The Manaslu Disaster

Memories Transcend Time.
11 followers
4 Video Views·Mar 28, 2026
In the early morning hours of September 23rd, 2012 a group of climbers waiting out a snowstorm in their tents surely didn't know the immense danger lurking above them. This is their story.
AI Generated·May contain errors
High in the northern Nepalese Himalayas, an intimidating, jagged peak looms above the
surrounding mountaintops. This grand mountain is known as Manasla. Standing at 8,156 meters,
it's the eighth highest mountain in the entire world. Its uniquely steep slopes and long ridges
lined by sharp cornices give the mountain an equally beautiful yet frightening appearance
from afar. Manasla was first noted by mountaineers in 1950, and several expedition teams noted a
potential route up the mountain from the northeastern face, but the European expeditions
did not actually make any attempt to summit it. The mountain did prove to be popular with Japanese
mountaineers however, and there were several Japanese expeditions that attempted to climb
to its summit before it was successfully accomplished by Toshio Imanishi of Japan
However, after Imanishi and Norbu summited in 1956, Manasla would not see many climbers
attempt to reach its summit for quite some time, as the next successful summit of Manasla would
be in 1971. As the expeditions from 1950 to 1956 were being attempted, the local people had
gradually become quite hostile to climbers, as after a particularly bad avalanche in 1954 that
destroyed a monastery and killed 18 people, the locals had begun to believe that the climbers had
angered the gods. Despite this, by the 1970s the locals began allowing mountaineers to climb the
peak again without further hostilities, and while it's certainly not the most visited of the 8,000
meter peaks, Manasla's unique climbing experience inevitably draws mountaineers to its sharp,
steep slopes with hopes of reaching its treacherous pointed peak themselves. Despite its menacing
appearance, the route that mountaineers most often take to reach Manasla's summit is fairly
straightforward, and offers a rather unique climbing experience amongst the other 8,000
meter Himalayan peaks. When compared to those other 8,000 meter peaks, Manasla has historically
high levels of snowfall during the Himalayan monsoon season from April to June, and thus,
most ascents of the mountain are attempted in the early fall once the snow has had time to settle
and harden, and the extra snow accumulating on the mountain makes the ascent easier for climbers
as well, as navigating the steep, rocky ridge to its summit is considerably more difficult
in the spring before the ridge has been fully caked by snowfall and ice, which is subsequently
lashed by the high mountain winds and forms the distinctive cornices that line the top of the
mountain. So great are these cornices, in fact, that it is thought that most who reach what they
believe is the summit of the mountain do not actually reach the true summit of Manasla,
as the true summit is a pointy, rocky outcropping that when fully covered with deep snow in the
autumn, appears to be a large, unsupported cornice, and without knowing of the true
summit beneath the snow beforehand, many assume that climbing any further than the fore summit
appears to be borderline suicidal, although the snow is not as deep nor unstable as it appears
to the eye. Aside from the final push to the summit though, Manasla is considered to be one
of the easier 8,000 meter mountains to climb, due to its relatively gentle incline and lack of high
technical skill needed to reach the top when ascending the northeast face. However, despite
this reputation, when compared to the other easier 8,000 meter peaks such as Cho Oyu, Manasla has
significantly higher fatality rates. While the route up Manasla is not particularly steep,
the ascent up the glacier is riddled with large, gaping crevasse fields, a particularly active
icefall between camps one and two, and large, looming seracs lining its upper ridges. Along
with these dangers, due to high annual snowfall on the mountain combined with typically warmer
weather than other 8,000 meter peaks, avalanches are a constant threat to mountaineers, and climbers
that hope to summit Manasla must maintain constant vigilance regarding the snow conditions at all
times, lest they be swept away by a mighty Himalayan avalanche. In September of 2012,
the climbing season on Manasla was in full swing. The teams of climbers began to arrive at base camp
and had begun to set up their ropes and climb to higher camps, acclimatizing as they went,
as is typical for any 8,000 meter climb. The conditions in 2012 were rather poor to start.
There had been many days of snowfall before an opportune 10 day weather window opened up around
September 15th. This year, camp three had been set at a location lower than usual, as this lower
camp three was sheltered from the wind by a large serac field above it, as the typical camp three
site sat about 100 meters further up the mountain, but was much more exposed to the high winds that
constantly lashed against the mountain. This favorable weather window was again brought to
a halt by the evening of September 22nd, 2012, as a fierce blizzard engulfed Manasla. The climbers
that had been hoping to reach the summit within the next few days hunkered down in their tents
for the night, hoping to get some rest and that the storm system would ease up by dawn. At 4 30 am
on September 23rd, as most of the climbers on the mountain were soundly slumbering, a huge serac,
estimated to be approximately 600 meters wide, broke off from above camp three, creating a
monstrous avalanche that quickly gathered speed, accelerated by the added mass of the huge serac.
The avalanche tore through camp three, uprooting the climbers tents, and swept away the 31 people
at camp three in its torrent of moving snow. A professional skier named Glenn Blake, who was
attempting to reach the summit without oxygen and then ski back down, recalled that he was doing
some reading in his tent, as his tent mate, a man named Gregory Costa, slept in his sleeping bag
next to him. Suddenly, their tent was flung into the air by the wall of moving snow, and Costa was
catapulted from the tent. He was never seen again. After feeling a huge surge of air from the
avalanche lift their tents up off the ground, many of the climbers at camp two knew that the avalanche
was likely over by this point, and peaked their heads out of their tents and up the slopes towards
camp three. Another professional skier, a Canadian man named Greg Hill, recalled that he saw headlamps
scattered along the mountain above him, and at first assumed that it was some climbers doing a
early morning acclimatization climbing, but quickly realized that camp three was no longer visible,
and it was then that he knew that the avalanche had swept away camp three. Hill and the other
climbers at camp two rushed up the mountain to aid in rescuing the climbers from camp three,
and by the morning, helicopters were dispatched, and a full-blown search for survivors had gotten
underway. Of the 31 people that had been swept away by the avalanche at camp three, by the end
of the 23rd, eight had been confirmed dead and three were still missing. As the days passed, the
fate of the three missing had been all but sealed. In the aftermath of the incident, many of the
remaining mountaineers abandoned their climbs, while some pressed on to the summit. A French man
and the guide for Glenn Plake's team named Remy Lecluse was one of the missing men, and his wife
heartbreakingly searched for him on the glacier, as a large funeral was held for him and several
other French climbers back in Chamonix, France. He was later found deceased in a crevasse, having
been swept there by the avalanche. Ultimately, 11 people were killed in the incident. This tragedy,
however, would raise awareness about the dangers of monosyllus slopes and the dangers of the herd
mentality while climbing, as several small independent teams had abandoned their climbs
just days before, concerned about a potential avalanche. But as the larger commercially-led
teams began to ascend the mountain, the other larger commercial teams felt pressured to get
their clients to the top of the mountain as well. The mentality of, they did it so it's probably safe,
had been festering within many of the more recent expeditions to Monasla, with several climbers
noting that many guides were unclipped from the ropes while crossing the crevasse fields,
and so the clients too mostly crossed the crevasse fields unclipped as well.
This herd mentality had permeated the psyche of even more experienced climbers,
and while extremely unfortunate, the avalanche in 2012 served as a much-needed wake-up call
to many of the expedition companies that overlooking potential safety concerns
can have extremely deadly consequences. And in the decades since this tragedy,
there have been no further fatalities caused by avalanches on Monasla.
Thank you all for watching.
