Three ultra-cozy, flavor-packed soups enter the kitchen… but only one can be crowned the ultimate comfort champion. In this episode, I’m making and comparing three incredible vegan soups: an insanely creamy mushroom soup, a hearty meal-prep-friendly lentil soup, and a bold, spicy Thai pumpkin soup that just might steal the show.
Get ready for rich umami depth, nourishing ingredients, and big, vibrant flavors—all made with simple techniques you can recreate at home. Stick around to the end for a family taste test to see which recipe wins the crown!
Key Moments 00:00 Introduction 00:20 Mushroom Soup (Insanely Creamy & Savory) 06:13 Lentil Soup (Hearty, Healthy, Perfect for Meal Prep) 10:13 Thai Pumpkin Soup (Spicy—Maybe My Fave!) 17:04 Taste Test with My Family
Okay, so today we're making three of my favorite
cozy soup recipes.
Got a creamy, savory one, a super hearty one,
and one that's a little spicy,
but only one of them can be crowned
winter's coziest soup.
So stay tuned until the end
because I'm gonna be presenting all three of these soups
to the most opinionated foodies I know, my family.
Would you consider yourself a foodie, mom?
Oh yes, all Indians are foodies.
First soup on our agenda is a creamy mushroom soup,
kind of like the cream of mushroom soup from your childhood,
but like grown up, a little fancy.
This is an ounce of dried porcini mushrooms.
We're gonna use this to make our own homemade mushroom stock
and infuse even more mushroom flavor into the soup.
This bowl is definitely not big enough.
And I've got one and a half cups of room temperature water.
And we're just gonna soak these for 30 minutes,
but some of them will float up to the top, as you can see.
So grab another bowl that you can kind of like
submerge them with and set them aside for now.
Let's work on our fresh mushrooms now.
You need a pound of fresh mushrooms for this recipe.
With a lot of my mushroom recipes,
whether it's a risotto or a mushroom stroganoff
or this soup,
I think you're gonna get the best flavor and texture
if you use a variety of mushrooms
because every mushroom variety has a different flavor
and a different texture.
First, I've got oyster mushrooms.
We also have cremini mushrooms.
And then we have shiitake mushrooms,
which are really meaty and robust in flavor.
For oyster mushrooms,
they're gonna have this tough white stem at the bottom.
You wanna get rid of that.
You're just gonna tear them apart with your fingers.
They're quite soft, so it's really nice.
It's also very therapeutic.
And if you're watching and thinking,
you know what?
Mushrooms are not for me.
I'm just gonna go ahead and skip this.
I will say that Max and my partner hates mushrooms,
but he happily enjoys the soup.
So, you know, don't knock it until you try it.
Isn't that right, Max?
Yeah.
Please sound more convincing.
Yeah, I love mushrooms now.
For our brown button mushrooms and our shiitake,
we're just gonna slice them.
We'll just set this glorious pound of mushrooms aside.
Get all in there.
It's lovely.
Okay, we're gonna use a large onion and some garlic.
Just gonna finely chop the onion.
Oh, a little strong.
Not with these on, though.
Give me all your onions.
Chop them right up.
We've got a lot of garlic, eight cloves.
I can't help myself.
And we'll just finely chop these up.
All right, garlic is chopped and chopped.
Final thing to prep is to make our bouquet garni.
That's just a fancy French word for a bundle of herbs.
It's my favorite technique
for infusing great flavor into soups.
You're just gonna take some fresh herbs
and tie them into a bundle.
We're gonna get two sprigs of thyme,
large sprig of rosemary, and two dried bay leaves.
You're gonna line up your herbs in a little pile,
and then you'll take some kitchen twine like this,
and then you're just gonna tie it up
like a little cute present.
You can also just chop up the herbs and saute them,
but this method is obviously quicker.
I think we're ready to start cooking the soup.
I just need to drain our rehydrated mushrooms
and tidy up a little bit.
All right, we've got a big soup pot,
Dutch oven on the stove, medium-high heat.
I'm gonna add in about a tablespoon of olive oil.
I mean, I'm just eyeballing it, but it's a tablespoon.
In go our onions, a little pinch of salt.
While this cooks, we're gonna do two final things.
We're gonna get two tablespoons of butter.
Butter and mushrooms, fabulous combination.
And then we're gonna just roughly chop
those rehydrated mushrooms.
Let's give these a stir.
Our onions have softened,
so now we're gonna add in our garlic.
And the garlic just needs a minute or two.
Smells so good already,
and we've only added two ingredients.
Now we're gonna add our two tablespoons of vegan butter.
Right, just plopped right in there.
Look at that, it's so pretty.
Shroom time.
Rehydrated mushrooms go in as well.
It looks like a lot of shrooms,
but as you can see, just within a minute,
it's already cooking down quite a bit.
Let's hit the shrooms with a little bit of salt
and pepper to season.
Once the shrooms start to soften like this,
it's time to add in my favorite step, the white wine.
We're gonna use a half cup of a dry white wine.
I've got Sauvignon Blanc.
I don't know if this is a half cup or not.
I'm just testing to see if the wine has cooked off yet.
If it still smells like wine to you,
let it cook for another minute or two.
Now it's time to add in our liquid.
This is three cups of store-bought vegetable broth.
And if you soaked the dried mushrooms,
you're gonna end up with some homemade mushroom stock.
We're gonna pour that in,
but reserve the last tablespoon or so
because it can be sediment heavy.
Almost forgot our bouquet garni.
Just go ahead and tuck it right in there.
Let those herbs infuse all the shrooms
and the onions and the broth.
And now we're just going to bring it up to a boil.
We've got a nice boil on the soup.
So now we're going to reduce the heat.
Cover, simmered for 15 minutes.
Our soup has been simmering.
Oh, a mushroom steam facial.
Now we're going to make it creamy without adding any cream.
What we're gonna do is scoop out
maybe two and a half cups of the soup.
We're gonna blend it in here with a few other ingredients.
You wanna make sure you get some mushrooms in there,
but don't get that bouquet garni in there.
Let that hang out in the soup.
We're gonna add a half cup of raw cashews.
These are gonna make it velvety and just really luscious.
As I mentioned earlier,
this is gonna be a super savory soup.
So I've got two very powerful savory ingredients here.
Tamari or soy sauce.
And it's gonna just add that lovely layer of flavor.
Need a tablespoon of that.
And some white miso.
This is a mellow form of miso.
A tablespoon of this as well.
Now we're just gonna start blending.
Have a look.
She looks creamy.
If you don't have a high powered blender like a Vitamix,
make sure you soak those cashews first
so they blend really well.
And look at this creaminess.
Just wanna simmer this for another five, maybe 10 minutes
so the flavors have a chance to meld together.
It's gonna make it even creamier
during that short time too.
While this simmers,
I'm going to chop up some parsley as our final garnish.
Just gonna give it a taste
to see if it needs any salt and pepper or anything else.
I really don't think it needs any salt.
Maybe just a little pepper.
Oh, and let's not forget,
we need to remove that bouquet garni.
If you taste this
and you feel like you want a little brightness,
go ahead and add a quarter teaspoon of Dijon mustard.
I think this is perfect as is right now,
so I'm gonna leave it.
And I like to serve this soup in a bowl
with a little bit of chopped parsley on top,
a drizzle of olive oil for that nice mouthfeel,
and of course some crusty bread on the side for dipping.
Wow, this one's gonna be hard to beat.
It's so savory.
It's creamy like a bisque.
It's just got so much flavor.
I think you're gonna love it.
Next up, we're making a hearty lentil soup.
Super simple ingredients,
budget-friendly, and really comforting.
We're gonna start with our aromatics.
You wanna finely dice one large yellow onion
and mince up six cloves of garlic.
We're also gonna add some carrots and potatoes to our soup,
make it a little heartier,
but both of these are a little dirty,
so I'm gonna go wash them first.
Potatoes are dirty little things.
Let's give them a rinse.
You wanna dice these carrots
so that they cook thoroughly in the soup
and kind of soften and melt into it.
I needed a snack.
This recipe calls for three medium carrots,
but these are chunky boys, as I like to call them,
so I might use two and a half of these.
Now for our potatoes.
The recipe calls for one pound of baby potatoes.
These are actually really tiny ones.
They're peewee-sized,
so I feel like I'm just gonna have them
instead of quartering them.
Ooh, look at that, purple potatoes, surprise!
If your potatoes are on the bigger side,
make sure to quarter them,
because you want them, again, to be soft
and kind of melt into the soup.
All right, last prep element are fresh herbs.
Kind of similar to last time,
we're gonna make a bouquet garni
to add that really lovely earthy, woodsy depth of flavor.
We'll do two rosemary, one nice big sage,
and maybe two thyme, two thyming, and two bay leaves.
Get your twine and just give it a double knot
so it doesn't come out of the twine.
We're gonna get our Dutch oven over medium-high heat,
and we need a little bit of olive oil,
maybe two tablespoons.
I'm obviously not measuring, just eyeballing it today.
Get a pinch of salt in there.
If you've got a lot of browning on the bottom,
add a tiny splash of water so the onions don't burn.
Nice, golden, savory nuggets, beautiful.
All right, now we'll add in our carrots and garlic.
A little more salt.
After a couple of minutes, it's time to deglaze.
Any little brown bits on the bottom,
we can release back into the soup.
We're gonna do four cups of low-sodium vegetable broth
just so it's not too salty.
If you're using a regular non-low-sodium vegetable broth,
just go easy on the salt later
so your soup doesn't end up too salty.
Come on, taking your sweet time.
All right, we're gonna add our bouquet garni,
lots of flavor in here.
And of course, some lentils.
These are French green lentils, a cup and a half.
I love French green lentils in salads and soups.
If you can't find French green lentils,
you can use regular green lentils or brown lentils.
And our little baby cute potatoes.
In they go, lovely.
And our tomatoes, we're gonna use a 28-ounce can
of whole peeled tomatoes.
So this is the fun part.
You're just gonna get in there with your hands
and smoosh it.
Ooh, that's the good stuff.
It's very satisfying.
And any juice or liquid goes in as well.
I'm gonna need to wash my hands now.
We're gonna season with some salt and pepper.
And then that's about it for now.
Look at this beautiful, colorful soup.
Let's get a lid on this so it'll come to a boil quickly.
All right, now that the soup is coming to a boil,
we're going to reduce the heat to a simmer
and partially cover it to simmer for 40 to 50 minutes
until the lentils are tender.
Let's see what it looks like.
Ooh, nice.
It's looking so good.
All right, guys.
This is exactly what I would want to come home to
after a long day of shoveling snow,
which I will never do because I live in California
and I hate snow.
But if I were to hypothetically shovel snow,
this would be the perfect meal to come home to.
We're just gonna fish out our bouquet garni.
And because this is a hearty stew,
I want to freshen it up with a couple of ingredients
to brighten the flavors.
First, half teaspoon of Dijon mustard.
And then one of my absolute favorite ingredients,
a good quality aged balsamic vinegar.
If you can, try to spring for something
that is aged for at least a few years
and isn't like the watered down,
sour imitation stuff at the grocery store.
And if you want this to be a soupier consistency
and less like a stew, you can always add more broth.
So cozy.
It's rich.
It's thick.
It smells amazing.
And because it is winter,
one of the many things I don't like about winter
is that it gets dark quickly.
So I can't actually finish the third soup today,
but we will do that tomorrow.
And after that, we will take all three of these soups
to my parents' house and see what they all think.
Next up, we're going to make a Thai inspired pumpkin soup.
It's got all these amazing Southeast Asian flavors
and aromas and aromatics.
It's spicy.
It's a little creamy.
It's just a party for your taste buds.
We're going to start with our pumpkin.
This is actually a kabocha squash.
I love this recipe with kabocha squash the most,
but any pumpkin winter squash is fine.
Even butternut squash will work.
This is about a three pound squash
and we're going to slice it in half,
but it is a little tough.
So first we'll pop it in the microwave for two minutes
to soften it up.
All right, got a nice little warm kombucha.
Kombucha, it's a kabocha squash.
Kombucha is the beverage.
Anyhoo, got our nice warm kabocha squash.
We're just going to remove this top stem
and we're just going to use our sharpest,
heaviest knife to cut it in half.
If it's still too tough, like this feels a little tough,
you can pop it in the microwave for one or two more minutes.
Take a look at these guns, strong enough to cut any squash.
Is this how you do it?
I just feel like I'm doing a dance move.
Look at these muscles.
Everything's fine here, totally normal.
Yes, yay.
We're just scooping out the seeds with a spoon.
If you want, you can save them and roast them later.
Oh, grab a sheet pan, get your squash on here.
We're going to add some flavor directly
into the squash while it roasts.
We need just a little bit of oil
to kind of make sure the squash doesn't stick.
A half teaspoon of kosher salt, some white pepper.
It's used often in East and Southeast Asian recipes.
Smells amazing.
And some ground cinnamon.
Just mix this together.
And I'm going to pour it like inside of the cavity,
inside of here.
And then you can grab a pastry brush
or just use your fingers to coat the mixture inside.
A tiny drizzle of oil on the rims.
Spread that out with my fingers or the brush.
And we can do some salt on the top too
because that won't burn.
We're going to put it flat side down on our sheet pan.
I'm just going to prick the skin in a few places with a knife,
which will allow the squash to vent and to evenly cook.
And now we're going to pop it in the oven
at 400 degrees Fahrenheit for 40 to 45 minutes
until it's nice and tender.
Okay, while the squash roasts in the oven,
we're going to get started on everything else.
We're using some pretty classic Thai aromatics in our soup.
We've got shallots, ginger, garlic, and lemongrass.
For our shallots, we've got three large ones
and we're going to chop those up.
For our garlic, we need six cloves.
And finally, we need some fresh ginger, about two inches.
Lemongrass, one of my favorite ever ingredients.
It's got this incredible aroma.
Oftentimes, it'll be sold whole like this.
Well-stocked grocery stores will sell it pre-trimmed,
so you can look for that as well.
Anyhow, for the long stalks, most of this is inedible,
so I'm going to show you which part to use.
You're going to remove some of these loose,
papery outer layers that come off immediately.
Basically, like this whole top part you'll feel is quite tough.
You want to get rid of that too.
Also, this bottom nub right here, super tough as well,
so you want to get rid of that.
Now, there's still quite a few papery outer layers here
that you don't want to eat because they won't soften.
All right, we have gotten to the tender core on the inside.
Aromatics are ready.
Now, we need some spices.
We want a teaspoon of coriander seeds
and a teaspoon of cumin seeds.
I'm going to add them to my spice grinder.
If you don't have one, you can use a mortar and pestle.
Some ground cinnamon, a quarter teaspoon of ground turmeric,
and a teaspoon of that white pepper.
We're going to add some coconut oil to our medium sauce pan.
Let's add our aromatics.
We're going to cook these over medium-high heat
for about three, four minutes until they are softened.
Smells fantastic.
You do want to stir pretty frequently
because the ginger and the lemongrass might stick.
It's been about four minutes.
Let's add our spices that we mixed earlier,
and these just need 30 seconds.
We've got all this flavor sticking to the bottom of the pan,
so we're going to deglaze the pan a little bit.
We're going to add in a little bit of coconut milk right now,
just a few spoons.
We're going to use that liquid to scrape everything up.
Two tablespoons of red curry paste.
If you've got baby mouth,
you want to use maybe just one tablespoon
so you don't overwhelm your taste buds.
That's good for now.
We're just going to add the rest of the coconut milk.
Gurgle, gurgle.
Now for my favorite special ingredient.
Like the lemongrass,
these are going to add that very classic Thai flavor.
These are fresh lime leaves.
If you crush them a little bit with your hands,
you release even more aroma,
and it's just like intoxicatingly citrusy and just so good.
So we're going to add about six fresh lime leaves.
We're going to just crumple them a little bit with our hands
or bruise them to release more aroma.
Couple more ingredients for our soup.
We need some soy sauce for the savory saltiness.
I'm using Thai soy sauce because I went to the Thai market.
I'm using a tablespoon and a teaspoon of this.
If you've ever had a Thai curry,
you know it's a little bit sweet too.
We're going to add a tablespoon and a half of coconut sugar.
And lastly, our vegetable broth.
This is three cups of vegan chicken broth.
It's not actually chicken,
but any sort of vegetable broth is fine.
This has been simmering for 10 minutes.
Let's go get our roasted squash now.
So I can't quite touch the squash right now
because it's pretty hot.
I'm going to show you how to make an optional
but delicious topping in the meantime.
We're going to get a frying pan over medium high heat,
and we're going to make a peanut chili crunch.
Totally optional if you're allergic to peanuts
or you don't want something spicy.
We love peanuts and we love spicy food in my house,
so we're going to make it.
You want a half cup of roasted peanuts.
While those are on the stove,
we're going to prep our Fresno peppers.
Just dice them up.
Peanuts are nice and toasty.
Set them aside for now.
And now we're going to add these diced chili peppers.
Oh!
Don't stand right on top of the pan.
And these need just a minute or a minute and a half.
We're going to add them to this bowl.
And then just a couple of dashes of soy sauce
to bring that saltiness, to bring it all together.
Let's give it a taste.
Mm, mm, mm, mm.
It's spicy.
It's definitely spicy.
One minute.
Woo!
This is only for spicy food lovers.
Now that our squash is cool enough to handle,
I'm just going to show you what it looks like.
So you've got this nice brown, roasty coating.
The peel should come off pretty easily
if it's nice and tender.
And then it's easy to just plop the whole thing in there.
Now, the second component of our soup
is that soup liquidy mixture we made earlier
with the aromatics and the coconut milk.
And we're just going to pour this mixture
directly into the blender with the squash.
Since it's still warm,
I like to leave this off
and just cover it with a towel
so some steam can escape.
Feels nice to me.
You can see it's like super velvety.
It's got a dreamy texture.
This is also one of those soups
that's much better if you let it rest for 15 minutes
because the heat will mellow
and the flavors will melt together.
If you can exercise a little patience,
highly recommend waiting.
Some Thai basil.
This is going to add that characteristic
slightly sweet, spicy aroma and flavor.
If you love, love spicy food,
you can add some of that peanut chili crunch on top.
The soup is spicy.
It's creamy, subtly sweet.
It's got so much good aromatic flavor in there.
So now it's time for us to head over to my family's house,
bring all three soups with me
and see which one they like best.
For our taste test,
I was joined by my sister Pooja,
her husband Andy,
and of course my parents, Nila and Deepak.
I thought this was going to be
a pretty straightforward taste test,
but it turned out to be anything but.
For one thing,
my sister and her husband brought their son,
my very adorable nephew, Nico.
Hi, yo!
I love you!
Also, my dad couldn't resist breaking out
his karaoke machine and singing the hits.
And by the hits, of course,
I mean old Indian songs I've never heard of.
Chika pika dika!
Nina nina dika dika,
there's dynamo dika,
maka naka manga naka,
chika pika rola dika,
rumpa basi ke kuma ho!
Yehi hai, yehi hai,
yehi to hai,
whoa!
Spicy, spicy.
This head looks good.
You look like you're a jazz musician from Louisiana.
My most beautiful, talented, intelligent,
smart, educated, well-placed,
and well-situated daughters with white boys.
But eventually, I was able to start serving the soups
and getting everyone together for the taste test.
Pooja, how do you feel about soup?
It's not my favorite.
It's not your favorite?
Do you like soup?
Not really, but yours, yes.
You've got the perfect taste test.
We started with the creamy mushroom soup.
Oh, yeah.
This will be my favorite, I think.
How do you feel about mushrooms?
Terrible.
How about vegetables in general, mom?
It's a family operation to get some soup in her mouth.
I love mushroom.
Can I put some spicy food?
No, not yet.
Hot sauce?
The mushroom is hitting, for sure.
Follow that up with the hearty lentil soup.
It's my favorite.
I love it.
Let me taste.
Oh, okay.
We have one more soup to try.
There was a brief interruption
when my dad decided to turn on the microwave
because Nico likes the sound of the microwave beeping.
Microwave ding ding.
And finally, everyone had a taste of the Thai pumpkin soup.
I initially declined to give my sister and her husband
the spicy peanut chili crunch topping
because I wasn't sure they could handle it.
Yours is the not as spicy version.
You don't have the topping.
Put it on.
I'll take the spicy.
Put it in there.
Oh.
No.
Oh, it is spicy.
Andy, you better get some water ready.
Andy loves spicy food, but he does not love him back.
Ooh.
Oh, my God.
Ooh, and it's all red.
It's good.
We'll be back after these messages.
Even my dad, who thinks nothing is spicy enough,
thought this soup was pretty spicy.
Hot.
Spicy, hot.
Ooh, this is even spicy for me.
Finally, we were ready to tally the votes.
The mushroom.
The spicy one.
Dad?
All three.
Pumpkin.
Yeah.
One, number two, number three.
All three are great, but this is the most nutritious.
The lentil one is definitely the good hearty meal.
Perhaps why it did not win.
I like it though.
It's a good meal prepping one.
This one needs more spices.
It was a tie.
I guess in the end,
the coziest soup is the friends we made along the way.
Just kidding.
These soups are all good.
Give them a try.
Please.
They're great.
I promise.
Thanks for joining and thanks to my family
for being in my taste test.
Bye.
Bye-bye.