Rare Earth Minerals- Mr Carl Delfeld

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
9 Video Views·Mar 6, 2026
23rd Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, D.C🇺🇸- December 6-7, 2022
-Mr. Carl Delfeld
President, Economic Security Council - Managing Director, Blackthread, LLC
AI Generated·May contain errors
Nice to be with you today.
I very much enjoyed the previous space panel,
where we all learned that all our iPhones are connected
to space.
These iPhones are also full of rare earths and rare metals,
which have rare earths and rare metals have certain qualities
to allow us to have things like this iPhone smaller, lighter,
more durable, from jet engines to semiconductors
to satellites.
They are really crucial.
As I mentioned yesterday, the Japanese
call rare earths and rare metals industrial or technology
vitamins.
A very small amount makes everything work better,
much higher performance, which is
why they're so important in the technology
century that we live in.
Now, rare earths, let's start with just very briefly
what are rare earths, because it sounds very mysterious.
If you remember back to your high school chemistry,
the second from the bottom row, those are the rare earths.
There's 17 of them, but there's really only four or five
of them that are really important,
and they're very important in permanent magnets, which
are in, for example, electric vehicles and F-35 fighters.
They make machines move, basically.
The four or five of them probably
constitute about 90% of the value of rare earths.
So that's the 17 rare earths.
Now, US used to dominate the production in our main,
really our only rare earth mine, which
is in Mountain Pass, California.
It's had a very troubled history.
It went bankrupt and now has been reconstituted
as MP Partners, which is a private equity firm.
There's a Chinese partner, believe it or not,
that has a 9% stake.
We can talk a little bit about Mountain Pass.
The new management is doing some things right,
and it's going in the right direction.
But this is really why I got interested five, six years ago.
I'm not a metallurgist.
I'm an Asia and emerging markets analyst.
And I saw how dependent US industry
was on Chinese rare earths.
For some time, China has produced roughly 80%
of the world's rare earths.
It's interesting.
In 1978, 79, Deng Xiaoping famously
was quoted as saying, Saudi Arabia has oil.
China has rare earths.
And they very steadily picked up market share
and developed the industry just roughly something like this.
In the 1970s, they produced rare earth concentrate,
which is like a cocktail of all the rare earths inside.
In the 90s, it began to develop the technology
to what they call separation.
That's taking that cocktail and taking
each one of those 17 rare earths out and isolating them.
This is a very environmentally damaging process,
which is another reason why China took it over,
because the US environmental safeguards made
it very difficult for Mountain Pass to do it.
And then in the 90s, they started
to go to the next step.
You take the rare earths and you use
them to form metals, magnets, polishing powders.
And then lastly, in the 2000s, they
started to incorporate them in final products,
electric motors, computers, batteries, mobile phones.
And that's where we got where we are.
The only other major producer in the US government
is working with this company.
It's an Australian company called Linus.
They produce about 15% of the world's rare earths.
Right now, the mine is in Australia, Mount Weld.
And they do the processing in Malaysia.
They plan to open another processing plant in Texas
with US government support, so that's a good sign.
But it's very interesting how we let this happen,
how we let China dominate this industry.
The Wall Street Journal just recently
noted that the F-35 production line was held up
due to Chinese rare earth content in permanent magnets
in the F-35 fighter.
And as you can imagine, rare earths and their cousin,
what I would call rare metals.
So let's stop here just for a moment.
You have the 17 rare earths, but there's
many, many other rare metals, which
are also just as important, if not more important.
For example, germanium for fiber optics and satellites,
gallium for semiconductors and permanent magnets.
All these markets, they're just small markets.
They're opaque.
They're fragile, easily disrupted and manipulated.
For example, copper.
Everybody knows copper, a very important metal.
About 20 million tons of copper is produced each year.
Nickel, another important metal, about 3 million tons.
Whereas some of these rare earths,
if you add all the rare earths together,
it's about 200,000 metric tons.
About half of those are not that important.
So now you're down to about 100,000 metric tons.
Scandium, which is very important for naval ship
building, aircraft, 20 metric tons a year production.
Unbelievably small market.
And then I would say the rare metals, also known
as minor metals, strategic metals, critical metals,
tech metals, sort of tops out at about 200,000 metric tons
a year.
So that's how small these markets are
and how important they are.
Now in defense, I would just say that the Congressional Research
Service estimates it's about 920 pounds of rare earths
to make an F-35 fighter, 5,200 to make a destroyer,
9,200 pounds to make a Virginia class submarine.
And as tension is rising in Asia,
the pressure and the possibility of conflict over rare earths
is definitely there.
And I don't know if anyone recalls,
but roughly 10 years ago, a Japanese Coast Guard vessel
collided with a Chinese trawler in the East China
Sea near Senkaku, the disputed island.
And the Japanese basically took the ship, the trawler,
let the crew go, but kept the captain for questioning.
The Chinese lost it completely.
And basically, for a brief time, about a week,
embargoed rare earths exports to Japan.
Japan was completely dependent on rare earths and has none.
And this led to a tremendous spike in rare earth prices.
And ever since then, people have been spooked about them
and worried about the availability.
And so if America can more fully develop the Mountain Pass
mine, also work with Linus to do the refining,
because the refining is really the key issue.
We need to find new technology to do it cleaner, more safely,
more economical.
All those things are important, because the price.
There's another reason that Apple
makes 90% of their products in China.
Besides low-cost labor and low-cost land,
that's where the rare earths are.
One of the neodymium, you wouldn't
believe, but a neodymium magnet is right here in your speaker.
That's a tiny little magnet.
A regular car has hundreds of magnets.
And that brings me to clean tech, clean energy,
whatever you want to call it.
As Congressman Smith said, the transition
to a renewable energy future will not be easy.
The typical electric car requires six times more inputs
of rare earths and 3,000 microchips.
And the present scarcity and concentration
of production in China and other countries unfriendly to the US
suggests that conflict over these strategic materials
is definitely going to grow.
And then there's the paradox of clean tech.
All the critical metals necessary for wind turbines,
solar panels, electric vehicle engines and magnets,
such as cobalt, gallium, lithium, germanium,
rare earths, are far scarcer than petroleum in anything
but clean.
So we can talk more about Mountain Pass.
As I mentioned, they are expanding.
They're trying to be able to refine the material.
Right now, they have to ship it to China.
So technically speaking, the US produces zero rare earth oxides
right now.
They make the concentrate in Mountain Pass.
They ship it to China, and it disappears
into the marketplace.
They're working on doing it here.
They're refining here, which would be a major milestone.
And then they also want to go a further step
and make the permanent magnets in the United States.
So slowly but surely, unfortunately too slowly,
we're filling in the supply chain.
And so we just need to accelerate it.
And wherever Congress can help in terms of funding
to move things faster, I think it would be welcome.
I'll just say one final comment.
What happens when everybody starts
talking about rare earths is that every junior mine,
I shouldn't say every, many junior mines in Canada,
the United States, South America,
suddenly change from a silver mine or a copper
mine into a rare earth mine.
They all want funding.
And so they use it as a marketing tool.
We're going to solve our problem.
And so my 501C, the Hay-Seward Economic Security Initiative,
is basically monitoring these hundreds of junior miners
and trying to figure out the 10 or 12 that
are really worth supporting.
So I think I'll stop there and look forward to your questions.
Thank you.
Dennis Bartow, if you would make your presentation.
Thank you.
Good to see you, man.
Good to see you, too.
Hi, everybody.
How are you?
Congressman Pittenger, thank you for having me
in the Washington Intelligence Policy Forum.
It's a real honor to be here.
So my name is Dennis Bartow.
I'm the president and founder of Polymarky Incorporated.
We are what we like to fashion as great power
competition or strategic competition experts.
I have listened to all the speakers.
And these are all very, very well-informed folks
in various policy and other industry matters.
So I'm trying to shape exactly what
I would say as a complement to the conversation
and hopefully be a little bit intriguing to you
for some question and answer later.
But my background, I was the Deputy Assistant Secretary
of Defense for Africa Policy.
I was the Pentagon's senior policy maker and advisor.
And Congressman Smith, I don't know
if he's still around, but we can rant together
about DRC and some of those issues for sure.
And then I was also the DOD's small business director.
So I was the first appointed small business director
in five years at the Pentagon, a direct report
to the Office of the Secretary of Defense.
So much of my time in the last number of years,
previous to that, I was at Interpol's Washington
office in their counterterrorism division
and working Africa issue, illicit trafficking
in the Gulf of Guinea and things like that.
So a lot of what I've done over the past decade plus
and 30 years in the military has been
encountering illicit activities in various ways,
but over the past few years in strategic ways,
focusing on, like I said, that strategic power
or strategic competition, great power competition world.
So essentially, I represented the Pentagon
at a thing called Prosper Africa,
which was the interagency's framework
to increase two-way trade between the continent
and the United States.
As DASD and as part of the office,
we looked at various different commodities
on the continent for various strategic access
and strategic denial.
And we had identified 16 mines on the continent,
a couple of uranium and a bunch of other things
that we did everything we could to get a U.S. mining firm
to go over there to take them over.
The Africans are begging for it.
The Africans want trade, not aid.
They'll tell you that.
The Africans present, I'm sure you can back that up.
Rwanda wants to be the Silicon Valley of Africa.
I'm actually working with a company
to do space launches in Africa,
and Rwanda, I should say, as well, just as an aside.
But when we look at these issues
from a broad strategic standpoint,
all the valid points that we've talked about,
the Chinese dominance in the industry,
one of my colleagues said, we've already lost.
I mean, we've lost Africa.
We've lost the processing, the access,
the extraction as a country.
And that's a sad thing to hear.
But since the 80s, when the Chinese really took over
the global raw materials supply chain in every regard,
I mean, everything we have is grown or mined, everything.
All the food, every chair in here, all the microphones,
everything we've talked about are grown or mined.
And even though the United States is still number two
in critical materials extraction and production,
we send it all to China for processing.
We talked about Linus, we talked about MP materials,
we didn't talk about USA rare earths,
but there are a number of folks that are trying desperately
to get something going, kind of picking over the corpse
of a previous operation, which is often the case.
But we have not actually had a new green field,
which is a new mine in this country for 40 years.
So I was honored to be a small part of an IPO
here in the United States that was done on private lands,
on already used copper mines with better technology
to kind of get at some better stuff.
And that's about as good as we've gotten
for almost a generation now in the United States.
A lot of the things that are still in production,
copper and others, they're 80, 100 years,
a lot of them are reaching their end state.
And then you have situations
where you have the twin mines in Minnesota,
which is our best nickel deposit overall.
It was shut down.
It's been sued about 19 different times.
For those that were following it,
there was $2.8 billion given up by the administration.
107 million, I believe, was given to Talon Mines,
which for a processing facility,
and they're not even in production.
And the average in the United States, as an aside,
takes about 14, 15 years to get a new mine going.
Canada, about five years.
Australia, about the same.
So I guess where I'm getting at,
whether we talk policy
or we talk what legislators could do,
the reality is we have to compete,
to out-compete the Chinese and other malign influencers,
near-peer competitors.
We need to support our partners and allies
around the world, predominantly the Australians,
the Canadians, the Brits, the Kiwis, and others
that are out there scratching the earth
and doing patriotic work to keep the Chinese at bay.
They're always looming at every deal.
Most of the mining companies I should swerve into,
what I have been doing the past two years
since leaving government,
is work with some of the globe's
best mining and mineral houses.
And believe it or not,
one of the things that we provide as a service
is keeping it quiet, okay?
Spouting whales get harpooned.
Every one of these projects has somebody looming,
the Chinese, the nation.
I mean, if we can look at an example in Mexico
where they nationalized their lithium.
And we talked about Congo.
We don't need to talk about when it turned into Zaire
and kicked all of the industries out
from the West and others.
So that is part of it.
I have a client that they have manganese
and they don't want anybody to know
because their government will probably nationalize it
like they did other minerals in that country.
So it's a huge challenge.
And one of the things that I've done,
again, over the last two years in government,
helped to kind of set the table
some of the broad strategic policies
within the interagency, mostly the Pentagon,
but working with State Department,
AID, other interagency colleagues and various agencies
is try to set the table to support industry
when they're doing things around the planet.
And when you talk about strategic competition
or defense support for economics, as I would call it,
is industry is very, very, very open
to supporting our global strategic priorities,
whether it be buying up a port or developing something.
They just need some help from the government
to let them do that.
So we talked about various ways to get at human rights
and environmental rights abuses,
whether it be through Child Soldier Protection Act,
the Kimberley Process for Deconflicting Conflict Minerals,
Child Soldier Protection Act.
These are all things, by the way,
that that's your day-to-day in the Africa policy world.
They're all great and they're all fantastic,
but our values travel as far as our influence, okay?
Remember that.
If you don't remember anything else I say
about this global discussion on mining and minerals,
your values travel as far as your influence.
If you want influence in these countries in Africa
or the Middle East or in the Indo-Pacific region,
you have to have some sort of influence over them
to push all the gold standard things we talk about.
And the reason, frankly speaking,
that we have so much conflict minerals in Central Africa
is because we just don't care about it.
We really don't care about it.
I can pull up 20 years worth of videos
on the human rights, just hell on earth,
that these kids live through, getting cancers early,
having mines collapse on them multiple times a year
if they survive.
They have no other options, but a lot of that
is because of the feel-good things that we try to do
to get at abuses when we actually create
a more illicit situation.
You have black markets in mining and minerals.
You have.
