The World's First Reflecting Telescope

Inventions and Inventors
25 followers
2 Video Views·Feb 12, 2026
In this video, a departure from our normal format, we're going to be screening a discussion
which covers some of the trials and tribulations that Isaac Newton may have encountered in his
development of mirrors for the world's first reflecting telescope, that is the original
Newtonian reflector. This replica of his telescope of 1671 is part of a small batch that myself and
a few friends in the engineering and telescope industry collaborated on and built in 2009.
Now although our project was primarily about making a replica of this historically important
telescope using methods and technology that would have been available to Newton,
a parallel track kind of running alongside the project was also to note any of the difficulties
and methods of overcoming them that Newton may have encountered while he was working
on his project and then feed that back in to the modern commentary. Unfortunately,
one of the collaborators who worked on the project, James Munson, who was responsible for
all of the hand-turned woodwork using fruit woods, is no longer with us. He passed away a few years
ago but we can still tell you a bit about the metal mirrors that we built for the telescopes
and there is some interesting stuff there that I think is worth hearing about. The general metal
work was pretty straightforward. We had to learn to do a couple of things that were a little bit
unusual but it was the mirror, the metal mirror, that was probably the most challenging part of
the project and the mirror made by Newton, cast by himself, was an alloy of copper, tin, antimony
and probably some other elements in there as well. We used aluminium, a type of aluminium
that was a good approximation, we think, of the metal that Newton was using. Remember, aluminium
wouldn't have been available to Newton, it wasn't discovered until 1825. So what follows is a
discussion between myself and my friend Terry Pearce, who has spent a lifetime both making
Newtonian mirrors and helping others to make Newtonian mirrors as well.
Terry was the guy who was responsible for grinding and polishing all of the mirrors
for our replica telescopes and the project of grinding these very small two-inch mirrors
threw up quite a few problems for Terry to solve. In fact, at one point, he didn't think he was
going to be able to do it at all and he'll tell you, for the remainder of this video,
he's going to tell you in his own words about those difficulties. Let's say hello to Terry Pearce.
Hello Terry. Nice to see you again. You found us. Good, good, good.
Well, this is all very familiar. You've changed a few things but I was 19, I think, when we first
met and the circumstances of this meeting was me buying a telescope from you. So that rather
underlines your period in the business and of course when I met you, you'd already been making
telescope mirrors for quite some time. You'd been advertising in the
back of the British Astronomical Journal. I've got one of them here.
This isn't the one I actually bought the telescope from. Oh, right. Someone had coloured it in.
Well, that's me. Interesting, yes. Talking to you on the phone, I did that. No, really? That's a
camera look. Yes, you were thinking of taking a photograph. I was talking to you about putting
whether the drive was good enough. Photography. And you were trying to baffle me with that ----,
I think. No, no. Well, the gear wheels were made by Ron Irving. Don't worry, I'm not going to ask
you to take it back or anything like that. Don't worry. Yes, well, the gear wheels were made by
Ron Irving and as far as I knew that was the best person I could find to machine a very good
worm and wheel. No, this was at the time, when I was 18 when I took the delivery of it. Yes. I
think it was easily the best telescope I ever looked through. It wasn't a nine inch, it was
eight and three quarters, I think. It was an odd size glass blank. Well, possibly, well, you may
have wanted a Pyrex mirror. But if you wanted a Pyrex mirror, you had to have the size that
the Pyrex people made boilerplate windows, which was eight and three quarters, whichever millimetre
size that is, or that's why they're 11 and seven eighths and eight and three quarters and various
other peculiar sizes, because then they cottoned on, they were being used for telescope mirrors,
and then they relabeled them astronomical mirror blanks, which is the David Hynes and Henry Wildey
bought them by the tonne. Strange you should say. David Hynes. Because they were immediately above
your whatever. David Hynes. Now that brings me to an interesting point, really. Yeah. We've got,
this is 1978, I think I bought, it would have been like 1976 or something like that, maybe,
it may have been a little bit earlier. When did you start advertising in? Oh, it was only 1976 or
77. Yeah. Yeah. So you may have been one of the first people to buy one for me. By June 78, I'd
already got the telescope. Right. For sure. So this was me noodling, talking to you on the phone.
Yeah. Yeah. Because I've got another journal with all the notes that I made on the page, scribbling
on the page when I was talking to you about the price of it when we were negotiating. Right.
I came down to see you about three times. Yeah. About it. And of course, we were also buying a
telescope for the Iliastro Society, which was another little story with that one as well. But
there's an interesting thing here. Yeah. In 1978, here's David Hynes. Yes. Who is now one of the
world's premier importers of telescopes. Celestron telescopes. Celestron telescopes. Yes. There's you,
same size as just underneath. Yes. Yes. What went wrong? He went off to power and glory,
and you're still talking to people like me about rubbing old mirrors up. Well, because
some people like buying and selling things, and some people just enjoy making them. And being poor.
Yes. Well, yes. Well, both Henry Wilde and Ron Irving told me in their time that you'll never
be rich making telescopes, especially Ron Irving. Henry Wilde, I think, was rich, because I remember,
I think I went to Henry's house in about 1972, because he bought some castings from me. And I
was astoundingly impressed, because he opened his checkbook, and I saw that he had £1,082 in his
bank. A fortune! And I thought, wow, there must be money in this, right? And at your face, you
weren't exactly bumping along the bottom. No. Because I paid you about 250 quid for the... Yes,
well, it's true. Well, yes, but if you... They were pretty expensive things. Well, yes, exactly.
But this was, you know, the 1970s. Yes. But if you think I was paying for all the castings,
I had to pay for the illuminising, you buy the mirror blanks and everything else,
there wasn't that much money in it, really. Honestly. It was quite surprising. Because
in 1970, I met a gentleman who bought a four-inch brass refractor from Fuller Scopes in about 1972
or something. And he phoned up my friend about 10 years ago and said he still had it in his
garage. Would we like to take it away? Now, Doug thought he said a four-inch reflector. And Doug
said to me, Terry, I don't want a four-inch reflector. You can have it. I said, well,
thanks, Doug. When we got to the chap's house and he unveiled this brass four-inch refractor,
I could see Doug's face dropping, really, because he donated me a telescope, which this gentleman
paid Dudley for the £500 for. Worth a lot more than that. So in 1970, a four-inch refractor was
£500. So I would say a reflector that size was... I tried to make them as cheaply as I could.
Yes. It was a three-inch refractor, and I think it cost my family a similar amount of money when
I was about 13, 14. Yes, yes, yes. It cost an absolute fortune. It was Japanese-made.
Yeah. Well, this is why I started telescope-making classes, because I used to say to people,
you can spend £50. For £50, you make a whole complete telescope. This was the early 1970s.
You make a whole complete telescope for £50, whereas if you go to Fuller Scopes,
you've probably got to pay £200 or £300 for one. How many people do you think you've taught
over the years? Well, when we started those classes, we had up to 20, 22 people in the class.
And it was a class which Doug Daniels started in the 1960s. And when he left college and started
a proper job, he said to me, Terry, it's not worth going to an evening class and working all
night to earn two guineas. Would you like to take it over? And I think I was probably still at
college at the time. So I said, thanks, Doug. So I started an astronomy class. And then after a
couple of years, I thought, well, people are talking about where do we buy a telescope from?
Why don't we start a telescope-making class? And we did. And then we got to the 1970s,
and I had so many people in the class. Peter Chambers, another friend, he used to come along
as my assistant. So I had a teacher and an assistant in a London educational authority.
And that went on for years. And I've had people from India, people from Los Angeles. One chap
from Los Angeles made himself a telescope, and he was horrified. He said, does the sun ever
rise in England in the winter? He was really furious with the weather, yes. So hundreds and
hundreds of people, but it always upsets me. There's always people who never actually quite
finish. And you try to persuade them not to start unless you think they really are going to finish.
But even now, we've still got this telescope class running.
How many do you think you have? Well, if you say, well, 20 a year for,
say, 35 years, I don't know how many that is. That's a lot.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Absolutely.
Eroding the business, basically. Making their own telescope.
Yes, well, this is wonderful. But of all the people who've joined the class over the years,
because it's been held in the Hampstead area, we've slowly fed members into the Hampstead
Scientific Society. And one of the members, Simon Lang, he joined the class, and he made
himself a six-inch reflector and then another reflector. And he still comes along even now.
And he's now one of the leading members of the Hampstead Scientific Society.
So we've collected quite a few people along the way. But Simon wrote an article for the
Sky At Night magazine, and he made the video, although I sort of helped him with the advice
of how to make it. And that's on YouTube, how to make yourself a telescope mirror.
And we've had 30,000 hits from that, which is quite amazing, really.
And has that brought people to you as well? No, because wouldn't they have to find me?
Well, you can give yourself a plug. Yeah, well, I don't need them to find me,
that's why David Hynes has got that big import business.
Okay, let's look at the telescope. We're looking at a replica. The original for this was presented
to the Royal Society in 1671. Terry Pearce here, myself and my uncle, Mr Munson, he made all the
replica. And Terry worked on the mirrors for this replica. So we're just going to show it to you in
its general parts of how it actually fits together. We've got the plate on here, giving us the
information about the telescope is exactly the wording that was put on the original Newton
instrument. The method of movement is, in its way, incredibly modern and smart using this gripped
ball. There've been a couple of modern telescopes that have used this idea of the ball support.
The telescope tube itself is, again, quite sophisticated. The eyepiece arrangement with
its thread was added in the 18th century by the instrument maker, Wing Heath. Basically, he was
given a box of bits from the Royal Society, took it away and made it into a complete telescope.
But the original assembly that Newton was working with actually had this wing nut focuser on the
rear here, which is really rather nice in the way that it allows the tube and the mirror, of course,
to move backwards and forwards relative to the secondary. We've also got these rather nice
features whereby we can just undo the instrument briefly, rotate it to a new position, or if we
want the eyepiece over here, if I'll leave it on this side, rotate the eyepiece to a new position,
reinsert the clamp, and that grips the tube again. And we've got exactly the same arrangement
down the bottom here, so that can be undone and we can, you can see, we can remove the whole tube
and there's the mirror support at the bottom there. Now, one of the things we want to talk about is
the little discoveries that we made while making this. I don't think we discovered anything
sort of earth-shattering, but there were certainly some interesting moments of discovery.
I'm thinking mostly when you were working with the metal mirrors. The original mirror,
in fact, we've probably actually now, but prematurely... We've taken the mirror out.
Yeah, we've taken the mirror out. The mirror is actually only held in here. The original was in a
wooden turned base, and we reported we turned, we made the mirror... One complete piece.
Now, Glenn, our hand turner at Astroengineering, actually made these for us to our specification.
And what he did was take a piece of aluminium that was a very similar kind of performance to
the tin mixture that Newton had used, and put a very basic sagittar on it. And once we'd got that,
we passed that on to Terry, for him to do his magic, and actually put an optical surface on
there. Do we want to get your bits and pieces out? Talk about that. Well, let's see what we've got in
here, because I haven't looked, you see. I mean, these are blanks you gave me, and I've made
polishing laps for them. I genuinely don't know what I've got in here. It's very, very heavy,
whatever it is. Oh, you've got it all. You've got all the bits and pieces. That's a grinder with a
small polisher in the middle, Indian ink, polishing powder. When did the moment arrive when you felt
you had to use Indian ink? Well, it's funny, Rob, because we were trying to... No, I don't have
anything else. You know those little squares you put between sheets of glass? Well, that's what we
ended up using, I think, for getting the general polish. You see all these peculiar laps I made,
to try and polish different bits to change the figure. See, little polishing laps. That was to
polish the middle or reduce the ring. That was an overall polishing lap.
The truth is, of course, I don't suppose Newton would have used a pedestal drill to do the
polishing, right? No, no. And I have to confess that I did all the grinding. If you remember,
you gave me one that was beautifully polished, and you said, it's fantastically polished,
but it doesn't give me a picture. It was useless. Yes. Now, that was the moment that worried me,
because I thought, well, you can either get the polish with no figure, or you can have the figure
with no polish. Now, how long it would have taken to polish that by hand on a little polisher,
I've no idea. And I don't know whether Newton would have done one, or whether he would have
thought of the idea of the spectacle makers at the time, and perhaps had a big batch and polished
lots of them. I think we've got some very basic details of, one, how they were polishing lenses.
Yeah. They would have made them in batches. In the 17th century. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. But given that
he must have got information, because we know he went to London specifically to find out from
London instrument makers how he might be able to go about making this mirror. Yeah. But we don't
really know exactly what they told him. No. We're fairly sure that he couldn't. There's a real
limit to how much they could have told him, simply because nobody had done this, really. No. Nobody
had actually made this work. No. So they must have only given him sort of general guidance, and they
certainly couldn't have given him anything that we would regard as crucial, which is the method
of measuring the mirror, so that he could adapt what he was doing as he was going along. And, of course,
at this point, it's probably fair to say your experience of doing this job, you almost know
too much. Well, this is why I've never ever tried to polish a metal mirror, and the only
examples I've seen of polished metal were the one that you showed me. And also, we actually coat
little metal shields for some of the satellites, thruster engine protectors, and we put aluminium
coating on the polished aluminium to make it slightly brighter. And the people who polish
those get a fantastic polish on them, beautiful polish, because there's no optical finish to them.
Yeah, that's an important point to mention. Getting this to shine beautifully is easy.
Yes. You've only got to take a mild liquid abrasive. Yeah. And you can get this to shine,
and it looks absolutely lovely, but it's useless as a telescope component. You can't get anything
out of it at all. Now, obviously, we cheated. Yes. Because we took this straight off of a Haas
mill. Yeah. And with a ground sagittar already on it, he would not have had that advantage,
presumably. So I suppose he might have cast it with a certain amount of shape to it already.
Yeah, but then, you see, I thought, well, I must not read anything about this. But, as you say,
I've only ever ground glass things. The people he spoke to probably had only ever ground glass
things. And the only other thing I ever remember seeing on the television was
things about Galileo sort of grinding lenses on cannonballs to get a curve in the glass.
So it was a metal grinder. And I would have assumed that the people who ground the lenses
would use metal grinders. And that kind of rough and ready knowledge was not long before. I mean,
you're only talking, what, 40, 50 years before Newton was doing this. Yeah. I mean, one of the
extraordinary things to remember, really, modern people looking at this, here's Newton making this
in the 1670s. Oh, surely the Newtonian telescope took off within a decade. But, of course, it
didn't. It was 50 odd years before somebody succeeded in actually making this idea work.
Yes. As I say, I subsequently saw, if it's genuine, one of Herschel's mirrors in the
history of whatever is science in Oxford. And it looked like a beautifully aluminized mirror. So
Herschel obviously knew how to polish mirrors to an amazing quality. But presumably, it was partly
the mixture of the metals that he had. And I had no idea what Newton had done. And I only assumed
that, possibly, he would actually have to grind one little mirror on one little grinding tool and
not make them in a batch. There's no information that he made a big batch of them and then chose
the best one. Oh, no. I don't see how with the equipment that he had and the way he approached it.
No. He certainly wasn't doing a commercial operation. He was just trying to feel his way.
Yes. To make good an idea. After all, the idea, the concept of the reflecting telescope was not his.
No, no. He just thought that his ideas about optics led him to believe that a reflecting
telescope would be the only way of getting a perfectly sharp, clear picture without a
chromatic abrasion. So presumably, then, you attacked this as though it was a piece of glass.
Yes. So I thought, right, well, I thought, OK, well, he's probably not made a big batch of them
and then slowly rejected them as they fell by the wayside. So I just took a metal blank, which I
think you may or may not have provided, with a matching curve, which I suppose is a bit of a
cheat, but he would have easily worked out how to make a curve. He'd have known how to make a curve
by grinding any curved surface. So I just simply ground it in the way I would ground an ordinary
piece of glass with successive grades of powder. They had grinding powders of different grades
and when it got to a fine grind and it was genuinely done by hand, I started trying to
polish it by hand and it seemed to be very slow. And I then, I have to admit, I had different polishing
devices in an electric drill and by offering the mirror up to that and moving it backwards and
forwards, I was beginning to get a polish quicker. Obviously, why spend two days doing it if you can
do it in half an hour when I'm not the Newton desperate to prove a point. But even polishing
it by hand and testing it, it gave terrible optical figures and it really did give terrible
optical figures. I was continually, you know the old-fashioned idea with glass, people grab
their telescope mirror, they polish it, it gets hotter and hotter and hotter, the edges swell up,
you polish them off, when it's cooled down you've got a terrible turned down edge and a terrible
focal image. So metal would heat up very, very rapidly and I would have assumed, unless he was
very, very careful, he would have polished the edges down very, very quickly and got very bad
figure. One of the interesting things you were telling me about when we were talking about it
at the time, and this is probably important to remember that this is on the edge of our memories
now because this was in 2009 when we did this and we're recording this in 2016. I was
interested in the fact that you told me that you found it very difficult to employ your muscle
memory that you've built up in grinding mirrors because you couldn't get a rhythm going with this
very small. Yes, it's so small. Especially trying to keep it cool. Yes, the whole thing is fraught
with disaster if it's so small. It's easier to make an 8-inch mirror than a 6-inch mirror because
it's big movement. Yes, and the 10-inch one is lovely. With that you've got to be extra careful
and extra delicate and extra sensitive because any over generous movement instantly figures in the
most atrocious shape into the optical glass. I'm not going to do this but you see, look,
he could only do little tiny strokes. Now your natural impression is I want to get this polished,
I want to do this. Now would he have known by doing that he was making a bad figure? He wouldn't
have known whether he was figuring it badly. So let's just be clear about something. You keep
saying an atrocious figure. Yes. Give me an idea what you're talking about. The difference of a
possibly three or four millimetres, eighth of an inch from centre to edge. Genuinely atrocious.
You could have a range of focal points. Yes, we're not talking about less than core wave,
we're talking about waves and waves and waves. Not capable of producing an image. No, no, no.
But then if you think it would never have a very high power so I can't see that you need to be
more accurate than probably half a wavelength or even a wavelength. If you've got a wavelength
accuracy there you'd get a perfectly good power at five times per inch of aperture, wouldn't you?
Really. Just give us a clue here. So offer up the mirror again today and just show me again
the scale of the size of movements you think you were actually making. Well in theory
the optics would be in a wooden block and kept very steady and I used the technique you would
have to use with a telescope mirror to try and keep the figure correct and you can only sort of
just do little tiny short movements. Sort of keep the whole thing under control. Chewing backwards
and forwards over a big surface would have ruined the edges. Long strokes over a small surface would
have ruined the edges so it had to be little short polishing strokes at all times. Once you start
doing the long stroke you start figuring. The texture that you see on the edge in the centre
is about as good a reflection as I could achieve with all my different polishing techniques that I
could think of and then we did some research and discovered that possibly Indian ink would be the
finest possible finishing material and I was just getting to the point where I was discovering how
to get an extra shine while I was adding a figure to the surface. Now this one you'll see has a shiny
ring there. Some of those scratches are very deep. You'll find all those marks are left over
from the fine grinding because the other problem is if the powder becomes too fine it clumps
together again and acts like a coarser grade of powder and starts scratching. So that was the
smoothest surface I could get to polish. That zone there is where we had an up and a down figure
left over from the rough polishing even with my careful polishing.
So then with a ring polisher, you can see the ring polish, that ring matches the shiny zone.
That ring then polished into that part of the mirror taking down the crest of the up and down
parabola and brought it down and brought it down such that it was virtually spherical and therefore
gave me a good picture. You see that's another little device I made up to obviously deal with
further out nearer to the edge of the mirror because each individual mirror,
every one that was polished, came up with different awkward problems and I could get a
semi-shine on it and I could get a semi-optical surface on it but I could never get an actual
perfect working surface until I chose these little polishing devices to fine figure away
the high spots on the mirror that I'd made. Do you think he might have been happier as well
actually using that as the working tool? Well I don't know, you see we've no idea what kind
of polisher he used. He may have had a very big polisher in the same way that other people did.
So by chewing this backwards and forwards over the big polisher, he would have got a lovely polish
but he would have chewed in by that much all around the edge and turned it down completely
and ruined the image. So if he actually made it work and got a picture from it,
he must have learned in some way or other that you can't do those very large movements. And he
would have eventually learned to... Slow and steady. He may have made himself a personal
polisher the same size. Once you've got a big polisher the edges are always chewing into the
unprotected edge of the big polisher and you're always polishing the edges off. But I suppose the
clue would have been when he got to that point he would have wondered why the edges of his
mirrors were always going shiny and the middles were staying dull. So then he'd possibly think to
himself well perhaps I'm wearing the edges down too much and modified his movements accordingly.
Well he actually talked about the sound as well of course. That's something you would have been
familiar about with the sound that the mirror makes while it's running on the polisher due
to the abrasive distribution. Right well with Rouge, total silence. So if he talked about sound
I've no idea what he was using to polish on unless it was paper or something. I've no idea.
See I tried lots of things. These are, this is not pitch, these are little tiny
cork squares used as used in separating sheets of glass. Pitch, waste of time. Little cork squares
gave me quite a reasonable polish in the end. Sorry just amplify that. Yeah. Waste of time, why?
The pitch, it just would not work. It just did not seem to polish properly and of course
it melted too quickly. Yeah with the heat. Yeah yeah and kept on flowing. So the cork,
although it's whatever is that rubber side not the cork side, the foamy side with ordinary
polishing powder seemed to give a reasonable polish but not an incredibly shiny polish.
Using your glass methodology. Yeah. Got us to a point where this was not working. No I could only,
I could never get quite as fine a ground surface as I could with a glass one but I then went to
polishing and I used the Rouge you know standard old Ceri Rouge and that gave a passable polish
but only a passable polish so I didn't get any further. It was most odd. And still didn't get
no. It was an optical surface. Well it would it would give a it would give a polish like the
outside of this surface. I achieved this horrible grey semi-reflective surface by working in the way
that I would if I was polishing glass. So a very even surface but not really something that we
would recognize as a mirror. It would be a glass mirror that possibly being polished for 30 minutes
So it was a case of finding out a different type of polishing material to bed it to which
was as I say these cork squares which were more rigid and then some other fine optical surface
polishing surface powder that we could use and this is it was Indian ink in the end and how
Indian ink would polish it I don't know but that's what did it. And you you found your way to this by
looking at what? Well I did I did actually think about using Indian inks I'd already known about
using Indian ink but in the end by cheating and reading about the NASA website to discover they
could polish aluminium mirrors accuracy of an eighth wave and it was Indian ink that they used
and I had heard from other people that opticians in the late 1800s 1900s have made incredibly good
optical surfaces by using Indian ink as a final polishing material because it is in fact a powder
I've got a block of Indian ink which you can grind down to write with if you want to. It's such a
fine powder you can see how it's stained these squares black. Well part of the mission actually
was to feel our way into this rather than get too much information to try to replicate and get some
of the feel for what Newton himself would have actually done. Well yes you see I tried polishing a perspex
mirror once I've read about people polishing perspex mirrors and plasticine and fairy liquid
does the trick there so that sounds crazy so I tried soap with this. Obviously one of
our biggest cheats here was using aluminium yes now we've used the type of aluminium that has some
of the properties of the mixture of material that he was using but nevertheless it wasn't
at all commercially viable for us to go off and create that exact same mixture
that he was using. To what extent do you think he will have had an experience that is quite close to
yours? Well I'm assuming that a you said he found out from the opticians how they made their lenses
I'm assuming therefore he would have tried that way I'm assuming he would therefore have discovered
that he could not get a surface that gave an optical picture and possibly he might have
deduced by the shine in different zones that one part of the mirror was being polished more than
another and slowly adapted his techniques accordingly. One of the things I'm particularly
interested in is when you were telling me that you found it so difficult to improve the figure
once you've got an optical surface because that would have been incredibly frustrating
for him as it was for you to find that he's got a procedure that has you know this eureka moment
he puts the mirror into the telescope yeah finds now he's got an optical surface and he's actually
giving him an image excitedly goes back to do a little carry on polishing and then finds he's
now that is perfectly true because it's such a soft material compared to glass
the obvious thing is you say well compare a glass mirror to a pyrex mirror a glass mirror scratches
twice as easily as a pyrex mirror a glass mirror changes figure twice as easily as a pyrex mirror
when you're figuring it this I would say changed figure 10 times more easily than a glass mirror
so you need only to do a minute's polishing to bring up the shine the figure was completely gone
I guess he could have done things by changing his mix in terms of the how much arsenic and
antimony and various other things he was putting into the metal but he would have still I think
encountered this same puzzle that you were on because of course one of the things we know he
couldn't have got from the London instrument makers is a methodology for improving the mirror
a method of measuring the mirror no no no not at all no you see I'm what I'm trying to say is that
I was struggling to find a lap surface and a powder that matched that actually enabled me to
gain a shine with that metal I could not make it go more than that rather dull
20 30 percent reflection and I could get it to that point but anything any hard work or any other
material to make it go shinier than the figure would go and having made how many of these I did
for you was it about 10 we ended up with about I think 13 good mirrors right well having worked my
way through those I just got to the point where I just started learning I thought I was beginning
to get a figure and I was beginning to get a shine and I think had I carried on for another
three months um well if this was Newton's be all and end all he might have spent two years on it
so so I can quite see that when you're talking about the maximum reflection he could get obtained
I'm talking about not being able to even get near the maximum reflection because I couldn't
find a method to make it go shiny and take away the pits without continually losing the figure
and it going atrocious we know the mirrors produced produce an image very like the image
the gentlemen of the royal society said they could see in the telescope yes we've seen the similar
kind of details yes yes and even with the best will in the world though you're you're thinking
that the they're probably not even quarter wave the quality of the optics no um I would say that
they must be better than half way but you're not talking about eighth wave accuracy or anything
if one or two of them hit quarter wave astounding because it's a fairly very small mirrors on the
moon right well you see I I reasoned that I could have struggled on to try and get a greater shine
but I reasoned that if he had one of those as the primary and another piece of metal for the
secondary the two non-reflecting surfaces added together must have been atrocious so um I think
he must have struggled we used a piece of glass exactly so I worked on the principle that as we
had one really good reflecting surface I probably only needed to get the primary about two-thirds
as good as Newton would have got them to end up with a reasonable overall image that might match
his image and logically I figured them and I tested every individual one and every individual
one was tested on the moon and I could see craters with every individual mirror and I assumed I
figured it well enough it might be a quarter wave half wave but it's bright enough to show me a
picture of the moon it's bright enough to give me an image of the moon showing craters so I really
think if I carry on and try to improve it now I've learned to get this far um I'm going to go beyond
the point that Newton got yeah exactly there would be a problem here with you there was always going
to be a problem with you bringing your knowledge of the problems of turn down edge and the control
of the figure that you would be bringing to the party rather more than he he had not would have
had no idea about optical surfaces no one of the things if you remember at the time one of the
things that bothered us at an embarrassment level was that we were producing mirrors that most
people would look into and say oh what are you really saying the world's biggest scientist
produced a mirror that looked like yes well yeah we are yes we are yes yes the mirror he produced
actually wasn't very good you see this is what fascinates me because you get optical firms
and the whole of their being exists on the thing they produce looking perfect yes from the
scientific point of view what it looks like is of no consequence whatsoever it's the optical surface
that you can't see the quality of that counts yeah absolutely so it may look rubbish um but then
I was horrified when I saw my first real spitfire because I thought it was a beautiful glossy thing
and when you see lots of squares and metal all riveted together and oh dear what a terrible
disappointment but it works beautifully and it looks good from a distance and this looks good
from a distance well now that's a nice link back to the uh the architecture of the telescope because
um now what we've discussed here and the this alarmingly frustrating process that he must have
gone into yes of finding himself scrubbing away at this thing and getting absolutely nowhere or
getting a hint of something a tantalizing glimpse of something that was working and then losing it
yes could have I can picture him with several mirrors well that's why I was saying I wondered
if it started off with half a dozen blanks and kept on working on them and kept on checking and
discarding and slowly as he went he may have learned well that's one of the things that
obviously the telescope body um that is believed to be now our replica is a faithful replica of
some of that the parts of the relic in particular these different eyepiece positions yes it's very
tempting when you put the telescope together to to nose the eyepiece into that position
but there's no real evidence that the um mirror that was recovered with the telescope would have
actually required this to be in this position and there's also another eyepiece position that's
covered with a piece of cork and we've got that on our replica as well so the fact that a mirror
was eventually put in and used this eyepiece position now why would he have made this
architecture and then you know cut a piece out clearly he did this for one of his mirrors yes
he built this he had somebody make these parts for him for how he thought the mirrors were going
to be or perhaps one of the mirrors that he'd got ready to go but later on with different
experiments he's had to make changes to the system and i think that's the beautiful thing
about the royal society um relic that they've got um that it really does capture the um the
laboratory nature yes his first telescope where he was trying to put different things together
and what i would say is that the experience that you'd had with the very frustrating oh yeah
elements now obviously our mirrors to a certain degree were only millimeters different in focal
length because we had started out with a milled sagittar he did not have that advantage no he was
using a um a tool an oversized tool but he was constantly bumping his head on which bit of the
no no we don't know if the tool had flat areas on it we don't know no condition how that was made
no um so it could have been more like your story about galileo and the grinding yeah on on the eye
lenses on a cannonball it could be more like that kind of issue but certainly when you put some of
these ideas together i think it does throw cast some light on why the telescope would have this
and provisional character to it and i find it impossible to believe that the instrument maker
that the relics were given to would have preserved no why would you copy those faults of course not
all variations so clearly the these parts are almost the the body work of the logical yes
are almost certainly yeah the original original telescope not the parts that are obviously 18th
century like the eyepiece holder and things see the other interesting thing is that that
hole there which is a much relatively shorter focal you see is another isn't it down by another
f ratio there the f1 or f see look yes one two three it the first one was virtually probably
less than f4 focal length this one is probably f5 and the one out there may have been f55 or f6
now what fascinates me is that we all know that to figure an f4 mirror is much more complicated
than figuring an f6 he didn't know that no that's the interesting thing you see he had no idea about
optical figures now why did he was it just chance he had a very short focal length one did he
actually think to himself i'm going to get a brighter image or is that being too clever
why did he not think all refractors that work a very long focal length yes why do i not make a
long focal length mirror the same as a long focal length refractor which is guaranteed to give me a
so there was no thinking whatsoever about optical quality related to f ratio i suppose one way of
looking at that could be we could have when we did our made our blanks we could have very easily
got the hass mill to put almost any sagittar on here that we would have liked yes he would
have found that quite a bit harder making bigger and bigger especially when you consider that he's
using a portion of a much larger tool there would have been material cost and other difficulties he
would have encountered making a big tool so you think he acquired something of a possible curve
which which governed this and he never it never occurred to him did he want the compact telescope
was he interested was was one of his ideas to prove that refractors were very long and cumbersome
he could make a reflector and it didn't have to be long and cumbersome i think definitely if you
think about the the fashion of the day and the technology that was available yeah um and the
type of telescope you had to be using to be a name in observational astronomy it was something
with uh meters right so he would have said to himself long focal length lens is very cumbersome
but we know there's no chromatic aberration short focal length lenses are rubbish i can prove
short focal length mirror isn't rubbish that makes a lot of sense put that together with the
difficulty you would have yeah the tooling yeah i mean one of the interesting things here is that
he was able to go to um presumably a guild certified instrument maker in london and get
information like this out of it because they are well known for not giving information even to their
employees no uh they kept their their knowledge very safe and secure but so money must have
changed hands or he must have put a dagger at somebody's throat to get the information about
yeah but look if you turned up with a lump of metal and said i'm going to turn this through
an optical surface they thought well they're only interested in lenses they probably would have
laughed yeah they probably thought he was nutty so let the poor guy have some information about
how to polish his silly lump of metal no my imagines he wasn't taken too seriously no no
by people because he wouldn't have been but at that point uh people often forget he didn't get
his um uh appointment to the royal society no he wasn't inducted it was this telescope that
just a practical object yes yes so he wasn't exactly a household name when he was pestering
the instrument makers of london yeah so um and of course we do know that when the royal society
gave quite a bit of cash to a couple of instrument makers to make five and eight inch
mirrors they failed miserably really they completely failed to actually turn this idea
into a working telescope they could not manage it no exactly and even though they had this to
work from uh it was what 50 odd years i think more than that even before somebody successfully
replicated the idea of producing the telescope that we know and love the newtonian reflector
yeah so i think there's also the size of this telescope i think takes people by surprise as
well i think a lot of people oh you see the picture in books and you think oh it's a big
thing like this yeah you really see people handling it and i think people think oh you've
made a miniature a mini version you've made a mini version that's it yes yes telescope yes
oh it's fascinating yes quite incredible there wasn't that exciting that's about it for this
video uh if you want to find out more about newton's um first reflecting telescope um i can
suggest you find uh this monograph uh on the subject by alan mills and pj turvey uh reprinted
from the notes and records of the royal society of london it's a volume 33 number two from march
1979 you can find full details of the publication in the notes below this video as well as details
of the video that terry somewhat self-effacingly mentioned during the video in the notes below this
video as well anyway that's it for now um if you want to see more like this don't forget to
subscribe and do click on the little bell gadget to make sure that you get notifications
when we upload something new in case you missed something important anyway bye for now
