Donatello and Michelangelo

Donatello
7 followers
17 Video Views·Mar 4, 2026
Saul Escobar and Chris Helms discuss Donatello's "David" and Michelangelo's "David."
Hello everyone, I'm Chris. Hey and I'm Saul. And today we'll be looking at two sculptures by
really renaissance rock stars Donatello and Michelangelo. Now the piece of art that we're
looking at here is Donatello's Bronze David. This was sculpted in 1430. Now this is a very
interesting piece of art because it was the first bronze sculpture since the classic times as well
Now Donatello was one of the founding fathers of art and upcoming he was very odd, very weird,
and pretty strange. He would smash his work when he didn't like it and people kind of saw him as
an odd fellow. However the Medici family stood up for him and they were considered outsiders
themselves. We can see that Donatello put a lot of movement and motion into the sculpture. As we can
see the left wrist and arm of David is resting on his left hip which kind of flings out his elbow
and then we can see his left knee is slightly bent over Goliath's head and his right leg is stiff.
And as we look at the sculpture David and look at his face he's a lot younger and very youthful.
Now there's also something interesting here with the sword and the rock. Now what do you think
about that and what it's representing? Totally it's a great observation. We can tell that Donatello
had a message I think in this in this sculpture the sword and the rock symbolizing almost the
people of Florence and the Duke of Milan. Now we know that there was you know some war against
those two and I think that the story of David coming up as the little guy overcoming the big
guy beating all odds really portrayed that story. So we can see that obviously the sword is a
superior weapon symbolizing the Duke of Milan and the rock kind of you know not as a big weapon
or a major weapon of choice. Kind of a primitive weapon. Exactly exactly like the people of Florence
the rock really really symbolizes the common folk and then those people and how I think Donatello
portrays how they overcame. Now this this sculpture is very very realistic as well there's some
certain details in there that really show that. Yes exactly if we can look at Goliath's head it just looks
so real. The facial expressions that that are portrayed here as well as the beard and the lines
and the curvature down there as well it's just it's really realistic and also if we look at the
sword you can see that there's actually notches on the sharp side of the sword which which kind
of shows that this this is that this sword has been through battle. It shows Donatello's very
detailed perspective to his artwork. Now this sculpture resides in the National Museum in
Florence where it is frequently visited by people all over the world. Now here we have the sculpture
of David by Michelangelo. While Michelangelo is most often known for painting the ceiling of the
Sistine Chapel he thought of himself more of a sculptor than a painter. He thought it gave him
the almost divine ability to create something out of a solid block of stone. In fact the giant piece
of marble that this was carved from was nicknamed the giant and David in this figure himself is 14
feet 3 inches tall and with the pedestal below it he is 26 feet up in the air which is an absolutely
imposing majestic figure. This sculpture really exudes power and fearlessness and determination
which represented the Florentines view of themselves as kind of a commemoration of Florence's
connection to the story of David and Goliath. This sculpture has a very classical look and feel to it.
It's almost identical to some of the classical Greek and Roman sculptures. Michelangelo also
used the classical style of contrapposto in here. It gives the figure a lot of movement. Yes it does
as we saw earlier with Donatello's David. This David here has a lot of movement especially with
that left foot kind of arched up and also that left arm up right around his shoulder you can
just see a lot of movement. It's very beautiful. David's positioning in this sculpture also shows
a lot of tension. He looks like he's spring-loaded like a cat ready to pounce on Goliath. It's really
apparent that he's not focusing on something real close he's focusing on something that's
far away and that shifts the viewer's perspective from David himself to possibly another being in
the situation and of course we know that that's Goliath. That takes the focus from this sculpture
away from being inward to being almost transcendent. Which raises the question can the focal
point in a work of art not actually be part of the physical art itself? It depends on the situation
but when we look at this sculpture of David we're drawn to where his eyes are looking. Yeah. We want
to look where he's looking. Yeah it almost gets the audience or the viewer very curious to where
David's looking at and I think that kind of draws a lot of attention to this art as to what is he
looking at and there's a lot of room for interpretation for that which I think is you know
very interesting. Now let's talk about the differences and similarities between the two
Davids. Earlier we mentioned the contrapposto that both Davids show. You can see a lot of movement
and motion within the extremities and the core and the torso of both Davids but some of the
differences are pretty obvious. I mean we can see the physicality of both Davids here in
Michelangelo's. It's very masculine very muscular and huge you know a lot older as well. This David
is a lot more fierce and just someone who's ready to go into battle. Now we can see Donatello's
David which is just like a young boy and someone who maybe has never fought in his life. Which
shows a little more of a realistic view of the story of David and Goliath. Besides just their
appearances as well we have a large difference in physical size. The David by Michelangelo is
just about 14 feet tall from head to toe while Donatello's David is just about five feet tall.
Yeah but I think without a question that Donatello's David is just way better. I mean there's
no way. The David by Donatello is just it's almost a little boyish. It looks weak compared to the one
by Michelangelo. I mean come on Donatello's David he's holding a sword in one hand and then he's got
Goliath's head at his feet. Michelangelo's David doesn't have any clothes on. Well Donatello's
doesn't either. Dude look at that hat though. No question. Guess we have to agree to disagree huh?
All right.
