he told me you'd be
great because you're an actor and so
you're basically acting in this thing so
aw I really liked getting the part
because I was u in a category of one
young conservative actor in La able to
work on a dime I you know there wasn't a
lot of competition well you did a great
job thank you so why did you study what
you studied in college you went to Yale
yeah I went to Yale to now I used to say
you know to my great shame I went to
Yale but you'll notice a lot of
prominent young right- Wingers somehow
emerged from Yale because when I was an
undergraduate these guys are a little
older than me but uh VI and JD Vance
were both at the law school so we
overlapped a little bit on campus and I
think the explanation is if you go to
Yale probably you're going to go left
and and you might go really far left and
you might be a they them by the time you
graduate but if you
don't you you will become radicalized to
the right you will actually become a
reactionary fter yes I when I entered
Yale I was a kind of uh Happy amiable
libertarian or something and religiously
agnostic or even an atheist and by the
time I graduated I was significantly
more right-wing traditionalist
conservative uh much more open to the
possibility of religion obviously I
reverted later um so if you if you can
survive the onslaught of propaganda it
can really being in that kind of
leftwing environment can really help you
hone your thoughts in the other
direction so I studied history and then
I picked up a a second major an Italian
literature major because I already spoke
Italian going in so I didn't have to
take language classes but I liked
Italian literature and I fig a good P
pad the grades a little bit you know get
that GPA up and by the end I had enough
courses for a major so they said oh you
should just do it
and you know don't worry you won't have
to write a thesis and I said oh well
that's easy okay and then there was a
real bait and switch there because then
they said okay so what's your thesis
going to be I said hold on you told me I
didn't have to do a thesis but I ended
up translating a play uh by makavelli
that had not been translated for the
English stage the Yale Department was
really big on this play so they said
okay if you translate it we'll let you
produce it you like politics you like
show business so what a great thesis
isn't it and I did it it was a lot of
fun it it that helped Advance my love of
political philosophy which you know
continues in an amateur way to this day
and I did have something akin to a
liberal arts education real proper
liberal arts education is basically
doesn't exist anymore Donald Kagan who
was a legendary Yale Professor a
right-winger I think it was Dean of Yale
College for a while he said you no
longer had to have an education to
graduate Yale and eventually he said I'm
not sure if it's even possible anymore
but one of the defining features of a
liberal arts education is you're not
you're not really learning anything
practical you're not learning
engineering you're not learning business
you're not you're you're learning uh
history or literature or something and
the idea is it's to help you come to
understand your freedom the liberal arts
and so you're you're cultivating uh
something within you from the Great
Western tradition and then if you want
to go be a doctor or a plumber or
whatever you're going to be you you you
learn that afterward you know you go to
trade school whether it's for law or for
electricity afterward but I never did I
skipped that part I just had the liberal
education and then I never had any
practical education whatsoever well life
taught you something do you feel like
you got something out of your education
certainly I did um not always in the
classroom sometimes in the classroom
there there there were some classes that
were really great um however it was it
was a lot of outside the classroom if
you're with people who are
intellectually curious and capable
especially if you're in an intellectual
minority as as conservatives are on
these campuses you can
you can learn a lot you can learn a lot
by way of contrast with what the
dominant culture is so I certainly did
and then I also got a lot out of um
fellowships so you know because
conservatives have been totally run out
of the universities we have all of these
institutes and we have all of these
little summer fellowships and where you
may never hear the name Aristotle in
your University which is a scandal but
you will read Aristotle and Plato and I
don't know John Lock and montue in these
summer Fellowship so I had one of those
the hertog program through the Hudson
Institute oh yeah great a great program
highly recommended and I've had other
other fellowships since then but that
that was able also to augment some of
what was missing in the more Lial so
interesting Michael NOS goes to Yale
spends all this money all this time and
where does he learn everything during
summer Institute of course that's great
and one thing I should on the money
point I should give credit to Yale I I
went not on a complete scholarship but
almost a complete scholarship you know I
I paid very little for Yale because they
had it's not anything about my uh
brilliant scholarship it's just they had
need-based financial aid so Yale paid
for the vast majority of my education
now I think they probably want to resend
their diploma and deny any connection
with me whatsoever um but you know
Yale's very rich Harvard's very rich
these schools have huge endowments and
so when we're thinking about how can
conservatives reclaim the universities I
think in part one of the reasons that
the ivy league has gotten a little bit
looser with the financial aid is they're
afraid that conservative lawmakers might
come in and pull an a Henry VII you know
and start looking at those endowments
and say hey we're not going to let you
pervert the minds of of the next
generation of leaders anymore if only
they did that right if only they did
where was our Henry VI I never thought
gr okay so want to ask you a little bit
about your political philosophy and it
sounds like it was something that was
developed over the years I mean you went
into college kind of somewhat of an
atheist not sure if you're a Libertarian
I guess now you define yourself as a
conservative and so how did that develop
where at what point in your life did you
start realizing what you believe in well
libertarianism is a great phase that
many of us go through so I don't mean
everybody has to read iron Rand yes you
have to at College it's 17 I remember I
really liked iron Rand at you know and
uh but I don't I don't think ultimately
libertarianism is really sufficient I I
I don't think it's a stable or coherent
view um much of what passes for American
conservatism is not totally stable I
mean that's why we're in this big crisis
that you mentioned earlier of what does
it mean to be a conservative who are we
what are we all doing together so I I I
grew up in a very liberal place in
Hudson Valley of New York basically
everyone I knew was a liberal basically
everyone I knew was an atheist or
practically
atheist so I always knew I was a little
bit more the young Republican you know I
smoked cigars from a young age I I think
I came out of the womb with parted hair
wearing a tweed jacket so I was always a
little bit different however I came to
examine my conservatism I remember in in
college we were debating all sorts of
things in one of our debate societies
and then also just around the the suite
you know with the guys who shared a
common room and I said well look the one
first principle I know is that I support
Liberty and someone asked me well why is
Liberty good and I was scandalized by
this question what do you mean why is
Liberty good we could we could make fun
of the Democrats we could poke them why
is equality good why is inclusivity good
why is this that or the other thing but
why is Liberty good that's so
self-evidently good but it's not
self-evidently good you have to really
ask yourself what is Liberty what and
what is liberty for perhaps and uh it
drew me to the conclusion that um the
the libertarianism that I had U
enjoyed was really not all that
different from the liberalism of the
left or the leftism or the Socialism or
the they were all kind of well I guess
two sides of the same coin let me do me
you do you let's Le Fair hands off
um which denies a I don't know a kind of
te- loss to the world an end of of man
it denies really the ability to know
what we're all doing and and this has
political ramifications because it it it
leads us to radically different
conclusions about what politics is about
you know the the Libertarians and the
leftists and the Socialists and the
Communists would say well politics is
about just individuals you know getting
what they want you know the the best for
the individuals I guess whatever they
want to do if it's not harming other
people and it's maximizing utility say
or whatever
whereas the conservative would have a
radically different view and say no man
is not fundamentally an individual we're
individuals we have Liberty Liberty is
the greatest gift that God ever gave us
but it's for something man is
fundamentally a political animal or a
social animal we did to quote comma
Harris we didn't pop out of a coconut
tree you know it's what's funny we make
fun of her for saying that it's the
smartest thing she's ever said that's
like the one thing she's said that's
that's true uh we're now we born into
families and and so that means that the
Bedrock political unit is not as the
left and the Libertarians would say the
individual the Bedrock political unit is
actually the family because that's
because politics means more than one
person you know it's it's public so if
it's the family what then that means
we're born not primarily with rights and
entitlements we're born primarily with
obligations and duties in relationship
with other people you know I owe my
parents reverence and respect and I got
to do the chores my parents owe me
certain love and and consideration
nurturing and uh well that means means
that politics is ultimately about the
common good wouldn't the left then say
the same thing I mean the left is also
about collectivism and communism and
socialism and the common good it might
be a different view of what the common
good means but you are basically saying
that conservatism should take some of
what we view as leftism and collectively
decide what is better for the common
good where the Libertarians or maybe the
classical liberals would say Live and
Let Live and so maybe they're more
different than the left in conservatism
that's what they would say but they're
wrong because at a superficial level it
does seem similar to to say that uh we
have a collective interest versus we
care about the common good but how does
the left arrive at its
collectivism does the left do that by
building up really strong families as I
just suggested certainly not the left
hates the family the left wants to tear
kids away from their families and put
them in government schools or kill the
kids give their parents the right to
kill the kids or encourage divorce or
really do anything they can to explode
the family redefine the family redefine
marriage and the law so the the left
likes collectivism but in order to get
to that collectivism they have to break
down all of the organic natural units of
politics especially the family so that
at first we're all atomized
individuals we have no Civic
associations we have no natural
institutions that that can defend us
against this this acidic leftism and
then what did they do at that point
point the classical liberals and the
Libertarians say okay good we're all
individuals good the left just takes it
further and says okay now that we're all
individuals now we're going to scoop you
all up again and so you see this very
clearly in the symbolism of fascism
which is the the bundling together of
sticks in in this unit of the state with
leftism you see it in communist
symbolism I suppose but it's all
basically the same it's an artificial
inorganic uh collection of people so
then for the left
the they I don't even know that they use
the term the common good but whatever
they're talking about you know the
collective will of the people or
something it it really derives from
utilitarianism this notion that we can
derive moral conclusions from what might
bring about the greatest good for the
greatest number of people you know we're
try to measure measure this in in units
called utils or some totally contrived
nonsense whereas the conservative and
the classical understanding of the
common good is totally different from
that the common good is not just what
51% of the public wants the common good
is not just um what some kind of vague
General will would desire the common
good is what is good for the individual
for the family and for all of us
together it's it's Goods that we hold in
common so in order to understand that VI
we have to think that there's such a
thing is human nature don't forget the
left and even some of the radical
individualists on the right they kind of
deny Human Nature but on on the right we
say no no there's human
nature man has certain ends certain
material natural ends you know we feed
ourselves we get married because we're a
coupling creature we uh we're fruitful
and multiply I don't know and we have
Supernatural ends as well you know we uh
we can know the existence of God with
certainty from the natural world we uh
we want to know God and enjoy him
forever and in eternity and the the we
come to understand our natural ends
better in light of our Supernatural ends
but we can at least reason through some
of these things and so as we can know
that we can know for instance to just to
bring this all down to earth that it's
not good to mutilate a little kid's body
to it's it's not good to um I don't know
uh encourage kids to take a bunch of
drugs it's not good to expose kids to
pornography in elementary schools the
left is actively trying to do all of
those things the classical liberals and
the Libertarians I think are somewhat
effectless at at U rebuffing those those
predations because they don't have a an
epistemological or political framework
to to actually say no to that and but
the conservatives are saying no that's
actually not good for you you know we
can I know what my eyes are for my eyes
are for seeing I know what this mug is
for this mug is for giving me delicious
coffee I know what other uh biological
features and appendages are for and I
know what marriage is for and I know
what Society is for and we can come to
those conclusions and if we can't this
is where the rubber really meets the
road if we can't through Reon come to
certain conclusions about society and
make and therefore make certain
exclusions then we're not capable of
self-government because we're saying we
don't have reason we don't have moral
conscience we can't really know anything
about anything so then what are we doing
voting what we don't we don't even know
what we're all what we're all doing here
so who in your opinion is the we that
concludes what is good for society so
you know you take the left and you give
all these examples of how they're
basically creating utter chaos out of
our societ right that's what they're the
left creates chaos
conservatives say that they create order
and they they're the common sense party
and so conservatives or Republicans are
now inheriting the non wokes right
people who are non-woke we are
inheriting them because they're saying
well I don't want that left-wing
extremism and so I'm either a classical
liberal I believe in Live and Let Live
let me go to the conservative camp where
I'm not seeing all these children being
mutilated being torn apart all of this
complete crime bunker stuff on the left
but then when they do come over to the
conservative Camp what does that
actually mean and who gets to frame that
what is the framework for
conservatism well I'll let you know when
we all decide I mean we'll see who wins
maybe people can come and and we can
take a vote what that should mean but
but I'm not even sure the vote would
would resolve it you know this to to
your point this is an
extraordinarily live uh question
uh because you do have a lot of people
who say they say look I didn't leave my
party my party left me I'm I would be
considered I mean many of these people
would be considered Radical leftists by
the standards of 2009 on questions about
marriage on questions of reproduction on
questions perhaps even of
migration American identity but the left
the Democratic party has moved so far to
the left that they find themselves oddly
in the middle now or even on the center
politically homeless
to so so then the question for the
Republicans and I count myself a you
know tried and true Republican because I
I don't think politics just exists in
The Ether you know it's real practical
stuff we got to put it into action in
real life uh the question is how do you
welcome these people
in enjoy their votes which is very
important encourage them in in their uh
political thinking to uh say okay good
you've you realize you were going down
the wrong path you've turned around
you're walking down the right path well
keep walking keep going you know don't
just stop at a at a mey mouthed in
incoherent Center leftism but keep going
you know really follow your intuitions
to their logical conclusion how do you
get them to do that and how do you
maintain some kind of coherent
conservatism without just becoming the
radical Democrats of
2013 it's not not an easily resolved
question well you you want to have a big
tent you want people to walk away from
the worst you do need to win elections
you also need to win common sense right
just you know just stay away from the
bad stuff but you also need to
articulate as we all need to know what
we stand for so that first of all we're
honest with the people who are following
us right that's the first thing come
follow me follow me into what right
right what does that mean come follow me
and what does what does that even mean
let's say you could wave a magic wand
and you would be the leader in that tent
yeah what would you define as what is
right and true and best for
conservatives today well I I'm going to
steal a line from the late great sir
Roger scrutin who was asked what what is
conservatism and he said well I think
conservatism has something to do with
conserving things which is very
unsatisfying for people who want it to
be about Liberty or rights or even
tradition you know tradition is a better
guide uh Trump articulated this pretty
well he said look we um we we don't want
to upend everything you know we want
things that have been practiced for a
long time we're going to we're going to
defer to that a little bit you know
that's a kind of because tradition is
not just some old dusty thing that
existed in the past that if that were
the case it would just be an antique it
would not it wouldn't be tradition
tradition is that which has endured from
the past all the way up to the present
it means it's quite durable probably and
it's developed and it's changed and it's
been translated over time but but uh you
know I I would be more inclined to
follow something that's lasted 2,000
years than some dumb idea that that
someone came up with a few days ago so
what is it what what makes us
conservative well I think one good way
to think about it is conservatives are
the party of normal we're the normal
party this is something that I think is
true and it sells to the leftists and
the Libertarians who are scandalized by
how crazy the the Democrats have become
We're the Party of normal we want to
live a normal life we want a normal
country we want to raise our normal
families and normal communities and not
be be subject to these insane social
experiments on our kids on our small
towns in the middle of the country on
our education on on our on our economy
for that matter uh and the reason I
think the party of normal is is an
effective way to think about it is that
normal can mean two things normal is the
way people ordinarily behave and normal
is the way people ought to behave like
normative like standards and norms and
this is an area where this is really the
point of my book speechless and I think
it's affected the conversation to some
degree on the right you know that was at
least what I was aiming at we need to be
the party of standards and norms for
when I wrote that book The Right was in
the throw of free speech absolutism and
I totally understand why we had adopted
that perspective because the left was
censoring us everywhere and we said no
we stand for free speech in all cases
nothing should be banned ever but that's
not really a conservative view that was
a that was a very reactionary view from
from us uh not only is that not a
conservative view it's never existed
anywhere we came to view the the fight
over Free Speech say four or five years
ago as a battle between free speech on
the one hand and censorship on the other
that's not what it is it's a battle
between two competing sets of norms
conservatives don't we don't think that
that we have ought to have free speech
for obscenity we don't think we ought to
have free speech for fraud or for direct
threats or for there's plenty of stuff
that we we right or no censorship of
books that are pornographic in schools
right schools yeah for your 11-year-old
to read of course not I'm all for
Banning those things in those
circumstances according to what is
appropriate and standard and normal uh
so the only question is to use the
school
example what books are we going to
include which books are we going to
exclude in the 50s you could read the
Bible in schools you could not read
pornography in schools today you can't
read the Bible in schools you can in
some cases must read pornography in
schools well I think they had it right
in the 50s actually maybe we should go
back to that standard uh
so there's a a Chasm obviously between
the two forms of normal you know how
people all behave and how we ought to
behave according to standards and norms
and I think part of the conservative
project is we want to well it's really
just part of the process of Education we
want to bring the way that we behave
more into line with that which is
reasonable you know uh people our Wills
are divided right like I for instance
really want to eat another one of these
chocolates but I don't want to get fat
because I will fat shame you and you
will fat shame me and I might go into a
diabetic coma if I keep eating these CU
they have 7000 gram of sugar in them so
what is it I want the chocolate I don't
want the chocolate well it's because my
will is divided I have a lower will
which is irrational it's an appetite you
know it's the will of uh you know the
nice looking lady crosses the street and
you can just kind of look it's it's the
will of um just kind of Bas desire and
then there's the rational will just say
no I I want uh I want to refrain from
eating the chocolate because I want to
fit into my suit because I want to look
good at the speech that I'm giving
because I want to live longer and be
around for my family and I and
classically understood the the rational
will was was understood to mediate
between the appetite and the Divine will
which is objective and obviously
omnipresent and omnipotent uh so we want
our politics to be a little bit more
reasonable we understand it's a Fallen
World we're never going to totally get
there we have to make accommodations for
people who are not totally advanced in
virtue and we got to live in reality of
course that's a big part of the party of
normal but it is urgent this is not just
Pie in the Sky uh Ivory Tower stuff if
we don't return our
politics to some Accord with reason then
politics will become more of what it has
become in recent years which is just an
irrational battle of wills where one
side is clubbing the other over the head
and we're just going to see who's got
the biggest club and who's going to
bleed the most first that's a very
dangerous situation it's how polies fall
apart uh and so right now I would at the
very least like to have one political
party arguing for for a reasonable
Society the issue is again who defines
what is normal so let's take hungry like
Victor orbon he is in some ways the
opposite of what you would call a
classical liberal right he's just you
know he's a right-winger who draws the
line and says this is what is acceptable
and this isn't what is acceptable and so
some would call him a tyrant some would
call him basically the mirror of a
leftist where he would basically say
this is what's going to be done like it
or not I'm running this country so is
that the expectation that a somebody on
the right would come in and and take
over America and basically draw the
lines for us as to what is normal who
defines what is normal and if normal is
defined but what the culture is driving
right well oh it seems normal that
transing your kids this seems totally
normal because everybody is doing it
right this this concept that if
everybody is doing it now it means it's
okay and normal then very quickly the
left can just create new norms and we've
seen that in America but the flip side
of it is that if you become a tyrant
then one person gets to decide what is
acceptable and what is normal and I
think that's really the tension that
we're dealing with right now because if
we don't know what we stand for then we
don't know what to teach our children is
in fact normal the reason you're
refraining from eating this entire bowl
is because somebody taught you that it's
bad for you and that it shouldn't be
normal because it's going to hurt you
and so who gets to Define what we should
teach our children in the Next
Generation and the public in general
what is acceptable versus what is
harmful and not normal well the first
thing to lay out is somebody will do
that sometimes the objections to
conservatism from the Liberals on the
left and the right will be well who
decides yes but the inevitable
conclusion is somebody somebody will
decide even in the sort of
Utopia you know we're human beings who
live in a finite World someone is
setting these norms and so it's funny
you mentioned orbon who I think is a
marvelous leader uh but you say well
look some people especially on the left
they call him a tyrant But the irony of
course is Victor orbon is one of the
most popular democratically elected
leaders in the entire West Victor Orban
has a far greater Democratic claim to
govern than really any American leader
has for decades at this point he he he
won very clear elections he he's not
liberal he says look we we're an
illiberal democracy you know we think
certain things are true and look we're
country founded on the C on the crown of
St Steven and so we're going to we're
going to just kind of do what we've been
doing for about a thousand years and
we're going to create all sorts of carve
outs for people you know not everyone
needs to be a Christian I mean first of
all Hungary is a Catholic country Victor
Orban is a calvinist uh Hungary has one
of the most thriving Jewish populations
in the world I think it's got the second
largest synagogue in the world world I
was I was there last year visiting the
Jewish neighborhood great good food a
little overpriced as kosher food often
is but it was very good um so it's a
thriving in a certain sense
Multicultural country but the but it's a
country that still has its identity it's
still Hungarian in America it's hard to
say what are we anymore even in the
United Kingdom what is you know you walk
through the United Kingdom you sometimes
think you're in Karachi or something
like that you know what is it the
British don't really have a sense of
their identity anymore uh and I when I
when I say that not even referring to
you know all people being descend
descendants of the angles I I mean like
what do they believe what do they do
what are their behaviors what unites
them is Britain's so uh this question of
who
decides is
uh well let's use the family example
right now the Liberals would say that um
the the liberal left would say well the
public schools should decide what your
kids believe the public schools so
really the state should decide what your
kids think about transgenderism what
your kids think about porn what your
kids think about God what your kids
think about everything and by the way
they're going to answer those questions
all on the wrong side the libertarian
right would say well uh no one should
decide ideally maybe the kids should the
kids should decide for
themselves we don't want to indoctrinate
we don't want to indoctrinate which is
really in my we don't want to educate
yeah right exactly yeah I to me the term
indoctrinate is is just a a propaganda
term a pical term that it it just
basically comes down to the we the good
people educate but you the bad people
indoctrinate but they come from the same
root word do in Latin and so they'll say
well the kids decide you know we don't
want education to be coercive heaven
forbid but of course education is by
definition coercive a little 5-year-old
can't decide much of anything he can't
decide if he's going to have chocolate
milk or regular milk for lunch or what's
the point of educating them if you're
not teaching them exactly yeah the whole
the whole purpose is you've got to uh
form their minds and their character by
the way and their soul and their
disciplines so you hear this phrase a
lot from liberals on the left and the
right they'll say we uh don't want to
teach students what to think only how to
think
yeah but it is impossible to know how to
think without first knowing at least a
little bit of what to think so I I can't
know how to think about mathematics if I
don't know that 2 plus 2 equal 4 I can't
know how to think about battles between
the Christian West and the Muslim East
if I don't know that the Battle of
lantto took place in
1571 I have to know certain things and
and that means that if I go on my math
test and I say 2 plus 2 equals 7 that
means some teacher is going to
coercively come over to me and give me a
bad grade and I don't know put me in
detention at a certain point maybe if I
keep getting it wrong and put me in
remedial classes but there's going to be
a a sort of gentle coercion to push me
toward the right answer and then that
that um firm hand will become a little
less firm over time as as one is
thinking in in a more complex and
Abstract way as reason have the capacity
to think through things right like go
play a symphony without hearing great
pieces of music first yeah right or
without hearing what the instruments
sound like that's the PO point of
Education I'm sure a lot of people are
going to get very upset about how you
know here you know two right-wingers are
saying that we have to indoctrinate the
public but you got to teach something
otherwise what's the point of paying all
this money to send them to school right
I thought education important that's
right that's right and and so CS Lewis
talks about this in abolition of man he
says uh you have to begin with what he
calls the tow and when he says the tow
he's referring to natural law he's
referring to First principles uh he's
referring to things that that are kind
of the just the foundation of knowing
stuff the left always wants you to
provide some statistical scientific
stupid paper that's probably false you
know to to prove everything that you're
saying but
it's good that the human race
persists I can't prove that there's no
there's no
um logical proof of that you you can't
really prove first principles you can't
prove these premises you have to begin
with premises and then you build up from
the premises even in mathematics there
are basic axioms of mathematics a equals
a A plus b equals B plus a basic stuff
that mathematics is built on you can't
prove those premises and so then the
Liberals would say well who decides what
the first principles are who decides
what the premises are and my answer
would be uh well I hope we decide rather
than they because they are very confused
and we seem to have a little bit of a
better idea but I don't want it to just
be me I don't want I don't want to be
the dictator or something like that uh
one way that we can decide is uh through
Common Sense the vast majority of people
everywhere in the world who come from
radically different cultural Traditions
agree that it is wrong to commit murder
agree that you ought to honor your
father and mother agree on really basic
so we just kind of know it even when we
pretend that we don't and then
furthermore when we get a little
confused I would maybe ex expand
democracy through time I would expand it
to what has been called the Democracy of
the Dead if if my forefathers have been
doing something for three or four
Millennia that's that's not dispositive
that they were right but it's a pretty
good inclination that they kind of
understood something so I would I would
defer to the wisdom of the ages and I
would defer in practice to what works
we've decided in recent years that we're
going to upend how how the family Works
we're going to upend how we view men and
women we're going to upend how we
understand marriage through divorce
through the definition of marriage how
we understand kids you know whether you
can kill kids whether you can mutilate
kids whe we've changed that over the
last 60 years or
so has that improved the family or has
that harmed the family has that improved
Society or harmed Society anyone being
even a little bit honest is going to say
it's it hasn't been good okay well then
how about we we use the scientific
method we had a hypothesis we tested the
hypothesis we disproved the hypothesis
from the 60s and 70s okay well let's
maybe we we ought to return to what was
working a little bit better that's who
decides but the one thing I can promise
you all the all the critics of
conservatism on the left and the right
someone is going to decide and so if if
you throw your hands in the air and say
well I hope it's not me okay well what
you're really saying is then the other
guy's going to decide yeah I think it's
it it is so profound because the
conservative movement has taken on this
libertarian approach of Live and Let
Live or just let somebody else fill in
the vacuum and the vacuum obviously gets
filled up and then everybody looks back
and says how could this have happened
why didn't we why did we stand idly by
while you know our colleges have been
taken over by radical marxists and
recently you you've seen many colleges
come out with these um neutrality
statements which is another one of those
like Live and Let Live Well let the
professors and the teachers do whatever
they want and you know you are seeing
conservatives celebrating that because
they're saying oh this is great now they
won't give left-wing statements yes
right so a neutrality statement is such
a copout because again it just means
that somebody else gets to not be
neutral probably foreign monies pouring
into our universities to make these
decisions on what is the statement that
is going to be dominant on our college
campuses and how do you educate
neutrality the whole purpose of educa is
that you you'd not remain neutral this
was the point of the book that is widely
considered to have started the modern
conservative movement that's God and man
at Yale by William F Buckley which I I
got to write the introduction to the the
70th Anniversary Edition people
sometimes it's so sad these modern
conservatives they cite that book in
defense of academic freedom the subtitle
of the book is the superstitions of
academic freedom in quotes the whole
book is a polemic against academic
freedom which Buckley rightly points out
has never existed can never exist and
really should not exist because the
point of education is to to pursue truth
he quotes a former president of Yale
there he says uh skepticism has utility
only when it leads to conviction so I
recently had a debate on this subject at
isi it was me and Professor Robbie
George who is a Great Hero I Robbie
George is has done as much or more than
any conservative intellectual in the
country he's an amazing man but we were
debating academic freedom he took the
pro academic freedom side I took
the bill Buckley side you know the
anti-academic freedom side it was
moderated by Michael Brandon D in
National Review and the conclusion that
I came to was that uh academic freedom
has never existed um didn't exist in
medieval universities in the Catholic
universities it didn't exist in the
Protestant universities it's not
possible to exist uh in practice um
however if I were Robbie George I'd make
good Arguments for
it
because I I mean to say if one is an
intellectual minority one can uh do
quite a lot to crack certain orthodoxies
by appealing to this neutrality by
appealing to uh freedom in the abstract
but the whole point of opening one's
mind is to close it on something uh so
you saw this most clearly I think with
the Free Speech movement in the 60s at
Berkeley remember they called for free
speech total academic freedom and but
would you say that um the University of
California Berkeley has has a lot of
Freedom today a lot of intellectual
diversity not a chance it's one of the
most leftwing schools in the country
they wanted academic freedom as an
instrument to crack up the conservative
curriculum take some power and then set
new standards and Norms themselves so
that's why I I really hope that my
debate is not misinterpreted to to be a
criticism of uh of Robbie George or any
conservatives in the academy who were
arguing for more academic
freedom if the left can be hoisted with
its own sophis iCal patard I'm more than
happy to do it just as they did it to us
in the 60s however we shouldn't believe
our own press releases and we need to
remember that the purpose of education
is to teach something and if we're going
to pursue the truth then we're going to
come to certain conclusions about the
truth and we're going to exclude that
which contradicts those conclusions
about the truth and uh Unfortunately
today many students Minds have been so
empty that their brains have so open
rather that their brains have fallen out
do you think the Bible belongs in
schools of 12 of course how for those
who are not religious who are watching
the show or listening let me just ask a
simple question do you think the Bible's
an important
book do you think the Bible is more
important than say The Call of the Wild
by Jack London do you think the Bible's
more important than say uh catcher in
the Ry by JD Salinger I think we would
all agree it is it's the most important
book ever composed
it is impossible to understand the
Western tradition without knowing the
Bible intimately it is impossible to be
an educated person without knowing the
Bible intimately that's the one book we
ban from schools that seems kind of
crazy now the argument is that well we
have a secular country the framers
didn't think we had a secular country
the Great Men Who Built our country
didn't think that was quite religious
and we have in God we trust on our money
and in our national anthem but which
they'll take out if they could but
certainly they they and they're they're
trying to to but they said well it's a
secular country and so so what so now
we're the purpose of education is to to
teach kids to pursue the truth so but
we're going to take out the very
Foundation of all truth the we're going
to take out the
Creator uh the Living God who is the the
Bedrock of all that
exists being being himself uh how's that
going to work for you I mean again for
people who are not persuaded by religion
I guess just I'd ask do you think do you
think people generally were better
educated in
1945 before we took the Bible out of
schools or after the the 1950s or early
1960s is anybody really going to tell me
the kids these days are are better
educated I don't think so well we know
the literacy rate has dropped but what
they would probably say is well Michael
you know you can't force religion on
Americans and what you're trying to do
with asking for the Bibles to be back in
the classrooms is force Christianity on
people who don't want to be Christian
and that is not fair well there I'll
I'll calm them down I'll calm down their
fears because I'll point out I am a
mackerel snapping papist I come from the
Catholic church and at the time that the
Bible was taken out of schools one of
the controversies was that the Bible was
being taught from a Protestant
perspective so this this disadvantaged
Catholics as well I think now Catholics
Jews Muslims really every anybody would
say please we're Protestant whatever we
don't care just get God back in the
schools in any way uh but I'm not
suggesting that public schools need to
become a rigorous catechism class there
probably ought to be a little catechism
in there and and well I guess my point
is there already is a sort of catechism
there already is a lot of religion in
schools the schools teach that um a man
can become a woman to use a a prominent
example that is an anthropological and
ultimately religious point of
view the schools teach that if uh little
boy thinks that he's a girl he ought to
act like a girl they teach just you know
just in the other LGBT element op stuff
they teach that uh well not that men and
women are meant for each other and that
there's a purpose to sex and coupling
and you what and actually even when
people get married they ought to have
children if they're able to and they
don't teach any of that but they don't
teach nothing either they say no uh
people are born a certain way they might
have an orientation it's innate it's
immutable and you you ought to pursue
those desires to the exclusion of others
same point then every time you create a
vacuum something else comes in so if you
take out the Bible there'll be a
different religion some incarnation of
another religion that will come in in
the same way every time you say Live and
Let Live just pull everything out
something will come in and it's most
likely bad something certainly is is
going to be taught um the question is
just what I would imagine that people
who are thinking about even America's
sovereignty right now when it comes to
Wars world war wars right and so does
America get involved in wars that are on
the other side of the planet do we get
involved in the Russia Ukraine war do
you get involved in the Iranian War the
Israeli Palestinian War some would say
well we need to protect ourselves we
need to put the mask on and protect our
country our country is under attack and
some would say well but do you just let
the whole world Live and Let Live or do
you need to step in right this is now
you take this small thing that we were
discussing and you amplifi this and it
becomes bigger where do you draw the
line between we're all children of God
and there is some morality the United
States has played a very big role in
that if you look at Eastern Europe and
the Berlin wall and just how the world
become a better place when America does
get involved and then with that said
we're bleeding here in the United States
how do we take the little that we have
with this national debt that we're
accumulating and reckon with the concept
of getting involved in another
International War right the first
question that people are debating should
we be involved in these other parts of
the world I'll sidestep the debate we
will be we are the global
Empire you might not like that you might
not think it was prudent to become the
global Empire you might not like Empire
and principle we just are that we just
are the global hedgemon
and if we cease to be that which we
might well do or the Empire might crack
that's one of the issues we're facing
right now some other Empire is going to
take over China is going to take over or
probably just it would be China at this
point but that will happen uh the the
West failan system of you know Sovereign
Nation States that that came after the
wars of religion and that really you
know is is um concrete after World War
II that is that's just kind of an
abstraction but that's not you know
we're not really um a nation in exactly
the same way that maius is a nation or
Sri Lanka is a nation you know we're
we're quite different and uh so when
When Vladimir zinsky criticizes Donald
Trump as he has criticizes JD Vance a
lot of Americans are offended I'm I'm
offended by it too say you know who are
you man we've given you a ton of he he
he made these criticisms while he was
touring Munitions factories in America
Shapiro autographing the little bomb yes
yeah and you think you know talk about
looking a gift horse in the mouth you're
and you're complaining attack but in
zelinsky's defense zalinski is not
viewing himself as the leader of a
Sovereign Nation he's not he's not they
don't they don't hold elections in
Ukraine he's we've been involved in
Ukrainian politics for a while including
the way that he ascended and uh
Ukraine's not really a Sovereign Nation
it doesn't have anything resembling real
borders right now Ukraine is a vassal
state in the American Empire I'm not
even saying that's a bad thing I think
Empire is is the norm throughout history
but we will be involved in some way so
then the question is okay do we go full
you know George W bush let the bombs fly
Freedom seeds down the range baby we're
going to be the World
Police or do we do something else and I
think just not even as a matter so much
of Principle as of prudence we have to
pick and
choose uh I thought it was very foolish
for um to get to this point in Ukraine
Biden effectively invited Putin to
invade I mean he literally invited Putin
to invade Ukraine he said a minor
incursion will not be met with much
resistance
by the United States I can't help but
notice when Trump was president is Trump
an isolationist or an imperialist is
Trump a a dove or a hawk I don't know
here's what I know I know Trump's
unpredictable and he had relative world
peace and he brought peace broadly to
the Middle East and he was the only
president on whose watch in the last 20
years Vladimir Putin has not further
invaded another country so that's a
pretty good record and I think that's
really the way that the American Empire
has to think about itself we we are the
hamon there's no getting around that but
we can't just be
uh expending all of our resources
everywhere overseas when we don't even
have a functioning border at home that's
that's just not going to work we will
cease to be the Empire our our country
will collapse if that happens uh so you
bring up all this interconnectedness and
these questions of universality and and
you know this question of how we even
make sense of what we're doing here I
think one important Insight that is a
classical political Insight that many on
the left and the right would deny today
is there's no such thing as private sin
there's no such this and this brings in
the religion aspect of it too there's no
such thing as private sin you he uh you
know don't we don't want the Republicans
in our bedrooms which they usually say
we don't want Republicans to stop us
from killing our babies you know I don't
that usually doesn't take place in a
bedroom anyway but
furthermore if you have a if you have a
country that is constantly enthralled to
grave and persistent mortal sin that's
just doing really bad vicious stuff all
the time
privately you can't publicly have a good
country this is not some radical
far-right authoritarian Catholic Patrick
Denine Michael nolles point of view our
founding fathers said that and actually
before our founding fathers you go back
to the Rhode Island state Charter or I
guess this was before it was a state in
1663 they said you know we're giving you
these Liberties if you abuse them to
lenti justness and profaneness you're
sunk the New York state constitution
1777 said much the same thing uh
founding I mean George Washington
Benjamin Franklin even who was a little
bit of a you know derel in some of his
behaviors and John Adams they all said
these things you know the country is
built for moral and religious people so
we have this idea now the left certainly
which openly exalts vile and disgusting
sin by you know twerking naked for
little kids on Main Street during their
parades but and you know bringing drag
kids so-called onto network television
but the right does this too where we say
hey man you know stay out of our
bedrooms do whatever you want don't yuck
my yum
they're they're pretending that there's
this perfect distinction they want they
want us to live double lives you know
but you can't live a double life you
there's an expression that a friend of
mine who is a recovering alcoholic says
he got from AA it's really good wherever
you go there you are you know you're
you're you okay and so if you live in a
way privately that is virtuous and you
know you basically try to do the right
thing and you cooperate with God's grace
ideally um if you do that that'll be
good for you and if enough people do
that you'll have a good country and if
you don't do that then it doesn't matter
how much political philosophy you write
it doesn't matter how many constitutions
you scribble on parchment you're going
to have a bad country and it it's really
as simple as that such a good point such
a great way to end really at the end of
the day you want things to be better
take care of yourself of your family of
your community right if you you hate all
this pornography that is happening and
all this child abuse that is happening
start with your home you know don't
bring porn into your home don't bring uh
promiscuity into your home have
standards in your own home and then
bring that to your community and show up
and do good things and then you'll start
seeing great things around you as
opposed to be a social media Troll and
constantly accuse other people for not
being good enough well in the meantime
you're a complete hypocrite and you
yourself are rotten from inside right
right right that's you know my Hebrew is
not so great but I believe isn't that
what Satan is called in the Old
Testament the accuser all he ever does
is accuse people you know it's there
there's a role for uh constructive
charitable criticism you know it's
important but you got to you got to live
it too man you got to walk the walk fix
yourself right I love that well great
way to end uh we usually laugh more so
next time we're doing an Absolute Comedy
shtick but of course these are crazy
times but but listen that's cuz you
started you put my book with words on
the table if you had just put my blank
book on the table then it could have
been much lighter you know well people
should know that the riots on college
campus started against you and then
after October 7th the attention went on
to Israel but I think there were so many
riots on colleges Across America against
Michael N showing up to speak that's
true you know I think it's because the
Italians and the Sicilians physically we
have a lot of similarities with the Jews
so maybe that was it was just like a
figure or prototype either that or
you're clear Pioneers pioneers
[Music]
