Economist explains what happens after AI takes all jobs

Loan Hub
4 followers
Who is pushing this revolution in technology?
It is the richest people in the world.
This is what Elon Musk says,
AI and robots will replace all jobs.
Someone at a computer doing something,
AI is going to take over those jobs like lightning.
If there are no jobs and humans won't be needed for most things,
how do people get an income to feed their families,
to get healthcare, or to pay the rent?
If we really see rapid automation in the next few years,
then there's going to be a whole class of white-collar workers
who are in some ways redundant.
Having a whole class of people who are unemployed
and not valued much
because what they used to do is now done by machines.
There is a very high likelihood this is all coming at us.
It is coming sooner than most people realize.
What will our economy look like
as we progressively automate more and more and more?
We are in the midst of the greatest economic transformation
in our country's history.
What experts are calling the fourth industrial revolution.
If we go back to the beginning of the industrial revolution,
there was this big debate between the Luddites
and the entrepreneurial class on the other hand.
Is automation good or bad for wages?
Economists have been arguing that automation is good
because it is what ultimately makes us as a society much wealthier.
Yet, from the perspective of an individual worker
who gets automated,
the question has been just unambiguously obvious
that automation is bad for them.
For the past 200 years, economists have argued,
well, automation is painful for the individual,
but it allows our economy to produce more with less.
It makes the economy more efficient.
It is also good for the workers
because they can switch to more productive jobs
and jobs that will ultimately generate higher income for them.
AI agents could automate more than half of US work hours,
both manual and cognitive.
If millions of people lose work,
how will they support themselves?
Unemployment could spike to 10 to 20% in the next five years.
So we're looking at a world
where we have levels of unemployment we've never seen before.
Job automation is one of the greatest public concerns.
These large language models
can perform more and more intelligent tasks.
So economists have jumped to their natural reaction,
well, we need some automation for our economy to grow
and for workers to ultimately be better off.
But the big question is whether this time is different.
Societies that we had 250 years ago,
the vast majority of people worked in agriculture.
Today in a country like the US,
less than 2% of the population still work in agriculture.
The rest has all moved to complex, more advanced jobs.
We have already automated 98% of those tasks
that people worked in 250 years ago
because now only 2% of workers
can produce that kind of agricultural output.
In a future in which machines can do more and more,
do we actually want to maintain a role for labor
because that's the way our societies have been organized
for the past few hundred years?
Or do we want to find a better way of distributing income
without all having to work on something
that the machines can do better than us?
So there's this hump-shaped relationship
between automation and wages
if we have just a little bit of automation,
then more automation helps workers.
As we approach the very last tasks left for humans,
then automation hurts workers.
Almost everybody who sits on a stage like this would tell you
it is vital that your children learn computer science.
And in fact, it's almost exactly the opposite.
Everybody in the world is now a programmer.
This is the miracle of artificial intelligence.
What is happening just in the tech industry
and just in software engineering,
I think we have to take seriously the possibility
that we are about to see a real bloodbath
for entry-level white-collar workers.
Whenever we automated something simple,
let's say spinning and weaving,
we humans on average focused our attention
on more complex things.
So in the narrative that economists have been telling
the public to push back against Luddism
and push back against the lump of labor fallacy
and oversimplified understanding
of how labor markets work,
economists have always focused on this new task creation.
For the past 250 years,
that description has been spot on.
The big question is,
how far can we extrapolate that into the future?
Like chimps don't have control over humans.
There's nothing they could do.
As humans, we could go, for example,
and eliminate all chimps.
If we put our minds to it,
we could say we could go out
and we could annihilate all chimps.
The brain is a biological machine.
They are the best information processing devices around.
But at the same time,
they can do only so much.
85 billion neurons.
We can't really transcend that limitation.
On the other hand,
if you look at computers,
can ultimately have more connections
than we have in our human brains.
Throughout our history,
we have never ever had machines
that were anywhere near the complexity of our human brains.
But now we are suddenly on the cusp of that.
That may fundamentally change what we have experienced.
Once these machines clearly surpass
our cognitive and intellectual capabilities,
it is by no means obvious
that we humans would be able to invent
or execute new tasks
that are not also amenable to the machines.
Anything that isn't moving atoms,
like during physical work,
those jobs will be and are being eliminated
by AI at a very rapid pace.
The ultimate measure of complexity
that's relevant for machines
is computational complexity.
How many computations do we need to execute
in order to produce some results?
For the past 15 years,
the algorithms we have developed
have become two and a half times as efficient
every single year.
To perform the same task,
we need to perform fewer computations.
In robotics,
there are lots of things
that we humans can perform very easily
that are still a challenge.
Folding laundry is something
that we humans can do relatively easily.
But for a robot,
it has been almost impossible a couple years ago.
Evolution has basically endowed us
with a lot of computational hardware
that is particularly well suited
for performing those specific operations,
walking, manipulating things with our fingers.
That brain is not necessarily adept at performing math.
With machines,
we can optimize them
for whatever we need them to be optimized.
In the 2010s,
we trained vision systems
and made them more and more efficient
to perform vision tasks.
Maybe doing advanced math
will be automated
before dance instructors are automated.
Will we all suddenly become dance instructors?
I would bet probably no.
We humans,
we spend many years
accumulating human capital
for a specific career
to become an economics professor.
That means it's kind of hard
to switch between those jobs.
If we can perform lots and lots of things really cheaply,
labor, which is relatively scarce,
will earn large returns.
That was the story of the past 200 years.
We had more and more machines
that became ever cheaper.
And we humans,
we were the bottleneck.
Everything we produced ultimately required us
either to press a button for the machines
or to perform
more higher-level complex reasoning.
We will find out
that there are other factors
in scarce supply,
minerals or energy,
that are going to become
really important bottlenecks.
For the past 200 years,
we humans have been the scarce factor.
We have been the bottleneck.
Our wages have risen so much.
But if in an HEI-powered future,
energy is the bottleneck,
then those scarce factors
are going to gobble up
a significant part
of their returns to economic growth.
This is what von Neumann
called the singularity.
It is possible for that to happen
maybe later this decade
or early next.
And economists always thought
that improving our technology
is really the critical part
to making us grow.
If it turns out that AI
can do all of these things,
then technological progress
is bound to happen much faster.
Our biological minds
are no longer the bottleneck
for improving science.
We may see a whole bunch of breakthroughs
that look like low-hanging fruits
to the AI minds,
superhuman-level AI,
that we will see a take-off
in technological progress.
Now, would I view this as a singularity?
As an economist,
there's always some scarcity.
We will see a take-off.
Then at some level,
the machines may also run
into problems that are hard for them.
Maybe there's going to be
several waves of that.
What would that actually imply?
Our human world
does not really change as much.
A very fast take-off
that changes the face of the Earth
would probably be a misaligned take-off.
Two separate islands
growing at very different rates.
I hope it won't be that bad.
If a lot of humans become impoverished
because machines can do their jobs
at a much cheaper rate,
human GDP may actually decline.
The danger is that it'll make
the rich richer and the poor poorer.
That's not AI's fault.
That's how we organize society.
This race between automation
and capital accumulation,
if we automate very quickly
and we displace what the humans can do,
but we haven't actually
accumulated the machines,
the economy does not grow very much,
but the labor already can become
devalued and displaced.
Now in the age of generative AI,
we need the server farms
to operate the language models.
In earlier times,
we needed the excavators
to automate creating new buildings.
If we don't have that capital,
then the benefits from automation
don't really materialize.
If we develop the technology
to build excavators,
we actually just use a hundred of them
all around the world.
You won't really see
a macroeconomic productivity impact.
You need millions of excavators
working all around the world
for human labor to benefit
from producing the remaining tasks.
This is maybe a bit utopian now,
but if we manage to share
the benefits of these machines,
then we would actually be all better off.
Working will be optional.
You'll have robots plus AI
and we'll have universal high income,
not just universal basic income,
universal high income,
meaning anyone can have
any products or services that they want.
If we live in a utopian world
where we manage to share
the gains from technological progress,
every human's consumption
is going to go up
and then human GDP
would also grow much more significantly.
If AI automates things really quickly,
wages will face a lot of downward pressure.
We either have lots of workers
with really low wages.
In the worst case,
those wages are too low for me to survive.
If the machine can cut and sew shirts
at a cost of $10,
you would earn only $10
for the same shirt.
Two years later,
you'll get only $5, $2.50.
When it comes to writing an essay,
it would take a human two hours.
It takes a system like GPT for 20 seconds,
less than a dollar.
For a human, more than 50 bucks probably.
Well, all right.
From now on, I will write my essays
and I'll earn only 50 cents.
By the way, next year,
it will be 12 cents
and you get the idea.
Right now, there are lots of tasks
that machines could in principle perform,
but they are just too expensive
and that's why they're done by humans.
Let's take doctors.
AI performs a lot of the tasks
that human doctors perform,
but some humans are still gonna say,
well, but I wanna see the human doctor.
If the AI just becomes
really significantly better,
more and more humans are gonna say,
well, but my life is on the line.
I'll just go with the best system available.
There's also gonna be cost pressures.
Machine doctor is equally good,
but costs just a 10th of the human doctor.
The humanoid robots would be 10x better
than the best surgeon on earth.
So we wouldn't even need surgeons
doing operations.
You wouldn't want a surgeon
to do an operation.
The lump of labor fallacy,
there is a fixed amount of labor
and if we automate one chunk of it,
the jobs in that chunk will be missing
and the reason why it's false
is of course because our economies
are highly adaptable systems
and we automate something.
If there is still something
that only humans can do,
then humans will switch into that.
If AI comes closer and closer to AGI,
there may just be nothing to switch into.
So there's the good and the bad
if that were to really happen.
The greatest bottleneck
in our economy right now,
which is the availability of labor,
would suddenly be lifted
and our economies could just
grow significantly faster.
UBI could fix the problem, so to say.
It would still be politically
very difficult to implement.
We would be speaking about
very large-scale transfers.
We have never done something
as ambitious as UBI,
given our current political environment.
I'm worried that we may not
be able to pull it off,
but of course the alternative
is even worse.
When it comes to the meaning challenge,
UBI would not address it in any way.
Would it still give people meaning
if it were to work,
but they know that a machine
can do the same work
much cheaper, much faster,
and much better?
If I put myself in that situation
and I know a machine
can write much better economics papers,
devise better lectures,
can teach better than I,
would I still want to do that?
Honestly, my gut reaction is no,
I would not.
There is a very high likelihood
this is all coming at us.
It is coming sooner
than most people realize.
So what is our best bet?
Our best bet is that
there will be a transition
that takes some time
that gives us a little bit of a runway
to devise solutions.
I propose something
that I call a seed UBI.
Introduce a small UBI
as soon as possible.
It could be 10 bucks a month
just to have the system operating
because it will take significant time
to set up the infrastructure.
We have never done something like that
at the national level.
It can be really small
as long as we don't see major disruption.
If significant parts of the economy
get disrupted,
the UBI should automatically ramp up.
So to pay out a UBI,
we would need our economy to grow.
The growth takeoff
would always come hand in hand
with the labor displacement.
We only need to compensate workers
in scenarios where growth
would also be significantly higher.
That would make it affordable.
If you lose your job,
you get another equivalent one,
which is likely in these HEI scenarios
because let's say
if it automates all cognitive labor
and you used to be a cognitive worker,
then everybody at the same time
is going to look for something.
Then the unemployment insurance
replaces a fraction of your income
for a limited amount of time.
That limited amount of time
traditionally was meant to allow you
to look for something new
to potentially reskill a little bit.
That will be very useful.
However, if one of these HEI scenarios
materializes,
that limited amount of time
is going to be over at some point.
Government funded retraining programs
had a success rate
of between zero and 15 percent.
People legitimately talk about
retraining coal miners
to be software engineers.
It makes no sense.
The reason why we're stretching for that
is because we're looking for
some kind of retraining-oriented solution
when the numbers show that
that's just not going to be the recipe.
A lot of the inequality
that we currently experience
in our world
would suddenly have to dissipate.
Let's say you are
a highly paid software engineer.
If you are in the right area,
you can easily bring in
half a million
or a million a year these days.
Once that's over,
there is really no ethical reason
to pay that software engineer
significantly more
than, let's say,
a taxi driver
who gets displaced from their job.
We will have to accept
that there's going to be
a lot of revelation.
We will have to accept
that we're all going to be equally useless.
If we want those AIs to be aligned,
part of that alignment
is to take care of
the basic material needs of humans
and we want those humans
to live well.
The markets in which
these companies are operating
are becoming more and more concentrated.
What is market structure?
Market structure basically
looks at how many players
there are in a given market
and how much competition
there is between the players.
And I should say,
it's not only the market structure
for the AI systems themselves,
but also the market structure
for compute,
for chip production.
And that's really where we see
the biggest monopolies right now.
Economies of scale
means that as you produce more,
your unit cost of production goes down.
In the context of AI,
we face these mass training costs.
And then the more
you operate the AI systems,
the more inference you engage in,
the more you can amortize
that massive training cost
over a larger number
of output tokens.
People are estimating
that the cutting edge systems
are soon going in the range
of billions of dollars.
Only very few players
will be able to afford to participate.
Those players therefore
have some market power
which allows them to charge more.
Vertical integration is
if you have a company
that performs multiple steps
of a production process in-house.
Right now the way
the AI value chain looks is
you have companies like ESML
in the Netherlands
that produce the machines
to create chips.
Then you have TSMC in Taiwan
that actually produces the chips
based on specifications from NVIDIA,
which is really good at chip design.
And then you have OpenAI
or Anthropic that buy the chips.
If you have integration,
then you don't have multiple steps
of the production process
that each charge you
their own profit margin.
You have one player that decides
what is the best profit margin
overall to charge.
The main downside is
you'll have less competition
in such a market.
Imagine NVIDIA owned OpenAI.
So you would have much less competition
in such a market.
And as a result of that,
all the benefits from competition
would be much lower.
We don't want monopolists
because they will charge
excessive prices
and they tend to slow down innovation.
From the perspective of companies,
being a monopolist is wonderful
because you can charge incredible margins
that you could otherwise never charge.
The income statement of companies
like NVIDIA,
more than half of every dollar in revenue
that you make goes straight into profits.
It's deemed that the competition
is really quite fierce.
All the top players are in a race
to gobble up market share.
The market is very competitive right now.
One of the risks in the market
for large language models,
people become locked into a player.
Then that player would suddenly
have much greater market power
and would have the ability
to raise prices significantly.
In some ways,
these systems have a tendency
towards natural monopoly.
They are so expensive,
it is not actually desirable
for us as a society
to train 100 competing foundation models
at a cost of a billion dollars each
because that would be
a needless duplication of effort.
Given this kind of cost structure
with very high fixed costs,
it is actually socially desirable
to have a relatively small number of players.
Having said that,
we usually still want some competition.
It's probably most desirable
to have a small number of players,
but more than one
that compete with each other
without duplicating efforts too much.
Where regulators and competition authorities
I think should pay close attention
is this issue of vertical integration.
If you are vertically integrated,
it becomes much, much harder
for consumers to switch
or for businesses to switch.
That means they have more lock-in,
they have more pricing power.
We don't want a small number of tech companies
to gobble up all the startups.
Let's take the example of an AI assistant
that can read your calendar,
give you advice or write emails for you.
If startups have the ability
to integrate with your calendar
and with your email in the same way
as big corporations have
with their proprietary system,
then this danger of vertical integration
and of its anti-competitive effects
would be much mitigated.
Throughout our history,
whenever there are
some very large corporations,
they can bend the rules in their favor.
In the case of AI,
the risk of power concentration
is much more significant
than with any other technology
because our intelligence
is what made humanity
the most successful species on the planet.
If we develop AI systems
more intelligent than us humans,
the power they embody
will also be greater
than the power of humanity.
This is why AI alignment
is such an important question.
Once we come close to HAI,
the best utopian answer
to such a situation
that would probably be
to have an AI
that is created
not by competing companies,
but that is an all-in
kind of moonshot effort
that is advanced
by either the leading nation-state
in this area,
or ideally a group of nation-states
in a similar way to,
for example, CERN.
Create AI systems
that we all collectively invest in
such that we can experience
a level of flourishing
that is perhaps unimaginable
looking at the current world.
I'm very optimistic about the future.
I think we're headed for a future
of amazing abundance.
We are in the most interesting time in history.
