I was recently able to acquire this Lionel-compatible new old stock O gauge O27 K-Line Alco S2 switcher for a really great price. Though not a scale model train by any stretch of the imagination, I have always liked the look of the Marx/K-Line/RMT switcher - and it is proportioned just right to go with undersize Marx and Lionel Scout-derived rolling stock.
After acquiring most of the old Marx Trains tooling, K-Line began producing its version of the ALCO switcher in 1989. K-Line improved the appearance of the Marx tooling by adding a full set of metal handrails to the sides and by adding an ornamental bell. The Marx stack design was kept, however. Below the walkway, the K-Line version uses a traditional two-truck drive - both of which are powered by can motors. With both traction tires and considerable added weight, for traction, these little K-Line models can pull a mighty load!
The trucks on the K-Line version represent the AAR type truck similar to the ALCO FA models, actually making these models more akin to S-4’s than S-2’s. With one exception, all K-Line ALCO switchers are equipped with a 3-position electronic reverse unit. The single exception is the #2326 Southern Pacific in Black Widow colors. Part of the basic starter set, this model was made for operation on DC power only, and has no reverse unit - and only a single motor. Later, K-Line made a different, AC-powered #2326 SP ALCO. This one includes the words “San Francisco” under the number on the cab to differentiate it from its cheaper predecessor.
With smooth-running can motors and operating couplers at each end, these K-Line models are great switchers - especially with O27 track and rolling stock. But, as nice as they are, these K-Line models are not perfect. First, the powered trucks on these models are rather inflexible on the vertical axis, so they don’t work well on trestles or steep grades. The flatter the track, the better.
**As an Amazon Associate and a member of other affiliate networks, We may receive commissions on qualifying sales generated from the links on this channel.***
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
The model so nice they made it twice, or three times. The Marks K-Line RMT Alco S2,
on this episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
Hello again, this is Mike with another episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
I was recently able to acquire this new old stock K-Line Alco S2 switcher for a really great price.
Though not a scale model by any stretch of the imagination, I've always liked the look of the
Marks K-Line RMT switcher, and it's proportioned just right to go with undersized Marks and
Lionel Scout-derived rolling stock. The Marks model 1998 S2 was available from 1955 through
the 1960s in Santa Fe, Union Pacific, Allstate, and Rock Island versions.
There are a number of variations, including the color, two-unit powered and dummy sets,
and some examples featuring Marks' crude but effective diesel roar sound.
While lacking in detail, the Marks models are considered to be excellent runners for their era.
Perhaps the most interesting feature of the Marks model is that it actually uses a standard
four-wheel Marks drive similar to that of the 70-ton diesel and small steam locomotives.
The front and rear wheels are non-powered axles attached to the main drive with articulated trucks,
providing the appearance of a pair of four-wheel trucks under the diesel.
In the real world, S-series S1 and S2 switchers had begun production in 1940, and the S2 would
remain in production from both ALCO and under license from Montreal Locomotive Works in Canada
until 1957. Similar S3 and S4 models began production in 1949 and remained in production
concurrently with the older models until 1957. The S1 and S3 were 600-horsepower models that were
visually distinguishable from their counterparts by having radiators that were taller than they
were wide, as well as a larger smokestack with oblong bases. The S2 and S4 were 1,000-horsepower
models that featured wider radiators to accommodate their more powerful prime movers.
The S1 and S2 models rode on ALCO's own mount truck design, while the S3 and S4 models
rode on standard AAR-type switcher trucks. Some S1 and S2 switchers had their trucks
later swapped with AAR types, making true identification difficult, while the S1 through
S4 series as a whole was very successful for ALCO with more than 2,500 models made,
the S2 was by far the most common version with more than 1,500 examples made. While most were
retired from Class 1 railroad service by the mid-1970s, many of these ALCO models survive
today on short lines, in industrial service, and on tourist lines. On the Marx model, the smokestack
is incorrect, but the radiator shape more or less represents the S2 model. The trucks are not a
great representation of the ALCO mount truck, but they're closer to the ALCO design than to the AAR
type. After acquiring most of the old Marx train's tooling, K-Line began producing its version of the
ALCO switcher in 1989. K-Line improved the appearance of the Marx tooling by adding a full
set of metal handrails on the sides and by adding an ornamental horn. The Marx stack design was kept,
however, but below the walkway the K-Line version uses a traditional two-truck drive, both of which
are powered by CAN motors. With both traction tires and considerable added weight, for traction
these little K-Line models can pull a mighty load. The trucks on the K-Line version represent the AAR
type truck, similar to the ALCO FA models, actually making these models more akin to S4s
than to S2s. With one exception, all K-Line ALCO switchers are equipped with a three-position
electronic reverse unit. The single exception is the number 2326 Southern Pacific in Black
Widow colors. Part of a basic starter set, this model was made for operation on DC power only
and has no reverse unit and only a single motor. Later, K-Line made a different AC powered number
2326 SP ALCO. This one includes the words San Francisco under the number on the cab to differentiate
it from its cheaper predecessor. With smooth running CAN motors and operating couplers at each
end, these K-Line models are great switchers, especially with 027 track and rolling stock.
But as nice as they are, these K-Line models are not perfect. First, the powered trucks of
these models are rather inflexible on the vertical axis, so they don't work well on
trestles or steep grades. The flatter the track, the better. Second, like most early K-Line models,
the CAN motors on these ALCOs are wired in parallel, so they tend to have jumpy starts and
stops, especially when using older Lionel transformers, and their top speed can be in
the ludicrous range. This can be fixed with a simple motor rewire, changing the motor wiring
from parallel to series, a project for an upcoming video. Some later K-Line models,
like some MP-15s, came with a pre-wired selector switch to change from parallel to series operation.
K-Line's ALCO switchers were staples in starter sets from 1989 through the 1990s, and were also
available for separate sale. Many were utilized in limited run sets for various companies,
including Coke and Pepsi, Procter & Gamble, True Value Hardware, and many more. In all,
more than a hundred different variations of the K-Line ALCO switcher were produced,
more than enough to keep any collector busy for a very long time.
But the story of these ALCO diesels does not end with K-Line. After K-Line's absorption into Lionel,
Ready-Made Trains, or RMT, acquired the tooling for these models and produced their own versions
beginning in 2011, calling them Bangs. RMT added more details, including wire handrails,
a new and improved pilot, and they finally changed the smokestack to a more ALCO-like
appearance. They retained the AER trucks, making them more like S4s than S2s. RMT also added a
flashing strobe to the cab roof, directional headlight and marker lights, and the motors
on its version featured improved low-end performance. Unfortunately, these improvements
also came with a higher price tag, and the RMT models of 2011 retailed for about 60% more than
the K-Line versions of 1995. These ALCO models are no longer offered by RMT. Despite their
diminutive size, the reliability and collectability of the various S2 models makes them more valuable
than comparable O27 diesels. Common Marks versions in good condition can be found for $50 or so,
but more desirable variations and those in excellent or better condition are often priced
at $100 or more. Likewise, common K-Line versions can often be found in the $75-$100 range,
but rare and desirable versions, and of course the RMT versions, can bring $150-$200 in excellent
condition. In my case, this new old stock model, which appears to have only been test run,
if ever run at all, based on the lack of wear on the wheels and rollers, set me back all of $35.
I don't know how this would slip through the cracks on eBay, but every once in a while my
ridiculously low bids will hold up. So, if you're looking for a great running, but not necessarily
scale-detailed diesel for your layout, especially if you run smaller O27 equipment, keep these fine
Alco models in mind. Whether an original Marks, a colorful K-Line, or a feature-packed RMT version,
these models are as durable and dependable as their real-world counterparts.
As always, I hope you enjoyed this video as much as I enjoyed making it, and if so,
please like the video, subscribe, share, and leave a comment about your favorite Alco switcher.
And remember to tell your friends and neighbors,
keep the trains running, and we'll catch you next time on Toy Train Tips and Tricks!