Silenced by Xi? The Secret Power Struggle Behind Liu Yazhou’s Disappearance

China Insider
192 followers
484 Video Views·Feb 24, 2026
Beneath the Chinese Communist Party's familiar anti-corruption facade,
the case of Liu Yazou stands out as an anomaly.
No official statement, no public verdict,
no media campaign meant to serve as a warning.
This silence suggests that it is not merely a criminal case,
but very likely a flashpoint in a strategic power struggle
between Liu Yazou and Xi Jinping within the military.
On one side is Xi Jinping, a man pursuing absolute power
and harboring ambitions to use force to unify Taiwan.
On the other is Liu Yazou, a full general and strategic thinker
who dared to lay bare the military's real limitations
and warn of the catastrophic cost of an unprepared war.
When the National Defense University was downgraded,
when Liu Yazou's ideas were branded poisonous weeds,
and when he effectively vanished from the public sphere,
the question ceased to be what crime he committed.
Instead, it became what did he say that Xi Jinping could not tolerate?
Let's explore this question in today's program.
Among the National Defense University leaders who later fell from power,
the case of Liu Yazou is arguably the most consequential and also the most secretive.
Born in 1952, Liu Yazou is the son-in-law of Li Xiannian,
a former president of the Chinese Communist regime.
Under the protection of revolutionary elite family networks,
he was promoted to major general in the Air Force in June 1996.
In 2002, Liu was selected by Jiang Zemin to attend the National Defense University's
senior training program for officers at the core level and above.
Known within the PLA as the Dragon Class,
the program admitted only a handful of top candidates.
Liu was one of just three Air Force generals chosen.
He was promoted to lieutenant general in 2003 and to full general in July 2012.
However, in early 2017, before reaching the customary retirement age of 65,
Liu stepped down early from his post as political commissar of the National Defense University.
Contrary to convention, he was not subsequently assigned any position
in the National People's Congress or the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference.
Reports emerged in late 2021 that Liu was under investigation.
In March 2023, Hong Kong's Ming Pao reported that he was suspected of using foundations
and associations as fronts to amass enormous wealth, amounting to serious corruption.
His wife Li Shaolin, the daughter of Li Xiannian, was said to be safe and unaffected.
In March 2024, rumors circulated that Liu Yazhou had been sentenced to life imprisonment.
Yet unlike the highly publicized cases of Fang Fenghui and Zhang Yang, who died by suicide,
or the recent open purges of Xi Jinping's close associates such as Heiwei Dong and Miao Hua,
the Liu Yazhou case has to this day been accompanied by no official information whatsoever.
A Controversial Figure
The Chinese Communist Party's National Defense University was established in January 1986
through the merger of the Military Academy, the Logistics Academy, and the Political Academy.
It is responsible for training senior command officers for the Army, Navy, and Air Force,
as well as for research on strategy and defense modernization,
and is widely regarded as the military's highest academic institution.
Following Xi Jinping's military reforms, the university was restructured in July 2017,
incorporating the former National Defense University along with the Nanjing and Xi'an
Political Academies, the Academy of Arts, the Logistics Academy, the Shijiazhuang Army Command
Academy, the Armed Police Political Academy, and parts of the Equipment Academy.
Three military academies report directly to the Central Military Commission,
the National Defense University, the Academy of Military Sciences,
and the National University of Defense Technology.
Before the reforms, the first two were ranked at the military region level,
while the latter was one rank lower. After the reforms, all three were downgraded by one level.
Notably, the restructuring and downgrading of the National Defense University
coincided with Liu Yazhou's quiet departure from the military.
Among the university's leaders, Liu Yazhou served the longest,
holding the post of political commissar for seven years.
The university has long been a pipeline for mid- and senior-level military talent,
and many of today's top commanders are alumni. Some were Liu's students or former subordinates.
Known for his flamboyant personality, Liu's tenure also marked what many described as
the university's golden age. During this period, Liu frequently delivered internal
speeches on military anti-corruption, reform, and political loyalty. Videos and transcripts
circulated widely. In a Teacher's Day speech on September 8, 2016, he mentioned a young
instructor who died from overwork, and in other recorded talks, he was seen choking back tears.
On July 6, 2016, at a seminar studying Xi Jinping's July 1st speech, Liu recounted remarks
allegedly made by former Central Military Commission Vice Chairman Xu Kaihu before his
death. That Guo Boxiang's problems were more serious than his own, and that among full
generals at the military region level, only two had not given him money, Liu Yuan and Liu
Yezhou. Liu notably spoke of giving bribes, not taking bribes, and did not claim personal
innocence. His remarks also implicitly suggested that current CMC Vice Chairman Zhang Yuxia had
once given money to Xu. For years, Liu was embroiled in ideological controversy and
targeted by mainland China's left wing. After his downfall in 2023, the leftist website
Red Culture published repeated attacks accusing him of promoting universal values such as human
rights, democracy, and freedom, branding him an ambitious and conspiratorial figure. Liu did
display liberal leanings. In a 2010 interview, he said that a transition from authoritarian
to democratic politics within 10 years was inevitable, and that any system denying citizens
freedom and suppressing creativity was doomed to collapse. However, after Xi Jinping came to
power, Liu appeared to pivot, throwing his support behind the anti-American film Silent
Contest as a gesture of political loyalty. Released in 2013, the film claimed the United
States was infiltrating China on multiple fronts to overthrow its system. It was praised by
nationalists and the left, criticized by others as Cold War-era thinking, and later banned for
unclear reasons. After Liu's downfall, even amid anti-U.S. political needs, authorities have shown
no interest in reviving the film. Liu Yazhou's works labeled poisonous weeds in the military.
Although Liu Yazhou has been imprisoned, he has not been formally expelled from the Communist Party
or stripped of his military status. This does not so much suggest that Xi Jinping was showing
deference to the entrenched networks of revolutionary elite families. Rather, it more
likely reflects Xi's lingering apprehension and fear of backlash within the military, prompting
him to avoid handling the case openly. It is precisely this unusual restraint that has made
the Liu Yazhou case one of the most bizarre major cases in the history of the Chinese Communist
regime. What makes the Liu Yazhou case so exceptional may lie in the fact that he displeased Xi Jinping
during strategic discussions over the use of force against Taiwan. The scholar Yuan Hongbing,
now living in exile in Australia, has pointed out that Liu Yazhou believed Xi Jinping lacked the
capacity to command a war in the Taiwan Strait, and that it was precisely this assessment that
led to Liu's political purge. Yuan stated bluntly, Xi Jinping does not possess the talent of a supreme
commander. After joining the military, Liu Yazhou rose to prominence through his military novels
and frequent appearances as a strategic thinker. He was the author of the nine-volume collected
works of Liu Yazhou. His essay A Review of the Kinmen Campaign, often referred to as The Battle
of Kinmen, largely completed around 2001, laid bare the entire course of the People's Liberation
Army's failed assault on Kinmen in October 1949. The work reflected critically on the causes and
lessons of that defeat, emphasizing the principle of never fighting a war without adequate preparation.
Even after being abridged and edited, the essay circulated widely within the military for nearly
a decade before Xi Jinping came to power, causing a major stir. In A Review of the Kinmen Campaign,
Liu warned, if we engage Taiwan militarily in the future, we must be prepared to deal with the
sudden intervention of a third force. He added, that third force could be Japan, but it would
mainly be the United States. Today, as Japan's new prime minister, Sanae Takaichi, continues
Shinzo Abe's assertion that a Taiwan contingency is a Japan contingency, the Chinese communist
authorities have reacted sharply time and again, developments that in some measure validate Liu
Yazhou's earlier prediction. In the same work, Liu further stated, I can say with certainty
that once a war breaks out in the Taiwan Strait, the United States will definitely enter the
conflict. He went on to predict what he called the U.S. military's third option. The United States
would allow China to complete a landing with more than 200,000 troops, then intervene suddenly to
seize control of the air and sea, impose a blockade on the Taiwan Strait, and coordinate
with Taiwan's forces to encircle and annihilate Chinese troops that have been cut off from
ammunition and supplies. This option would deal China an enormous political blow, and to a
considerable extent, shake and destroy the fighting will of the remaining Chinese forces on the mainland.
In the author's view, Liu Yazhou was not opposed to the use of force against Taiwan per se.
However, in the eyes of the Maoist left in mainland China, such statements were seen as boosting the
enemy's morale. Xi Jinping, who harbors ambitions to use force against Taiwan at any cost, was
therefore very likely deeply displeased. In his essay China's Grand Strategy for the Next 20 Years,
Liu Yazhou proposed that resolving the Taiwan issue required winning the hearts and minds
of the Taiwanese people, advancing political reform on the mainland, addressing governance
problems in Hong Kong, and pursuing the integration rather than conquest of Taiwan.
He introduced concepts such as one country, two systems of governance, and divided but not
separated, united but not absorbed. These ideas were, of course, not what Xi Jinping wanted to see,
hence why, in recent years, Hong Kong has been transformed by the Chinese Communist Party into
one country, one system. Reports have indicated that in late February 2023, the military issued
a notice requiring the elimination, by March, of harmful information related to Liu Yazhou,
including books, newspapers, magazines, articles, handwritten materials, and speeches associated
with him. On December 7th of this year, the author searched for keywords such as Liu Yazhou,
collected works of Liu Yazhou, and Liu's requiem of the Jiazi year on platforms including Dangdang,
Kongfs, Confucius-used books, and Xinhua Bookstore, but found no results. Liu Yazhou's
manuscripts and writings had exerted a profound influence on the middle-aged and younger generations
within the People's Liberation Army. An observer close to Beijing's political circles revealed that
a review of the Kinmen Campaign was once labeled by Xi as poisonous weeds, and that Liu Yazhou
himself was accused of bewitching minds and undermining military morale. After Liu Yazhou's
downfall, open discussion of military strength and national power became a taboo subject.
Liu Yazhou's warnings may be coming true. Part of the lasting value of a review of the Kinmen
Campaign lies in how it exposes uncomfortable truths. During the Kinmen Battle, more than 4,000
PLA soldiers were captured. In 1952, Taiwan repatriated about 3,000 of them to the mainland
by fishing boats. All were expelled from the party and the military and sent back to farm.
Some were labeled traitors and sentenced. During the Cultural Revolution, every one of them was
publicly denounced, farmers included. As they later said themselves,
three days of bitter fighting, 30 years of suffering. After 1983, policy rehabilitation
amounted to little more than modest financial compensation and nominal restoration of party
and military status upon demobilization. Many had already died from hunger, illness, persecution,
or old age. The survivors were all in their 70s, hair completely gray, their lives effectively
destroyed. One example was Chen Jiwen, an assistant instructor in an assault unit. Captured
but unbroken, he organized resistance in a POW camp, yet upon return was branded a traitor. Only
in 1983 was his party membership restored after a retrial. After more than 30 years of injustice,
he died suddenly of a heart attack from emotional shock. Villagers mourned, saying,
Old Chen suffered every hardship and bore every accusation,
yet never enjoyed a single blessing. Such a cruel fate. These facts lay bare the Chinese
Communist regime's brutality and utter disregard for human dignity. Simply allowing soldiers to
know this history would be enough to shatter military morale. Today, Chinese veterans face
severe difficulties defending their rights. As noted earlier, the treatment of demobilized
reflects the status of those still in uniform. Even when the families of active-duty soldiers
suffer injustice at home, seeking redress is extraordinarily difficult. This is a systemic
problem. In recent years, the PLA has flaunted its power in the East China Sea, the Yellow Sea,
and the Taiwan Strait, projecting arrogance and overconfidence. Yet through the Kinmen campaign,
Liu Yazhou directly identified the CCP's chronic flaw, underestimating the enemy. In a review of
the Kinmen campaign, he issued what many see as stark warnings to China's top leadership.
Today's Taiwanese military is no longer Chiang Kai-shek's army, and Taiwan is no longer Kinmen.
Add to that the natural barriers. Warfare in the Taiwan Strait would be 10,000 times more
difficult than at Kinmen. It is not Taiwan alone defending Taiwan, but the entire West.
Civilian boats are unreliable. Popular sentiment cannot be exploited. History teaches us that when
the overall direction is wrong, even callous, brave, and loyal warriors will only spill blood
in vain, left to look up at heaven in sorrow. Over the past two years, a series of generals
personally promoted by Xi Jinping have fallen in succession, showing that corruption in the
PLA has by no means been eradicated. Resentment among lower-ranking troops is intense, morale is
unstable, and if war were to break out, mutiny could erupt at any time. Combined with China's
economic downturn and rising social tensions, Liu Yazhou's warnings may well prove prophetic.
As for Taiwan, even with Western support, it should remember that heaven helps those who
help themselves. From another angle, Liu Yazhou's old writings may still be worth revisiting in Taipei.
What do you think about Liu Yazhou? Leave your thoughts in the comments below.
Thank you, and see you next time.
