2026 Regular Session - Day 53 - SB 59 | Rep. TJ Roberts

Kentucky House GOP
24 followers
Mar 25, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Thank you. Mr. Speaker, please have the clerk report House Committee Substitute 1 to Senate
Bill 59. Clerk, please report. House Committee Substitute 1 to Senate Bill 59. Move adoption.
Move adoption. Motion is for the adoption of House Committee Substitute 1. Is there any
discussion of the Committee Substitute? Seeing none, those in favor signify by voting aye.
Those opposed, nay. House Committee Substitute 1 is adopted. Gentleman from Boone. Thank you,
Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, please have the clerk report House Floor Amendment 2 to Senate Bill
59 as amended by House Committee Substitute 1. Clerk, please report. House Floor Amendment 2 to
Senate Bill 59. Gentleman from Boone. Move adoption. Motion is for the adoption of House
Floor Amendment 2. Is there any discussion of the Floor Amendment? Seeing none, those in favor
signify by voting aye. Those opposed, nay. House Floor Amendment 2 is adopted. Gentleman from Boone.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, without a penalty, a law is not a law. It is just a suggestion.
We took a significant step in the right direction to protect the voices of Kentuckians
and to ensure that they are not compelled to finance advocacy with which they disagree.
We did that in 2021 with the lady from Shelby's continuing improvement bill to our elections.
And in so doing, we prohibited the use of tax dollars to advocate for or against a public
question appearing on the ballot. The problem that we face, Mr. Speaker, is that there were
no penalties to this bill. Senate Bill 59 addresses that issue by ensuring that there
is a fair and measured approach to ensuring that there is accountability when there are
blatant violations of the law. Simply put, Mr. Speaker, an error where a Kentuckian is
forced to finance advocacy that they disagree with is not only a statutory violation,
it is a constitutional one. In 2011, the Supreme Court in Arizona Free Enterprises Club's Freedom
Pack v. Bennett held that this is a violation of the First Amendment to compel such advocacy.
It's a violation of the First Amendment. It is compelled speech, a doctrine that has been
recognized by the highest court in the nation since 1943. This bill simply ensures that we
have compliance with this mandate that we have had for over half a decade now and ensures that if we
are having a ballot measure, any advocacy for or any advocacy against that measure,
no matter what the message is, no matter what the ballot measure is, is funded through private
means, through voluntary donors, and that our tax dollars are used for the essential
functions of government, not for politics. With that, Mr. Speaker, I move for passage of
Senate Bill 59 as amended by House Committee Substitute 1 and House Floor Amendment 2.
I yield to any questions, but if there are none, I would welcome a motion from
the gentleman from Perry that I would otherwise expect from the gentleman from Wayne.
