Da Vinci vs Michelangelo: The ‘Scandal’ of the Sculpture of David | BBC Timestamp

Wander the World with Me
13 followers
#Renaissance #Michelangelo #LeonardoDaVinci
Michelangelo's statue of biblical hero David has long been regarded as both a symbol of the Renaissance and an embodiment of the city Florence. However, one of his greatest works met unexpected resistance in the form of his professional rival, Leonardo da Vinci, who artfully used the threat of scandal to undermine Michelangelo’s masterpiece.
Michelangelo starts work on his David early in the morning of September the 13th 1501.
He toils for almost two and a half years before finally unveiling his eight and a half ton
masterpiece. David is so impressive, it's so realistic to have been able to do that out of
The moment that Michelangelo chose to depict is not the victorious moment where David can
stand on top of Goliath and he's won. It's the moment just before, it's the moment where he's
not sure if he's going to win the fight where he's scared and you can see the tension in his
body, you can see the fact that he's just starting to twist and the muscles are bunching up. David
totally changes the conception of sculpture. He shows that he is able to make inert matter
live and asking it to carry feeling and thought. When David was revealed you know people couldn't
believe it. It's not just this placid blank face, there is thought going on and to be able to sculpt
thought, I mean that's incredible. To be able to sculpt thought onto someone's face,
come on it's crazy. So in a sense it's exceeded its commission but there's a classic piece of
republican bureaucracy around the David piece because there is a committee which is set up
and they meet to discuss both the piece and where it should be cited
and Leonardo da Vinci sits on that committee.
I wanted it placed outside so it could be seen in close-up and in the round by everybody.
Proud symbol of the city in defiance of the tyrants that surrounded it but not everybody
agreed. Leonardo senses an opportunity to keep Michelangelo's sculpture hidden in the shadows.
He declares that David's nudity is an offence to the good people of Florence
and should not be publicly displayed.
David caused a bit of a scandal and can still cause
scandal to this very day because he's very lifelike.
