2025 Regular Session - Day 28 - SB 61, Rep. Myron Dossett and Speaker of the House David Osborne

Kentucky House GOP
24 followers
5 Video Views·Mar 15, 2025
thank you Mr Speaker Senate Bill 61
deals with property owners
rights Senate Bill 61 amends KRS to
specify that a Class A or Class B public
pool does not
include a pool located on the same plot
as a single family residence intended
for the use of the owner or their guest
regardless of whether the guest gain
use of the private single family
residence pool through a sharing
platform or pay a fee for the use of
that pool Mr Speaker I would like to now
yield to the gentleman from odm please
CH recognize gentlemen from old
59 thank you Mr speaker thank you
gentleman from
Christian um Jeb clerk report house
Amendment Three Please Mr clerk please
report house floor Amendment Three to
Cate Bill 61 gentleman from OD thank you
Mr Speaker members of the body house
floor Amendment Three I think strikes a
very delicate balance between um the
ability to regulate and the preservation
of PIV private property rights um it It
ultimately or basically prevents local
governments from
arbitrarily Banning short-term term
rentals does not prevent them from
passing ordinances does not prevent them
from regulating uh but it does prevent
arbitrary bans and I know that a lot of
communities a lot of our communities
have faced problems with short-term
rentals uh over the last couple years
and uh and some very significant
problems that uh that local governments
have to deal with and are dealing with
um and and so they should be allowed to
regulate them they should be able to uh
to be able to pass ordinances Rel to
them but at the same time they also have
to respect the pr property rights of
property
owners you know I I
think prty property rights is one of the
most sacred rights that we are granted
under our Constitution and the Fifth
Amendment prohibits government from
taking property without without
compensation prohibits them from taking
property rights without du process and I
think in Extreme Measures this is
happening in some areas of the
Commonwealth
if you buy a
property if you mortgage a
property if you develop a plan around
how to pay for a piece of property that
has certain rights inherent in it when
you buy that property and that right
that that ability to do that is taken
away that is the taking of a property
right now specifically the amendment
itself says that
you cannot base restrictions solely
on density solely on um the distance
apart that they may be solely on the
percentage um of of houses in a
particular area um it it it just says
that if you can point to a reason why
those things are problematic then you
can regulate them based on those things
but they cannot be solely based on those
those IND individual
problems they have the ability to this
amendment will allow them to have the
ability to issue conditional use permits
those conditional you per use permits
are revocable at will uh for cause um
cannot restrict the number of applicants
can certainly revoke those uh
conditional use permits uh anytime that
uh that any violation is found uh and
they can prevent uh they can absolutely
consider in those things the protection
of public health related to Fire and
Building Safety sanitation
Transportation traffic issues Pollution
Control residential uses relating to
zoning like noise protection and Welfare
Property Maintenance nuisance they can
limit things based on age of renters the
number of occupants uh anything that is
empirical they can limit except the
arbitrary ban of the use of property for
this
purpose and I know that that as I said
obviously a lot of our communities have
battled these problems but there are a
lot of good actors in this space too um
there are a lot of good actors that
simply like uh to have the the the extra
income um and the ability to uh to
supplement um their ownership of their
property uh and for those good actors um
they can't be P we cannot take their
property rights away from them and
penalize them because there's some Bad
actors in the space we need to get to
the Bad actors penalize the Bad actors
put the Bad actors out of business and
allow the good actors to continue to
utilize their property with every right
that they were granted when they bought
the
property in constructing this there have
been multiple versions of this amendment
you notice there's also house floor
amendment to after consultation with uh
City of Lexington City of Louisville uh
League of cities um we made some changes
to clarify uh the authorities that they
have uh those are incorporated into
house 4 amendment 3 um and and I believe
that this is a a good balance
between protecting communities and
protecting property
rights you know there have been a number
of these things that have been litigated
uh around the country uh they've yet to
get to an appellant level here in
Kentucky but uh a number of these uh
these restrictions have been litigated
around the country and in many instances
those things have been overturned by uh
by appic courts because they've been
deemed as The Taking of property rights
now I I know that that a lot of you have
been have been bombarded by Kentucky
League of cities by the
ktia I will tell you the league of
cities and kti is not being paid to
protect your property rights but every
one of us in this room are being been
elected to protect the property rights
of our constituents and I believe this
draws that balance and those so
therefore I move for adoption of house
floor Amendment Three
