Disney’s animated princess movies set the tone for how girls would view royalty for generations. In recent years, the studio has tried to change the stereotype of a young princess from a damsel in distress to a strong, empowered female, as evidenced in their recent live action remakes. However, many historical dramas made during the Golden Era of Hollywood achieved what these modern films have been trying to do by accurately depicting the powerful roles many royal women held without pushing an agenda. A great example of this is “The Private Lives of Elizabeth and Essex” from 1939. This fabulous Technicolor Warner Bros. costume drama stars Bette Davis as an aged Queen Elizabeth I, with famous swashbuckler Errol Flynn as her erstwhile paramour Robert Devereux, Earl of Essex. This powerful film features a dynamic blend of romance, political intrigue, Elizabethan grandeur, opulent costumes, action, humor, and heartbreak. “Reel Thoughts with Tiffany and Rebekah” is a weekly film review show hosted by Tiffany and Rebekah. They dive into traditional and classic films, covering everything from mainstream blockbusters to indie gems. Each episode offers thoughtful analysis, diverse perspectives, and an engaging experience designed to connect with and entertain viewers. #movies#talkshows#classic#americanagriculture#movieclips#theater#cinema#entertainment#moviedetails#performance#actors#drama#arts#music#films
Come play with me, and be my love.
Enjoy with me the pleasures here above,
the hills and valleys, dens and fields,
and all the old mountain hills.
If I could be as young and fair as you,
believe what every shepherd said was true,
these pretty speeches I'd remove
to live with you and be your love.
And I'll make a vase of a thousand,
and a thousand vacant flowers,
a cup of rose and a cup of lily,
if these invites your mind may move,
come live with me and be my love.
Your Majesty.
Have you come to mock me, my lady,
because you think yourself fairer than I?
Know your grace.
So say you, that you ridicule me with your youth and your beauty.
Tell me, do you not think your queen too old,
too ugly for a man to look upon with love?
If you think so of yourself, my queen, do not ask it of me.
Rather, consult your mirror.
I should smash every mirror in the palace
before I would allow a pane of glass to affront me so.
Just as you say, your Majesty.
I know what runs through your mind.
You would plot to take from me the man I love.
Surely it's not in my power to take anything from your Majesty
which belongs to you.
You brazen wench! Get out of my sight!
You dare to meddle in the private lives of Elizabeth and Essex?
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
One of the most talked about films that's come out recently
is the new live-action remake of Snow White.
Absolutely. Live-action remakes of the classic or renaissance films
have been coming out in hordes from Disney,
even though they've received kind of mixed reviews in general.
Some were very successful and some weren't.
Right. But even though a lot of people haven't liked all of them,
it seems like they've all made a good deal of money.
True.
People do seem to say that Disney and Hollywood in general
doesn't have any new ideas.
But Snow White really was a flop financially,
as well as people don't like it.
Right. The backlash and jokes and memes about it
I think have become more widely publicized
than the actual film itself.
I think more people know all the jokes.
But when you look at what this film was trying to achieve,
or what kind of genre it has,
you see that it's a period piece,
a costume drama,
and really a fairy tale about royalty.
So, our recommendation for a classic film
that's a better alternative to this
is The Private Lives of Elizabeth and Essex from 1939.
One of the most popular jokes, I think,
about the 25th Snow White
is that the prince might tell Snow White
to step aside and want to be with the queen
because people felt the actress playing the evil queen
was so much more beautiful than the actress playing Snow White.
And funnily enough, that's sort of like
the premise of this movie.
Of course, based somewhat loosely on real historical events,
it is about Queen Elizabeth when she was about 63,
at the time this story takes place,
and she's madly in love with the young Earl of Essex,
Robert Devereux, and he with her.
However, one of her ladies-in-waiting,
young beautiful Lady Penelope,
is also in love with him.
However, he only has eyes for the queen,
even though she's constantly afraid
that he doesn't truly love her,
and he's just seeking power because she's old
and doesn't think she's very attractive.
And they are constantly fighting
as quickly as kissing
and telling each other how much they love each other.
But she fears that his enemies in court
will try to turn her against him.
And this comes true
when he goes away to Ireland
with the regiment
to try to quell the uprisings there.
She writes letters to him and he to her,
but they are intercepted by Lady Penelope
at the command of some of the other lords
in the court who want to get Essex in bad with the queen.
So finally, he is ordered
to disband his army and come back and turn himself in.
And angrily, instead, he storms
the palace with a battalion of his men
and basically takes over.
And when Elizabeth learns that he did try to ride her,
she's willing to forgive him
until he says that he wants to rule alongside her.
And then she furiously,
she sort of tricks him
into sending his men away
before having him arrested.
This is a Warner Brothers film,
and unusually for the late 1930s,
it's in beautiful Technicolor.
But that was a growing trend
as the technology was being perfected.
It stars Errol Flynn as Essex,
Betty Davis,
who was only 31 at the time,
as Queen Elizabeth,
Olivia de Havilland plays Lady Penelope.
And this film was directed by Michael Curtiz.
It was produced by Robert Lord
with executive producer Hal B. Wallace.
It has a beautiful score
by Erish Korngold.
It was based on a play
of the same storyline
by Maxwell Anderson.
Interestingly, talking about the play,
the title of it was Elizabeth the Queen.
Right.
But Errol Flynn and presumably his agent
objected to his character not being mentioned in the title.
So I believe Betty Davis thought Elizabeth in Essex
would be a very good title.
They tried The Knight and The Lady at one point.
Oh yes, but I think someone else objected to that
Elizabeth wasn't in the title.
It might have been Betty Davis.
So quite a bit of conflict about that.
But there was a popular historical book about them
at the time called Elizabeth in Essex.
So they decided to go with The Private Lives of Elizabeth in Essex.
Although it's a bit long,
there had been a film called The Private Life of Henry VIII.
Right.
It was almost like a sequel to that.
She was the daughter of Henry VIII.
You could say that this is
historical fiction.
I think so, yes.
Because it is about real people.
Queen Elizabeth, Robert Devereux,
Lady Penelope.
But their relationships are changed significantly.
People are alive who should have been dead by this point.
Oh really?
A couple of the men in court had died by this point.
That's interesting.
Is it not true that it's somewhat debated
whether or not she and
Essex were actually romantically involved
and whether they were in love with each other?
Yes, that is debated. Some people say he was just
one of her favoured courtiers.
And his father had been
one of her favourites when she was younger.
Is that true?
Yes, I've heard that too.
There is a lot of debate about
what Elizabeth's romantic
situation was because she was known as
the Virgin Queen and she
famously never married.
There are rumours and lots of
speculations as to whether she was involved
with any man at any point.
But it is known for a fact that she would have
men who were her favourites.
Just what that entailed remains
unknown to history. No one really knew at the time.
And there's a rather important
plot point involving a ring.
She says her father gave it to her and if he was ever
very angry with her, she could send it to him and he would forgive her.
And she gives that ring to Essex.
Now, there's some debate about whether
or not this ring actually existed.
It was mentioned in one
novel, I think, but a lot of people think it's sort of a myth.
Right. And the thing about
stories like this, when you think about how long ago
this happened, I wouldn't say
most or maybe even any
of the things in this movie were just
Hollywood making things up to be romanticised.
No, they were all sort of popular plays.
Yes. In books. This story is also
an opera. Roberto Devereux
by Donizetti. True.
And it also romanticises that relationship
between Essex, Robert and Queen Elizabeth.
That's maybe even more of a love triangle because the character
of Lady Penelope, she was a real woman but she was actually
Essex's sister. Right. And was not really
involved in the intrigue. But there was another lady,
Lady Nottingham. Yes.
Who, if the story of the ring is true,
supposedly, Robert
gave it to her and asked her to bring it to the Queen
but her husband was one of his enemies so she withheld it.
And didn't tell Queen Elizabeth about it until
years later on the Queen's deathbed and she said
may heaven forgive you lady for I can never forgive you.
But is it not true that
there were intercepted letters?
I believe there were. There may have been, yes. I sort of heard
mixed accounts. Like you said, it did happen so long ago
it's very hard to know really what
was true and what was false.
Sort of going back
to Snow White briefly, it's interesting to
think, how could there be any similarities
between this new film
and a movie that was made only
two years after the original Snow White
that everyone was saying is so antiquated.
But I think there are a lot of similarities.
Or rather, I think
Elizabeth and Essex is an example of
what they could have done. What they were trying
to do and what they missed by a mile.
Because the original Snow White is very much
a fairy tale. It's very much in that old
Disney-fied style. And it's
my favourite Disney princess movie.
But what are the things people didn't like
about it? There's not a strong female
character. They made the prince
sort of a rebel instead.
Someone who's trying to overthrow the throne.
Sort of a Robin Hood
character. A swashbuckler.
Of course, Errol Flynn was the famous
Warner Brothers swashbuckler of the era.
And then the younger woman who's opposing the Queen.
And all those things are things
you see in this original. I don't think
you can get a much stronger female character than
Queen Elizabeth as played by Bette Davis.
And also, if you look in history,
she was a powerful woman. When she was a young woman
she would lead her troops into battle on horseback.
In her long gowns!
She was very much
a daughter of her father, King Henry VIII.
There hadn't been that many
Queens of England before her.
That's true. They were usually the wives
of the king. She wasn't the first, but she was
certainly one of the most powerful
and influential. A whole era, decades
is named after her. The Elizabethan era.
She influenced fashion.
And I think
one of my favourite things about this movie
is the amazing job that
Bette Davis does in it.
Especially considering she was so young.
It's honestly kind of wild that they cast such a young
actress in this part. There were excellent
older actresses. And she herself
felt intimidated by this challenge.
What I think is kind of interesting to note is
the idea of this very strong
romance with this very much
older woman, young man, is
something that, you know, it's a bit
of an uncomfortable topic. I think even
now, there's still
more of a stigma about that than
the expression of cougar
and that kind of thing. You don't see that at all
back then in old movies. Or very
little. Very little, yes. So I
wonder if they chose to cast
a younger actress so it would, even though
she's supposed to be older, she
was only one year older than he was. Maybe it was
a little more palatable for audiences. I wonder
if that was something they had in mind. That could be.
But the way she embodies
the character is so stunning. The first
shot you see of her, it's like, it's Queen Elizabeth
come back to life through the paintings.
And a lot of credit has to be given to the costume and makeup
department, of course. Amazing. The wigs,
everything. But she shaved her
hairline back two inches so that
under the wig it would have that look of her being
bald. And she wore that heavy white
makeup like Queen Elizabeth to
cover up the Queen.
It was rumoured she had smallpox when she was
younger so she had bad scarring. Yes.
As well as to hide the effects of age.
And a slight adjustment she does with her
voice to make it sound a bit older, the way she walks
to serve her carriage. But it's amazing
to see a really great actor such as Betty
Davis, or actress, where
at the same time she's
100% Elizabeth
and she's also still 100% Betty Davis.
Yeah, you see all those mannerisms. If you've seen a lot of her movies
when she's more playing herself
in modern settings, you see the same
like, the way she laughs, the inflection
certain mannerisms. It's still
But she also adopted certain other
characteristics that are particularly for this character.
She's very uptight.
Yes. If you watch her, even when she's
sitting, she's never holding still. She's fidgeting
constantly. She's moving a little bit or she's
playing with her necklaces or rings or something.
She's just got all this
angst because they made it
something of a tragedy, her character
being a Virgin Queen. She's so lonely
and she feels her duty.
It comes before that but she says to a Queen
you have to give up everything that a woman holds dear.
Yeah. It is a really
emotional and a beautiful
love story even though it might
seem a little strange and you're like,
are you really going to be rooting for these characters?
But you are. I always find
rooting for them, even though they
get along so badly.
But in those few moments when they're being nice
to each other. Sadly,
obviously there's a power struggle
between them. He believes if
they lived in something more like a democracy
he is more qualified to rule than she.
Yes. But
one of the biggest rifts between them, I think, is
that she never fully believes that he
really loves her. She can't
fathom how this handsome
virile young man would really
want her when she thinks she's so
old and ugly and worn. She acts
really confident but deep down she's
not delusional.
She knows who and what she is
and there is the dramatic scene where she
breaks mirrors, like a get rid of all the mirrors
in the palace, which is based on the fact that in her
older years Queen Elizabeth would not allow any
mirror to be around her and she stopped
allowing anyone to paint portraits of her
because she wanted to be remembered as she
looked when she was younger. And then of course
Essex. We have to discuss
Errol Flynn. I'd say he's a natural
choice for that role because, as you said, he was the top
swashbuckling star. He was
Australian and so he had that
British type accent.
And he and Olivia de Havilland were sort of
the dream couple. They made a lot of movies together.
So it's fascinating that in this movie she's
interested in him but he's really passionate about her.
This is the only one where they're not the main couple.
And Olivia took a smaller role. It's kind of an
unusual part for Olivia de Havilland at the time.
Although I understand she didn't love when
she was constantly being cast in these sort of
sweet ingenue characters. So I wonder if she actually
liked getting to play somebody with a little more
espionage. She may have enjoyed that but she may have hoped
that she had been disappointed that she had kind of a
smaller role. She really takes a back seat to
Bette Davis. But it's always
interesting to see the behind the scenes how Bette
Davis didn't always like her leading man.
As a matter of fact, she's kind of notorious for
not being happy with
the person who was chosen. I feel like she always had very
strong ideas. She was so good for this part.
And she usually had somebody in mind
for the part. And if she didn't get that person
then she wasn't happy with the
second right replacement. What she saw as a
replacement. And she wanted Sir
Laurence Olivier for that part.
Which is funny because he also
always was dissatisfied with his leading lady.
Because he always wanted Vivian Leigh, his
eventual wife. But because
he was that real
Englishman with a lot of stage training,
very refined, she thought he would be perfect
in that part.
And she saw
Errol as a poor substitute.
But I think he does a fabulous
job in that role.
And I think maybe the fact that they didn't get along
makes it work better. He's not too noble.
He's more a man of the people.
You really see the rebellious
spirit. And when she
was much older, she re-watched the movie
with Olivier de Havilland and she said,
I was so wrong. He was wonderful in the part.
Of course he had passed on
by that time. But she did eventually admit
that she was wrong. She was upset at the
time, but she was able to see it from a
clearer perspective. Just like Elizabeth.
Exactly.
So to see the history,
and these are names we know, but a lot of
the intricate history of these characters
isn't common knowledge. That's true.
For instance, the fact that Henry VIII was
Queen Elizabeth's father, and Anne Boleyn was her mother.
They refer to that, but they never
say Henry as her father.
They say your father the king, or she says my father
the king. But there are references to
him and his infamous reputation
such as, I never knew who
my mother was because he had so many wives.
And she refers to how my mother took that
walk going to execution. So those
poignant little historical references
just showing how deep the screenplay
is. Yes. But you don't have
to be a history buff to enjoy this movie.
It's really entertaining. It's only an hour
and 46 minutes. And I think something
that is
very true from a modern perspective.
What do they do
in movies now?
Do you think when, I don't know, sometimes it feels
like they need to cover up a lack of plot
or something. CGI!
They create all these beautiful backdrops.
So this film has that, but it's
real. Everything you see on the screen is real.
But even if the story
doesn't grab me, although I don't see how it couldn't, because
it's such a captivating story. It's just such
a beautiful movie to look at. You could just
enjoy watching it, even if they weren't talking.
Just the backdrops, the costumes.
Every detail is
so impeccable. The elaborate
palaces. You can see, I don't
know if they just built these huge places, but
there are streets, there are stony castles.
Yes, absolutely. It's a real place.
There are huge fireplaces.
The final scene, when they're in
the infamous tower of London.
The floor
opens up and there's this stone staircase
and he comes up and she's sitting on the throne.
It's so dramatic. Her green velvet gown.
It's just, yes, it's just all
so breathtaking. It looks like they spent a lot of money
on this film, but they made a lot of money too,
so it was worth it. I'm sure they were
able to reuse some of the costumes in other
period pieces. Honestly, in that one scene
where you can see it with the fireplace,
I'm pretty sure that's also Prince John's
drawing room in Robin Hood.
Right, which was made the year before.
I'm sure they reused some costumes, sets,
but it just looks so fresh and beautiful
and I guess you could say, is this
a good first swashbuckling movie?
You could, but I don't think you have to be a
swashbuckling fan to enjoy this movie.
There's not that much sword fighting.
There isn't a lot of sword play, right?
Even as far as Errol Flynn's films go.
There are a lot of others where he engages
in more of that. Men threatening
to draw their swords. It's really more of
a romance.
It's more of a melodrama. Maybe even more
political conflict.
Yes, absolutely. Political intrigue.
I don't know if I would actually define this
as a swashbuckling movie. Is there one sword fight?
No. There's some arrow, there's a battle.
Yeah, there's a battle, but not like
ungod, none of that.
And there are some arrows, but
Robin Hood is a little on the heavy-handed side
with arrows flying into people.
There's just a little bit of that in this.
Or if you want just a real honest-to-goodness
swashbuckling film, kind of Errol Flynn's
breakout movie was Captain Blood.
Right. And that one is
a lot of action. Almost entirely.
But there isn't that much action in this movie.
No. It's still exciting.
It's one of those interesting films
and I think this is really just brilliant screenwriting
where some of the really dramatic things
can happen off-screen, if you know what I mean.
You see the human relationships on-screen
but more of the violence.
They refer to it like,
oh, all these troops were massacred in Ireland.
You don't see any of that.
And of course, the ending.
Essex's fate, of course, does not happen on-screen.
Yes. It really is
about Elizabeth and
Essex and creating
those characters and
that time period through the beautiful
costumes. Of course,
it's hard to replicate the
grandeur of the Warner Brothers creating the
Elizabethan era, but you can actually
get costumes for a reasonable price
at places like Amazon
or even at a higher scale
historical emporium. My dress is
blue, the colour which you see Lady Penelope
wearing the most, with
a little bit of sparkly jewellery,
like diamonds, and a little bit of a
jewel in the hair, but definitely
at a much less elaborate scale
than Elizabeth.
My outfit is inspired by the style of
Queen Elizabeth, with her signature ruff,
just about the same
shape of the dress, and
thousands of pearls, which the
lady herself in real life was known for adoring,
as well as the signature red wig.
In creating a historical
drama, romance,
action film
of this kind, modern
cinematographers and filmmakers
I think would go for
ideas that involve a lot of violence
and
lots of low necklines,
and also... Sort of like Game of Thrones
I want to say, it's sort of a good comparison.
And really exploiting
every scandalous possibility of
romantic relationships. Right, especially if they
were doing a romance of Elizabethan Essex, you know
it would be really physical. They use the term
lovers many times, yet
there are a couple of kisses, but
they usually are fighting more
than anything else, but it was very
important at that era
to follow the moral guidelines
that Hollywood had adopted, which was the
Motion Picture Production Code, as enforced
by the Production Code Administration from
1934 to 1954.
And these included principles such as
avoiding excessive violence, no
nudity or indecency, and
to not dwell
on immorality of a romantic
nature. It's not that it was
100% forbidden, it couldn't be
glamorized, it couldn't be depicted
too explicitly. And in cases
like this, I would say they were to avoid
excessive implication of
an immoral relationship. The references
several times to
sharing the throne would imply
that they're suggesting marriage.
That's the only way he could be king.
They never actually say that, but
it's a pretty open secret at the court
that they're in love with each other.
She says it very plainly, that you know how I love
him and things like that, I wrote my love.
She's not afraid to talk about that.
I find it kind of funny when he
is sort of conflating the
issues of their personal relationship and
their professional, if you will, relationship
in front of the whole court. He's like, do I mean nothing
to you? It's like, this isn't really the place for that,
Robert. But apparently,
at least in the world that they're showing,
everybody knew, and
she wasn't ashamed of it. She
saw nothing dishonorable in it.
This film doesn't have any of the qualities
which maybe people think
movies did because of the Code, as being
bland, watered down,
boring, too
much adolescent or childlike.
Not to spoil it, but
if you know history, you know what happened to
Robert Devereux. He was
beheaded. So that is how the
film ends. And I don't think
it could be possibly any more
dramatic than it is.
All it could be is more violent
and bloody, and it would not be as impacting
because then you're just thinking about
there's blood everywhere and it's
horrible. Instead of
they focus on Elizabeth and you just hear
the drum roll and then when it stops, you know,
that's it. She knows what happened. Watching her
face is far more dramatic
than just violence. Violence is
anybody can do that. But to see
someone portraying it,
you know what she's thinking and everyone else
is thinking too. And there's nothing
as horrible as the human imagination
like what you can come up with in your own mind.
If you need to think about that, you can.
If you don't need to think about that, you don't have to. By the time
of his death and the way they wrote it
and whether it's historical or not,
it's not even that she's angry with him anymore
or that he tried to overthrow her. They both have decided
that the good of England is
more important than their personal feelings
or their love for each other.
It's definitely true that the way
his last moments are depicted
are very definitely not historically
accurate. They let him be more
proud and noble. But I think
they captured what was really
Elizabeth's spirit. Yes, she was angry with him
but deep down, the reason
she was angry was because he and other
people always wanted her throne
and she wasn't necessarily
about power for herself but what she thought
to be the good of England. Yes, it wasn't as
straightforward. He didn't actually
take over the castle
that way. He attempted to but was
stopped pretty quickly.
Having that scene though, it's just
from a story standpoint, so gorgeous
when he comes and she's begging him
to give her the ring and ask for her forgiveness
and then she'll pardon him but he actually
chooses to walk that road.
And of course, it's always accompanied
by a fabulous score
by Erich Wolfgang Korngold
who was one of the
most classical composers to
write during the golden era of Hollywood because
he was a classical composer in Germany
who ended up coming to America
to make Robin Hood and
he always said that that movie saved his life
because he was a Jew and the Nazi
party was coming to power around that time
and if he hadn't gotten out of Europe
when he did, he may have been killed
at a concentration camp. So he was
very grateful for that and then he
continued to score many amazing
Warner Brothers movies with his
cinematic but also very
symphonic, beautiful music
and there also is sort of
an unusual musical scene when
Olivia de Havilland's character,
Lady Penelope, and another lady of the
court, played by Nanette Fabray in her first
credited film role, do a little duet
based on a real poem,
Come Live With Me and Be My Love, and then
a little response which
Olivia de Havilland really composes
just to insult the Queen, but it's
to a lovely little melody which
Korngold himself composed and actually played
the piano part that you hear.
And he used that same melody
for his adaptation of the poem Oh Mistress Mine
by Shakespeare. Yes, that's how we recognize
I know that melody. Yes, he later put it
in his song cycle Songs of the Clown
which was debuted in Hollywood
just at a concert of some kind
in the early 40s and Nanette Fabray
sang it then too.
It's very interesting to hear
that great classical music
that was original.
They could have used something that was
actually old but they wanted something original
that reflects the era.
Because they're not just having music for the sake
of having music. It's to make a point that
Lady Penelope is mocking the Queen
about that she's old and
Essex is young because she wants him for herself.
So if you want to watch
a beautiful, colorful
live action film about
a jealous queen who is
affronted by a mirror
who is jealous of a
much younger woman and there's a
scoundrel who's vying for
someone's heart and trying to overthrow the throne
and it has a historic setting and it's in Europe and there are castles
don't watch Snow White.
Watch this movie instead.
And it's very easy to find. You can purchase it
or rent it for a reasonable price on Amazon
Prime Video or YouTube
many streaming services. It's available
in a beautifully remastered
copy so there's none of that you have
to be alright with graininess or black and white.
If you're accustomed to modern films you won't be
put off by
the way this movie looks. It's very clear.
It's just much more
beautiful. And it's also available
on DVD. You can purchase it on
Amazon or Walmart so it's very
easy to find. Join us next
time as we bring things
up to date a bit more with a film
set in the time when it was made.
Featuring songs
and ballet in a somewhat
unusual setting for such high art form.
Thank you for watching.
Goodbye.