A leaked letter said to be from Zhang Youxia’s son is circulating inside princeling networks, raising one explosive question: is it real — or a carefully crafted warning to Xi Jinping? In this episode, I break down what the letter actually says, why it focuses on the alleged illegality of Zhang Youxia’s arrest, and how it signals unrest inside the PLA. Fake or not, the message reflects real power dynamics — and real pressure on Xi’s camp.
Okay, let me first walk you through what this letter actually says.
I'll give you my analysis after I tell you what this letter is all about.
All right, so the letter, said to be from Zhang Youxia's son,
has been posted by multiple social media accounts. Some people tried to verify it
through their own contacts and were told that the letter is circulating inside
the Red Princeline networks in Beijing. So that alone gives it weight.
So we shouldn't dismiss it as random hearsay. The letter is written by his son. His name is
Zhang Xin. The tone is careful and polished. The letter then lays out nine main points.
I'm not going to read you the letter. I'll just quickly tell you what the points are.
First, it refused the PLA Daily editorial accusing Zhang Youxia of wavering in his
political stance and betraying party beliefs. Number two, it firmly denies the charge that
the general leaked state secrets or betrayed the country and calling this kind of accusation
quote, if you want to frame someone, you can always find an excuse.
Third, it denies corruption allegations, saying Zhang Youxia's income came only from regular
salary and benefits with no great income and no bribes or gifts. Fourth, it denies claims that
Zhang Youxia undermined the system of the CMC chairman being in charge or opposed the top
commander. Then in the remaining five points, the letter moves into much more sensitive territory.
First, it directly names this guy, Zhong Shaojun, Xi Jinping's former chief of staff in military
affairs. So the letter accused this guy, saying that this is the man who was causing the conflict
with the general. And it says that he stirred up trouble behind the scenes and misled the top
leadership into making wrong decisions leading to the current situation. And the letter also says
that on January 20th, Zhang Youxia attended the opening of a seminar at the Central Party School
and was detained by special forces from the Ministry of Public Security as soon as he
arrived. Since then, he has been held at the MPS, the Ministry of Public Security's,
one of its interrogation facilities. It says that after Zhang Youxia was taken away,
many of his colleagues and subordinates contacted the family to express concern and their support.
They showed respect for the general and said military morale has been shaken. The letter
warns that if the authorities don't handle this rationally, there could be serious consequences.
And this part is written in a restrained way. But the message is very clear. Zhang Youxia has
strong backing inside the military. And if Xi Jinping's side mishandles this,
the consequences could be unpredictable. It's a veiled warning. Now, the most critical part of
the letter is its repeated emphasis on the lack of legality of the general's arrest.
The letter says that having the Ministry of Public Security arrest Zhang Youxia is a serious
violation of both procedure and law. Given Zhang's rank, even if there were suspicions,
the case should have gone through Politburo discussion, National People's Congress review,
and then investigation by military discipline authorities. A direct police arrest not only
breaks procedure, it risks dangerous chain reactions. Basically, it's saying that police,
Wang Xiaohong's public security forces have no authority to arrest a top military general
who sits in the Politburo. And the letter calls this handling, quote, an absurd joke that no one
can accept. As family members, they say they expect a basic due process, no matter what
accusations are made against Zhang Youxia and the other general, Liu Zhenli. Any investigation
should stay within the legal framework, no illegal arrests, no coercive interrogations.
The letter ends with a direct demand, release the two innocent generals. All right, so that's
what the letter is all about. So let's move on to analysis. What do I think?
The writing is airtight. It perfectly balances law and emotion. The part defending Zhang Youxia's
character is just the setup. The real message is the following four signals. First, it zeroes in
on the lack of legality of the arrest, putting Xi Jinping on the defensive from the start,
morally and legally. Second, it avoids naming Xi Jinping directly and shifts blame on his
aide, Zhong Shaojun. But what it really reviews is the core conflict, Zhang Youxia insisting on
rules versus Xi Jinping's breaking rules, and Zhong Shaojun is a proxy.
And the third point is, it sends a clear message that the military reaction is intense.
Many inside the PLA reject the accusations and morale is unstable right now. It even hints at
something very serious, that the gun no longer fully obeys the party under Xi. And fourth,
the boldest move of all is the son publicly demands his father's release. They want him back,
not just because he's innocent, but because his return is more a political objective.
So is this letter real or not? Now, if the letter really was written by the son,
he absolutely did not write it alone. Without very strong backing, there's no way he could
make such a confrontational demand in today's China, not in this system. The tone of this letter
is very interesting. There's no pleading, no submission to Xi Jinping. The tone is very calm,
firm, and controlled, neither humble nor aggressive. The arguments are framed around
law, political norms, and internal rules. So it doesn't sound like a subordinate begging the top
leader for mercy. So considering the son being a colonel in the PLA, this letter really reads like
a public negotiation between two sides that believe they have leverage, rather than a
subordinate pleading the top leader for leniency. So if his name is really on this letter,
if the son really penned this letter, that tells us something important. He was confident
he wouldn't backfire and wouldn't make his father's situation worse. And that can only mean
one thing. The forces behind him and the people who helped draft this letter believe they have
the upper hand in this round. So that's if he really wrote the letter. Personally, I think
this scenario is less likely. My own judgment is that the son probably did not write the letter
himself. People inside the military likely drafted it using his name. And Zhang Xin, the son,
probably knows about it, but didn't personally get involved. By keeping some distance, he leaves
himself room to say, if pressured, he could say things like, this is a fake letter, and it has
nothing to do with me. And that will protect him. And more importantly, it will protect his father.
So yes, the letter may be fake in a technical sense, but the fact that it's circulating inside
Princeton circles, as well as outside China, tell us two things. First, many people inside those
circles in Beijing see it as credible. And second, many of them would probably like to see it being
spreading. And they probably agree with its message. That alone puts real pressure on Xi Jinping. And
that's why this letter matters. Now, after the letter surfaced, more follow-up details leaked
through one of Zhang Xin's friends to overseas influencers. And family members have actually
gone to the interrogation facility where the general is believed to be held. And they've
gone there several times to request visits, and were turned away very coldly by the guards
every time. And so the son reportedly said this. He said, there's been no information at all. It's
like my father just vanished. Our whole family sits by the phone every day waiting for news,
but nothing. My mother can't sleep at night. She's quite her eyes out. He also said that
a rumor is spreading widely inside the military. The authorities want his father to record a
confession video, which would then be shown across the PLA and broadcast on state TV
to, quote, stabilize military morale and public opinion. So according to these reports,
the authorities have tried multiple times to pressure Zhang Youxia into a recorded confession,
and he has flatly refused. And the junior Zhang said his father is the kind of man who would
rather break than bend. So the son warned people not to believe any such video if it indeed appears.
He said his father would never destroy his own reputation just to save his life.