In recent years, Wisconsin-based home improvement chain Menards has produced many unique and well-detailed buildings for the O and HO scale model train market. II recently purchased the Menards American Materials Plant #1 in hopes of modifying it to solve a unique problem on my model railroad. Let’s take a look!
This structure is a good fit for small spaces with a footprint of less than 6 inches by 6 inches, yet it has an impressive height of more than 15 inches. While the Menards building is fine as-is, I was not really looking for a sand, gravel, or concrete facility for my railroad. What I really wanted for my layout was a coal flood loader. I saw the Menards Materials Plant and thought I might be able to use it as the start of a coal loader facility and save myself a lot of time and design work.
**As an Amazon Associate and a member of other affiliate networks, We may receive commissions on qualifying sales generated from the links on this channel.***
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
In recent years, Wisconsin-based home improvement chain Menards has produced a number of unique and
well-detailed buildings for the O and HO scale model market. I previously purchased and reviewed
the Menards Tide Plant and National Light and Power Facilities, and I recently purchased the
Menards American Materials Plant No. 1 in hopes of modifying it to solve a unique problem on
my model railroad. Let's take a look! Hello again, this is Mike with another episode of
Toy Train Tips and Tricks, and this is the Menards American Materials Plant No. 1. There
is also an American Materials Plant No. 2, which is essentially a set of cylindrical silos with
no doors, windows, or ladders, or any other features to define its size, and therefore
it's offered as both an O and HO scale product. This plant, on the other hand, does have defining
scale features, such as two workers and a ladder system that clearly define it as an O scale
structure. This structure is a good fit for small spaces, with a footprint of less than 6x6 inches,
yet it has impressive height of more than 15 inches. Like most other Menards structures,
the base is particleboard with printed paper overlay to provide visual texture and details.
I mentioned in my previous Menards reviews my concern about high humidity spaces.
Well, with the help of a dehumidifier, my basement typically stays between 35% and 40%
humidity in the summertime, and in the past year I've only experienced some minor peeling on a
sign or two, and these were easily repaired with a spot of glue. I've been pleasantly surprised.
The base also features a tall opening, tall enough for a Menards auto carrier in fact,
so trains may pass under the structure with no clearance problems. The four silos are plastic,
a thicker plastic than is used on the tanks of the Tide plant. These silos provide a sufficiently
sound structure for the building. The handrails on the upper two levels are plastic and are quite
fragile. There are two Oscale workers on the top level, one working with his toolbox, and
the other apparently staring off into space. Maybe he's the supervisor, or maybe he's just
contemplating his place in the Oscale universe. The highlights of this building are two animated
flag signs. When I picked up my building at the store, I noticed that one of the signs had come
loose. I looked carefully at the wiring and everything seemed to be intact, so I took a
chance on it. Luckily, my instinct was correct and the sign worked. Replacing the sign was a simple
process with a hot glue gun. I also had to make a few minor repairs to some of the handrails.
The structure also featured four flashing red aircraft beacons on the roof. Also on the roof
is some simulated ductwork constructed from basswood. Overall, the structure is a good
representation of the type of silo one would find at a gravel or concrete facility, but it can also
work for other industries. Stickers are included so that you may label your silos if you wish.
While the Menards building is fine as is, I was not really looking for a sand, gravel,
or concrete facility for my railroad. What I really wanted for my layout was a coal flood loader.
Unlike traditional coal tipples, flood loaders may be located miles from the actual mine.
Coal arrives at the loader via a series of conveyor belts, and a single loader may receive
coal from several different mines. For the modeler, the advantages of a flood loader are that only a
single track is required, and the mine itself need not be modeled, both points saving space on the model railroad.
My first idea was to scratch build a flood loader, so I began researching the various types.
Then I saw the Menards materials plant and thought I might be able to use it as the start
of a coal loader facility, and save myself a lot of time and design work. In the Powder River Basin
in the western United States, flood loaders are massive concrete structures that can easily load
150 car trains one after the next. These western loaders use tall cylindrical concrete silos to
house the coal for distribution. In the eastern United States, flood loaders tend to be smaller and
rectangular in shape, and they're often clad in wood siding or corrugated sheet metal.
Regardless of east or west, large or small, all flood loaders share certain common characteristics.
First, there must be some sort of silo to receive and store the coal. The Menards structure has four
cylindrical concrete silos. While eastern loaders are usually rectangular and made of wood or steel,
there's no reason an eastern loader could not have concrete silos, so check that item off the list.
Next, a typical loader is elevated over the tracks to allow the train to pass under the
structure for loading, just like the Menards building. Check. A retractable chute drops down
from the ceiling to fill the cars, and there's usually some sort of control room for the operator
nearby. When the Menards building is situated on the layout perpendicular to the viewer,
one cannot see underneath to view a chute or a control booth, so these details are irrelevant.
Check. A stairway or ladder system allows workers to climb the structure to access and maintain
equipment. While a stairway system is more common, some smaller loaders do use ladders,
just like on the Menards building. Check. Finally, there is some type of conveyor system at the top
of the structure to deliver coal and fill the silos. This is the only part that's missing.
I thought this would be a rather simple addition to the structure,
certainly easier than scratch building the whole thing. First, I measured the top of the building
to determine what was possible. I determined that if I relocated the tool chest worker
and some of the horizontal ductwork, I could fit an additional structure between the other two
pieces of ductwork. Then I went to Tinkercad and designed a simple utility structure, as seen here.
The walls would represent corrugated sheet metal. I added an access door, a mechanical cabinet,
and several vents. I also added a connection to accept a half-inch PVC pipe, representing
a conveyor system. A simple corrugated roof completed the look. The structure is roughly
two and three quarter inches by three and a half inches and is five and a half inches tall,
or about two stories high in O scale. A link to the free Tinkercad file can be found in the video
description. I printed the structure on my Creality Ender 3, although one could certainly
build it from styrene, basswood, or even cardstock. I painted it a shade of gray that I had on hand
and I thought looked close to the original Menards building. While it was printing,
I removed the workman figure and the toolbox by twisting them off with a pair of needle nose
pliers, and they came loose very freely. Removing the duct work was more difficult,
as I had to avoid causing damage to the plastic handrails as I worked.
Eventually, I carved out two paths in the wood piece with a rotary tool to allow my addition
to sit on top cleanly. With a final test fit, I concluded that the gray paint on my addition was
too light and clean compared to the original structure, so I weathered the addition lightly
to tone down the color. I then reattached the worker and his toolbox, each with a dab of super
glue. My eventual plan is for the conveyor to pass through the top of a mountain before arriving at
the loader. For now, I simply painted my half-inch PVC pipe black and placed a simple temporary
backdrop where the mountain will go. A hole in this foam core backdrop supports the far end of
conveyor pipe. After I complete my mountain, I will add support structures to the conveyor.
I decided not to permanently attach my addition, at least for now, because I will need to adjust
it when I add the final conveyor piece and scenery, and also to add an aircraft beacon LED
later, since this is now by far the tallest building on my layout. A dab of gorilla poster
putty will secure the addition for now. So now I can complete the scenery on this portion of my
layout as I have my centerpiece building in place. While it does not match any particular prototype,
it has enough of the necessary features to pass as a believable flood loader for my coal trains.
The track that services my loader disappears into the mountain and reappears as the service track
for my power plant. In operation, empty coal trains will enter the loader track,
only to exit the other side as empties from the power plant. Loaded coal trains will enter the
power plant, only to exit as fresh loads from the flood loader, and the cycle can continue forever.
While I now need to build a mountain or two, I'm very pleased with how this project has turned out.
The overall height of the building and the LED signs make my coal loader an eye-catcher for this
portion of the layout, and in conjunction with the power plant, it will provide endless hours
of operating fun on the layout. I hope this video has inspired you to think outside the box with
model structures, and see how with a little modification, even pre-built structures can
fill a different role than the ones for which they were designed. As always, I hope you enjoyed this
video as much as I enjoyed making it, and if so, please like the video, subscribe, and share with
your friends and neighbors. So keep the hopper cars loading, and keep the trains running,
and we'll see you next time on Toy Train Tips and Tricks!