*Andy Hardy Gets Spring Fever* (1939) is a charming MGM family comedy starring Mickey Rooney as the energetic and lovestruck Andy Hardy.
As spring arrives in the small town of Carvel, Andy finds himself swept away by an unexpected romantic infatuation with his drama teacher. Convinced that his feelings are true love, he begins imagining a future far beyond his years, leading to humorous misunderstandings and heartfelt lessons.
With the guidance of his wise father, Judge Hardy, Andy gradually discovers the difference between youthful dreams and the realities of growing up.
♪
♪ To live to dance, age is full of care.
♪ Life is short, youth is nimble.
♪ Age is lame, youth is hot and burned.
♪ Age is weak and cold, youth and age is tame.
♪
♪ Oh, sweet shepherd, hi there.
♪ For me things, for me things, for me things,
♪ for me things shall stay.
Miss Meredith, I didn't know you were still here.
Oh, Polly, did you want something?
Well, I was just looking for Andrew.
Well, he's not here right now.
I sent him out to see about costumes,
but if it's about the play, could I help you?
It's just, I wanted to talk to him about my role.
T'Hula? It's the leading female part.
Aren't you happy with it?
Oh, what about that horrid ending?
You mean where the poor little native girl
jumps into the erupting volcano?
Andy thought it was quite spiritual.
He wrote it deliberately to humiliate me.
To humiliate you? What do you mean?
Well, just because a girl goes out
with a naval officer a couple of times.
Oh, I see.
Well, Andy's just full of enthusiasm right now
about drama and literature,
especially after reading Romeo and Juliet.
He certainly has changed.
You never know what's going to happen
when Andy Harding gets spring fever.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
Modern Hollywood makes its bread and butter
on long-lasting series and ongoing franchises.
In the golden era of Hollywood,
filmmakers preferred to make simple,
quick, standalone films all in the same formula.
However, there were a few longer-running movie series
made during the heyday of Hollywood's studio system.
Similar to the long-running TV
and streaming series of later years,
these film series developed characters
and scenarios across many related installments.
The most successful movie series
was MGM's Hardy Family series,
which quickly centered its focus
on the youngest member of the family, Andy Hardy.
Our favorite installment in this lengthy series
is the seventh, Andy Hardy Gets Spring Fever from 1939.
This movie was the only one in the series
directed by W.S. Van Dyke.
It starred Louis Stone as the father of the family,
Judge Hardy, Fay Holden as the mother, Emily Hardy,
Cecilia Parker as older sister, Marion,
and Mickey Rooney as the titular Andy Hardy.
It also featured guest star Helen Gilbert
as Andy's substitute teacher.
In this film, Andy Hardy, as he always seems to,
is having girl trouble.
His steady girl, Polly Benedict,
is interested in a young naval officer
and Andy feels rejected.
Meanwhile, they have a new literature teacher at his school,
a lovely young woman named Rose Meredith.
She opens Andy's eyes to the beauty, drama,
and romance of literature such as Romeo and Juliet.
And he writes a play based on Romeo and Juliet
with a bit of Polly's romance
with the naval officer thrown in.
But as time goes on and they decide to do his play,
Andy begins to feel very serious feelings for his teacher,
unlike any he's had
for any of the younger girls around town.
Meanwhile, Judge Hardy has troubles of his own
when two businessmen approach him about a property he owns,
the aqueduct property,
and tell him that he can make millions
by extracting aluminum out of the soil.
It's so interesting to look at the Andy Hardy series
because it became this, almost like a sitcom,
and there's so many different movies,
yet it was really interesting how it started.
It began as a play called A Family Affair,
very successful play,
and then that was made into a movie in 1936.
Which had a very different cast,
much bigger stars, I would say.
Yes, it did.
Lionel Barrymore played Judge Hardy.
And Spring Byington was Mrs. Hardy,
but Mickey Rooney was always Andy Hardy.
And Cecilia Parker was Marion.
But there was a third sister.
That's right, the oldest.
The oldest, who was completely written out after that.
And interestingly, even that work was almost,
I want to say, a spinoff of the very successful
All Wilderness the year before.
Which had the same Cecilia Parker as the young lady,
and her sweetheart was played by the same young man
who didn't feature in anything other than the first film.
With Lionel Barrymore as the father,
and Mickey Rooney as the younger brother.
It was so successful, they said,
let's do something similar.
So they did that play.
And then it was so successful,
they saw the potential to do more adventures
of the Hardy family,
but they knew that they couldn't really make it profitable
if they kept using these big stars.
So they kept the children and recast the parents,
cut out the older sister,
and the first film with that new cast
was called You're Only Young Once.
Came out in 1937.
And the first couple of films, I'd say,
focused pretty much equally on Marion and her romances
as she was in her later teens, if not early twenties.
She seems to have already graduated from high school.
And then her younger brother, Andy.
And that film, You're Only Young Once,
I think it was really focused on Mr. and Mrs. Hardy as well.
They're sort of recapturing the romance of their youth
when they go on this vacation to Catalina.
So the first few films really were
about all the family members,
but by the fourth film, which is Love Finds Andy Hardy,
Andy's name was in the title,
and he really was the focus of every film after that.
Each one of these movies in the long lasting series
is a masterpiece.
You could say-
You could do a separate episode talking about each one.
You could say that the main branch of them
took place over the course of 10 years,
as the last one in the main series,
Love Laughs at Andy Hardy, came out in 1946,
after Mickey Rooney had returned from World War II.
And so had Andy, right?
That was written into the story.
Yes, it was.
But then another 11 years passed
before the final film was made,
which was actually supposed to be the beginning
of a new bunch of Hardy's films.
And in that one, Judge Hardy has died,
and Andy is kind of taking over as the father
as he returns to his hometown of Carvel.
And that was Andy Hardy Comes Home.
It failed to restart the series,
but it remains the last one in this far reaching series.
With all due respect to the film,
I can see why it didn't take off.
I think they were a little torn
on whether they wanted to appeal to the old audience
that had grown up with these films,
or try to bring in a new audience.
And so it ended up being a bit not sure quite what it was.
So across all these 16 films,
I could probably name like three or four
that are toward the bottom of the list.
The first one is just very different.
Yeah.
And the last one is very different.
But in the middle, like you said, each one is so great.
Why do you think we've always chosen
this one as our favorite?
For a couple of reasons.
For me, I find this one the easiest to watch.
Straight through.
Because even though Andy does get into some romantic trouble
and he goes through a pretty tough experience,
kind of having his heart broken for the first time,
he doesn't get into as deep of trouble
as he often does in films.
A lot of times he gets into monetary issues.
A couple of times he kind of gets in trouble with the law
and his father has to bail him out.
And this one, it's more,
it's kind of first time Andy's standing on his own feet.
And even though he talks about it with his father,
he ultimately has to kind of learn the lesson himself.
So the stakes aren't as high, I think, as they sometimes are.
And also there's this interesting element
that they're putting on this play.
And I think as a performer, that's very interesting.
It's interesting because besides the Hardy Family Series,
some of the most successful films Mickey Rooney made
at this time at MGM were the Let's Put On A Show musicals
that he made with Judy Garland.
So I consider this like the unofficial
Let's Put On A Show movie of the Hardy Family Series.
Which is funny because Judy Garland did feature
in some of the Hardy films, but not this one.
So she wasn't in the Let's Put On A Show film.
And there's nothing musical about this one,
but you see that process of how excited he is
to be writing this play and playing the leading man
and directing and building sets.
And that's that kind of showman enthusiasm
you see in those movies.
Our first introduction to it is when he's showing it
to his friend, Beasy.
He says, now listen, Beasy, because it's terrific.
It's like, if only we could all be that confident
about our work.
And I think that it probably was a direct result
of the success of the first Let's Put On A Show movie,
Babes in Arms, which went live in 1938
and earned Mickey Rooney his first Academy Award nomination
in the adult category.
So I think that they thought, let's put a little bit
of that into the Hardy Family Series
and have him put on a play in his school.
But going back to what you said about how this is almost
like a TV sitcom, it had a similar quality
to later in sitcoms.
So many actors were introduced through that.
And that was the case.
There were the two big series at MGM.
This one and the Dr. Kildare series.
And there was this stream of young women
who kind of broke out on the screen
by being in these two series.
And a lot of them, at first they were in this,
and then they went on to Dr. Kildare as the more mature role.
And in this case, it was Helen Gilbert,
the young teacher.
This was her film debut.
Wow.
And it's so interesting that she's a beautiful young woman
with a lovely voice and a great actress,
but she was a musician too.
That's right.
I always forget that.
She actually was a cellist in the MGM Studio Orchestra.
Because there weren't many women
in orchestras at the time,
largely just because of the look.
It kind of breaks up the look.
If you have all the men in their white tie and tails
and you have the lovely female harpist.
But if you have a woman in the cello section,
it's not as streamlined.
But it doesn't matter in the studio orchestra.
So there were far more women in studio orchestras
than in symphony orchestras.
And somebody saw her and said,
you're too beautiful to be playing a cello.
So she ended up making some movies.
And like you said, after this,
she then appeared in one of the Kildare films,
The Secret of Dr. Kildare.
The Secret of Dr. Kildare, the third film in that series,
which came out the same year as this movie, later in the year.
Now, there's a big point about that
she is obviously the older woman in relation to Andy.
Was she actually that much older than Nicky Ray?
He was, depending on when they filmed this movie,
either 18 or 19, because he was born in 1920.
I'm not sure.
She was in her early 20s.
There's not as big of an age gap because he wasn't 16.
He was two years older than Andy Hardy,
consistently throughout the series.
Eventually, by the time of the war,
they got even more ahead
because he got even more than two years older
than the character.
But for the majority of the series,
he was two years older.
And so then there was a realistic aging.
And because of his boyish appearance
and diminutive stature,
he was very convincing as that age.
At a certain point, you see in the series
when eventually they finally kind of accept,
it's like, yeah, it's not just that he's young anymore.
He's just short.
Because it's not talked about that much when he's younger,
but particularly the last couple of films,
they make a couple of passing references
to that he's not going to grow anymore.
He's supposed to be in his 20s, we all know.
He's a really light bloomer.
And I think Nicky Rooney is often considered
just like this comedian or this child star,
this juvenile star.
But in every one of the Hardy films,
he shows what a dramatic actor he was.
I think this one stands out to me for the scene
when he's doing the final scene of the play.
And it's one of those interesting performance
within a performance moments when Andy realizes
that there's another man in his teacher's life
and he's having a parallel experience
to his character in the play.
And so you get this multilayered effect.
And that scene is just a masterclass in acting to watch.
He really gets, like you say,
to really show that dramatic acting prowess,
which you do see at some point in all of the Hardy films,
but I particularly like the way it comes out in this one.
And I think there's more seriousness
and more maturity for him in this movie
than in many others.
Because right at the beginning,
he realizes Pauly is going out with this other guy.
So he's sulky, he's serious.
Instead of just being more playful
and fun-loving throughout,
he really isn't for most of the film.
And I know we immediately after watching this film
just laughed on, like, this is such a great one.
And we watched this one more than any of the other ones.
And then I feel like we went back
and watched a few more of the ones before this again.
And then watching this again,
it's really striking how serious he's being in this film.
It's like he wants to get married.
It's like, wow, Andy's really growing up.
It's very, it really stands out as quite a-
Turning point.
A turning point for him, yes.
And he really develops a lot of maturity.
And then, you know, at the end, he kind of, you see,
it didn't-
It didn't make him too serious and gloomy.
It's still good old Andy.
But it is interesting to look at the trajectory
of his career in relation to this series,
because if you look at some of his performances,
even as a very young child, before Andy Hardy,
I feel like he played some darker characters.
Yes.
And then, like, in a very notably in Boys Town,
that's a very troubled character.
Yes, yes it is.
And that was just, like, right as the series
was getting started.
That was in the first couple of years,
but he hadn't really been established as,
he became this, like, every mother's son,
so they had to be very careful about how he was handled
in all his other movies.
Yes, that's true.
And he began to be more Andy Hardy
in various different scenarios,
even when he wasn't Andy Hardy.
Some movies in the series feature the other characters more,
and some feature them less.
Like, there are some movies where Marion
isn't even in them, some of the later ones.
Now, she is in this one.
It's not about her romance or anything,
but she wants to get a job.
She feels like her life is pointless,
so she gets a job as a secretary.
So that's a subplot for her.
Aunt Millie is there.
She doesn't do a whole lot.
It is the main Aunt Millie, who is Sarah Hayden.
There was an alternate who appeared
in a couple of the movies.
But this is the main one.
And the mother is there being more of a source of advice
and comfort to her husband than to the children in this one.
Right.
Because she takes on different roles.
She's always there being the great mother.
But this one isn't as much about her as some of them are.
Andy doesn't really let her in on this problem.
He's really just asking his father about it.
But this film really allows Andy and his father to shine.
And almost every one of the movies
begins in Judge Hardy's courtroom.
It's true.
That was the formula that they used.
And then they would branch out to show the children,
the mother, the other characters.
And it starts with, he's sentencing a young man
who was kissing a girl in a parked car.
Very serious offense at the time.
And he fines him $10.
And you can see that the young man looks rather distressed.
But then Judge Hardy stops and says,
what's that nice smell?
Lilacs, Judge, it's spring.
And then he looks out the window
and sees lilacs are blooming.
He says, ah, spring.
Sign suspended.
So he takes pity on the young man
and realizes, oh, he has spring fever.
And that's the theme of the movie,
how spring fever affects not only that young man,
not only Andy, but even the judge himself.
As he later says, I smelled some lilacs
and I got greedy for the first time.
As he has a flight of fancy with these two men
who come to him with his offer.
And right before that, we see him
complaining about having to pay
a significant amount of property taxes
on the aqueduct property.
Now, if you watch this movie out of context
and you haven't watched any of the other movies,
you'll be like, okay, what's that?
It still stands alone and it makes sense.
But if you've been watching the movies
as far back as the very first film,
A Family Affair, the aqueduct issue
was kind of the main point of that first movie.
That was the major conflict of this aqueduct
and the legality surrounding it
of developers wanting to use an aqueduct
for personal profit versus the public good.
And Judge Hardy ultimately resolves the issue
by buying the property himself.
And that remains, like I said,
it's not always there,
but it pops up every once in a while
and it really comes to a head in this film.
In the very next film, which was You're Only Young Once,
it's a major issue in there.
And like I said, it pops up several times.
This is the last time, film number seven,
that the aqueduct property is mentioned
because near the end of the film,
he sells the property to the city.
So that's the end of it.
But you can tell they kept that going for a while
because like, let's not write it out yet.
We can keep using it.
We might need it.
It's used very well in this film.
As that's the property where then to realize
that it's not just a bunch of useless gravel,
that it could have a very valuable mineral in it.
So then he gets some of his friends in
in this business deal and Marion becomes their secretary.
But then he begins to wonder if these two men
are maybe not as honest as they seem.
So that's another reason why I consider this
one of the best of the Hardy films
because it continues and concludes that thread
that came from the very first film.
And I think it creates a very special moment
sort of bonding for Judge Hardy and Andy
because almost every film Andy comes into his studies
like, dad, we need to have a man-to-man talk.
And there's a moment when he has realized
what a mistake he's made with working with these two men.
And Andy asks to talk and he's like,
no, no, not tonight, son.
And he starts to leave and he looks disappointed.
He's like, no, wait, I've never refused
to listen to your problems before.
I won't now.
So that's a very important moment
when he realizes he has to be there for him as a parent
even though he has arguably much more serious problems
of his own that he's dealing with
a very serious monetary issue.
But it's very important that Andy always knows
he can talk to him.
And the next film was called Judge Hardy and Son.
So I think they really saw how strong that relationship was
and how important that was, really the heart of the series.
And it truly was.
And I think that's why that last film
really couldn't be a success without Judge Hardy.
That's a good point.
This whole series is just so beautiful
and so poignant even today,
as it shows the importance of family life
as it's the nucleus of a community.
This is a story about a community, Carville, USA.
They never say the state.
It seems to be like Midwest.
And I think, again, this movie is great
because they travel in a lot of the films,
but this one takes place all right there in Carville,
good old hometown, USA.
And it's everybody's hometown.
That's why they didn't say the state
because everyone who lives in a small town lives in Carville,
a place where people are striving to do the right thing
and to find honesty and be good neighbors.
There's a lot of failure to that.
There's a lot of dishonesty and people make mistakes
and wrong each other.
But ultimately, they're just common Americans
trying to do the right thing.
And Judge Hardy is such an example of a virtuous husband,
father, an honest judge, and a great community member.
Across the films, the life advice
that Judge Hardy gives to Andy is really beautiful
and it's all very true.
And you see, and this is something I think, again,
you see reflected in some of the 50s and 60s sitcoms
like My Three Sons, where you see a father
and how he is always so understanding with his children
and how he tries to get them to think on their own.
When Andy comes and is like,
I want to marry this woman who's a good five
or six years older than he is.
He's maybe 17, he's like, I'm pretty near 17,
I'm almost 18, he's not quite 17.
Instead of just telling him what's wrong with you,
of course you're not going to marry this woman,
he tries to just present to him
what could possibly be problematic about that,
but he never gives it as an order.
And then in other films, every once in a while,
when he's just doing something wrong,
he has to tell him and be very strict.
But if it isn't that he's done something wrong,
it's just that he's confused
or he's learning things about life.
He just wants to help him learn himself
so that one day he can be his own man instead of,
so he won't rely on him too much,
but he wants him to know that he's there
if he needs advice or help, yes.
And it's a good example of life in this late depression
and pre-World War II era,
eventually even going into World War II,
showing what this family life was like.
And I think people look back and consider
that life at this time would have been very harsh,
like father would have been the disciplinarian
and mother was downtrodden
and the children would just be
very much under their father's thumb.
But movies like this paint a very real picture
of family life, showing that parents wanted the best
for their children and would give them strong morals,
but Judge Hardy never talks down to his children.
He treats them as intelligent individuals
and gives them advice tailored to their circumstances
so that they trust him as a friend,
but he's not trying to be their pal.
He wants to talk to him man to man.
And that is the thing that you see from the earliest films
that Andy and his father talk man to man.
And this is the kind of father figure
that all young men need today.
And so many of them don't have that in their own father,
maybe not even in their own uncle, grandfather, teacher,
but to see an example of that in a movie like this,
I think is an excellent pattern that fathers can take,
male teachers can take and coaches,
anyone who could be that male role model.
And even young men as they're seeing,
this is great advice and that's the kind of man
I want to become.
Sure, we'll do dumb things and Marianne and Andy
make their fair share of mistakes,
but the wisdom and respect that you see
alongside a lot of fun,
that's why these movies are so much of product
of that wholesome time in the late thirties,
as well as you see in just the common everyday fashion
of that period.
My outfit is inspired by one which Andy's teacher,
Rose Meredith, wears one day at the Carvel Bank
when she has a talk with Judge Hardy.
It is a fitted short jacket over a mid calf length skirt
as was standard in the thirties,
the white tailored blouse and a very businesslike hat.
My outfit is inspired by one worn by Polly Benedict
played by Anne Rutherford in a scene
where she's rehearsing for the play.
It's a pleated skirt with low shoes,
a blouse with a bow at the neck,
sometimes called a kitten front blouse
and a little matching jacket.
She also wears a bracelet.
You definitely see a lot of films from this time period,
which I think give you an honest look at life.
There are the very glamorous films,
but also that's the sort of simple Midwestern culture.
But this series, I think, really stands out
for being focused on the youth or adolescence
as they call them in the film.
And so it gives a very unique perspective,
I think, when looking at the golden era.
That's true.
Instead of focusing on young adults
or people who are in their careers in their twenties
or thirties, this really does focus on,
I mean, Andy's very young when the series starts.
He's like 14.
And we see him growing up
and we see what it was like for young people in that era.
So I agree, it's a good relatable starting point
for young people who want to discover this era of film.
If you want to know what the thirties are really like,
it's not the flappers, it's not like the jazz age,
that's the twenties.
And it's not the stereotypical thing you think it is.
This shows you what everyday average life was like.
The ups, the downs, the little challenges,
the things that you never even consider.
Like when Marian says, I want to get a job.
For one thing, her parents are completely fine
with the fact that even though they don't have
that much money, she lives at their house.
She doesn't work.
And because she has a daughter, that's okay.
They're happy to provide for her until she gets married.
But she feels like her life is pointless
or she wants to get a job,
which is typical of, by that point,
a lot of young women were working.
And her father is open to the idea, but he says,
I think it's good for you to do something
that would be serious and practical and productive,
but I'd hate for you to take a paycheck away
from someone in the family who might need it.
I mean, that's so far from the consideration
we'd have today as every business, like Help Wanted,
they need more employees.
But at this point, this is still the late depression era.
Jobs were scarce.
And a lot of them, there were more jobs
that women could get.
And people with families
were really still struggling to provide.
So that shows just the social conscience
that Judge Hardy has in a very honest, practical way.
He's not an over-the-top do-gooder,
but he's just practical.
And he thinks about, if there's a problem,
how can we solve it?
So that's why he gets her a job working
for these two men who are starting the aluminum company,
but he doesn't want to sort of influence them
and say, well, because I'm investing in your business,
I want you to hire my daughter.
That wouldn't be ethical.
That would be nepotism.
So instead he says, with the provision
that I pay you her salary.
I mean, they can't say no to that.
It's a good deal.
But because he wants her to get some experience,
I think he knows she really isn't that well-trained
for a secretarial job.
Before that, he's having her be sort of secretary for him.
He's dictating something for her.
So he's trying to train her for work.
Because he said, I'd like to know
you could provide for yourself if you needed to.
And that's the kind of practical wisdom
we see from Judge Hardy.
So if you're interested in finding out more
about life in the 30s, I would highly recommend
that you watch all of these movies.
This is a great starting point,
and then go back to the beginning.
Start with A Family Affair,
and then watch them all in order.
You can buy two different collections
that are from Warner Archive on DVD,
and together they make up the whole Andy Hardy series,
all of the episodes.
There even are a couple of short films
that I don't think are included on there,
and I've never even seen them,
but they do exist, that were made,
a lot of them to promote different ideas
about not buying a new car,
or helping this cause or that cause.
And they would make things like that
back then interesting, almost like infomercials.
And in addition to that,
all of the films are available to rent
or to purchase on streaming platforms
like Amazon Prime Video, YouTube.
And a few of them are more available
and for free than others,
particularly Love Finds Andy Hardy
and Love Laughs at Andy Hardy.
That one is free on many platforms.
I think it must have,
the copyright must have lapsed
because it's free a lot of places.
And Love Finds Andy Hardy is very popular
because of Judy Garland being featured in it.
Yeah, that was her first film in the series.
And she sings a very,
well, I think well-known song of hers, In Between.
So you'll be amazed at all the well-known stars
you'll see in their very early days in the series.
And each one is just a charming film.
They're all under an hour and a half.
Like some of them are around 70, 80 minutes.
And I think this was 82.
It's not much longer than an episode
on a modern streaming series,
but the content is so rich, so wholesome.
It's just, it'll leave you with a smile on your face.
We've said many times
that these films are very true to life.
However, they are fictional.
Many great classic films were biopics,
true stories based on composers, authors, or musicians.
Join us next time as we talk about a great dramatic musical
all about a lesser known musician from the jazz age.
Thank you for watching.
Goodbye.