Sargent’s Dreamlike Study for 'Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose'

Antique Auction
8 followers
5 Video Views·Feb 11, 2026
During a summer spent in the Cotswolds in 1885, John Singer Sargent set out to paint a scene he described as “two little girls in a garden at twilight, lighting paper lanterns among the flowers.”
This oil study — focused on the elder sister, Polly Barnard — is one of the key preparatory works for 'Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose' (1885-86), Sargent’s luminous plein-air triumph.
Here, Sargent captures the soft radiance of Polly's complexion lit by her lantern, as floral forms dance against the deep green background. Painted outdoors in snatched minutes each evening before darkness fell, this study holds the same dreamlike atmosphere that would come to define his now iconic masterpiece.
In 1885, John Singer Sargent set out to capture a moment he described as two little girls in a
garden at twilight, lighting paper lanterns among the flowers from rose tree to rose tree.
This study focuses on Polly Barnard, one of the two sisters who posed for him in the Cotswold
village of Broadway. Her face is softly illuminated by the lantern she lights amid the deepening dusk.
Sargent painted outdoors, racing the fleeting evening light.
Each night, he had only minutes to work before darkness fell,
dashing forward to place quick strokes as the colours shifted around him.
A year later, the finished painting, Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose, appeared at the Royal Academy,
where London was enchanted by this poetic vision of childhood and twilight.
This small study instils the same sense of dreamlike magic that defines the finished work.
