ARTH 4007 Northern Renaissance Sculpture Part 1

Art of the Renaissance Period
59 followers
4 Video Views·Mar 6, 2026
Art Historian Dr. Vida Hull
ETSU Online Programs - http://www.etsu.edu/online
Northern Renaissance
I've got sculpture, mostly German sculpture.
I've got to divide the sculpture one and sculpture two.
So this is sculpture one.
We're going to talk about the artwork,
the sculpture of Nicholas Gerhard von Leiden.
And you'll notice I've got a couple of spellings
of his name here.
Sometimes you'll see it with Gerhard with an S on it,
sometimes without.
Sometimes you'll see Leiden spelled with a Y
and sometimes with an I.
And he lived from approximately 1430 to 1473.
Michael Paquere from about 1435 to 1498.
And Michael Earhart from around 1440
into the 16th century, 1522.
Michael Earhart also has a son who continues his style
and I do wish they had put him in your book
because there are some Michael Earharts
that just take my breath away.
Excuse me, there's some great,
well, there are some Michael Earharts, you'll see it,
but there's also Gregor Earhart statues
where he continues on the style of his father.
First artist we're going to talk about,
Nicholas Gerhard von Leiden is actually from the Netherlands
and all the other artists we're talking about,
we're talking about German sculptors here.
But although he is from Leiden in the North Netherlands,
he moves to Strasbourg and then eventually to Vienna.
And of course, when we say German,
we're not talking about the present day modern boundaries
of the nation states that exist in the 20th and 21st century.
So when I say he moved to Germany,
he's in Strasbourg.
Strasbourg today is part of France.
At that time, it was German territory.
There are very few works of art by him
that we are sure are by him.
There are some that are signed
and there are others that are attributed.
One of the things he's noted for
are these very active and complex
and dramatic shapes and forms in his work.
And you can see that in the example
that you're looking at right now,
which we'll comment on a little bit later,
but essentially is a sort of,
rather a twisted, complex pose for a man in repose.
This is, it's an extremely high relief
and it's a monument of Canon Conrad von Busenang
in Strasbourg Cathedral.
It's, if I remember correctly,
it's in one of the transepts.
It's off to the side and it's very high up on the wall.
So you would be looking up at this.
And so it's interesting to me,
I found this photograph where they've obviously
been able to probably get up
in some kind of ladder or scaffolding
and take a photograph sort of directly.
But I'll show you another one
where you're looking up at it.
It's made out of limestone
and you'll find that Gerhard works
with various stones and with wood as well.
Now, you'll notice how high the relief is.
You have this OG arch, which is a flamboyant Gothic shape,
a late Gothic, very florid shape
and the interlocking tracery and arches.
And then you have a kind of half-length Madonna
and then the baby Jesus and then the donor, the canon.
And the canon is in prayer.
It's presumably a very realistic image of him.
And the Christ child is really incredibly lively.
He's reaching from his mother,
he's sort of playing with her veil,
reaching right over to the canon.
And it really forms this kind of bridge between them.
So he's obviously very receptive
to the prayers of Canon Conrad.
Now, I told you I'd show you a picture.
This is one that I took and I did a little adjusting
to try to bring out the contrast of it
so you see it better.
But you're looking up from under.
And then there's this other one which I found somewhere,
which once again, you're looking up from under.
And you can see, essentially,
the figures have to be very three-dimensional almost
because otherwise, if they're flat against the wall,
when you're down below,
you wouldn't be able to get a good view of them.
But that kind of liveliness and complexity
is something that we see with Gerhardt's work.
This is probably one of his most famous pieces,
which is, as you can see,
quite unusual in the shapes and the forms.
It's a bust of a man.
It's actually a little more than a bust
because it's got the arms and the upper torso and the head.
But the figure is twisted around
in a very active position,
even though he seems to be sleeping
or at least thinking very hard.
So it's a kind of contemplative or figure and repose,
but not a very restful repose, actually.
It has been suggested that this may be a self-portrait
of Nikolaus Gerhard von Leyen.
It's made out of sandstone, and it's created in 1467.
Also in sandstone is this crucifixus.
It's just, you know,
making the Latin word out of crucifix.
So it is a stone crucifix with Christ on the cross
in the old cemetery at Baden-Baden in Germany.
It is a very naturalistic image.
You can see that Christ is emaciated in his suffering.
You know, the ribcage is extremely pronounced.
But there's a kind of dignity to it.
You have probably seen some of these images,
and we'll see some later,
where Christ is perhaps terribly distorted
to show you the suffering.
And there is that feeling.
You know, as I say, the ribcage is so prominent.
And yet you have that very simple,
what, horizontal and vertical of the cross.
It's a kind of severity to it.
Then it's enlivened with, of all things, the loincloth,
with these very deeply cut folds.
The loincloth, you know, sort of comes out on either side
like it was floating in the breeze,
or maybe really the wind.
And that, you know, imparts activity
to what is essentially a very static pose.
Not in your textbook,
but I thought this would be interesting
to see what he does with wood.
And also, that's the same subject,
so there's a similar treatment
with the ribcage emphasized,
and then the drapery, you know,
which has a certain amount of movement to it,
and the loincloth.
And you can see this, of course,
being a painted image.
It is wood.
It's a little bit earlier than the work in Baden-Baden,
about 1462, and then it would be painted.
At this time, wooden statues usually were painted,
and sometimes stone statues as well.
So this is another Christ on the cross,
and you can see that the wounds, you know,
are emphasized with the paint,
as though the blood has dripped down the arms,
has streamed down the arms.
Okay, when I think of Nicholas Gerhardt,
I think of this statue,
probably because it's one that I've actually seen
several times, actually.
This is the Madonna of Dengelsheim,
and we think it's around 1470.
It's not dated.
It's not signed.
It's made out of walnut,
and, of course, it has been painted.
You may remember that it's not always the,
there may be some sculptors like Mozart, for example,
and we'll hear about Pacquiao soon,
who have both painting and sculpture in their studio,
in their workshop,
but, you know, many other sculptors did not paint theirs.
They, the guilds would have very firm guild laws
that painters would paint and the sculptors would carve
and not take the,
not take the painting trade away
from those who were skilled in painting,
so it's quite possible that he did not paint this,
but at any rate, it's a wonderful, wonderful work.
It's about 40 inches high,
and when I've seen her, she's on a pedestal,
so you look up at her,
and you have the Christ Child, who is this plump,
big baby cheeks.
We'll see the spiral curls,
and he is just wiggling and squirming around.
He is so active,
and, you know, it almost,
he's twisting around to look at you,
so, you know, maybe that's it.
Maybe the Christ Child's actually wants to see you.
One of the things that's just marvelous to me
is the hair, of course.
You'll see this with other artists as well,
other people who do wood carving,
but you have these spiral locks of hair,
and they're just so,
they're just so energetic and beautiful
as they, you know, cascade down Mary's back.
I tried to lighten my image up a little bit
so you could see it a little better,
and then here's a detail.
These, you know, they're corkscrew curls,
and now they've been drilled,
and I'm not a wood carver,
so I don't know all of the techniques
that may be used to create these,
but I just find them actually fascinating.
And, you know, the face of the Madonna
is very smooth and beautiful,
and then you have the little spiral locks of hair,
both with Mary and these little curls
that the Christ child has this, you know,
head of curly locks.
To give it even more energy,
you have the veil is not just, you know,
hanging there with some design along the edge,
the edges are actually rippled,
and so that adds more energy,
and they're not just falling there.
Here's the Christ child,
it's almost like he's playing peekaboo
or revealing himself to us,
you know, as he's pulled up the veil on one side.
And the draperies also form very complex forms
and very dramatic and very deeply cut.
I was able to make that detail
where you could really see these deep shadows
where the artist has really carved deeply,
leaving shadows and complex angular forms,
and you can see this kind of triangular form
that descends down from,
it's about the feet of the Christ child,
cascades down the body,
and then there's all the breaking folds
where Mary's knee, you know, comes out.
So it's beautiful.
It's one of these beautiful Madonnas,
and just also a very dramatic work
that has been attributed to Nicholas Gerhardt.
A minute ago, I mentioned Michael Paquer.
This is his most famous work.
It's the St. Wolfgang Altarpiece,
and it's still in place.
It is in Trial in the Alps.
The area now is Italy,
but as I say, borders change.
So it's really where Italy and, I guess,
Germany, Switzerland, Austria,
Austria and, where Austria and Italy,
you know, sort of meet up along the Alps.
It's made of two different types of wood.
Limewood and pine.
And there are painted scenes in the wings.
It seems that Michael Paquer,
or at least his studio, his workshop,
was both a painter and a sculptor,
a woodcarver.
And so, you know, he had this workshop
that could produce, you know,
these large, complex altarpieces.
And I guess we'll just talk a little bit
about the structure of this.
You have the sarg, S-A-R-G,
which in Italy would be called the predella, actually,
the bottom piece that rests on
or right behind the altar.
And then there is the center,
which would be the center of a triptych,
the center of the triptych,
which is carved.
And this is the corpus,
and then the body of the,
of the altarpiece.
On either side, you have, in this case, painted wings,
and sometimes multiple wings.
And then up above, even, you know, more carving.
The altarpiece is crowned with all of this,
but beautiful, not just the figures,
but, you know, all of the complex
Gothic tracery and carving.
So let's look a little closer at some of the parts of it.
The center is the coronation of the Virgin.
And as you can see, it's polychromed using a lot of gold.
And the gold reflects often,
and I think it does make it hard to see individual parts,
at least in reproduction.
But you have Christ with a very elaborate crown,
blessing, holding the orb and cross,
and the Virgin Mary kneeling.
She's already been crowned.
And then just, you know, many angels all around.
On either side are two very important saints,
for this altar, anyway,
the St. Wolfgang and St. Benedict.
And this is the Church of St. Wolfgang,
who was a Benedictine.
And with the detail here,
you'd see Christ a little bit better.
One of the things I wanted to show with this
was how some of the color and the decoration comes in.
You have this raised surface on the,
what would be the embroidery along Christ's robe.
And then you have the way they're sort of imitating
brocade with the very fine colored lines
in this beautiful cloth.
And of course, the whole thing is surmounted
with what seems like a church architecture
in these overlapping, as we say, flamboyant Gothic.
Florid has been used,
but just a very intricate
and complex decoration
in the architectural structure.
Just another detail of Mary.
We're seeing her from another point of view.
She's looking very devout.
Her eyes are downcast because she is humble.
And I think you can see right behind her in the detail
some more of that,
you know, the place where you have the thin lines
of the decorative pattern
that are colored in contrast to the gold.
It gives it additional richness here.
Some of the way you can actually see the color.
Little musical angels.
And there is St. Wolfgang.
And you might notice how dramatic this drapery is.
You know, this is,
everything is activity, color, gold,
you know, very, very exciting.
The scenes that are on the
wings, the flugel.
On the outside, they tell a story of St. Wolfgang.
And on the inside, as you can see here
in the final opening,
you have scenes from, well, in this case, the nativity.
You can see scenes from the life of Christ.
And this is just one.
This is the nativity.
I tried to get a good reproduction
of the marriage at Cana scene that's also in your text.
And I wasn't able to do it.
The one that I found,
art store didn't have one
except for the black and white image
that was probably from your textbook.
The one art store that I,
the one that I did find,
the colors were just really bad.
So I decided to leave that out.
But let's see what we can see from this one image.
You can see that the artist is extremely interested
in the architectural structure of the
stable with all of these rafters.
And, you know, if you look at this
and also look at that picture in your text,
you'll see that there's
sort of a push back into space.
And he's interested in very dramatic foreshortening.
Both the ox when you're seeing from the rear
and the ass when you're seeing
in a foreshortened view from the front,
you know, are quite dramatically foreshortened.
There's a kind of hardness
about some of the drapery folds
and the way the Christ child is lying
at this foreshortened angle
that suggests that there might be some influence
from North Italian art,
specifically Montaigne.
Now, we don't have a recorded trip
by Poquer to go to see art in other places,
but certainly that seems to be most likely.
And here are panels from another altarpiece,
this one all painted of what we have left.
This is the Altarpiece of the Church Fathers.
Now, these are the Latin Church Fathers.
You have Jerome, Augustine, Gregory, and Anselm.
And you can see some of the things
we've already talked about
with the elaborate, in this case, painted architecture
with the OG arches that overlap
and have extensive dramatic tracery.
So they're all under these very active canopies.
The artist is really interested in things
like foreshortening and looking up at the saints.
You'll notice, once again,
that in this case, the lion of Saint Jerome
is foreshortened from the rear.
And each one of them has a dove
representing the Holy Spirit coming down
to give them inspiration.
That, of course, is part of the legend of Saint Gregory.
The Holy Spirit was supposed to speak directly
to him.
Jerome, I may have spoken to you about this before.
I'm not sure.
Jerome is shown usually in two different ways
in Renaissance art, either as a cardinal,
usually a cardinal in his study,
or as an ascetic saint who goes out into the wilderness
and beats his chest with a rock.
And so you'll see his chest all bloody
and the rock all bloody.
While he's out in the wilderness,
he meets a lion who has a thorn in his paw.
And being very kind, he takes the thorn
out of the lion's paw.
And the lion is very grateful
and essentially becomes his pussycat.
Follows him everywhere.
So that's why the lion is associated with Saint Jerome.
The cardinal's robes are a little bit ahistorical
because at the time Saint Jerome lived
in the late 4th and early 5th centuries,
the church had no cardinals.
That was a rank that was developed much later.
But looking back, they decided this man
is the doctor of the church.
He's the person who translated the Bible into Latin.
Surely he should have been a cardinal.
So I guess he's got his cardinal robes posthumously.
And here is a detail from one of the scenes
and this now not complete altarpiece,
dismantled altarpiece.
Once again, you see this kind of dramatic foreshortening
of the altar you're seeing going back into space,
this sort of rowing vault over the altar and further down.
And then the angel just flying in.
Dramatic diagonals.
Artist likes diagonals a lot.
And a great deal of drama to every scene.
And I also mentioned those sort of hard, tight folds
of the cloth of all these little angles
of the angel's garment.
You can see that quite clearly.
This is a miracle.
St. Sigismund is praying for guidance
should he start some of the reforms of St. Augustine.
And he prays that there will be a sign given to him
and the angel flies in and offers him
the heart of St. Augustine.
A very clear indication of the directions he should take.
Michael Earhart is from Ulm.
And this is probably his best known work.
It is in the museum in, well, now it's in Berlin.
And so it's in a major museum
where a lot of people, of course, would see it.
It is from, undoubtedly, from an altarpiece
that had more figures, had more parts to it.
But this is what has survived and she's beautiful.
She's made out of lime wood, linden wood,
which many of the German late 15th
and early 16th century sculptors worked in
and just were most accomplished craftspeople
working with lime wood.
This is polychrome and it was intended to be polychromed.
And you can see, of course, the gold in Mary's garment.
And Bach Sandel is talking about this in his book
on the lime wood sculptors of Germany.
And he talks about the use of the gold
and how, you know, if you just had the drapery folds,
you know, in this, he calls them wads,
coming down the side, you know,
that might not be as interesting.
But you put the gold on it, you know,
it has just the right diffusion of light
and you can see it from different points of view
and it's very deeply cut and works beautifully.
He talks about the simplicity of the garment
with the richness of the coloring and the gold.
This was from the Liebfrauenkirche.
The lieb is beloved, frauen is lady,
and kirche is church.
The Church of the Beloved Lady,
that's Mary, of course, in Ravensburg.
And she is a type of the Virgin of Mercy.
Now, this also has some other names.
In German, you say Maria mit den Schutzmantel.
Or in Italian, the Madonna della Misericordia.
Misericordia does not mean misery, it means mercy.
And this is then the Virgin Mary
with the mantle of protection, the Schutzmantel.
And as you can see, she has this dramatic cloak
that is open and is sheltering people
from all different types of people.
There's, you know, there's men and there's women.
They all do sort of look like
probably middle-class burgers, actually,
but she's sheltering all of these people beneath her cloak.
Anyway, and they are in prayer
and they look up to her in gratitude.
And she's looking up, too, or out
to God to intercede for them.
But in a sense, she's both lofty and tangible.
She's, you know, she's compassionate enough
that she shelters people beneath her own cloak.
She guards them.
And yet, she's the queen of heaven,
even though she doesn't have a crown or scepter here.
Boxandel also talks about how these long drapery folds
descend from her breasts.
And there is an emphasis on the breast here.
And you'll remember that it is the breast
that nursed Christ.
And at the Last Judgment, Mary May, in some paintings,
she shows her breast to Christ.
And she, you know, I nursed you.
You can save another sinner from me.
Or, you know, I'm your mother.
You know, you're supposed to honor your mother, right?
So there is that idea of interceding and protecting.
And she has mercy on all of us sinners in the world,
as it were.
And here you see a closeup.
You love the subtlety of some of the different patterns
of the, so the straight lines of the curving veil
that goes around her shoulder.
And then, once again, this sort of pseudo-brocade
in the cloak.
And that's contrasting with the gold,
the diffuse light that comes off the gold.
And you see all the little people.
And it's interesting to see them
from different points of view.
These are two I took.
So the shadows here are a little darker.
But you can see also, to break up those sort of
columnar folds that come down from Mary's garment,
you know, her knee projects forward.
And it gives her the sense, once again, of movement.
And she has this beautiful, graceful, refined figure.
And here is a shrine by Michael Earhart,
where you can see, you know, how that kind of figure
might have been placed in something larger, too.
This also has the Madonna, and in this case,
it's the Madonna and child in the center.
And on either side of her, she has other saints.
And as you can see in the wings,
you have scenes from the infancy.
And Christ and his apostles in the half-length
down there in the sarg or the predella.
Close.
They, as we said, they're painted.
And, you know, the bright colors,
the blues and the reds, you know, sort of give,
they break up the gold a bit.
You know, there's a lot of gold,
but it makes it possible to see what's going on.
And you'll notice that each one of these figures
is sort of curved to one side or the other.
And, you know, it gives it a little bit of grace,
a little bit of movement, rather than standing rigidly.
Very similar facial type, the Virgin holding the baby Jesus.
In this case, much more complex drapery
than we saw with the Virgin of Mercy,
where the detail was often in the subtle details
of the textures of the garment,
but also, of course, of the people.
And here, you know, we have a lot of drama
just in this active drapery folds.
At her feet, there is a crescent moon
with, as you can see, the man and the moon.
I've seen this in a number of German work.
I'm thinking of some clay sculpture
that I know about from the 15th century,
where they have the crescent with the face,
the profile face of the,
it's called the man and the moon, at her feet,
a sort of a personifying crescent moon.
And that, of course, comes from the apocalypse,
the woman clothed in the sun with a crescent,
with the stars in her crown
and the crescent moon at her feet.
And here are just some details of some of the other saints,
Saints Benedict, John the Baptist,
and then my little half-length of John the Evangelist.
You can see his chalice
that he's making the sign of the crossover,
and Saint Scholastica.
And this is from a Benedictine monastery at Blaubaren,
and right close to the end of the century,
the 1490s, 93 to 94.
