CRITICAL MINERALS/GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAIN- Mr. Dave McMurtry

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
4 Video Views·Feb 26, 2026
27th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, D.C🇺🇸- December 4-5, 2024
-Mr. Dave McMurtry
CEO, The McMurtry Group, Investor and Advisor in the Lithium-Ion Battery
Supply Chain Industry
You said Robert, but I think you meant Dave.
I heard Robert's name and I wasn't listening to you.
No, I'm kidding.
I have to add, my role is always adding a small contribution to what Malo said.
I would even make that global footprint story even worse,
because yes, the extraction is controlled by China,
and yes, the processing is controlled by China,
and then when the batteries get to the end of life,
do you know what's happening to that black mass?
It's getting sold back to China.
Even though we have the capacity to do it in the United States,
and the reason for that is the Chinese will buy black mass
at prices that U.S. companies can't afford.
So that gets to your question, Jamil, of what can we do in this?
So the first thing we need to do, along with the tariffs that Malo is advocating for,
is we need to make the exportation of black mass illegal.
It needs to be considered a strategic asset.
Why are we giving this stuff away?
Not to mention the footprint, the carbon footprint,
of taking this incredibly heavy material and shipping it to the other side of the world
when we can process it here.
So the biggest challenge, and by the way, if you ever want to be miserable,
go be an officer in a publicly traded company in the United States.
That is a tough, tough job,
and the reason for it is because we have quarterly earnings reports that we have to meet.
We have to, as officers in these companies,
we have to respond to whatever somebody chooses to make public.
B, if we don't make profits, we don't get to keep our jobs.
And so this is what we have.
We have investors who are short-term minded and who are anxious,
and we are competing with AI and all sorts of other possible ways they could send their money.
So talk about a really difficult spot.
We are responsible, quite frankly, for the future of multiple industries.
The Chinese today, I think they're smart.
I don't think they're going to go to war over this.
They're not going to start a war.
Again, I'm a CEO.
You guys are the experts on warfare and governments and how these make decisions.
I think, what I worry about is how to run a business that's going to make money,
and what I think they're going to do is they're going to say,
you want a Chinese battery?
You can have it.
We're going to wrap it in a Chinese car or a Chinese laptop or a Chinese phone.
You can have as many batteries as you want.
So this isn't about the battery industry.
This is about every industry that uses batteries.
Including, by the way, national defense, right?
If you've got a modern soldier on a battlefield with his radio,
is he going to be lugging a car battery with him?
So Rear Admiral Mark, I'm putting you on the spot here.
We had a great conversation in the hallway.
I've spoken with others high up in DOD, and I'm not going to repeat them
because I don't know how confidential it was,
but the amount of reliance that we have on foreign-sourced batteries
to run the military is truly scary.
And we're increasing in a significant way both in the United States
and with our partners and allies abroad.
Boy, I don't know if those lessons learned were solely from the pandemic
or if they were just sort of co-located at the same time,
but half of my career was building technology companies,
sort of the internet companies, et cetera,
and the other half is in the renewable energy,
and the thing that I take away is how wonderful it was in the internet world
to not have to worry about transportation as a service.
And so the takeaway here is the value of co-location.
We should be, when possible, extracting and making batteries
and then recycling batteries in the same place
because of the impact on the P&L of transportation.
Now, the second piece is the importance of...
And the environmental impact.
And so one of the most important things I learned in...
I've been to probably every country represented here in the past two years,
even Papua New Guinea last month,
and one of the things I've learned is the importance of energy.
So in terms of...
I don't know if you've worked when you're Bain or BCG or McKinsey,
any of those guys will give you a site location service for about $1 million.
They'll assess your business and tell you where you should build something.
And what they'll tell you is what's different about the battery
and the supply chain industry is they will move the presence of energy
from being number 8 or 9 to be considered to be number 1.
It used to always be workforce, quality of the workforce, etc.
Now it's always where you have energy, that's where you should build.
So in terms of the pandemic and transportation challenges is
we need to, again, it's a 25-year problem,
extract so we can get about 10 million tons a year out of the ground,
start recycling, do it all in one place.
John, I like your colorful metaphor.
I'll share one back.
In fact, I'll even quote Captain Murphy yesterday when he said,
I'm not an economist, I'm just an MBA.
I'm also just an MBA.
By the way, do you know why you've never seen a one-armed economist?
Because they're constantly saying, on the other hand, right?
They're never making this...
So that's what's at play here.
I think, John, to answer your question,
I thought it was fascinating to watch the government the last four years,
the Department of Energy specifically, tried to be venture capitalists.
And how hard it was.
I come from Silicon Valley.
I'm a venture capitalist myself.
I know the model.
You make 100 bets and you know that 95 of them will fail.
And you go back to your limited partners and say,
95% failure.
But look, the other five were such big successes
that we're going to do another fund.
The government was unable to do that
because it's taxpayer money that they're investing.
You can't go to the taxpayer and say,
95% of your taxes were failure bets.
So what is the risk then of including industry?
I guess I would turn it around and say,
what is the risk of not including them?
Then you have people who are not in the business making these decisions.
So what I would like to see is,
if there is going to be a role in the next administration
continuing the BIL,
then I would like to have them change their risk profile
to the extent that that's possible,
maybe the first government ever to do it.
But we could actually look at China
and somehow they have figured out a way.
It's a different political system.
Let's call it up front.
I'll pass it to the expert over here.
It's a different political system.
They don't have to worry about running for a new job
every two, four, or six years.
Ever.
Or ever.
Right?
And so what is the risk of not including industry in a democracy?
And to add, it's the one piece we haven't discussed today.
The environmental side is actually the one competitive advantage
that the U.S. industry has right now over China
because what gets measured gets done.
China isn't held to any very many environmental thresholds
and as a result, they're not trying to be clean.
We are held to a higher threshold.
And so I'll give you an example.
Apem is one of the companies I'm advising.
They've figured out a really great way to cleanly recycle sodium sulfate,
which is a byproduct, a waste product of battery manufacturing,
and turn it back into its sodium sulfate, excuse me,
its acids and caustic sodas that you need to make batteries.
We are actually leading front on that.
China doesn't know how to do this.
They just dump it.
And so there's an opportunity here.
If we can get the rest of the world, right, rising tide rises all boats.
If we can get the world to take this environmental stuff seriously,
then we have a chance to actually beat China.
