Borgia Family - The Complete History of the Renaissance’s Most Notorious Dynasty Documentary

Archaeology Chronicles
17 followers
On the 7th of June 1494, a treaty was signed at Tordesillas in central Spain by the governments
of Spain and Portugal. The Treaty of Tordesillas was based on a papal bull issued earlier by Pope
Alexander VI. It divided the world beyond Europe between the Portuguese and the Spanish. It was
an extraordinary dispensation by a pope who was known for running the papacy in the interest of
his family, the Borgias, from which family Alexander was the second member to hold the papacy
in the 15th century. Who were the Borgias? Where had they come from? And how had they
obtained such great power? This is the story of the Borgias, the family that divided the world.
The Borgia family is keenly connected today in the popular imagination with the Machiavellian
politics of Renaissance Italy and Rome in particular. However, the Borgias were not Italian
in origin. They came originally from Spain, specifically the hilltop town of Borja, about
150 miles west of the city of Barcelona in the kingdom of Aragon. In the High Middle Ages,
many people still did not have modern surnames and instead often described themselves according
to where they were from. Hence, we might find John of Norwich or Bernard of Lyon. Some people
adopted surnames over time that reflected their profession, such as Smith for a blacksmith.
But other people who came from small towns like Borja took the name of their home place
as their surname. Hence, the ancestor of the Borgias in the 12th and 13th centuries
first became known as de Borja, meaning of Borja, which eventually became plain Borja.
Later, in Italy, this turned into Borja, with G instead of a J. Family legend held that the
Borja family were descended from King Ramiro I of Aragon, ruler of the kingdom in the middle
of the 11th century, yet there is no real evidence to support this and it appears to
have been a simple bit of family propaganda in later times. The founder of the branch of the
family that later acquired power and infamy in Italy in the 15th century was Juan Domingo de
Borja. He was born in the town of Borja around the middle of the 14th century and moved subsequently
to the Valencia region in the kingdom of Aragon, where he acquired an estate at
Le Torre de Canals. It was his son, Alonso de Borja, who would bridge the divide between Spain
and Italy. To understand how the Borjas ended up becoming the most powerful family in late
15th century Italy, one needs to look at the wider politics of Italy and the western Mediterranean
in the late medieval period. Owing to the intervention of various external powers in
the peninsula going back to the fall of the Western Roman Empire, Italy had ended up divided
into dozens of city-states and republics by the 14th century. Several of these were larger powers
like the Kingdom of Naples, the Papal State, the Republics of Venice, Florence and Genoa and the
But others were smaller powers like the duchies of Ferrara, Urbino and Camerino. The south of
Italy in particular had been fought over for centuries, with the Moors of North Africa,
the Normans and the French House of Anjou at various times controlling Naples and Sicily.
In 1282, the Kingdom of Aragon intervened when the War of the Sicilian Vespers broke out
in Sicily, as a revolt against Aragonese rule from Naples over the island. Aragon intervened
early on in what turned out to be a twenty-year-long war. At the end of it, the Aragonese
secured Sicily, while the Aragonese remained in control of Naples and southern Italy.
A further campaign between 1435 and 1442 would result in the Crown of Aragon securing control
of Naples as well, meaning that Aragon became the largest power in southern Italy and the western
Mediterranean. This created a tangible link between the society and politics of places
like the Borgia's native Valencia within the Kingdom of Aragon and Italy, with Rome
only a short journey by ship up the coast from Naples. Alonso, or Alfonso de Borja,
was born at la Torre de Canaus to Juan Domingo de Borjas and his wife Francina on the 31st of
December 1378. His father's ascent to become a considerable local landholder outside Valencia
ensured that he was able to send Alonso to study at the University of Lérida. He studied law there
and also took up holy orders. These two pursuits were not incompatible. The 14th century was a time
when churchmen continued to obtain senior roles in government and by combining legal training
with life in the church, Alonso maximized his chances of rising in Aragonese society.
He soon came to the attention of King Alfonso and he rose steadily in his service until he
became his chief secretary in 1416 at 37 years of age. This was at the height of the schism within
the Roman Catholic Church that had seen a series of anti-popes proclaimed who ruled from Avignon
in southern France, while papal conclaves elected a more legitimate pope who continued to rule over
the church from Rome. A lot of Alonso's service to the king was as a religious diplomat traveling
between Aragon, France and Italy to try to heal the divisions within the church. He played a
substantial role in the careful diplomacy that eventually brought the split in the church to an
end and Pope Martin V then made him Bishop of Valencia in 1429. This was one of the most senior
religious positions in Spain. After Aragon had secured control over Naples from the Angevins
in 1442, Alonso helped establish new diplomatic channels between Pope Eugene IV and the new
Aragonese administration in the south of Italy. For his work, he was made a cardinal of the church
in 1444. Gradually, he began to become a permanent resident of Italy, establishing the family in
Rome. Over time, he and other family members began adapting the spelling of their name,
hence Alonso de Borja with a J became Alfonso de Borja with a G.
Alfonso was already 65 years of age when he became a cardinal in 1444 and he had justified his move
to Italy to King Alfonso V of Aragon on the basis that he wished to simply live a quiet life
in retirement near the holy city. Perhaps he genuinely meant this at the time? If he did,
then the final act of his life must have come as a complete surprise. On the 24th of March 1455,
Pope Nicholas V died after a pontificate which had seen him try to revive the power of the papacy
after the lengthy schism, but which had also witnessed the fall of Constantinople,
the great capital of the Byzantine Empire to the Muslim Ottomans in 1453.
An acclaimed Greek scholar and cardinal from the east, Vesarion, emerged as an early frontrunner
to succeed Nicholas in the papal conclave. But prejudices against his eastern background soon
became apparent, and in the interest of not electing a cardinal from either of the powerful
Colonna or Orsini family factions that controlled a large part of Rome's politics at the time,
the conclave decided to elect 76-year-old Alfonso de Borgia as a compromise candidate.
He took the name Callixtus and became Pope Callixtus III. Despite his advanced age,
he served for nearly three and a half years down to his death on the 6th of August 1458.
His time as Bishop of Rome was primarily spent trying to develop a broad alliance within
Christendom to launch a new crusade against the Ottomans in the Balkans. Although powers that
were directly threatened by the Turks there, like the Hungarians, did rally to the cause,
the Christian kingdoms of Europe were too divided for Callixtus' ambitious plan to succeed.
Beyond this, he is infamously said to have excommunicated Halley's Comet after its
appearance in 1456. However, the story is actually a myth, invented two decades after
Callixtus' time. One of Callixtus' acts as Pope was to make his nephew Rodrigo de Borgia a cardinal
of the church. Generally speaking, Callixtus was nowhere near as corrupt as the subsequent
generations of Borgias, yet there is no doubting that his decision to raise his nephew to the
College of Cardinals was a corrupt act. Rodrigo was only around 25 years old at the time.
Then again, such corruption was hardly unusual in Renaissance Italy. The future Pope Leo X was
made a cardinal when he was 13 years old. Rodrigo was born around 1431 in Spain. He was the son of
Callixtus' sister Isabel via her marriage to her near-cousin Joffre de Borgia. Joffre died when
Rodrigo was only six years old, and even from afar in Italy, his uncle began to play a role
in helping to raise him, using his influence within the church to acquire a number of
positions for Rodrigo in Catalonia when he was barely a teenager. Years later, the uncle arranged
it so that Rodrigo and his brothers, Pedro Luis and Luis Juan, would travel to Italy to study at
the University of Bologna. Thus, like their uncle before them, the Borgia brothers, sons of Isabel
and Joffre de Borgia, were a Spanish family living in Italy. When Callixtus relinquished his own
religious positions in Italy upon becoming Pope, he transferred many of them to his nephews and
organized for Rodrigo to become a cardinal the next year. Callixtus even installed his protege as
Bishop of Valencia and had the diocese raised to an archbishopric. This highlights the manner in
which the Borgias, though now primarily based out of Rome, continued to play a role in Spanish affairs
and to hold extensive estates in Aragon. Amongst the many notorious elements of Rodrigo de Borgia's
life was his less than chaste existence as a cardinal. He had many mistresses over the decades
and one of these, Vanozza de Catanei, was a kind of surrogate wife, such was the length of their
relationship. He fathered multiple children with different women, albeit there has been an extensive
debate about how many children he had. Four of these were children that Rodrigo was said to have
had with de Catanei. These were Cesare Borgia, born in 1475, Giovanni, born either in 1476 or 1477,
Lucrezia, born in 1480 and Gioffre or Godofredo, believed to have been born in 1481.
Nearly all historians accept that these four children were sons and a daughter of Rodrigo
and he did legitimize them after he became Pope himself in later years, prior to which he had
publicly claimed that they were his nephews and niece. Still, a fringe theory speculates that
they were fathered by one or more of de Catanei's three husbands. The overwhelming likelihood is that
de Borgia was the biological father of Cesare, Giovanni, Lucrezia and Gioffre. There is much
less certainty about his other potential children. Girolamo was seemingly his daughter,
the only issue here is that the identity of her mother is completely unknown.
Perhaps the most mysterious of all is the case of a boy named Giovanni, nicknamed the Infanz Romanus
or Roman Child, who was born in 1498. It's uncertain if this was a child of Rodrigo's
or if Giovanni was born to Cesare or Lucrezia and the family was trying to cover up his birth for
one reason or another. In all, Rodrigo may have had as many as nine or ten children.
From early in his career in the church, Rodrigo had ambitions to become Pope one day,
like his uncle had been. When Pope Sixtus IV died in 1484, he decided to mount a campaign
to secure the papacy. He faced a strong rival in Giuliano della Rovere, a nephew of the recently
deceased Pope. In the end, neither man could obtain enough support within the conclave for
their election and a compromise candidate was decided upon with the election of Giovanni
Battista Cibo as Pope Innocent VIII. He reigned for eight years until his death on the 25th of July
1492. A new conclave then assembled, the first to be held in the Sistine Chapel. Amongst the
other candidates were Borgia and Giuliano della Rovere, his rival from back in 1484,
when Oliviero Carafa was also a major contender. This was a particularly corrupt conclave.
The French were on the cusp of trying to intervene in Italy to reclaim the Kingdom of Naples,
that the French House of Anjou had lost to Aragon a half a century earlier, and they poured money
into the process in the form of bribes to try to have della Rovere elected as their candidate.
Most of the 23 cardinals who assembled to decide the vote were paid thousands of ducats to sway
them one way or another. Carafa led with nine votes after the first round of voting, but 15
were needed to obtain a two-thirds majority. Three further rounds of voting ensued, in a
conclave that lasted six days, before the vote swung in favour of Borgia. Although the details
of conclaves were meant to be secret, it is understood that his election was primarily
due to Giambattista Orsini, a cardinal from one of Rome's oldest and most powerful noble families,
who finally swung his faction's support behind Borgia. Rodrigo took the name Alexander and
became Pope Alexander VI. Orsini was handsomely rewarded with a palace in the city, castles in
the countryside, and appointment as papal legate of the March of Ancona, a territory near the
northeast border of the papal state. Ultimately, della Rovere thwarted in his ambitions to become
Pope on two occasions in 1484 and 1492, would have to wait until 1503, when he was elected as
Pope Julius II. Alexander had not simply been elected as the Bishop of Rome and Pope of the
Roman Catholic Church, his election made him a temporal ruler. Although the state over which
the Pope rules today, the Vatican City, is one of the world's smallest micro-states,
covering a small part of the city of Rome, in medieval and early modern times, the papal state
covered a sizable part of central Italy, namely the Lazio region and an even longer strip on the
eastern side of the peninsula, running north towards the Romagna region. It was the only
major power between the Kingdom of Naples in the south and the Republic of Florence to the north.
Importantly, the region to the northeast of the papal state in the Romagna, was also one of the
most politically divided regions of Renaissance Italy, with many small duchies and principalities
here. Thus, Alexander was not just a religious figure, he was now a major player in the power
politics of late 15th century Italy, and it was entirely normal for him to act as a temporal
ruler. For instance, he would try to form strong marital alliances for his children,
just as a royal monarch would, while the popes of the 15th century were known for trying to
expand their revenues and laud their reign through patronage of the arts, just like other
ruling families throughout Renaissance Italy, like the Medicis in Florence, the Estes in Ferrara
and Sforza Visconti of Milan, and the Monfeltro and Della Rovere families of Urbino.
Popes of the 15th century had regularly engaged in such activities, although Alexander was
somewhat unique in how extensive his promotion of his family interests were.
Alexander was now the head of the Roman Catholic Church. Like his uncle before him,
he promoted a whole wave of his extended family members and allies to positions of
importance within the Church. Cesare, which is a Renaissance Italian variant spelling of Caesar,
was made bishop of multiple diocese, a form of pluralism which was one of the many critiques
of how the Church operated at the time, as was the kind of nepotism involved in appointing relations
to positions for which they were clearly unqualified. Cesare, for instance, was being
made a bishop when he was only 17 or 18 years old. He was quickly promoted to the College of
Cardinals too. This was simply the most glaring example of Alexander's corruption as pope.
He also appointed many allies to senior Church positions, regardless of qualification,
even where his allies, such as the Orsini family, were not Church figures, he bestowed ecclesiastical
properties on them, meaning that Church corruption was not limited to only putting
people into bishoprics or the College of Cardinals when they were unsuited to those positions.
All of this contributed in the long run to the image across Europe of the papacy
as an institution that dealt in nepotism, pluralism and corruption, while paying
scant attention to the strictures of Jesus' message in the New Testament.
The groundswell of opposition to the Church's worldliness would soon boil over in 1517,
when Martin Luther sparked the Protestant Reformation in Germany. Although Alexander
would be long dead by then, the fact that the protest against the Church spread so swiftly
across Europe once Luther began his movement, highlights the long-standing resentments which
the actions of popes like Alexander had aroused across Europe. Within months of becoming pope,
Alexander dispatched another of his sons to Spain with the goal of strengthening the family's
homeland. Giovanni Borgia arrived at Catalonia in 1493, with a small fortune in gold and jewels,
to begin influencing the politics of the country at a vital point in Iberian history.
The final Muslim stronghold in the south had just been conquered when Granada fell in 1492.
Christopher Columbus discovered the New World a few months later.
The two Spanish kingdoms, Castile and Aragon, were about to unify to become the modern nation
of Spain, and the Portuguese had also just discovered the sea route around Africa to Asia.
Using Giovanni and additional intermediaries in Spain, Alexander appraised himself of what
was occurring, and then issued a papal bull or religious proclamation, affirming what the
position was regarding the overseas discoveries. He was anxious to ensure that Portugal and Spain
would be the two paramount powers in this process, as they were much easier for the
Church to exercise influence over. The resulting Treaty of Tordesillas, agreed in the summer of 1494,
declared that Spain would have control over any lands it discovered west of a line approximately
2,100 kilometers west of the Cape Verde Islands, while Portugal would have dominion over everything
to the east. Effectively, what it was saying was, that Spain controlled everything in the Americas,
from the perspective of the Church, while Portugal would hold sway in Africa and Asia.
It is hard to understate how important Alexander's decision was. Spain and Portugal
adhered to its terms to a large extent, and Portugal was able to claim Brazil,
on the basis that it lay east of the line agreed upon under the treaty,
a development which had not been foreseen in 1494, while Spain was able to claim the Philippines,
based on its interpretation of the treaty in the mid-16th century. Beyond this, the two kingdoms
honored the terms of the treaty, as outrageous as the very idea of dividing the world up
between two kingdoms based on a papal bull was. While the Treaty of Tordesillas prevented the
outbreak of future hostilities between Spain and Portugal over their respective colonial spheres
of influence, Italy descended into war early in Alexander's time as Pope. The French had long
sought to reclaim the Kingdom of Naples that the French House of Anjou had once ruled over,
before the Aragonese claimed their territories in Sicily and southern Italy in the 14th and 15th
centuries. In 1494, King Charles VIII of France led an army into northern Italy and secured
control over the Duchy of Milan. This was the beginning of the long-running Italian Wars.
These lasted down to 1559 and became a proxy conflict in which France and Spain competed to
become the most powerful state in Western Europe. For every Italian city-state, there was now a
perilous diplomatic game to be played. France and Spain were more powerful than any of these
city-states and each of them could be invaded if they made the wrong move. Alexander's position
was especially difficult. The Papal State controlled central Italy and any army seeking
to move from the north of the peninsula to the south or vice versa, needed to traverse its
territory. Similarly, while an alliance with the French was attractive for the papacy for multiple
reasons, Alexander was a Spaniard by blood and his family had extensive interests still in Aragon.
He managed this well over the next nine years, presenting himself as a disinterested party who
did not object to armies passing through the Papal State as long as they did so peacefully.
In this way, he avoided disasters such as the one which occurred under Pope Clement VII in 1527,
when a Spanish army sacked and occupied Rome. Although Alexander was attempting to portray
the papacy as a relatively neutral party in the conflict between Spain and France,
in reality, all of the Italian city-states, no matter how small, were weighing how they could
use the chaos that had been unleashed in 1494 to their benefit. For instance, in Florence,
the enemies of the powerful Medici family that dominated the republic used the invasion of the
family. Alexander utilised the conflict to try to expand the Papal State, with Cesare acting as
his proxy. The part of Italy on the north-eastern frontier of the Papal States and to the east of
Tuscany was one of the most divided parts of Renaissance Italy. There were numerous small
principalities here in the Romagna and surrounding regions. Urbino and Ferrara were two modest
regional powers. Others like Imola, Forli, Fossombrone and Camerino were little more than
independent towns that were deeply exposed by the new ruthless power politics of the Italian wars.
In 1498, Cesare resigned many of his religious positions and allied with the French. He then
started carving out his own principalities here with the support of the papacy, though Alexander
tried to make it seem as though his son was acting independently. He acquired numerous titles,
such as that of the Duke of Valentinois and Duke of Romagna. He secured control over several of
the towns and small cities in east-central Italy and in 1503, he conquered the Republic of San
Marino. Eventually, his military activities extended around the peninsula and he became
the Duke of Andrea as well, an enclave further south near Bari to the east of Naples.
Though it is almost forgotten today, Cesare was an influence in the writing of one of history's
most infamous texts. At the time that he was carving out a minor dominion for himself in
central Italy, Niccolò Machiavelli was employed as a senior diplomat by the government of the
Republic of Florence, following the fall from power there of the Medici. Although his treaties
on how a renaissance ruler should govern in order to be an effective ruler, il principe, or the
prince, is rightly associated with the Medici today, Machiavelli was also enormously influenced
by the career of Cesare Borgia and his experiences of the way in which the Pope's son acted to secure
power out of the chaos of the Italian wars. He directly cites examples of Borgia's actions
in multiple places throughout The Prince. For instance, at one point in The Prince he states,
I shall never hesitate to cite Cesare Borgia and his actions. This duke entered the Romagna
with auxiliaries, taking there only French soldiers, and with them he captured Imola and Forli.
But afterwards, such forces not appearing to him reliable, he turned to mercenaries,
discerning less danger in them, and enlisted the Orsini and Viterli, whom presently,
on handling and finding them doubtful, unfaithful, and dangerous, he destroyed and turned to his own
men. Throughout, Machiavelli was anxious to emphasize that Borgia was a ruler who was
ruthless when he needed to be. He states, Cesare Borgia was considered cruel, notwithstanding,
his cruelty reconciled the Romagna, unified it, and restored it to peace and loyalty.
This was the essential basis of The Prince, a misunderstood text. Machiavelli claimed that
ruthless actions were justified in the short term, if in the long term they stabilized a region
and ensured its long-term peace and prosperity. For all that Cesare Borgia was seen as a
warmongering mercenary prince, Machiavelli saw him as a skilled political leader,
who, if he had been given enough time, would have made an excellent ruler.
Cesare was not the only one of Pope Alexander VI's children who was becoming deeply immersed
in the ruthless power politics of Renaissance Italy. His daughter Lucrezia became part of the
Pope's wider dynastic ambitions when she was still just a child. Although some historians
dispute whether she was, in fact, born in 1480, the strongest evidence suggests that she was.
This means that when she married her first husband, Giovanni Sforza, in June 1493,
she had only recently turned 13 years of age. Giovanni came from a junior line of the Sforza
family, the senior branch of which controlled the Duchy of Milan during much of the 15th century.
This early marriage was later annulled on the basis that Giovanni was impotent and Lucrezia
married twice more in quick succession, first to Alfonso of Aragon, an illegitimate son of Alfonso
II, the Aragonese ruler of Naples in 1498. When her second husband died in 1500, Lucrezia ended up
temporarily ruling over parts of southern Italy around Spoleto, cementing the perception of her
as the ruthless, power-grasping daughter of an even more ruthless Pope. In reality,
this arrangement was short-lived and Lucrezia quickly married for a third time in 1501.
Her third husband was Alfonso d'Este, the son of Ercole I d'Este, the Duke of Ferrara,
one of the greatest of the Renaissance princes. Alfonso succeeded as Duke in 1505,
making Lucrezia Duchess Consort of Ferrara, Modena and Reggio. Hence, by the middle of the 1500s,
Lucrezia and Cesare had risen to positions of some considerable political importance in Italy,
above and beyond their father's position as Pope. Several of their children became important
figures before long. Lucrezia's son, Ippolito, born in 1509, was made Archbishop of Milan when
he was ten years old. He subsequently became a cardinal and controversially dismantled large
parts of the ancient palace of the Emperor Hadrian to build his own palatial home,
Villa d'Este in Tivoli, near the Eternal City. With all of the political machinations of his
family ongoing, it is easy to forget that Pope Alexander was the head of the Roman Catholic
Church and had to attend to religious matters. His eleven-year tenure as Bishop of Rome was
significant for covering the 1500th anniversary of the supposed birth of Jesus Christ, although
nearly all historians and religious scholars today are agreed that based on the evidence of
the canonical Gospels, Jesus was probably born around 4 BC, at the end of the reign of King
Herod the Great of Judea. Contemporaries did not know this in the late 15th century,
and the year 1500 was a key moment in the religious life of the continent.
While Christians had been deeply anxious that the marking of the millennium back in the year 1000
might usher in the end of days, in 1300 the papacy had adopted a more festive approach to the major
anniversaries of Christ's birth, and none was as significant in the Renaissance era as the year
1500. The entire year was proclaimed as one of pilgrimage and hundreds of thousands made their
way to Rome to celebrate the 1500th anniversary, creating an economic boom in the city and
presenting an excellent opportunity for the family to further enrich themselves. It is not
possible to confirm this, and diarists of the time were prone to exaggeration, but one account claimed
that 200,000 people had streamed into the holy city to receive the Pope's traditional blessing
on Easter Sunday. Alexander did use the opportunity of the jubilee and the wealth generated for Rome
through it, to benefit the city to some extent. Medieval earthquakes and other disasters had
left Rome in a state of decline by comparison with lavish Italian cityscapes like Venice
and Florence. Alexander ordered the clearing of the Trastevere slums around the time of the jubilee
and the revitalization of the city of Saint Peter. Like any good Renaissance prince or Pope,
Alexander VI was alive to the need to be seen as a patron of the arts and humanism during his
time as pontiff. The princes of 15th century Italy were cultured individuals, but they were also
highly competitive, and art and architecture had become ways of expressing their taste and power
to the wider world. Therefore, they all competed to hire the best artists and scholars at their
courts. Alexander was clearly outdone by his near-successor and long-standing rival,
Pope Julius II, who became the head of the church who employed Michelangelo to paint the Sistine
Chapel. For this reason, Alexander's artistic patronage is frequently overlooked in studies
of the Renaissance. Yet it was not inconsiderable. He hired the painter Pinturicchio to paint numerous
pieces of religious art, including a depiction of the resurrection of Christ, which has garnered
a lot of attention in recent times. The work was restored in 2013, and this revealed pieces of it
that had been obscured for centuries, including figures in it next to Jesus' head, which are
believed to be the first depiction in European art of the Native American people. Pinturicchio
had produced these within a few years of Columbus' discoveries in the Caribbean.
Alexander was also the pope who had the Borgia Apartments designed as a suite of apartments in
the Apostolic Palace in the Vatican City. They are famous today because of how ornately decorated
they are with Pinturicchio's frescoes throughout. Elsewhere, Alexander's primary work was in
rejuvenating Rome, ordering the reconstruction of large parts of the city walls and also ordering
the cleaning up of much of the city, which in the late 15th century was characterized by ancient
Roman monuments that were in a dreadful state, with the Roman people regularly scavenging rocks
and building materials from these ancient monuments. Alexander wanted them restored
to their ancient grandeur to the best degree possible. In his final years, as Cesare sought
to expand his control over extended parts of central Italy, Alexander clashed with both the
powerful Orsini and Colonna families of Rome, the first of which had broadly been responsible for
making him pope by swinging their support towards him as the conclave intensified in 1492.
Now, they ended up in a power struggle and the Orsini retinues were seen battling with
Cesare's mercenary soldiers in the early 1500s. The pope had several members of these two families
arrested and removed from their powerful positions. With Orsini's fortresses under
attack in central Italy and the Roman nobility mired in virtual civil war, perhaps it is not
surprising that Alexander's death aroused some suspicion, both at the time and ever since.
Early in August 1503, Cesare was in Rome plotting with his father when the pair of them became ill
after dining with Cardinal Adriano Castalesi on the 6th of August. Both of them lay ill in bed
for days, but while the youthful Cesare recovered, his father's health further declined on the 12th
of August. He made his last confession and was given the sacrament on the 18th and he died not
long afterwards. It has been theorized that he and Cesare were poisoned in a plot by the Orsini
and their allies and that while Cesare's system fought off the poison, Alexander, who was about
72 years of age when he died, succumbed to whatever the toxin was. The problem with this theory is
that there is no real proof of any kind for it. It is suspicious that both father and son became
ill prior to Alexander's death. However, the symptoms they exhibited were in line with malaria,
which was an ever-present problem for the people of Rome prior to the middle of the 20th century,
when the large, mosquito-ridden Pontine Marsh near the city was finally drained.
It was this which probably killed Alexander. Upon his father's passing, Cesare moved to secure
the papal treasury and abscond with resources to continue this campaign, to carve out a fiefdom
for himself in East-Central Italy. However, now that his family had lost the papacy, his position
was fatally undermined. Moreover, Alexander's old rival, Giuliano delle Rovere, emerged as the new
Pope, Julius II, in November, after the short tenure of Pope Pius III, who died after just
26 days as head of the Church. Cesare withdrew to the Romagna, where he had been building up his
lands and where he had recently employed Leonardo da Vinci to act as an engineer, as he developed
siege weapons and fortifications here. Cesare had been able to exert a lot of influence over
the conclave of September 1503, that elected Pius III. Had he lived longer, Cesare might have
been able to establish control over parts of Central Italy in a more permanent way. However,
Pius's swift death and Julius's election in October were a disaster for him. Julius immediately
began moving to expel the son of his old rival from San Marino and other lands which he had
acquired. He had also acquired enemies amongst the Aragonese of Naples, owing to encroachments
on their lands and not long after Julius's accession as Pope, Borgia was captured, detained
and sent to Spain. His final acts were to escape from captivity in Spain and then head into the
Kingdom of Navarre, an independent state in the Basque country at the time, where he began military
campaigning again. He was finally killed there on the 13th of March 1507. He was only 31,
a young age for a person who had lived such a dramatic life. His rash decisions in his later
years were perhaps due to the early onset of syphilitic psychosis, syphilis having only
recently arrived to Europe from the Americas, where it ran riot through the armies fighting
in Italy in the mid-1490s, at which time Cesare appears to have first contracted it.
Numerous other Borgias remained, but the real story of the family and its grasp for power
across parts of Italy ended with the death of Alexander and Cesare within three and a half years
of each other. Lucrezia was the last remaining piece in the dynastic game of chess, which Pope
Alexander VI had been playing. In many ways, Lucrezia's story was the most enduring legacy
of the Borgias' grasp of power during the Renaissance, even though it was attained through
marriage alliances, rather than the aggressive military campaigns favoured by Cesare.
Her life as Duchess Consort of Ferrara, after the passing of her brother and father,
was comparatively uneventful. She and her husband's marriage was full of affairs. Lucrezia's
lover was the Marcus of Mantua Francesco II Gonzaga, who was also her brother-in-law,
as he was married to Lucrezia's third husband's sister Isabella d'Este. Later,
she had a lengthy relationship with the Renaissance poet Pietro Bembo. Her letters
to both of these lovers have survived and provide a window into her thoughts. Far from being the
femme fatale that she has frequently been portrayed as, Lucrezia was a cultured woman
who couldn't avoid being used as a political tool in the Borgia family's scheming when she was
basically a teenager. Later, she carved out her own place in the world and played a considerable
role in making the court of Ferrara one of the main centres of the Renaissance in Italy
in the early 16th century. For instance, it was in Ferrara, in Lucrezia's time,
that the poet Ludovico Ariosto wrote Orlando Furioso, which is considered amongst the great
works of the later stages of the Italian Renaissance. Lucrezia died young, like her
brother, though she lived slightly longer than Cesare. In mid-June 1519, she gave birth to her
tenth child. She died on the 24th of June, from complications from the pregnancy, at 39 years of
age. The passing of Alexander VI and his children signalled the end of the period in which the
Borgias were at the centre of Italian politics. Alexander had married enough of his reputed
children off into aristocratic matches, that many of his grandchildren became nobles in their own
right. For instance, one of Cesare's daughters, Louise, married two influential Frenchmen.
The second of these was Philippe de Bourbon, a scion of the House of Bourbon, who claimed the
French throne in 1589, at the height of the French Wars of Religion. Many of her ancestors held French
noble titles in the 16th and 17th centuries. Lucrezia had the foremost impact in Italy,
due to her third marriage to Alfonso d'Este. Their son, Ercole II, became the Duke of Ferrara
in turn, and Lucrezia's branch of the Borgias continued in Italy for a long time to come,
albeit without the Borgia name. Nevertheless, there is no doubt that the Borgias were eclipsed
by the rise of new Italian aristocratic families in the 16th century, that came to dominate cities
like Rome, notably the Medici family and the Barberini of Rome. Where the Borgia imprint was
felt, their name was often not used. For instance, Pope Innocent X, the head of the Roman Catholic
Church between 1644 and 1655, was a great-great-great-grandson of Alexander VI,
though as he was descended through several maternal lines, he bore the name Pamphili at birth.
Many Borgias continued to hold lands in Spain, while several became prominent churchmen in Italy
even centuries later. A distant descendant, Ettore Borgia, played a prominent role in the
Italian wars of unification in the middle of the 19th century. Many royal and aristocratic
lineages throughout Europe continue to have Borgia blood, however thin, owing to the labyrinthine
nature of European dynastic marriage alliances in the early modern era. A sign of the family's
changing fortunes in the century that followed and the evolving culture of the Papal States and
the Roman Catholic Church is seen in the life of Francis Borgia. He was born in 1510 and was the
great-grandson of Pope Alexander VI. Prior to his murder in 1497, Alexander's son Giovanni had
fathered a son named Juan, who in turn became a father to Francis when Juan was still a teenager.
In 1517, when he was a child, the Protestant Reformation broke out in Germany.
Hence, Francis spent his youth growing up against the backdrop of the wars of religion,
breaking out all across Europe as Christendom tore itself apart over doctrinal matters and
questions such as the nature of the sacraments and how mass should be celebrated. At the heart
of this had been the issue of the corruption and worldliness of the Papacy, as epitomized by
Francis's great-grandfather and near-successors like Pope Julius II and Pope Leo X. A period of
soul-searching on the part of the Papacy followed, and in 1545, the Council of Trent convened to
debate reforms to the Catholic Church. The commencement of the Counter-Reformation inspired
Francis. Although he had spent most of his life in Spain and had inherited the dukedom of Gandia
on his father's death in 1543, he decided to renounce his titles and become a member of the
newly formed Jesuit Order after the death of his wife in 1546. He eventually became the third
superior general of the Jesuits in 1565 and played a role in the foundation of the Collegium Romanum
in Rome. He was canonized as a saint in 1670. His life encapsulates the changing dynamics of
involvement with the Church by leading Italian and Spanish families in the 15th and 16th centuries.
As a result of the Reformation and Counter-Reformation, it was no longer acceptable
for Church figures to behave in the manner which Pope Alexander VI and the Borgias had,
at the height of the Renaissance. As a coda to the story of the Borgias, in the 18th century,
the family became associated with one of the most famous and mysterious manuscripts
relating to the history of Mesoamerica, the Codex Borgia, found today in the Vatican Library.
This is within the wider group of Borgia manuscripts there, that relate to the history
of Central Mexico prior to the Spanish arrival and the conquest of the Aztec Empire in the early
16th century. These are extremely rare manuscripts, as a huge proportion of the material culture of
the Aztecs and other Mesoamerica groups were destroyed in the conquest of the 16th century.
The Codex Borgia is the most elaborate of them and is a richly decorated volume of images
depicting the Aztec calendar and images of the various Mesoamerican deities associated with
different parts of the year. It then moves on to show images illustrating the stages of life,
such as the prognostications of marriage. There are details here surrounding the Mesoamerican
star symbols, their religion and cosmology, and it provides one of the greatest insights
into the culture of the people of the Aztec Empire and neighbouring powers in Central America on the
cusp of the Spanish conquest. The exact mechanism whereby it ended up in Italy is unknown.
It clearly must have been brought back to Europe at some stage in the 16th century
and was in the possession of the Giustiniani family in Italy by the early 17th century.
Stefano Borgia, a cardinal from a collateral branch of the Borgia family in the second half
of the 18th century, acquired it. His manuscripts were subsequently deposited in the Vatican Library,
meaning that the Borgia name is now forever associated with the study of Mesoamerica
and cultures like the Aztec Empire. The Borgias are one of the most infamous families to have
ever attained the papacy, a family that epitomized Rome's corruption in the Renaissance
era and on the eve of the Protestant Reformation. Nonetheless, to view them simply through the
prism of Alexander VI's mistresses, illegitimate children, and ruthlessness in furthering his
dynastic ambitions, obscures the story of the wider family. The Borgias were not Italian.
Instead, they emerged from a small town in the kingdom of Aragon in Spain in the middle
of the 14th century. It was Alonso de Borgia who raised them from obscurity to the center
of the labyrinthine politics of Renaissance Rome, first becoming a cleric and a diplomat,
and then a bishop and a cardinal, and finally head of the Roman Catholic Church as Pope Calixtus III
in 1455. He paved the way for his nephew Rodrigo's ascent. For all the scandal of his time
as Bishop of Rome between 1492 and 1503, Pope Alexander VI was nothing out of the ordinary
for popes of the Renaissance era, and his pontificate was about more than merely propping
up the family's dynastic ambitions. For instance, it was under Alexander that the Treaty of Tordesillas
was created, that the 1500th Jubilee was celebrated in Rome, and that the Papal State experienced
the early stages of the Italian Wars. In the end, the corruption of popes like Alexander VI
was their undoing. Once the Protestant Reformation began, a concurrent reform initiative had to be
launched in Rome too, and the Counter-Reformation ultimately brought an end to the kinds of
corruption seen in the 15th century. Nevertheless, by then, the Borgias were firmly rooted within the
Italian Church and aristocracy. While no figure within the family would ever rise to the position
Alexander VI once held, the Borgia line continued in a much less dramatic fashion
in various parts of Italy for centuries to come. What do you think of the Borgias?
Were they really the epitome of papal corruption at the height of the Renaissance, or were they a
fairly typical family, who held control over the Papal State on two separate occasions in the 15th
century? Please let us know in the comment section, and in the meantime, thank you very much for watching.
