CRITICAL MINERALS/GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAIN- Prof. Milos Ivkovic

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
5 Video Views·Feb 26, 2026
27th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, D.C🇺🇸- December 4-5, 2024
-Prof. Milos Ivkovic
MA, LLM, LLM - International Arbitrator/Advisor to Governments;
Washington University School of Law
The first matter that we need to address is actually to establish what our problem is,
or to be able to, through the analysis, share with our friends the solution.
Currently speaking, the supply chain is so distorted and so China-oriented
that it has become a national security issue in the United States and all Allied nations.
And this is by design.
Also, what we need to recognize is that almost all assets that China is currently using
had previously been developed by the United States and U.S. taxpayers.
So it is a self-inflicted wound in itself.
That said, certainly we can cooperate with our allies,
but we cannot start afresh and just tell them,
why wouldn't you jump in and start developing refineries in your territory,
start developing battery facilities in your territory?
That is not feasible at this stage.
We need to recognize that in many of these territories there is no infrastructure,
there is no access to energy required to power these facilities.
And the investments in the first place need to come from somewhere.
In almost all the regions affected by the supply chain abuse from China,
we talk about absence of critical assets on infrastructure.
And current financing almost solely comes from China.
All of these issues have to be resolved in Washington first,
and then we can speak with our allies.
We need to give them a chance to become a part of the supply chain,
and we need to respect their sovereignty because they sit on the minerals that we need.
So this is the first step.
The second step is we need to be incredibly aggressive towards the abuses that are taking place.
In my view, the list of sanctions currently on the record are laughable.
There is almost no criminal prosecution for violations of,
and we talk about mass scale violations of human rights in Chinese mines or Chinese ruled markets.
And if we don't start addressing criminally and prosecuting criminally the actors
and sanctioning those who are profiting on this supply chain,
we'll still leave that criminal incentive to bad actors.
So we need to clean up the market, have a playing field to play on,
incentivize our partners to work with us,
and we can only do that, again, if we respect them and give them a chance to become integral part.
But they also need to have understanding for us.
There is zero chance that such facilities can be built in one to three years
in any of the countries that call the ask,
because just the infrastructure needed in the first place is not there.
However, we can start working on it.
Well, let's be first very frank and honest.
Dumping pricing and then what's happening and coming from China is a tool to weaponize the trade,
to weaponize critical minerals against the United States.
I am 100% supportive of the upcoming administration's objectives when it comes to tariffs.
And I'll explain.
WTO is a dysfunctioning institution.
Procedures established in WTO don't function.
Nobody even pays attention to WTO anymore.
Any arbitral proceedings based on WTO rules are completely useless on enforcement level.
Period.
This is the world that we live in.
And if another abusive power is using pricing or dumping pricing
in order to effectively inflict harm on the United States and its allies,
we need to recognize this as an attack.
Period.
What can every sovereign country do?
Well, first and foremost, tariffs.
We have seen them in the European Union.
We have seen that the upcoming administration is going to work on the tariffs.
Secondly, what we can do is call what China is doing in real terms.
If there is an attack on U.S. sovereign interest, on U.S. companies and on U.S. citizens,
then it's an attack.
So we can use other means of economic warfare against China.
We can address their assets worldwide.
And it's not as if price dumping is the only problem that they are facing.
They are also facing 40,000 kids who work in their illegal mines in the Congo,
which is a crime against humanity that nobody is talking about because of our dependence.
And if we start prosecuting them, if we start taking away their illegal assets,
and if we start blocking their trade on other levels,
then they will suddenly start talking with us.
The level of price dumping is so high that no U.S. company at this stage can enter the market.
Period.
Because under U.S. federal law, any company, for-profit company,
holds responsibility back to its shareholders to achieve profit.
So you cannot enter into a market where you know that you will die without subsidies.
And what is homework here for the U.S. Congress is to draft bills
and finally allow for the federal government to help our companies be secured from price dumping.
It is very simple, actually, to do that because we can make an alternative market for ourselves.
If we completely exclude China based on these criminal enterprises that they have been built
from ability to sell in the Western world, in the free world,
then their price dumping is limited in itself.
The problem with that is quite technical, and that is we need more access to the minerals.
And at that point, their game is done.
