The Big Hangover (1950) is a lighthearted comedy starring Van Johnson as a young lawyer whose promising future is threatened by an unexpected weakness: alcohol. What begins as a series of humorous mishaps gradually becomes a story about personal responsibility, self-discipline, and the challenge of living up to one’s potential.
Balancing comedy with sincerity, the film explores the universal struggle between temptation and character. Rather than focusing solely on laughs, The Big Hangover reminds audiences that maturity often comes through learning from our mistakes—and finding the strength to overcome them.
And I will verge with thine,
This within the cup
And I'll not ask for wine.
The thirst that filled the soul doth rise,
Doth ask a drink divine.
But might I of Jove's nectar supply,
I would not change for thine.
I sent thee late a lousy wreath,
Not so much honoring thee
As giving it a hope that there it could be.
But now the handed stone may breathe
And send it back to me.
Since when it grows and smells,
I swear not of itself but thee.
Mother, I'm having a friend over this afternoon.
His name is David Mulden.
Well, who is he?
He's this year's honor student at the law school.
Are you interested?
I don't know. I only met him yesterday.
Well, what's the matter with him?
Why do you say that?
There's always something the matter with him.
I haven't forgotten that string of misfits
you brought back from the psychoanalyst's office.
It's just that I'm maternal.
You know, I was that way even as a child with my pets.
He'll probably marry some weakling so you can mother him.
I won't.
Well, why are you interested in your father's latest law partner?
He's had an emotional experience with liquor,
and I'm curing him.
Oh, for heaven's sake.
You used to bring back sick cats and dogs.
Surely you're not going to start on alcoholic young men.
He's not an alcoholic young man.
He's just a shell-shocked soldier
whose subconscious won't let him forget a near-death experience.
That's the big hangover.
I'm Tiffany Brannon.
I'm Rebecca Brannon.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
In today's world, terms such as PTSD, trauma, and anxiety,
when associated with traumatic memories,
are thrown around far too loosely.
That's a good point.
And because of this,
that tends to invalidate the real application
to people who've actually experienced trauma.
There are a lot of very dramatic classic films
about shell-shocked soldiers coping after World War II.
One surprisingly light film about this topic
is a romantic comedy with unexpectedly deep themes.
This film is The Big Hangover from 1950.
The honor student at a law school
is accepted as the newest member of a prominent New York law firm.
The beautiful daughter of the main law partner
soon discovers that this handsome young veteran
has a strange quirk left over from World War II.
Because he almost drowned in a cellar full of brandy,
anytime he tastes or even smells alcohol,
he imagines that he's drunk.
Thus, it's very difficult for him to be in social settings.
The intelligent young lady makes it her project
to cure him of this big hangover,
and along the way, they find themselves
beginning to have romantic feelings for each other.
Meanwhile, David quickly begins to realize
that he is a little too principled for this law firm
as he meets the People's Representative
who is supporting a Chinese doctor and his wife
who have been unfairly evicted from their apartment because of racism.
This film was made by MGM.
It was written, directed, and produced by Norman Krasna
and stars Van Johnson, Elizabeth Taylor,
Leon Ames, and Rosemary DeCamp.
I think this movie really is made by Van Johnson.
Absolutely.
It's a relatively short film,
but it really is all about his experiences,
both as a veteran and as this up-and-coming lawyer.
I think what is fascinating about it
is that you can't really describe it with just one topic
because there are two very distinct issues
really being addressed in the film
which are not entirely connected to each other.
No.
The principle of this controversy about this Chinese doctor
and so his journey to realizing what the law means to him
and what he wants to be as a lawyer
and then also, it's almost a subplot,
this condition that he has from his war experience.
It's just so unusual and, undeniably,
he says it's a comic ailment so you don't get much sympathy.
That makes it a difficult thing.
It's not like he says soldiers who've been in explosions
will get frightened when someone strikes a match.
It's not something that people can understand as easily,
so it's harder for them to sympathize with him.
And because it is a comic ailment,
the treatment of that is rather funny
and that makes the film lighter.
That gives us the comic aspect
whereas his relationship with the boss's daughter,
played by Elizabeth Taylor, gives it the romantic element.
Now, at this point, 1950, Van Johnson was 33
and he was a very popular actor
and he'd really become a leading man
during the World War II years because he was unable to serve.
That's right.
So he gained quite an impressive leading man status
which just continued in the post-World War II days.
He really had that boy-next-door quality,
that average American fellow kind of look,
so he was very believable in likable,
sensitive, principled characters like this.
Of course, the other main star in the film is Elizabeth Taylor
who, believe it or not, was only 17 when this was made,
which you would not guess from how she looks.
She had such a maturity about her.
And she definitely is supposed to be in her early 20s
because it almost seems like she's gone to college
and maybe even worked at a psychoanalyst's office.
So she's believable as a much older young woman than she actually was.
Now, although she was so young,
Elizabeth had quite a bit of experience as a movie actress by this point.
She began as a child star with movies like one of the Lassie films
and National Velvet when she was a young teenager.
And then, in sort of her transition period,
she'd made movies like A Date with Judy
where you're really not sure how old she is.
She seems like she's an older student,
so she's like maybe 17 or 18.
She was 16 at the time, possibly even 19.
And this was her second fully adult role,
having before that made one British film.
And it sort of was a test to see how she would fare
alongside a very experienced, mature and popular actor like Ben Johnson.
Right.
And I think that they have a really believable and interesting rapport.
Yes.
They're probably better known from co-starring in The Last Time I Saw Paris.
That's right. That's a very acclaimed film.
Several years later. Well, four years later.
But here, this is a very underappreciated and little-known film,
which didn't make a whole lot of money at the time.
It didn't lose money, but they just sort of broke even.
I think maybe it could have struggled to find an audience in a way.
Yeah, because like you were saying, it's sort of between genres.
Yes.
You kind of go into it not sure what to expect,
or maybe you just expect,
oh, this seems like it's going to be kind of a funny romantic comedy.
And then it actually has parts that are quite heavier,
not necessarily heavy, but just very, they really make you think.
It becomes sort of a think piece in the latter half of the film.
Yes.
And the main think piece element of it involves
David trying to find where he belongs in the world,
dealing with a little bit of survivor's guilt,
as well as this PTSD.
You find out more about this background from him
when he's reading his valedictorian speech to Mary.
And in it, he describes how he had this best friend in the service,
a very principled, mature young man, Nicky,
who ended up being killed,
but he had this great aspiration to be a lawyer,
which had been instilled in him by his father for years,
and that this idea was so much more than just making a living,
but to really protect the freedoms,
which are the whole belief system of America.
Yes.
And how those law books are the only thing
which are keeping the ideals of the United States intact
and keeping civilization from falling into total anarchy.
And that, in fact, that is what he fought and died for.
So even though he wasn't able to become a lawyer,
he was fighting for those principles and for those laws.
And it's a touching moment when he's reading,
as part of his speech, a letter,
an unfinished letter from Nicky to his father,
where he says,
I think you preach the law the way some men preach the gospel.
And you just see this passion that his father had for it
and then passed on to him,
and how David sort of took that up for him.
Yes, he had no aspirations of the law.
You kind of get the idea he didn't really have
any particular goal or aspiration.
His parents seemed to be dead,
but he lives with his aunt and uncle,
so we can assume he was orphaned.
And he has some goals now in life.
He decided to go to law school with the GI Bill of Rights,
and he just ended up being a brilliant lawyer.
He's number one in his class,
so obviously he's really smart.
But he's also driven.
He's driven by the idea that he's not doing it for himself,
he's doing it for Nicky.
And he believes that he isn't even the one who should be there.
It should be Nicky, not himself.
So there's definitely a little bit of survivor's guilt there.
But then, very soon in his law career,
he hasn't even graduated yet.
Right.
But he's been accepted as the newest member of the law firm.
He encounters the moral dilemmas which lawyers must face,
and he realizes it's not all the preservation of freedom
and the ethical, noble ideas,
such as he's been learning in law school,
as he realizes that this high-profile, high-power law firm
oftentimes is more interested in protecting their clients,
these wealthy business owners,
even if it kind of hurts the average person.
It shows sort of a naivety, in a way,
that he has these very definite convictions,
and he's just looking at the laws there
to protect everyone's rights.
And then he assumes these men,
these are all really respectable men,
and they have very high ideals, too,
that he just naturally assumes they would agree with him,
and then to find out they're actually kind of involved
in this whole shady transaction.
Because they're so smart,
they know how to use and manipulate the law
to serve their own purposes or their clients.
And the whole issue centers around this Chinese doctor,
Dr. Li, and his wife,
who are forcibly removed from their apartment
just by having the locks changed,
even though they had paid six months' rent in advance,
because basically these developers
don't want Chinese people in their shiny new complex.
And Leon Ames, as the public defender,
is trying to protect Dr. Li's rights.
But the wealthy law firm represents that building company.
So David sees this kind of lying and dealing
that goes on between the law firm
and this public defender,
who they act like he's their friend,
but they're really trying to outsmart him.
And they can, because they're all
much better lawyers.
Yes, they were valedictorians,
graduated at the top of their class.
And they actually quietly move in another tenant,
so that, well, he has a lease as well.
So how are you going to argue,
what has he done to be evicted?
So it'll just kind of end quietly.
And through this whole situation,
David begins to realize one reason why
sometimes the people aren't fairly represented
is that the best lawyers become high-paid attorneys
in these great law firms,
whereas the men from the bottom of the class
become the public defenders.
They're the ones representing the people
because there's not much money in that job.
And his eyes are really opened when he hears that
and he realizes that sometimes the difference
between honor, integrity, and justice,
and injustice, is that one person,
one lawyer, maybe one person will become a judge,
he's willing to have less comforts in his own life
so he can do something really to help the people
and to make the law be practiced fairly.
And I think what makes it so real
and so impacting in this film
is that it doesn't turn into a sort of fairytale
kind of he's the white knight
and comes and changes this law firm.
He's not going to change these people,
but he makes his own decision that
he, being the best in his class,
could actually be a great public defender.
So he accepts a job in the public defender's office
because he sees there's no way
that the people can have justice
if you have the man who was seventh from the bottom
of his class going up against the valedictorian.
One thing that's very noteworthy
and I think would surprise a lot of people in this movie
is the very honest and open exploration
of racial prejudice.
Yes.
Because a lot of people think
there was just so much racism in old Hollywood
and the movies just want to show
a whitewashed version of the world,
that this movie shows a very intelligent,
educated, dignified Chinese man
who's a Chinese American
and it reveals just how much prejudice there was.
This was not long after the ban
was actually overturned on immigration from China
shortly after World War II.
So it had only been a few years
that Chinese people were even being allowed
back into the country.
Of course, there were people who lived in America
who were of Chinese descent,
which is Dr. Lee's situation.
And David is completely unprejudiced,
as is the public defender,
but he's appalled to see the kind of prejudice
which people in a modern American society
would have against their fellow Americans.
Right.
And it's best exemplified in a scene
when he's arguing with the superintendent
and this man very insultingly
refers to Dr. Lee as a Chinaman.
And he says...
Have you heard from Mr. Park for today?
You mean about the Chinaman?
A Chinaman is a man born in China.
Dr. Lee is an American of Chinese extraction,
which puts him on equal footing with you and me,
unless one of your ancestors was called Pocahontas,
which I doubt.
What about the apartment?
So he really reminds this man and the audience
that we shouldn't look on these people
who have come either themselves or their ancestors
who've legally immigrated to the United States
and consider ourselves better than them
just because our ancestors immigrated
from a different country or came longer ago.
Right.
Because, as he very rightly points out,
Native Americans are the only true Americans.
We're all immigrants.
We are a country of immigrants.
That's what our country is based on.
Exactly.
Maybe that's why this movie didn't do as well.
Maybe its honest look at racism
was a little upsetting to it.
If you're saying people feel convicted.
And there might have even been some censors
in some areas.
Or they just didn't like
what a sympathetic depiction it was
if there was that much of a racial prejudice in place.
And it definitely wasn't as region-specific
as Prejudice Against Black People
because that was very much centered in the South.
But I think that there were people
who maybe would feel a little called out by that.
But I love the fact that MGM
and Hollywood in general
made a movie like this
showing an immigrant fighting for his rights
in a very calm, peaceful manner.
Especially in a film of this type
because you don't go into it
expecting to hear that strong of a social message.
Yeah.
Whenever looking at movies from this era
and there is some kind of a discussion about
racial topics
there always seems to be some mention
of the Hays Code.
Which usually is misspelled.
It really annoys me.
People often spell it H-A-Y-E-S.
Oh, you're right.
But it's H-A-Y-S.
And the name Hays Code is inaccurate altogether
because it's referring to
Will H. Hays
who was called the Czar of Hollywood
and he was the president
of the Motion Picture Producers and Distributors of America
from its founding in 1922
to his retirement in 1945.
But he didn't write the code
although he kind of let it be believed that he did.
And nor did he enforce it.
He was merely the political figurehead.
He lived in Washington.
What do you think was his reason for...
His reason was that it was actually written by
Father Daniel A. Lord, a Catholic priest
and Martin Quigley, a Catholic layman
who was a newspaper man
and there was still enough Catholic prejudice
in the United States...
Speaking of prejudice!
Speaking of prejudice, yes.
That he didn't think that people would like that.
He was a Presbyterian.
And that Protestant background was more accepted in general.
So he thought that the Jewish filmmakers
and the Catholic writers
wouldn't all be better if they were just all Presbyterian.
So people would accept it more.
So he was all about public relations.
That was Will Hayes' life.
He was the past Master General under President Harding.
So he was a politician.
And he knew...
Not to say he wasn't a very morally upstanding man
of high moral character himself.
He was.
He just wasn't the man in the trenches.
Yeah.
That man, the man behind the curtain, if you will
was Joseph I. Breen, who headed the PCA
the Production Code Administration
from 1934 to 1954
which we consider the golden era of Hollywood.
So in the code, in the text of it
as was enforced, there was a clause about miscegenation
forbidding the depiction of romantic relationships
between people of mixed races on screen.
Now, this was not in the original text of the code.
That's one of the only parts that Will Hayes probably did right.
He or somebody else in his office.
Because besides making films morally acceptable
and decent for people of all ages
the other job of the code and the PCA
was to keep movies from being censored.
Right.
And that involved cultural issues
social issues, political issues
things that had nothing to do with morality
because according to the Christian morality
or the Judeo-Christian morality as they often called it
which was inspiring to Daniel Lord and Martin Quigley
there was nothing in the Catholic catechism at that time
against miscegenation from a racial standpoint.
And actually they were kind of upset that that was added.
Sure.
But the PCA, for the most part, enforced that.
There are exceptions.
Such as Pinky, 1949.
Two versions of Show Boat.
Although the characters were played by white actresses
the characters are black.
Or they pass as white, but there's a point where they're black.
What's the other one?
Imitation of Life? Or was that not actually made?
No, the 1934 one was a film.
1934 is the trickier because it could be late pre-code.
Because the code wasn't enforced until July of 1934.
But besides miscegenation, the code included in the original text
a long section on national feelings.
And there were many varying sets of offensive racial terms not to use.
One of them was Chinaman.
Now the great thing about the code and its enforcement
was that it wasn't a hard and fast set of laws engraved in stone.
It was enforced intelligently.
So Mr. Breen would have looked at this and said
well obviously it's being used here to make a point.
This man, some use of offensive terms by bad characters
or in settings as long as it's shown to not be right.
Just like you will see an evil character doing a lot of bad things
but if the main sympathetic protagonist did that
then that wouldn't be acceptable.
So a lot of times it's who's saying it or who's doing it.
So racial prejudice can be shown as long as it's shown to be wrong.
So the men of the PCA were sort of like lawyers.
They had to take this document and interpret it in a way that was usable.
So it wasn't just do this or we're going to throw the movie out.
They had to work with people.
And that's why I think the code in the PCA was very American.
Censorship was more like some other country, some communist country.
Which actually there's a lot of censorship in communist countries.
But the PCA was like the Constitution or like lawyers in a free society.
A place of representatives who would help the filmmakers
express themselves in a way that was safe and decent for everybody.
Right, because there were people in Hollywood
just like there are people who want to break the law.
There were people who just wanted to make things that were questionable
and maybe it was just because they thought it would make more money or whatever reason.
But there are some people you see,
it's like say in the pre-code years, like Cecil B. DeMille.
I don't think he's just setting out to make this movie be dirty.
He's very much about the art and maybe he's just not being tasteful enough.
So it's sort of like a parent will be there to kind of
help you see the right way to go about something.
So really just there to help them out.
So we want to preserve your message but not offend anyone.
And it's great to see how many different types of movies come out of that green era.
Movies like this which are light and funny at moments but also very intense and serious.
And this film is very representative not only of the morals of the era
but the style of this post-World War II era.
My outfit is inspired by a costume which Elizabeth Taylor wears
the first time she brings David over to her house to work on his condition.
It is a white tailored blouse as you very often see in 40s or 50s fashion.
A black pencil skirt with a little striped scarf at the neck.
And in the last scene she wears a hat very much like this.
My dress is based on the gown which Mary wears to the alumni ball.
It's white with mesh as well as lace detailing with a full tulle skirt.
She wears fancy pearl jewelry.
Although it's very much a product of its time
I think that this movie could be very enjoyable to people who aren't as familiar with classic films
because I think it will surprise them.
If you haven't seen a lot of old movies before or maybe you've seen a few
I think you'll be captivated by firstly a very young performance from an actress
you'll probably recognize, Elizabeth Taylor.
Cleopatra.
Yes.
Some real heartwarming moments, some tender romance, some very funny moments
some great dog scenes. People always love scenes with dogs.
And a surprisingly poignant theme about mistreatment of a Chinese person
and just the importance of being unafraid to stand up for what you know to be right
even if it makes you unpopular.
This movie can be found in many clear black and white copies
for rent or for purchase on streaming platforms such as Amazon Prime Video
Apple TV and Fandango at home.
It also is available to buy on DVD from Amazon, Walmart and Barnes & Noble.
In today's world of constant sequels, streaming series and reality TV shows
it seems like there are more franchises than individual films.
This was not true in classic Hollywood
but there were a few very popular and beloved film series.
One of them centered on a simple Midwestern family
and particularly the misadventures of its incorrigible youngest member.
Join us next time as we talk about our favorite installment in this wonderful series.
Thank you for watching. Goodbye.