Episode 103: After the Second World War, Marx Trains produced several varieties of operating and non-operating couplers. Not all of them are compatible with one another, and none is compatible with Lionel knuckle couplers (although some will mate with Lionel Scout couplers). Let's examine these types and show how they can be mixed in a single train.
Chapters:
00:00 Introduction 01:25 Marx tab and slot couplers 02:39 Marx "Tilt" or "Fork" couplers 04:50 Marx Uncoupler Section Tips 05:15 Marx Plastic Knuckle Couplers 06:39 Which Marx Couplers are compatible with Marx? 07:10 How to make Marx couplers work with Lionel 09:00 Description of Marx Prewar Couplers 10:18 One train, 3 different Marx couplers running on the layout 12:06 Conclusion
Hello again, this is Mike with Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
And in the world of Lionel, in the post-war period, with the
exception of the short-lived and ill-fated Scout coupler, all Lionel
couplers of the post-war period were all compatible with one another.
They were all different versions of the same knuckle coupler,
but Mark's was a little different.
Uh, in the post-war period, there were in fact four different
couplers that were used by Mark's.
And at any given time, up to three of them could be in production at once.
So keeping track of the different types of Mark's couplers and which
ones are compatible with which, uh, becomes somewhat of a challenge
in the post-war period for Mark.
And this is one of the things that makes dating Mark's cars and locomotives
more difficult than Lionel, because there's overlap in the types of
things being used and you even get things such as, uh, this car, um,
features much less detail than this car, but yet it has the
better couplers than this car.
So, um, you know, Mark's it's, it's hard to keep track of that way.
So let's take a look at the different types of couplers and how they are
compatible or incompatible with one another.
So let's start with the Tab and Slot.
And it gets its name because it has a tab and a slot.
And this coupler originated in the pre-war period, uh, 1936, and it was
still in production all the way up to the end of Mark's production in 1974.
Uh, it is an outgrowth of the original pre-war Joyline coupler, which was
also kind of a tab and slot, although the slot was more of a donut hole.
Uh, much more round, um, than this.
And so this was used on, uh, for example, tin four wheel cars.
And, uh, later on, it was used for tender draw bars and couplers on the rear of
like E7s and other diesels that weren't intended, um, to be coupled to any
cars, but only to locomotives.
Um, but in any case, it stayed around.
So this is the Tab and Slot coupler.
Uh, from 1936 to 1974, there are some slight variations, but this is
the basic Tab and Slot coupler.
Which brings us to the Fork coupler.
Now the Fork couplers first were made out of metal.
Uh, this was made out of plastic.
The Fork coupler, or sometimes called the Tilt coupler, because they
tilt from side to side to uncouple.
And that's actually quite an ingenious mechanism, uh, with the spring here.
On the bottom side of the coupler, uh, is this little piece here.
So, uh, if you hit it one way, it'll slide out, but if you hit it
the other way, it stays coupled.
So these came with a special uncoupling section, um, which looks a little bit
like this, although there are parts missing.
What would also be here would be a, another bar, like a rail
and a spring attached to it.
And normally this would be in the up position, but the spring,
it could go side to side.
And what would happen is when the car approaches and it hits that rail, if
it's coming this direction, it hits the rail, the coupler isn't going anywhere,
but the rail has a spring on it.
And so it bounces out of the way and the car remains coupled, but coming the other
direction, the rail hits and the rail is now in its locked position, but the
coupler can slide out of the way.
And you see it tilts, uncoupling it from the coupler next to it.
And so these came in both metal and plastic.
The metal ones began in 1941, 1953 or so they started switching to the plastic.
And the other main difference between the metal and plastic is that the metal
fork couplers do not have this slot.
You will sometimes find them where someone has cut a slot in them, because
the advantage of that slot is that it will mate with a tab and slot coupler.
Without that slot there, obviously it will not.
So these are compatible, the tab and slot in the plastic tilt coupler.
These in good condition are becoming more and more difficult to find.
As I checked on eBay, I found that many of them were in this condition with parts
missing or especially with the spring missing.
So if you are going to purchase one of these at eBay, make sure you take a close
look and make sure that not only is that cross piece there, but also that silver
spring, without that spring, the uncoupler will not work properly.
Next we have the next cheapest, and this is the plastic knuckle coupler.
This is a non-operating coupler.
And so it looks somewhat more realistic because of the knuckle coupler shape,
but it is non-operating, non-functioning.
And these were made from 1950 to 1974.
So again, through the end of production.
And you can see these on eight wheel cars like this.
You see them on four wheel plastic cars.
You see them on some of the tin cars.
And so a lot of it had to do with the quality or the price point of the
particular set that Marks was making.
Those that were higher price points, higher quality would have the more
expensive operating couplers, whereas others would have the
non-operating knuckle coupler.
Now the knuckle coupler and the tilt coupler are incompatible,
whether it's plastic or metal, but the tab and slot fits nicely in that knuckle.
So these two are.
So the tab and slot is compatible with both the knuckle coupler
and the plastic tilt coupler, but the tab and slot is not compatible
with the metal tilt coupler.
Okay.
So to recap, tab and slot will meet with plastic fork, will meet with knuckle.
This one is almost universal.
Knuckle will meet with tab and slot, but not plastic or metal.
Fork coupler, plastic will meet with tab and slot, not with knuckle, but it
will meet with the metal tab and slot, or metal tilt, metal tilt will
only meet with plastic tilt.
None of these designs will directly meet with the standard Lionel knuckle coupler.
However, there are some things to do to make them compatible.
One of course would be to just swap out the trucks, the Lionel for the Marks.
But the problem with that is that Lionel trucks tend to be taller than the
Marks, and so you get a difference in height.
Another option is to take one of these early post-war bar end type trucks.
And if you take this metal plate off, attaches here and attach it to the
coupler, the wheel base on these is the same as the Marks.
So if you have a scrapped one of these Lionel cars, pull this off, attach
it here, and you have a Lionel coupler on your Marks car.
And lastly, if you don't want to modify the car in any way, then there is my
handy dandy coupler adapter, and click on the top here and you can see
a video on how I did these.
This is actually an earlier version.
The latest version, these little ears come down even farther to grip onto
the Lionel coupler even better.
But basically that slides onto there.
That goes in to the slot or into the slot or into the slot.
So with this adapter, the Lionel couplers are compatible with all three designs,
just not the metal tilt coupler.
And when you're done, you just slide it back off.
And so you've made no modification to the car itself.
And I printed this in this nice bright color to make it easy to find.
The first batch I made up was in black and they kind of
disappeared into the layout.
So again, as I mentioned before, for pre-war couplers, the most common
type was the Joyline, which was similar to the Tab and Slot, except for
instead of a slot, it was more of a big round hole, big donut hole.
And then these came along in 1936.
The other pre-war Marx coupler is called the One-Way coupler.
It was introduced in 1937, and it's called One-Way because
you can only run the cars one way.
On one end of the car is a big spring-loaded claw is probably
the best way to describe it.
And on the other end is a post and through this very complicated
mechanism, the spring-loaded claw will wrap around the post or connect
or disconnect through an automatic system.
It's very complicated.
It was very expensive to produce.
And that made it very allergic for the Marx company who's known
for reliability and being cheap.
These were very complicated, hard to work on and very expensive to produce.
So that's why after the war, the tilt coupler came about to
give the automatic coupling.
All right.
So let's put together a train using a mishmash of all of these different
couplers and see what we can come up with.
Okay.
Here's the train we've put together.
I've got our Marx 666 steamer 242 with the New York Central tender
with the plastic tilt coupler.
We have an NYC four wheel tender with the tab and snot in the front and a
plastic knuckle coupler in the back.
We have a B&O boxcar with plastic knuckle couplers on either side.
We have another NYC tender with the plastic coupler towards the boxcar
and a tab and snot going into the crane car with the plastic tilt coupler
going into the boxcar and caboose with plastic tilt couplers.
So using three different styles of Marx couplers all on one
train and let's give it a spin.