The visual trick that Dutch painters perfected- Art History Explained

Artifact Archives
9 followers
3 Video Views·Feb 25, 2026
Take a moment to consider this painting by the Dutch artist Samuel van Hoogstraat.
We find ourselves looking through three successive doorways, with the first marked by
the narrow edge of a door with an iron latch cast in shadow. Beyond, a sequence of rooms unfolds,
each one distinguished by the claved floor tiles. Now observe that a broom and a towel have been
left beside the second of these doorways. Then, at the threshold of the third, a pair of slippers
lie on a straw mat, clearly just kicked off. As with many Dutch paintings of the 17th century,
this image may seem at first to lack drama, but by directing the viewer's sight through a series
of visual cues, the layers build and the plot thickens. Let us suppose, judging by the utilitarian
influence left unattended, the house's maidservant has just finished her errands, or hastily abandoned
them. She has entered the room that is normally locked, note the set of keys hanging from the door,
painted in crisp silhouette. She ignores the bent over candle in its holder, and instead pauses by
the painting on the far wall. This painting within the painting becomes another room for us to enter,
taking us further into the scene. It shows a female figure in a satin dress, standing beside
a red canopy bed. With her is a messenger boy holding his hat in his hand. Though the woman
has her back turned, it is likely she has received a letter, a popular motif in 17th century Dutch art,
to heighten the intrigue. The letter is usually a romantic one, thereby prompting speculation
on the part of the viewer as to its sender and the contents. What exactly is going on out of sight
is open to question, but if our speculations are at all correct, then the maid is inside the room
right now, and since her discarded slippers lie scattered and unattended, we may surmise that
normal decorum has been breached, and in the language of 17th century iconography, this might
be read as a metaphor for sexual impropriety. Much of the Paul van Hoogstraten's ambiguous painting
comes from the telescoping series of rooms we are allowed to peer through. Spaces are revealed
and concealed simultaneously, encouraging us to imagine what lies just out of sight.
So popular was this technique in Dutch art at the time, that it acquired a name,
roughly translated as view through. Dorkijkia was a way for the artist to open up the dimensions
of the depicted space to link together separate realms, inside, outside, domestic, public,
intimate, communal, in a series of interrelated domains. Such portals acted as more than just
internal frames for a picture. They serve as a link between areas and imply an ongoing movement
of space and activity between them. Roughly a decade after the slippers, Johannes Vermeer painted
this painting, The Love Letter, an image that transposes many of the same motifs, but in an
altered configuration. Once again, a broom and a pair of slippers lie at the entrance to the room,
but this time the maid and her employer are both present. The letter occupying their attention
has been brought hastily in. The paintings on the wall hint that the letter is from
a suitor who is traveling. It is up to us to decide if the news is good or bad. What the Vermeer
and van Hoogstraten paintings both agree on is that looking through doorways provides an absorbing
conceit. By positioning the viewer slightly outside of the action, yet looking in, there is
an additional frisson of having come across something unexpected, perhaps fleeting and urgent,
even forbidden. Before both van Hoogstraten and Vermeer, the Dutch artist Nicolas Meijers
explored the idea of forbidden space more explicitly with a series of paintings now
collectively known as The Eavesdroppers. These lively and witty works feature a maid positioned
near an open door or passageway, caught in the act of secretly listening in. The subject of her
prying might be a pair of lovers whispering or other maids sharing gossip. Much of the ingenuity
of these paintings lies in their structural playfulness, either in the inventiveness of
the architectural space or in other details that suggest clandestine activities. For instance,
in Eavesdropper with a Scalding Woman from 1655, the figure of the maid servant is more or less
repeated, but Meijers adds an extra conceit with an amusing trompe l'oeil effect of a satin curtain
painted to look as if it's hanging in front of the painting and has just been pulled aside.
If ever an artist wanted to stress the idea of peering in, then this curtain goes as far as a
painting can to implicate the viewer in the act of furtive snooping. No other artists explore the
Numerous works of his contain such layered spaces, usually connected by a doorway,
a window, or an archway. In a painting like Car Players in a Sunlit Room, light moves through
several quarters, streaming through the window and reflecting brilliantly off the varnished floor,
thereby linking up outside and in. These images are not seeking to create a mystery as such,
but to awaken a greater array of possibilities in the subject matter.
The doorways, windows, passageways, and corridors extend the represented space of the painting by
implying the presence of half-glimpsed courtyards, streets, and rooms, supplementing largely
unconsciously our sense of the world beyond the frame and enriching the image with a quiet
complexity that invites deeper engagement. A painting like Woman with a Child in a Pantry
seems simple at first, but once again its richness deepens the longer you look at it.
It seems especially pertinent, for instance, that from the pantry, the room we are in,
we can see through an open door to an adjacent room with a portrait of a man hanging above
an empty chair. From there, a window opens out into a street. Air, light, and sounds,
these all move through the painting through these permeable boundaries.
In almost all cases, de Hooch used not only the doorframe or archways to imply a transition from
one space to another, but also other aspects like the differing flooring or rays of light
or shadow and texture. In one of de Hooch's most effective paintings, The Courtyard of a House in
Delft, the various passageways and spatial looks hook the viewer's eye, encouraging us to stay
with the painting longer than we might otherwise, perhaps even remaining so long as to imagine
hearing the conversation between the young girl and woman, or to feel the moisture in the air
as it clings to the sun-warmed bricks. As with all variations on the door keikyöp technique,
the composition guides us gently from one space to the next, across the courtyard,
through the shaded passageway, and out into the distant street, until we are no longer just
looking but taking part in the scene. In this way, door keikyöp doesn't simply represent a piece of
visual trickery, it guides the viewer to look through and beyond, expanding their perception
of the painted space.
