LIVE: House Foreign Affairs Committee Holds Hearing on State Department Promotion, Placement

Live News Network
1.4K followers
2 Video Views·Mar 5, 2026
The House Committee on Foreign Affairs holds a hearing at 2 p.m. ET on March 5 titled “Merit, Accountability, and Performance at State: Evaluating Promotion and Placement.”
Witness:
Sarah McKemey, senior bureau official, Bureau of Human Resources, U.S. Department of State
AI Generated·May contain errors
is filled with 10 nominations and one bill.
The nominations of Melissa Holyoke and Phillip Williams
to be US attorneys are listed for the first time
and will be held over.
Today, we're going to vote on Robert Cicada, director of ATF.
We'll also have four nominees for the judiciary.
Andrew Davis, Western District, Texas.
John Shepard, Western District, Arkansas.
Anna St. John, Eastern District, Louisiana.
Christopher Wolfe, Western District of Texas.
We'll also vote on three US marshal nominees.
Robert Rotter, David Satterley, and David St. Pierre.
Lastly, we'll vote on S3798,
the Safe Access to Cash Act of 2026.
It's a bipartisan bill led by Senator Cruz and Gallego.
It will help protect Americans who rely on ATMs
for cash withdrawals.
Senator Cruz will speak on that bill after we get it up.
At first, I'd like to say a few words
about highly qualified nominees.
That we're considering.
Mr. Cicada is well suited to lead the ATF
throughout his three decade career.
He protected Americans at the state and federal levels.
Mr. Cicada spent more than a decade as a police officer.
During that service, he received numerous awards
and commendations for his service.
He's also spent nearly 20 years
at the agency that he will soon be heading.
He did that as a special agent managing regional offices
and most recently serving as deputy director.
Our judicial nominees are highly qualified.
Each has extensive litigation experience.
They've zealously advocated for their clients
in different cases.
And they did it with utmost skill and professionalism.
Two of them, Judge Shepherd and Judge Wolf,
although already have experience presiding
in courtrooms at the state level.
Although their credentials vary,
I'm confident that all four of our judicial nominees
will make excellent federal judges.
The three U.S. Marshall nominees
that we're considering today are also exceptional.
Each has decades of experience in law enforcement,
and I believe all three will serve their community as well.
I'm particularly pleased that we're considering
the nomination of Mr. Rotter to serve in my state of Iowa
as sheriff.
He done outstanding work
to keep the people of Iowa County safe.
I hold him in high regard.
I've known him for probably three decades,
as do many other Iowans holding him also in high regard.
I encourage my colleagues to join me in supporting him.
On another matter,
I want to thank Secretary Noem for her testimony
at our oversight hearing.
I'm glad that she didn't follow the precedent
of former Secretary Mayor Yorka
set when he refused to come before the committee
the last year he was in office.
The hearing highlighted the successful steps
her department has taken to secure our border
and homeland from thousands
of undocumented immigrant criminals.
It's critical that Democrats fully fund DHS
and do so immediately.
I expect timely and complete responses
to the members' questions for the record,
and I say that directly to Secretary Noem.
I also want to note
the Government Accountability Office
still doesn't have access
to the Department of Homeland Security officials
for the review that I've asked the Secretary to complete.
That needs to be ironed out.
Senator Roberts.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I've served on this committee for more than 25 years
and been honored to do so.
I've never been through a hearing
like our DHS oversight hearing
with Secretary Noem last Tuesday.
The Secretary took an oath to tell the truth.
Instead, she repeatedly failed to do so.
Let me be specific.
When I asked her if her DHS department
follows court orders,
Secretary Noem responded, and I quote,
we follow court orders
when they are given to us, close quote.
This is demonstrably false.
Even the Trump Department of Justice
admitted in sworn declaration
that ICE has violated over 50 court orders
in the state of New Jersey alone.
The chief federal district judge in Minnesota,
a Republican appointee,
found over 200 instances of ICE violating court orders
in just the last two months.
Secretary Noem also denied
the DHS has detained U.S. citizens,
and we know better.
Americans around the country,
including in my home state of Illinois,
know this is false.
One of my constituents, U.S. citizen Diane Figueroa,
was detained for hours
after federal agents rammed her car
and forced her to the ground.
During Operation Midway Blitz,
my staff documented the arrest and detention
of at least 40 U.S. citizens
in my state of Illinois alone.
Secretary Noem also lied
about the role of her de facto chief of staff,
Corey Lewandowski.
When asked directly
whether Mr. Lewandowski has any role
in approving DHS contracts,
she denied it with an unequivocal no.
DHS records show Mr. Lewandowski
personally approved
a multimillion-dollar contract last year,
and he routinely signs off on large awards
before they reach the secretary's desk.
Mr. Chairman, the secretary's testimony
was not just evasive or troubling.
She repeatedly made false statements under oath.
This should concern every member of the committee,
Republican and Democrat alike.
This committee has an obligation
to hold the secretary accountable.
I look forward to discussing with you
and the other members of the committee
what our recourse is.
And let me say on a more personal note,
several of the questions
that were repeatedly asked of her
really got to the heart of who she is.
Question of common decency.
To call victims in Minnesota who died,
and a victim in Illinois who barely survived
five shots from the ICE agents,
to call, to refuse to say,
I'm sorry, I said the wrong thing.
She claimed that they were domestic terrorists.
There was no evidence of that, none.
Imagine those families
just having lost a daughter or a son,
mourning their loss,
and to have a member
of the president's cabinet
announce on public television across the nation
that their deceased child
was a domestic terrorist.
I know that the phrase,
I'm sorry, I shouldn't have done a better job,
is just unacceptable in this administration.
But most common decency
and most parents understand
that is just what we expect
to teach our children.
We cannot simply sign a blank check
for a lawless agency
to continue terrorizing America's cities.
We cannot ignore Secretary Nome
has seriously weakened our capacity
to prevent cyber security
and terrorist attacks.
From the first days
of the Trump administration,
the second administration,
we've sounded the alarm.
Trump administration officials
have gutted our national security
and counterterrorism apparatus
to support mass deportation,
and it leaves America dangerously exposed.
Let me give an example.
Homeland security investigations
and the FBI had a dedicated team of agents
dedicated to investigating Iran's efforts
to evade international sanctions,
sell oil on the black market,
and fund their military and outside allies.
Those investigations are now stalled
as the agents are too busy
with immigration enforcement.
Last spring, the FBI was forced
to recall dozens of agents
who specialized in counterterrorism,
counterintelligence, and cyber security
from immigration duty
because of possible Iranian retaliation
after the strike against their nuclear sites.
Last week, FBI Director Patel
attempted to distract from his Olympic trip
by firing at least a dozen personnel
who worked on counterintelligence measures.
We're in the midst of the sixth day of a war,
and the counterintelligence agents
in these agencies have been fired
for political reasons.
They also were part of a specialized unit
to investigate foreign adversaries,
including Iran.
As a result of the president's misguided priorities
and the incompetent leadership
of individuals like Secretary Noem
and Director Patel,
America is left safe
in an increasingly dangerous world.
I don't want to stand in the way of Markov.
Do we have quorum yet?
No, we don't.
Okay, so I'll be brief.
And the minute somebody comes in,
I'll stop mid-sentence.
I just want to clarify what I said this week
in the hearing with Secretary Noem.
I was, you know, every once in a while
I get a little bit hot around the collar,
but the reason that I was angry
is that an hour before the hearing,
I get a letter dated March the 23rd
from Secretary Noem
responding to a letter that I wrote a month ago
saying that I simply wanted an anonymized list
of incidents in North Carolina
under Operation Charlotte's Web.
They supposedly detained about 500 people.
I know because I've had constituents
call my office saying,
yeah, I'm a U.S. citizen.
I got my window broken out
and I had somebody hand me a piece of paper
saying we can reimburse you
if you fill out all this paperwork.
All I wanted was a list of the 500 incidences
that they referred to.
What happened?
Were they detained?
Were they interrogated?
Were they deported?
Did they have a criminal background
beyond crossing the border?
I want everybody reported,
but I want them done in an orderly fashion
and I get a dear sir, madam, or small child,
I'm not gonna give you that information
an hour before a hearing
where she knows I'm gonna ask questions about it.
So that was another bad management decision
and a long list of bad management decisions.
So Mr. Chair,
I did say that I'm objecting
to any en bloc nominations on the floor.
Between now and the time
I get an answer to the question
and beginning March the 19th,
you know this pains me
for this committee in particular
because I'm proud of being one of the members
that make quorum here and get markups done.
I will deny quorum and markups
for any committees I'm on
until I get the information I've requested
or she resigns or gets fired,
whichever comes first.
But I'm serious about it.
I will hold my own nominations.
I will not vote for anything
that are a priority for me
until we get it done.
Thank you.
Senator Wayhouse.
How do you feel?
Thank you, chairman.
I think we are taking up Marshall's nominees
for the first time in this.
I expect to support the Marshall's nominations.
I think to the extent this committee
can keep that out of the political warfare
that we're so often engaged in,
that would be good
and they all seem to be qualified.
But it calls to mind for me
a recurring problem
that I've had with the Marshall service.
As you know,
because it's been often publicly reported,
a Rhode Island federal judge
was the subject of many virulent death threats.
60 Minutes just ran an expose
on the campaigns of threats
that our federal judiciary is laboring under.
There has been a particular campaign of threats
directed against the chief judge
of the federal court in the District of Columbia.
The threat environment for federal judges
has been described as the worst ever.
And what I've asked the Marshall service repeatedly,
I think I've got more than a dozen asks in,
is a really simple question.
If the evidence suggests
that there is a campaign to threaten judges,
if the evidence suggests
that threats are being orchestrated,
if the evidence suggests
that there is an enterprise or a conspiracy
that is producing these threats,
will the Marshall service
be willing to investigate
behind the utterer of the threat
and look at the larger picture?
That is a super easy question
for the Marshall service to answer.
The answer is yes, of course.
And it is telling to me
that I cannot get that answer.
I'll give the Department of Justice credit
that they scheduled a meeting for me
to explain themselves.
And it happened while I was snowed in,
so we're rescheduling it.
But the fact that I have to ask this question
a dozen or more times
and never once get the simple answer,
yes, of course,
if there's evidence that the utterer of a threat
was connected to some campaign
or organized effort to threaten the federal judiciary,
we have criminal statutes specifically on that.
And of course we will investigate that.
I really would like to get that answer.
I've been in communication with the chief justice
about his responsibilities
to make sure as the chairman
of the judicial conference
that he is making sure
that the Marshall service
is properly doing his job.
And I think,
if you'll let me change the topic for one minute,
you have just produced a quorum.
So I will close my remarks at that point
so we can get ahead to the vote.
But I really,
I think the committee should have a bipartisan concern
about a Marshall service
that is not serving the federal judges
that is sworn to protect
by refusing to conduct investigations
behind the mere utterer of a threat
and look at those patterns,
conspiracies and enterprises.
Senator Whitehouse,
I'm willing to help you any way I can.
You don't have to ask me,
but if you want some help from me,
I'll be glad to.
Well, you having said this on the record is important
and I'll get back to you
after the meeting with the department of justice
is rescheduled.
And if their answers are inadequate,
then I'd be pleased to take it up with you.
And I'm grateful for your offer of assistance.
Thank you.
We now have a quorum.
So I'm going to call up the nomination
of Robert Cicada for the ATF.
Mr. Chairman, can I say something?
Please go ahead.
Well, Mr. Cicada is a career professional
who's committed to fighting crime.
I'm glad we had a chance to sit down together.
His hearing testimony does not assure me
that he would stand up in this administration
to ensure that this very controversial agency
is not weaponized against the American people.
I regret to say, I'll be opposing his nomination.
Okay.
Clerk will call the roll.
No.
Aye.
Aye, by proxy.
No, by proxy.
Aye.
The nomination having a majority
will be favorably reported.
Nomination of Andrew B. Davis,
judge for the U.S. District of Western District of Texas,
Senator Durbin.
Mr. Chairman, I'm deeply concerned Mr. Davis
will not be able to put aside his partisan advocacy
if he's confirmed to the bench.
He's repeatedly argued that the key TAM provision
of the False Claims Act,
a law the chairman has championed for so many years,
violates the Constitution.
Whistleblowers who bring key TAM actions
play an important role in holding accountable
those who defraud the federal government.
Of $6.8 billion in FCA settlements and judgments last year,
key TAM comprised $5.3 billion of that amount.
I'm also troubled by Mr. Davis's refusal
to disavow his controversial college commentary.
One example, he defended the racist commentary
from conservative pundit and former Republican official
Bill Bennett, who said, and I quote,
I do not know if it is true that if you want,
I do know that it's true
that if you wanted to reduce crime,
you could, if that were your sole purpose,
you could abort every black baby in this country
and your crime rate would go down.
Mr. Davis defended that statement as quote,
essentially accurate.
I recognize that nominees often write things in college
that no longer reflect their views today,
but when I asked Mr. Davis whether he still believed
in Bennett's statement was essentially accurate,
he refused to answer.
Mr. Davis's failure to disavow this article
is just plain unacceptable.
How can people of color have faith
that Mr. Davis will treat them fairly in his courtroom?
I urge my colleagues to oppose this nomination.
Circle call roll.
Aye.
No.
No by proxy.
Aye.
The nominee getting a majority will be favorably reported.
Now John Shepard,
judge, U.S. District Court,
Western District, Arkansas.
Clerk will call the roll.
Aye.
Where is the Shepard?
I don't see Shepard here.
No.
No by proxy.
Aye.
Majority vote reported.
The nomination will be reported to the floor.
Anna St. John, Eastern District, Louisiana.
Senator Durbin wants to speak.
Mr. Chairman, Ms. St. John's record reflects a partisan ideology
and raises serious questions about her ability
to impartially administer justice.
Her practice largely consists of challenging class action settlements.
She's also made time to file amicus briefs and politically charged cases.
Ms. St. John's public commentary is also troubling.
She has criticized what she called woke ideology.
She's challenged First Amendment protections guaranteed
by New York Times versus Sullivan.
And I would ask the committee to pay particular attention to this.
In November 2021, Ms. St. John testified against bipartisan legislation
ending forced arbitration in cases of workplace sexual assault and harassment.
The legislation enjoyed broad support among lawmakers from both parties.
Yet Ms. St. John argued in defense of her forcing
sexual assault victims into closed-door arbitration proceedings
and claimed that ending forced arbitration, quote,
turns these women into unwilling pawns.
Do you remember the issue?
The issue was brought before this committee
at the urging of former Fox News host Gretchen Carlson,
one of the leading advocates for the legislation.
Following her harassment by Roger Ailes,
she is speaking out publicly against Ms. St. John's nomination.
Listen to what Gretchen Carlson said.
While women around the country bravely shared the urgency
of eradicating forced arbitration,
St. John used her power and influence to gaslight these women and the public.
She downplayed their stories and minimized their pain.
I remember when Gretchen Carlson was in this committee room.
So many of us went to her afterwards and praised her courage to speak out
for the harassment that she witnessed in her own personal life.
Some pose for pictures.
We voted unanimously for that bill.
Democrats and Republicans.
Now we have a nominee who is opposed to it and says it was wrong.
I'm going to vote no.
Clerk will call the roll.
Aye.
No.
No by proxy.
Aye.
Majority voting for it.
The nominee will be favorably reported.
Christopher Wolfe.
Judge, U.S. District Court, Western District, Texas.
Mr. Chairman.
Senator from Texas.
Mr. Chairman, I have a statement relative to the nomination.
The committee's vote on Andrew Davis and Chris Wolfe.
I'd ask that it be made part of the record, please.
It will be included.
Thank you.
Clerk will call the roll.
Aye.
No.
No by proxy.
Aye.
Majority of the committee voting favorably.
It will be reported to the floor.
Robert Rotter.
To serve as U.S. Marshal, Northern District of Iowa.
Clerk will call the roll.
Aye.
No, I'm sorry.
Aye.
No by proxy.
No.
No by proxy.
Aye.
Majority in favor.
The nomination will be reported.
Daniel Satterly, U.S. Marshal, South Dakota.
Clerk will call the roll.
Aye.
No.
Aye.
No by proxy.
Aye.
Majority favoring Satterly will be reported to the floor.
David St. Pierre, U.S. Marshal, District of Maine.
The clerk will call the roll.
Aye.
Aye by proxy.
No by proxy.
Aye by proxy.
Aye.
Majority favoring Mr. St. Pierre will be reported.
I will now turn to our legislation.
The Safe Access to Cash Act of 2026.
As I said in my opening statement, it's led by Senator Cruz.
Sponsored also by Senator Gallego.
I'll now call up the manager's amendment on which is number WAL26101.
Without objections, we'll adopt the manager's amendment.
Hearing no opposition, the amendment is adopted.
Senator Cruz should speak now.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
In the early 20th century, banks were plagued by the likes of John Dillinger, Babyface Nelson,
and Bonnie and Clyde.
Armed robbers threatening the lives and well-being of customers, tellers, and owners alike.
Then in 1934, Congress enacted the Federal Bank Robbery Act, making bank robbery a federal offense
and unleashing the full power of federal law enforcement.
Bank robberies fell dramatically, and the violent shootouts, shattered bank vaults,
and frantic getaways of the past have now faded into history.
But while Congress protected the bank vault, the vault itself has moved.
Today, it sits on the sidewalk.
In the corner of a convenience store, at a gas station, on a backcountry road,
exposed and beyond the protective arm of federal law.
And criminals have taken notice.
ATMs have replaced banks as the main target of cash robbery.
That's why, together with Senator Ruben Gallego, the ranking member on the digital
assets subcommittee of the Banking Committee, I introduced the Safe Access to Cash Act,
bringing the Federal Bank Robbery Act into the 21st century.
Millions of Americans rely on ATMs to access cash as a lifeline, to buy groceries,
to catch the bus, to make rent.
These are working class Americans living in urban and rural cash deserts,
where the only source of cash might just be a lonely ATM.
Take the tragic story of Juan Lopez, remembered as a hardworking man and a good father.
Juan was on the phone with his sister, withdrawing cash from a standalone ATM,
when he was brutally murdered by a group of men.
It was Black Friday, the day after Thanksgiving.
He was just 29 years old.
Juan's story is not an isolated tragedy.
Even worse, most of these crimes are never reported.
There are now over 530,000 ATMs in the United States,
handling more than 10 billion transactions every year.
As bank branches decline, with roughly 20% fewer today than a decade ago,
thefts at ATMs are rising, increasing 21% year over year.
In some cases, robbers can walk away with $15,000 in five minutes.
And under current law, federal prosecutors often lack the authority to pursue them.
And as far as federal law is concerned,
it's smarter for a robber to hold up a mom-and-pop shop or a man like Juan
waiting at a standalone ATM than to try to break into a protected bank vault.
That makes it harder for working-class Americans to get by,
many who use ATMs to access government benefits on prepaid cards,
such as veterans and social security benefits, cash assistance, and federal disability.
The Safe Access to Cash Act closes that gap in the law,
allowing federal law enforcement to investigate and bring to justice crimes like these.
For that reason, our nation's leading law enforcement organizations support the bill,
including the National Association of Police Organizations and the major county sheriffs of
America. So do organizations that represent stores and retailers, from the small mom-and-pop shops
to national chains, such as the National Association of Convenience Stores and the
Retail Industry Leaders Association. And so do groups that bear the financial cost of repeat
ATM robberies, including the National ATM Council, the National Armored Car Association,
and the largest ATM manufacturers and servicers in the country.
Let me close by thanking Chairman Grassley for his leadership in bringing this bill to markup.
I'm also grateful to Ranking Member Durbin and his staff for their thoughtful,
constructive input as this bill has taken shape.
Thank you as well to Senators Whitehouse and Coons for their team's insightful suggestions
to the bill. And last but not least, my thanks to Senator Gallego for his partnership in making
this legislation possible. Today's cash robberies don't take place in marble-clad banks behind
tempered steel doors. They happen at the corner store, the gas station, and the standalone ATM,
where everyday Americans are most vulnerable. So I ask the members of this committee to vote yes
to ensure safe access to cash for working Americans. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Senator Durbin.
When I go to the supermarket in my hometown, there are two machines by the exit. They look
identical. One is an ATM machine, which is affected by this legislation, and the other
one is a crypto ATM, which is not affected by this legislation. I support this bill,
but there's more work to do. There are more than 30,000 crypto ATMs across the United States.
You may not have noticed them, but they're there, and they look just like ATMs.
Here's how the scammers use these machines to target vulnerable senior citizens.
A senior citizen gets a call from someone claiming to be from their bank or from the
government. The caller claims that their bank accounts have been frozen because of unpaid bills
or that the senior owes fines for skipping jury duty, and if he doesn't pay, he could go to jail.
Then the scammer directs the victim to the nearest crypto ATM and instructs them to insert
cash. Once the money is in the machine, it is virtually impossible to trace.
The FBI received over 12,000 reports of Americans falling victim to crypto ATMs last year,
12,000. Total loss savings for individuals and families, $333 million.
My Crypto ATM Fraud Prevention Act would establish nationwide protection
to reduce the risk of fraud at crypto ATMs. It would require operators to give clear warnings
about scams, set reasonable daily transaction limits, and allow victims to get a full refund.
I'm not offering this as an amendment today, but I hope we will work together
on a bipartisan basis as we did on the pending bill to make this the law of the land. Thank you.
Are there any other speakers on this subject? Hearing nobody asking for the floor,
I'd like to ask to report the bill by voice on favorably reporting S3798 as amended.
All in favor say aye. Aye.
All opposed say no. The ayes have it. The bill reported. Meeting adjourned.
