Could the Sun have a binary companion, are we the only observers in the Universe, will lunar bases be close to each other? And in Q&A+, could we grow crops in asteroid regolith?
00:00 Intro 00:23 [@SantiagoT75] Can the Sun be orbiting another star we just haven’t yet noticed? 04:54 [@silasmiller4417] Are we really the only true observer in the Universe? 07:25 [@terryhardaway3285] How hard would it be to put the ISS in lunar orbit or on the Moon? 10:00 [@Space_Whales42] How close do you think the Chinese base on the moon will be to the American base? 12:14 [@Noonyuh] What sort of internet bandwidth should we expect on our moon bases? 14:47 Outro
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Could the Sun have a binary companion? Are we the only observers in the Universe? Will lunar bases
be close to each other? And in Q&A+, could we grow crops in Asteroid Regolith? All this and more in
this question show. It's time for the question show, your questions, my answers. As always,
wherever you are across my channel, if a question pops in your brain, just write it down,
gather them up and I will answer them here. All right, let's get to the questions.
Santiago T75, would it be possible for the Sun to be orbiting another star and perhaps we haven't
noticed it yet due to the sheer cosmic scales and distances? This is an idea that people have
had in the past that the Sun was in orbit, a very wide binary with some other star. We see these
wide binaries out there in the cosmos. They can be tens of thousands of astronomical units apart
from one another. It's kind of surprising how faint a Red Dwarf star or even a Brown Dwarf
would be in the sky that, you know, the closest star to us is Proxima Centauri. And yet you can't
see it with your eyes. If you walk outside, you cannot see the closest star to us. You can see
Alpha Centauri, it's very bright, but you can't see Proxima Centauri. And it's a Red Dwarf star
that you would need a small telescope or, you know, a good pair of binoculars to actually pick
it out. And that's all you could pretty much see with your small telescope. You know, there aren't
many Red Dwarfs you'd be able to see because they're so faint, and you can't see any Brown
Dwarfs. Now, there's a couple of tools that have come along who have been able to sort of give us
a firm answer on this question. The first one is the WISE telescope. And this was a space telescope
that was launched 15 years ago. And it was doing a wide infrared survey of the sky, looking for
things that are bright, glowing in the infrared spectrum, but not necessarily bright in the visible
spectrum. And so, you know, it's looked at all kinds of things. But one of the specific targets
that astronomers were looking at is, are there any giant planets like Jupiter's in the outer
solar system? And are there any Brown Dwarfs in our vicinity that are in orbit around us? You know,
there's this classic idea of this nemesis, right, or Planet X, that, you know, what if there is a,
you know, some other companion object to the solar system that's on this really
wide binary orbit and comes back every few million years and devastates the Earth because its
gravity messes with the Oort cloud. And so, the WISE telescope was able to rule out,
like literally, if there was a Brown Dwarf in our vicinity that was interacting with us,
it would have been detected by the WISE instrument, and it wasn't. And we know that
actually ruled out Jupiter sized worlds within about 10,000 astronomical units of us, which is
really far, you know, like, say, a quarter of the way to Proxima Centauri. So, we now kind of know
that there are no giant planets in the outer solar system. And so, that's why when you think about,
say, Planet Nine, it has constraints about how big it can be. It has to be sort of Earth size,
maybe Neptune size, but if it's Earth size, it can be closer. If it's Neptune size,
it has to be a little farther, because those are the constraints that WISE has already set.
And if there was like some future infrared survey that was done of the sky, then we could set those
constraints even tighter. So, that's the first tool is WISE. The second tool is Gaia. And this
was, you know, my favorite mission recently, up until Fear Rubin came online. And this is the
European Space Agency's mission to chart the positions and the movements of about a billion
stars in the Milky Way, including especially all the ones that are nearby. And so, we have
incredible motion data. Just to give you sort of a sense of the capability of the Gaia mission,
it could measure the position of a star to the width of a human hair seen at 1000 kilometers.
Just let that sink in. You take a human hair, take it 1000 kilometers away, and then that's the
resolution that Gaia can provide. And so, it knows with exquisite precision, the movement of all of
the stars that are in our vicinity, and none of them appear to be in orbit around us. In fact,
what Gaia did was it found probably some of the siblings that the Sun formed with,
it actually detected stars that have the same kind of movement through the Milky Way, as the
Sun and the solar system does, and has similar chemical constituents to the Sun. So, we are
definitely not in a multiple star system. And we have the tools, we have the receipts.
Silas Miller, are we really the only true observer of everything in the universe? That
truly terrifies me. We don't know. So, either we are the only advanced civilization in the universe,
capable of observing the cosmos, and only we know the sort of true scope and scale of the universe,
or there are many civilizations out there across the cosmos, and they have their versions of
astronomers, which seems like a thing that you would eventually develop. Now, they're observing
the same kinds of things that we are, they're observing planets, and stars, and galaxies,
and quasars, and black holes, and all this kind of stuff. But maybe they have different wavelengths
of light, maybe their eyes work in a different way. And so, they sort of think about the universe in
different ways. And maybe they've made a lot of discoveries about the fundamental nature of
reality, about physics, chemistry that we haven't made yet. Just because we come at our discovery
in our science from a very specific perspective. I just finished reading Children of Time by Adrian
Tchaikovsky, and the protagonists of the book are spiders and humans. And the spiders are advanced
and intelligent, and eventually develop astronomers, and technology, and radio, and all this
kind of stuff. But it's all very spider-based. So, they think in terms of webs, they build out of
certain kinds of construction materials, and mathematics comes very easy to them,
while the humans have other things that they're good at. And the humans and the spiders meet,
and interact, and realize how much they have – they're understanding reality in the same way,
but they have different strengths that they bring to the table. So, it may very well be that the
perceive the universe in different ways, just because of what evolutionary pressures were out
there. So, you know, it's back to Arthur C. Clarke's famous quote, either we are alone in
the universe, or we're not. And either possibility is equally terrifying. It's time to shout out all
the new $5 patrons and above. Paul Schakenberg, Meg P., Andrews Ellison, Smurflet42, Todd Lechner,
Caroline Webster, Marco Van Leishout, Joe Reynolds, Charles Nutter, and William King.
Join the club at patreon.com slash universe today. Terry Hardaway, how hard would it be to
put the ISS into lunar orbit, or even on the Moon? It would cost all the money. So, I did the math
a couple of years ago. And the thing to always understand is that to go to the Moon is not like
you just drift away to the Moon. The Moon is at the top of this enormous gravity well. Think about
this feeling that you have when you try to climb to the top of a mountain, right? It's exhausting.
It takes a lot of energy and effort to get to the top of the mountain. Well, imagine your mountain
is 500 kilometers high. That is the altitude of the International Space Station. And so,
when we launch stuff into space, we have to climb a mountain, 500 kilometer mountain tall,
and go sideways 28,000 kilometers per hour just to be in orbit around the Earth. Well,
the Moon is on a further mountain is now a mountain that is about 400,000 kilometers tall.
And so, if you want to take the International Space Station, you have to lug it up that mountain,
you have to carry it, you have to push it up that mountain. And that requires propellant.
I did the math. And, you know, it depends on what you do use ion engines, do you use
starships or starships cheaper, who knows, but you're looking in the roughly the same amount
of costs that it was to build the entire International Space Station is what it would
cost for you to send it up into lunar orbit. You'd have to match the investment. So, you're looking
at well over $100 billion in just fuel to just raise the orbit of the International Space Station.
Now, if you want to land it on the Moon, then the problem is that you can't do it very slowly and
carefully. You have to at some point have a lot of rockets that are allowing you to decelerate
gently onto the surface of the Moon. And so, you would have to launch hundreds of rockets
that would be capable of carrying different parts of the space station and be able to
balance the forces as it's getting closer and closer to the Moon. So, it would cost again,
probably the cost of building the space station in the first place. You'd be looking at hundreds
of billions of dollars to have it land gently on the surface of the Moon. You'd probably,
you know, you'd probably send up starships, you'd break open the International Space Station,
you would chomp down on the different modules, you would put them inside starship, you then refuel
your starship, your starship would fly to the Moon, it would land on the surface of the Moon,
a crane would pull out the module, put it down gently on the surface of the Moon. Yeah,
you're still looking at hundreds of billions of dollars to try and do something like that.
Space whales, how close do you think the Chinese base on the Moon will be to the American base?
Seems like there's a lot of benefits being close, geopolitics notwithstanding.
Any base on the Moon is probably going to be set up near the permanently shadowed craters of the
Moon at the South Pole. But there's a lot of those craters, and there's plenty of places that are
ideal. You know, there are hundreds of good spots to build base, and they're going to depend on,
you know, how close you want to be to the potential frozen water, how much energy you
need to get, what are some interesting scientific sites that are around you, how is the safety,
are there landslide risks, how easy is it to move around on the surface in the region where you want
to set up. It's not like you've got all of planet Earth to set up. You know, you've got your areas
that you can set up your Moon bases on are filtered down from a large list, but it's still lots of
space. So, how close would they be? I mean, I would think it would be great if they were very
close. If you've watched For All Mankind, the Americans and the Russians set up their bases
very close to each other, like within walking distance of each other. And, you know, that's
to set up tension and conflict in the show. But, you know, I still hold that the International
Space Station was one of the greatest ideas that's been had in space flight, that you took
two enemies, the Soviet Union or the Russians, and the United States, and then all the other
countries in the world who participated Canada, Japan, right, Europeans, and had them come
together to build this space station in peace. And so, even if people are in conflict down below,
they're working together like a team, which scientists and explorers will that if you set
up one base, and you had it staffed with some Chinese and some Americans, some Europeans,
and, you know, the occasional Canadian, they would work in harmony, it would be great.
And that it would save in transportation, it would save in risk, it would be the ideal
situation. And I hope that's what happens. Because that's, you know, I think that's the right play
is to build together. But politics on Earth will transcend and go to space.
Nunya, what sort of internet bandwidth should we expect on our moon bases?
It won't be great. So the first issue is the ping times. So it takes about a little over a second,
1.3 seconds to send a signal from the Earth to the moon kind of depends on where the moon is
at its orbit. So if you want to do the roundtrip time, two and a half seconds for you to be able
to communicate and so you want to click on a web page, it's going to take you a couple of seconds
for that web page start to load no matter what. But imagine you're trying to play a video game,
play some first person shooter, and your ping times are 2,500. That'd be brutal. You don't
want that. You want 0.15, right? The other issue is that just it requires a bigger and bigger
transmitter to be able to send that great distance. But there are some new technologies
that are being tested in space. NASA has a brand new communication system which uses
an infrared laser to transmit data back home to Earth. And they're able to achieve broadband speeds
from tens of millions of kilometers away. So we will probably have arrays of infrared lasers
on the moon that are transmitting communications from the Earth and then the reverse on Earth
transmitting back up to the moon. They'll have dishes, they'll have telescopes essentially,
that are receiving the signals from those transmitters going back and forth. And so
the more bandwidth people are trying to send from the Earth to the moon, the more that they will
build more and more of these receivers and transmitters on both sides. It'll be lasers,
for sure. Did you know that you can watch the same video with no ads and get a bonus question
over on Patreon completely for free? We call it Q&A Plus. And this week's bonus question,
could we grow crops in asteroid Regolith? And I'll put a link in the show notes.
All right, those are all the questions that we had this week. Thank everyone who
joined me for the live show. Everybody who put your questions into the YouTube comments,
I really appreciate it. The new season of One Piece is out and I'm going to give you my thoughts.
But first, I'd like to thank our patrons. Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andrea Pergetti,
Bear Lake Roofing, Brian Bode, Kerwin, Chuck Hawkins, Commander Bailuck, Cooper Nelly,
Darkfinger, David Gilton, David Matz, Evan Dot Pro, Greg Feely, James Clark,
Janice Smith, Jeremy Mattern, Jim Burke, Jordan Young, Josh Schultz, Marcel Smits,
Michael Purcell, Nordspace, Onesetforanimals.org, Ren Kaidu, Richard Williams, Sean Sturgeon,
Stephen Featherman, Team 49, Telescopes Canada, Wolfgang Klotz, and Zeldaboard Galactic Defender,
who support us at the Master of the Universe level. And all our patrons, all your support
means the universe to us. So last week, we had the second season of One Piece on Netflix. And
I enjoyed the first season, but that was before I had watched much of the show. And since then,
I've watched about 500 episodes of the One Piece anime. And so going into the second season,
I was a lot more prepared for what I was watching. I understood a ton of Easter eggs.
And, and I really enjoyed the show. You know, my wife was on the fence. She didn't,
I think it was a little too weird for her. And, you know, all of the sort of anime references
and things, they all just sort of flew right past her. But for me, I thought they did a fantastic
job of, of trying to boil down what is one of the most epic pieces of literature ever created. Like
just in terms of sheer mass, there is a lot of story here. And I can't even imagine how hard
it's going to be to try and break up the story into all the different episodes that they're
going to have to do. And we got sort of through a lot of chunks were sort of leading up to the
battle for Alabasta, which is a whole other chunk of the of the One Piece show. But, you know, I
enjoy how much of the weirdness of One Piece makes its way into this show, the amount of creativity.
And it was funny because I was watching the show with my wife and it was a whole episode with
Labou and she says, Oh, I see what's going to happen here. And I'm like, you do not know what's
going to happen here. Like, I promise you this show is so weird and so creative that you have
no expectations. And I think that's one of the things that I just really enjoy is, is that a lot
of it is just so weird and so creative and so clever and so different that you don't have any
firm ground to kind of compare it to. It doesn't fit into a lot of the memes that you're familiar
with. And yet there's a lot of stuff that I am very exhausted within One Piece. That's why I know
there's a version of One Piece called One Pace that you can watch it kind of clip down with just
the important pieces, because there's a lot of filler in it. And there's a lot of tropes that
are bad in it. A lot of kind of misogyny and, you know, other stuff that I'm really kind of glad has
not made its way into the show. So overall, I'm really happy with the adaptation. And, you know,
I don't know how they're going to try and keep this going for season after season after season,
because these guys, these kids are getting older. And, and yet in the actual show, they don't age
because it's really just over the course of a couple of years. So but I guess there's the time
skip anyway. Oh, yeah. I've enjoyed One Piece season two. If you haven't watched it, go watch
season one and then watch season two. All right. We'll see you next time.