Weekend at the Waldorf (1945) brings audiences into the elegance and emotional complexity of New York’s most prestigious hotel. Inspired by the ensemble format of Grand Hotel, this classic drama follows a collection of strangers whose lives intersect over the course of a single weekend.
Behind the polished marble floors and grand ballrooms lie private struggles—fame fading, love tested, ambition rising, and quiet vulnerability. With performances from Lana Turner, Ginger Rogers, Walter Pidgeon, and Van Johnson, the film blends sophistication with heartfelt storytelling.
There in the dark, there in the still of the night,
I look behind a star and there you are.
Whenever there's a storm, I don't even hear the thunder.
My heart with love is so aflame.
I only hear each little ring now repeating your name.
Then when a long day is through, I long for you, only you.
Then I pretend you're there and there you are.
Oh, well, thank you very much.
Miss Malvern has changed her mind.
You know, that's how I'm going to be.
Sorry I can't come to work today. Changed my mind.
Sorry I can't pay the rent today. Changed my mind.
Gee, what a life she must lead.
Why, she's got everything.
She can go anywhere, do anything, buy anything.
Stop drooling.
How'd it go with Mr. Edley last night?
He asked me if I knew what a Park Avenue apartment cost.
What did you say?
I said, well, I wasn't a real estate agent.
And what did he say?
He said, what are you doing tonight?
Oh, I know the answer to that one.
Sorry, but I'm working tonight.
Say, Kate.
Yes?
What does a Park Avenue apartment cost?
Oh, well, I just wanted to know.
You'd better be careful.
You know, anything can happen at a weekend at the Waldorf.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
You know, there are a lot of classic films
which have remakes which were so successful
that they actually eclipsed the original.
That's true.
But in other cases, there are remakes which are surprisingly forgotten,
even though they have star-studded casts.
A good example of a surprisingly forgotten classic remake
is Weekend at the Waldorf from 1945.
The story, as the title implies,
is set over one weekend at the famous Waldorf Astoria in New York.
It begins with a columnist, Randy Morton,
whose dog, Susie, is expecting puppies.
A young honeymoon couple arrives at the hotel,
but there's no space for them.
However, businessman Jessup lets them take his apartment
away for the weekend.
Before leaving, though, he receives a call from Mr. Edley,
a shady businessman who's trying to get Jessup in on an oil deal,
but he turns him down.
War correspondent Chip Collier arrives at the hotel,
looking for a bit of rest and relaxation after his work overseas
before he has to take off again.
Also in the hotel is glamorous movie star Irene Malvern,
plus a simple stenographer, Bunny Smith,
who is looking for something better than what she's had
and thinks Mr. Edley can give it to her.
The male character is a young pilot,
Captain James Hollis,
who needs to have a life-saving surgery
to remove a piece of shrapnel that's lodged near his heart.
He's lost the will to live,
but he seems to find something worth living for again
when he meets Bunny.
Meanwhile, Chip, while after a story about Mr. Edley,
accidentally ends up in Irene Malvern's room,
and she believes he is a jewel thief
who is the sweetheart of her maid.
As these stories intersect,
they all find something new to live for.
This film was produced by MGM.
The producer was Arthur Hornblow Jr.
It was directed by Robert Z. Leonard.
The movie starred Ginger Rogers, Walter Pidgeon,
Lana Turner, Van Johnson, and Edward Arnold.
This film, as we mentioned,
is a remake of a very beloved classic,
which is Grand Hotel from 1932.
That's right.
They both are MGM films
and very much star-studded pictures,
all about the doings of these different,
interesting hotel guests
who all meet each other over one weekend at a hotel.
It's originally, of course, the Grand Hotel in Berlin.
This film is interesting in that
it's a more creative remake than a lot,
wouldn't you say?
Yes, absolutely.
They very easily could have done exactly the same story
and just changed a few things,
mainly for the moral codes of the time.
But they instead chose to take the basic idea
of these intersecting stories
taking place over a weekend at a hotel
and really made it into a new story
which is very much about World War II
because it's not, of course, combat,
but the characters are very directly affected by that.
Most notably, the two leading men,
Chip being a war correspondent
and Captain Hollis, of course,
having been a flyer in the war.
It's interesting because the original
is most notably a pre-code film,
meaning it was made in that brief time period
of about four years
when they were talking pictures,
but the motion picture production code
was not being enforced yet,
which is commonly called the Hays Code.
So the morals were very loose
during this time period.
And as a result, the films which were made
are surprisingly risque
compared to today.
And Grand Hotel was very much
a product of that time,
but it also reflected the worldwide
economic depression
as well as the forgotten man element
which was so prevalent after World War I.
Right, so this brings us up
to the greatest generation,
the World War II men.
And it's interesting
that they actually reference Grand Hotel,
which is kind of unusual in a remake,
but one of the most changed characters,
I would say,
is this rubber baron.
In the original, he's a jewel thief
and he sneaks into the ballerina's room
to steal her necklace.
So in this, Irene Malvern thinks
that he is this jewel thief
who's come there and he's actually
a perfectly respectable man,
but he plays along with her
because he says,
you wanted me to be that, so I was that.
So he tells her,
oh, they call me the baron,
and so I'll return.
And then he references the necklace.
It's kind of funny
that they acknowledge
the existence of that film
because the remake won't always acknowledge
the existence of the original.
Now, some people have even denied
that this actually is a remake.
I know, it's so funny.
It actually bears some strange similarities,
but the fact that it is a remake
is completely established by the credits
because it mentions that the screenplay
was by Sam and Bella Spiewak,
but it says that it was inspired
by the play by Vicky Baum.
So it is indisputably a remake.
And they both were by MGM,
so it was very much MGM material
that was being remade.
The character that I think
is probably the most similar
is probably the stenographer's.
Right. Buddy.
Buddy Smith, who was Flemchen
in the original.
She's obviously of a higher moral character,
but she faces the same dilemma
of she's just a poor working girl,
and then there's this wealthy,
older man who offers for her
to help her out.
Only the character who was originally
played by Lionel Barrymore,
of this older man who's dying
of an undisclosed condition,
it's this young soldier now who...
That's right.
It's fascinating.
They both are sort of facing
their mortality,
but the Lionel Barrymore character
is very much like,
I'm going to live it up.
Right, because he doesn't want to die.
Right, he wants to live.
It's a crazy chance,
but doctors can't give him
the will to live,
and so that's built up
as more of a love story.
It turns into sort of
an unlikely romance
at the very end of Grand Hotel,
but in this,
it's a very central love story.
All the characters were adapted
in different interesting ways.
As you said, of course,
the Joan Crawford character
became this Lana Turner character,
played by Ginger Rogers.
She's a bit tired
and a little depressed.
She feels that her life
is sort of empty,
but definitely not anywhere near
the level of drama.
She's not planning
on poisoning herself.
I would say the original
is such an intense melodrama
and becomes a tragedy at the end,
and this is really more
of a romantic comedy.
Right.
That kind of looming presence
of World War II
is the main thing about it
that's really dark at all.
Other than that,
it's just very lighthearted.
It's true,
and it was interesting
that it's set at this
really famous hotel,
the Waldorf Astoria,
which is, of course,
a real hotel,
and you can tell
that they did do
it on a little television
screen in the lobby.
Really?
Yes.
I didn't remember that.
This was a long time ago.
Wow.
And it's like,
I've never heard of that movie,
but look,
there's Ginger Rogers.
And of course,
the character of Chip,
as you mentioned,
goes from being a criminal
in the original
to a rather creative
journalist,
because all newspaper men
have kind of a
machinist side to them.
Yes.
But because of
the war correspondent,
we get that same attitude
of not young enough
to be a soldier.
A certain maturity,
but the fact that
I've faced war,
I've seen death.
Yes.
He's sort of world-weary,
and that's how
they relate to each other.
of the Baron is
in the original.
General Director Prysing,
played by Wallace Berry
in the original,
becomes Mr. Edley,
played by Edward Arnold,
and I would say
his character
got significantly reduced.
He's almost
a supporting character.
The fact that they cast
Edward Arnold,
who was a very effective
but still more
supporting actor
rather than Wallace Berry,
who was the top-paid actor
in Hollywood at the time
they made Grand Hotel.
So they changed the role,
and it's debatable
whether he's
more likable,
less likable,
more evil.
He's more
definitely dishonest.
It seems like he's just
unashamed
and kind of a crook
instead of
he has this
dramatic moral decline
over the course
of Grand Hotel.
He's really sort of
just like a catalyst
in Bunny and Jimmy's
love story
of this
kind of
the conflict between them
that he represents
what she thinks
she wants.
This higher echelon
of life.
So he's less important
as a person
and more just
a representation
of this upper strata
that she's trying
to achieve.
Yeah, it's true.
And he also
provides some impetus
for Chip's character
because you understand
that they've had
this long-standing rivalry
as Chip has tried
to find his corrupt
dealers before.
Yes, he is helping out
this young cub reporter
played by a very young
Kenan Wynn
to try to get
the story on Ed Lee,
and that's how
he accidentally
ends up in Irene's room.
So as I said,
Ed Lee is really
sort of a catalyst
in the story,
and there was the doctor
who's sort of a narrator
in the original film,
and the character
of the columnist,
Randy Morton,
kind of takes that place,
but there is a younger
doctor in this
who is a friend of Irene's,
Dr. Campbell,
and he's kind of
the character
that connects everybody.
I feel like he's
the only one
who interacts
with everybody.
It is clever
how different characters
were used,
like the fact that
the Baron notably has
this dachshund,
this beloved dog,
Adolphus,
but then in the remake,
the narrator,
you mentioned Randy,
this columnist,
has a beloved dog,
Susie,
who is going
to have puppies,
just like the concierge's
wife is going
to have a baby.
That just occurred
to me the last time
I watched it.
It's like,
oh, that's like
his wife's going
to have a baby.
That's pretty funny.
So there are all
these references to it,
references that would
have been very much
appreciated by people
who were old enough
to clearly remember
Baron Hotel.
But on the other hand,
it's completely enjoyable
if you've never
seen Grand Hotel
and don't know
anything about it,
because it's a great film
in its own merit.
Yes, it's a very,
very excellent film,
very detailed.
It's even more complex
than Grand Hotel.
Yes.
There are more characters,
and I just think
a lot more goes on,
and because there are
these two definite
separate love stories,
that right there
builds it up more.
Yeah, there really is
only one romantic
leading man in Grand Hotel,
and it's John Barrymore.
Like, both the ones
But by replacing
Lyle Barrymore
with Van Johnson,
then Bunny and Jimmy's
romance is almost,
not more important
than Irene and Chip's,
but it almost seems
like it gets more
screen time.
Yeah, because Van Johnson
was a very bankable
leading man at the time,
boy next door,
and a very relatable
character.
Yes.
This soldier,
who has both physical
and psychological scars
from the combat.
It's fascinating how
even though it is
a catalyst that he's,
has this serious condition,
he isn't visibly injured
in any way.
Right.
Showing the invisible scars.
Yes, it's really more
about that he has
this kind of lost feeling
that so many films did.
He said,
I've been wanting
to get home for two years,
and now I am home
and I have no home.
Yeah.
He sold his gas station
before he went into the army,
so he just doesn't really know
what he's coming back to,
and I know so many young men
could relate to that.
And one of the most
touching elements of the film
is he talks about
his closest buddy
was his navigator,
who was killed
on their last mission.
Mm-hmm.
And it seems like
he doesn't have any family
really, but this man
was like family to him.
Yes.
And I think he has
some survivor's guilt,
like, why did I survive
and he didn't?
Well, he says he didn't
have to go out
on that last mission,
but I kidded him into it,
so he feels kind of
responsible for his death.
But the thing he has,
which kind of keeps him going,
is that this friend of his
was a composer,
and he wrote
this beautiful song,
so one way
he pays tribute to him
is he gets the great band leader,
Xavier Cugat,
to play the song
at the Starlight Room,
and that brings in
some more of the culture
of the 1940s.
Right.
Xavier Cugat was a very
beloved band leader
with his Latin music.
And he actually was
the resident band leader
at the Waldorf at the time,
right?
Yes, yes, he was.
And he plays
at the Starlight Room,
and you see some real places
like they reference
Peacock Alley,
that's still there,
whereas most of the restaurants
and nightclubs have changed
in the hotel.
Mm-hmm.
That one is still there.
Do they still have
that rooftop restaurant
called the Starlight Roof,
or has that changed?
I know it's still there,
but I think it's more
of a ballroom now
for private events
rather than a nightclub
with live radio broadcasts.
Yeah, I can see that
that wouldn't really work
in a way in today's culture.
Yeah, sadly,
that kind of thing
isn't around as much.
Unless you really lean into
its being very vintage,
which, honestly,
I think would be brilliant.
Some places are doing that now,
so note to the Waldorf
you need to do that again.
You're watching this.
Yes.
But as we mentioned,
very much like Grand Hotel,
this really was a vehicle
for all these stars.
Indeed.
And the first one,
of course,
is Ginger Rogers,
interestingly enough,
interestingly playing
this Hollywood starlet.
And she was actually
one of the highest paid actresses
in Hollywood at this time.
Of course,
she's most famous
for her partnership
with Fred Astaire
from 1933 to 1939.
They made nine films together,
or eight in their first run,
and then a final one
in 1949.
But part of the reason
that they split up
was because she wanted
to pursue being
a dramatic actress.
Yes, yes, she did.
And right away,
the next year,
she made Kitty Foyle
in 1940,
won Best Actress
for it,
and then just went on
to become a really
great, serious,
dramatic actress
in this film
with no exception.
It's a brilliant
performance from her.
Yes, and it's interesting
that they easily could have
worked in some way
to have her do
some ballroom dancing
or anything,
but they didn't
because she was just,
she could stand on her own
as an actress at this point.
She didn't have to dance
or sing or do anything
like that.
The only real musical
element of this film
is the repeated playing
of that song,
and there you are.
Van Johnson actually sings
a little bit of it.
You don't hear him
sing that often,
but he was a good singer
and he was in some musicals.
And then,
during that extended sequence
in The Starlight Roof,
that song is played
several times.
First it's played
and it's sung by
Bob Graham.
Bob Graham, yeah,
this is his band singer.
Very nice voice.
And then the song
continues to be played
as background music
with sort of
some Latin rhythms.
But at the opening
of the scene,
there's an arguably
not really necessary
to the plot number,
Guadalajara,
just to show off
Xavier Cugat
and his style.
And the singers
and dancers.
There's also,
right at the beginning
of the scene,
there's these kind of
flamenco-esque
ballroom dancers
and a group of
chorus girls
in ballet costumes
and pointe shoes,
which I think is
sort of a reference
to Prison Sky
in the original.
And there's some
classical Tchaikovsky music
being played.
Right,
they actually play
a couple of the same
classical pieces
as are featured
in Van Johnson.
And you do hear
a little bit of
the waltzes,
which are very integral.
But you're right,
in the wedding scene
between Dr. Campbell
and his bride,
they play
the Sleeping Beauty Waltz
by Tchaikovsky.
And there's a lot
of Tchaikovsky music
in Grand Hotel.
So just more
little subtle references
to the original,
which, again,
would have been
very meaningful
for the people
who are old enough
to remember.
Walter Pidgeon
had been a mainstay
player at MGM
for many years.
You see him in the mid
and late 30s a lot.
He often would play
sort of a supporting actor,
sometimes even
a villainous one.
But in his later years
at MGM,
like in the mid
to late 40s,
he began playing more
really likable,
sympathetic characters.
Yeah, that's true.
I think this is actually
a somewhat rarer
reading man romantic
role for him.
He does it very well,
of course,
he's very charming.
But usually,
he would play
more of a other man
or supporting father role.
So it's nice to see him
getting to really play
this very likable character.
And this very prominent
leading man character,
Lana Turner,
who's I think quite
a well-remembered
classic actress.
Yes.
For some films
like The Postman
Always Rings Twice
is probably her
most famous film.
Imitation of Life
in the later 50s
is also very well-known.
And anyone familiar
with 30s cinema
will know her
from some of her
earlier performances.
She got her start
in the Andy Hardy series
and the Dr. Kildare series
when she was a redhead.
Yes.
And I got to know her
that way first,
and it's always still
startling to me
when I see her
with that platinum blonde hair.
But this is an interesting
part for her
because it is,
she's not quite
the leading lady,
but it is sort of a,
I think it's more
of a toss-up
between she
and Ginger Rogers
than it was
between Greta Garbo
and Joan Crawford.
Yeah.
I think they were on
more of an even playing field,
but she is younger.
And she strikes the balance
really well in this part
of this character
has sort of an edge to her
because she's had
a sort of tough
growing up
and she knows
what she wants,
but then this gentler side
comes out
when she meets Jimmy.
Yes.
And particularly in the scene
when she first meets him,
she does a lot of
very beautiful,
subtle facial acting.
Yes.
Yes, she does.
And then Van Johnson,
of course,
was one of the most
prominent actors
of this time.
He also got his start
in the Dr. Kildare series,
but really the spin-off
of that,
the Dr. Gillespie series
when Lionel Barrymore,
who was in Grand Hotel,
kind of ironic,
took over
as being the
Dr. Gillespie,
the focus of that series
and he played
a young intern.
And also,
Samuel S. Hines,
who plays the doctor
in this film,
played Jimmy Kildare's father.
A lot of interesting times.
If you're familiar
with MGM films
throughout the 30s and 40s,
you'll see
all those connections
of all those
different actors
who were well-known
and their paths would cross
many different times.
Van Johnson was
a very viable
young lead
during the war years
because he was...
He wasn't able to serve,
that's right,
because early in his career
in 1943,
he was in a horrible
car crash,
which he had
to have a plate
put in his forehead.
He almost died.
But then,
he wasn't able
to go to war
and he was going to.
So as a result,
he was one of the youngest,
most eligible
leading men in Hollywood
and then he really
got to be the star.
You can see
a bit of scarring
on his forehead.
Yes, you can.
And it just makes him
more believable
as a soldier.
Yes, it works really well.
He played a soldier a lot.
And he's very,
very likable in this part.
He's the boy next door
but he's also really deep.
He goes back and forth
between being lighthearted
and fun
and really serious
and emotional.
You see such a brilliant
contrast of this kind of,
he's sort of
closed himself off
and then when he's with her,
how he just blossoms.
You see this really sweet
personality coming out
and that's very,
it's very simple
but in a really charming way.
He just came from
this little town
in California
and you can tell
how much he loved
this hometown
and he's just looking
for a nice girl
to take back home
with him.
Yes.
What changes would you say
were definitely made
to the story
specifically because
of the motion picture
production code
and the greening
that had to be done
by this point?
I think the relationships
of the characters
were just altered
in sort of subtle ways
but that make
everything more
clean and wholesome?
More wholesome, yes.
They actually deal
very much with the whole
him pretending to be the bear
and the situation
with Chip and Irene
that he's playing up this act
and there's a detective
out in the hall
so he says,
oh I can't leave
so he says,
oh I'll have to
spend the night here
so he's sleeping out
on the couch
and he puts a bunch
of furniture
in front of the door
and it's like,
I once walked in my sleep
so they have to
handle that
carefully.
And he starts
referring to her
as his common law wife
and talking about
how they're going
to get married
and he wants them
to be married
so that's an important
establishment
and the relationship
of Bunny and Edley,
that I think is probably
the biggest thing
because they didn't
completely cut it out.
The other ones,
they could cut out
the other things
but they wanted
to keep this idea
of the temptation
which exists for a woman
who wants to get ahead
especially if she's pretty.
Right,
and it's handled
very nicely.
It's mainly just
this one scene
and this conversation
between Edley
and Bunny
where he says,
I want you to be
my confidential secretary,
entertain my friends
and business acquaintances
and she says,
what else would I have to do?
And he says,
oh nothing,
absolutely nothing
but you get the idea
of the undertones
and then when she tells
Jimmy about it
he says,
are you going to marry him?
She's like,
no I'm going to be
his confidential secretary
and you know,
Jimmy's very disturbed
by this idea
because he knows
what that will mean.
And it's amazing how
even though in a lot of ways
she seems more worldly
than he does
that when he sees
the way she's going
that this very protective
side of him comes out
and he's like,
don't go back Bunny,
you don't know
what you're letting
yourself in for.
Yeah,
he wants to believe
that she's a nice girl
and I think she is
up to that point
whereas it's very obvious
that Dern Crawford's character
is not a nice girl,
she's wearing a really
low neckline.
it's not even
things that she does
or says,
it's just a demeanor.
And she makes reference
to having gone on trips
with other men before
so it's pretty obvious
that she's not
selling her soul now,
she sold it a long time ago.
So that was
an important change.
I think a lot of people
might look at this movie
and say,
oh this is the
clean,
watered down version,
this is what they had
to do under the code
but I think
as we were discussing
most of the changes
they made
were a choice
that they wanted
to make a different version.
They wanted to
update it to a new time
and make it,
even just by making it
an American story,
there's a certain
kind of moody
European quality
about the original
which by putting it
in New York
you immediately
don't have that
but I think
you're absolutely right.
You very easily
could make
a code adaptation
of Grand Hotel
with that story.
a couple of years later
in the late 40s
they could have made it
with them being
World War II veterans
instead of World War I.
Absolutely.
And I know that
there was
a couple more times
that they wanted
to do another remake
of Grand Hotel
and probably
stay close to the story.
Sam Goldwyn
actually wanted to
make it around 1956
with Margot Fonteyn,
the famous British ballerina
in the Greta Garbo character.
So I think
that they could have
but they just wanted it
to be very different.
Yes.
One thing that's
really enjoyable
about this film
is the 40s style.
You really can see
the wartime fashion
and what people
were wearing
on the home front
as well as the architecture
and it's a great snapshot
up close and personal
of that beautiful hotel
during the war years.
My outfit is inspired
by Bunny's secretarial outfit
which she wears
a couple of times.
This is a grey pencil skirt,
a white blouse,
very indicative of the 40s
with full sleeves,
simple black shoes,
and her bracelet
which has her name on it.
My outfit is inspired
by the costume
which Irene wears
when she first meets Chip.
It's a black pantsuit
with decorative drapings on it
and a very elaborate hairstyle
such as you see her wear
throughout the film.
Why do you think this film
is almost forgotten?
I really don't know.
It's strange, isn't it?
I can't tell.
Because it has so many
well-known actors.
And it was very successful
at the time.
It was one of MGM's
top-earning films that year.
And because Grand Hotel
is so famous,
I think it would automatically
lead people to this film
but do you have any theories?
I think that people
are interested in Grand Hotel
because it was a trendsetter
being the first all-star film
and there is also
that cult following
of pre-code films now.
And there are so many
great films from
the golden era.
Yeah, I think that's
a big part of it.
In 1932, as we've referenced,
a lot of pre-code films
were just downright stupid.
They were just really shallow
and they were also still
working on the technology
of making sound films.
So when there is a film
that has artistic merit
like Grand Hotel
despite the risqueity,
it stands out.
But there are so many
great films from 1945.
It's abnormal.
And partly,
maybe there are so many
actors in it
that fans of each
individual actor
are more likely to look
to other films of them.
Like, if you like Lana Turner,
watch Postman
Always Wings twice.
If you like Ginger Rogers,
so many films she made
around this time
in the 40s.
Van Johnson,
he's the only leading man
in a plethora of films.
Even though he's only
fourth bill,
as I mentioned,
I feel like his character
is very important
and very strong in this.
I would highly recommend
this to any Van Johnson fan
because it's a really,
really great part for him.
Possibly the fact
that it's in black and white.
I don't know.
There are a lot of
colour films
from around this time
but also an equal amount
of black and white.
I think they wanted
to save some money
but they did end up
making a good profit
even though it was
expensive because
of all the stars.
I don't think it would
be as good in colour.
Yeah, it doesn't call for it.
Usually they save colour
for musicals.
Yeah, there's just
a certain...
I just don't think
it needs colour.
In some ways,
I think they wanted it
to be simpler
and more realistic
and most of the simpler
and more realistic films
of this era
were in black and white.
Yeah.
Why do you think
that people
should watch it now?
Why does this movie
deserve to be rediscovered?
Well, like you mentioned,
it's a really great
snapshot of the era
and I think it really
gives you a feeling
of how people,
both on the home front
and the soldiers,
felt during World War II.
I think if you're
kind of interested
in World War II,
I think this is
an unusual film
because it's not
your standard war film.
There isn't any
combat in it
but it just has
so many great elements
of the era.
It's got all these
great stars.
It's a great introduction
to a lot of actors.
It has more MGM
movie references
than you can shake
a stick at
and not just Grand Hotel.
They talk about
Goodbye Mr. Chips.
They talk about
The Wizard of Oz.
It's crazy.
It's kind of funny
how many references there are.
So it's a great introduction
to MGM
and then there's
that sort of
Battle of the Home Front feel
and it's just,
it leaves you
with a really nice feeling.
It's a very warm film.
It's kind of welcoming.
It definitely leaves you
feeling a lot better
than Grand Hotel does.
Because Grand Hotel
I kind of had to get used to.
The first time I watched it,
I was kind of disturbed.
I didn't like it.
This one,
I immediately loved.
I just thought it was brilliant
the first time I watched it.
Yeah, it's really
a great movie.
And the song written
by Jimmy's friend
and navigator,
And There You Are,
written by Sammy Fane
and Ted Kohler,
is an absolutely
beautiful piece.
And it was very popular
on radio for a while.
You can find a lot
of recordings of it,
most of them from 1945.
Perry Como is one
of the biggest names
that recorded it.
And there is a recording
by Bob Graham
who sings it in the film.
And it's woven in beautifully.
It's sort of their love theme.
Personally for me,
I think the character
of Jimmy
and his story with Bunny
is what really makes
the movie for me.
Yeah, and I think
that's where the movie
outshines Grand Hotel.
Because the relationship
with the Baron
in Gruzenskaya
is definitely a lot
more dramatic
than Chip and Irene.
Right.
But like you said,
Joan Crawford's character
doesn't really have
a romance.
She's interested
in the Baron,
but he's not.
He's just flirting with her.
And she's considering
selling herself to...
And prizing.
Yes.
But to make
the Lionel Barrymore character
this young soldier,
it was brilliant.
A brilliant way
of like someone
who would be dying
but be the young man.
Such a brilliant idea.
When we first watched it,
I very vaguely remembered
Grand Hotel because
I'd only seen it once, I think.
And I thought,
oh, this is like
the Lionel Barrymore character,
but they made him
this young soldier.
I was like, that's brilliant.
I just was struck by it.
It's a really good change,
just like you said.
And Chip and Irene's romance
is a little bit more
like a sort of standard
kind of romantic comedy
with the mistaken identity.
But I think Bunny and Jimmy's
becomes more of the
melodramatic story.
Yes, yes, it does.
Because it's a woman
has to choose between
love or money.
And just their interaction
and their dialogue.
I just think it's
so nicely written.
Yes, it is.
So I think that it's
worth watching
if you're a big fan
of the 1940s cinema,
if you like World War II,
if you want to learn more
about any of these actors.
And even if you're a fan
of Grand Hotel,
I think you should watch this
and see how it's interesting
to see this other take
on the same story
in a different setting.
And I think they coexist
very nicely.
Yes.
You don't have to choose
one or the other.
You can enjoy them both.
They're both good movies
in different ways.
I think they're
different enough
that you don't really
have to compare them
that much.
Right.
Now, this film isn't
as widely available
as Grand Hotel.
You can find it on DVD
for purchase
because Warner Archives
released it.
And you really can't find it
on any of the mainstream
streaming services.
Of course, if you know
where to look on the Internet,
you can find it.
But I'd say DVD
is the most reliable source
for where to find it
in a nice, clear copy.
This film was very modern
and up-to-date,
reflecting the era
in which it was made.
However, next time,
we're going to talk about
a historical film
which tells the story
of the most beloved
president of all time
before his presidency.
Thank you for watching.
Goodbye.