Can Chemical Recycling Solve The World's Plastic Problem?

Protecting The Environment
106 followers
Plastics recycling is failing.
Globally, over 350 million metric tons of plastic are produced annually.
But according to the OECD, only 14 to 18 percent of that is recycled.
In the U.S., it's even bleaker.
The recycling rate stands at about 8.4 percent, a number that has been on the
decline, even as the public has become more aware of the plastic waste crisis.
While we're all so shocked at the amount of plastic waste we generate each day,
virgin plastic production keeps increasing 4 or 5 percent year over year.
China used to be able to profitably recycle much of the world's plastic
waste, but that came to a halt in 2018.
And now we have to deal with it domestically.
Problem is, most plastics just aren't recyclable.
And even those that are degrade in quality each time they're remade, meaning
they'll eventually end up in the landfill, too.
So we can't recycle our way out of this problem.
Or can we? Mechanical recycling won't save us.
That is chopping plastic up, melting it down and remaking it the way that we
do now. Instead, the industry is betting big on something called chemical
recycling, which can handle all types of plastic waste.
This new technology can take those plastics, break them down into the raw
materials and make brand new quality plastics out of them, which gives you a
much bigger expansion in terms of potential and market.
With governments around the world increasingly banning single-use
plastics, industry groups like the American Chemistry Council are hoping
that chemical recycling can save both the industry and the environment.
Companies like Brightmark, Plastic Energy and Agilex are now trying to turn
plastic into fuel and plastic back into plastic.
We are going to have plastics in the environment for the foreseeable future.
And I want to find what is the most optimal way to reduce waste and increase
the environmental sustainability aspect of those products that we use.
But skepticism abounds.
After all, plastic made from scratch is actually cheaper than recycled
plastic. So how will the economics even work out?
And can turning plastic into fossil fuels really be considered recycling?
Shouldn't we just focus on producing less in the first place?
It's up for debate.
There are thousands of varieties of plastics, but seven main categories, of
which only two can be recycled by traditional means.
PET, which water bottles are made of, and HDPE, used in things like milk
jugs and shampoo containers.
Sorting plastics and removing contamination is labor-intensive work.
And so since the 1980s, the United States, alongside other nations like the
U.K. and Australia, sent much of its plastic waste to China, where cheap
labor allowed Chinese producers to profitably recycle it.
But as single-stream recycling became the norm and plastic was thrown in
the same bin as glass, cardboard and other materials, China noticed
increasingly high contamination levels.
After years of warning, the country set strict new contamination limits on
imports that were nearly impossible to meet, leaving wealthy nations
scrambling to find new overseas markets.
What we have done over the last few years is to export to countries that
they have less infrastructure of what we have and then creating a much
bigger problem. So why not just develop the infrastructure to deal with
it locally? Basically, mechanical recycling in the U.S.
just isn't profitable without incentives or subsidies.
Virgin plastic is incredibly cheap, and we are seeing traditional
mechanical recycling operations shutting down because it simply does
not pay. They cannot sell their recycled plastic at a rate that would
justify paying people to collect.
But even as states like California try to prop up their curbside
recycling programs and centers with subsidies, there's still just so
much that can go wrong.
While number one and number two plastics are recyclable, about 70
percent end up in a landfill or incinerator anyway.
It's too contaminated or it's too difficult to separate.
And then the recycled polymer is sort of low grade.
And then on top of that, it's typically too expensive.
Absent strong regulation, public pressure or true altruism, there's just
no reason why a corporation would pay more for lower quality recycled
plastic. So we need to find something else.
And then, of course, something else would be switch materials or source
reduction, use less.
But obviously that would be bad news for the plastic industry.
So I think I see the only way forward is chemical recycling.
Enter chemical recycling, a process that can break down any plastic
type one through seven into its molecular building blocks and then
theoretically convert it into virgin quality plastic, chemicals or diesel
and petrol fuels.
There's been a huge investment in these chemical recycling technologies
in recent years. They've been very hyped by industry.
They're saying that these technologies are going to allow them to
capture a much broader stream of plastics and turn them back into
plastics like new so we could get more of a circular economy with that.
The most common technology used in this process, pyrolysis, is not new.
It involves heating up a material like waste plastic in an oxygen starved
environment, which causes it to break down into a mix of simpler
compounds, which are then used as building blocks for new products.
But critiques abound.
Tongari's organization, the Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives,
or GAIA, recently released a report which concluded that no chemical
recycling facility in the U.S.
is turning plastic back into plastic at a commercial scale yet, though
there's been many attempts.
Of the 37 chemical recycling facilities proposed in the U.S.
since 2000, GAIA reports that only three are operational and they're
mostly turning plastic into fuel, which the organization calls the
opposite of an eco-friendly solution.
The companies themselves, though, beg to differ.
Brightmark, founded in 2016, is building a commercial scale plastics to
fuel plant in Ashley, Indiana, and aims to process 100,000 tons of
plastic by 2021.
It will sell fuel from this plant to BP.
So ultimately, our goal is to produce less combustible fuels.
There are at least 14 percent less greenhouse gas emissions associated
with the fuels that we produce versus pulling crude oil or natural gas
out of the ground. In addition to fuels, Brightmark's process also
produces paraffin waxes, and Powell says the tech is ready to convert
plastic back into plastic.
They just need customers.
I think the market is there, and I think what you would see from us in
the future is relationships with folks that achieve our goals around
circularity and their goals around circularity, because we can do it
now. But in the meantime, Tancre questions whether turning plastic
into fossil fuel is really a solution worth supporting.
Is plastic to fuel better than, say, I don't know, syngas derived from
coal? Yeah, probably.
But who uses that?
It's on its way out. These are not clean fuels.
Whether they are absolutely the dirtiest or they're the second dirtiest
or the third dirtiest, they're clearly fossil fuels and they are highly
contaminated fossil fuels.
Then there's U.K.-based Plastic Energy, which is turning plastic back
into plastic on a commercial scale at two facilities in Spain.
We targeted to have a processing capacity sometime by 2023 of about
300,000 tons of end-of-life plastics per year.
Much like Brightmark, the company started off producing fuels.
Also through a pyrolysis-based process that converted plastic waste
into naphtha and diesel.
But now, Monreal says they're totally focused on plastic-to-plastic
recycling. Since April this year, 100% of our tackle is used to create
new plastics. We are committed to the creation of a circular economy for
plastics going forward.
Monreal says that Europe's ambitious environmental goals provide unique
incentives for this type of technology to flourish.
We have commitments to double the recycling quotas in Europe from about
5 million today per year to 10 million tons per year by 2025.
He also cites Europe's high landfilling fees and multistream recycling
infrastructure as advantageous.
With plastic, glass and cardboard already separated at the source,
Plastic Energy can acquire difficult-to-recycle plastics more easily and
economically than in the U.S.
As the company tries to increase its processing capacity by over 2,000
percent in the next three years, it may face competition from Oregon-based
Agilex, which is also trying to turn plastics back into plastics and is
looking to expand internationally.
We have a pathway and a road map to take plastic recycling from the
current 10 percent to upwards of 90 percent.
Agilex was one of the earliest companies in this space.
Founded in 2004, it ran a plastics-to-fuel operation until 2015, providing
jet fuel to the Department of Defense.
Low oil prices forced the company to pivot.
And now, Agilex specializes in converting polystyrene back into styrene,
which is used to make disposable cups, takeout containers and packing foam.
Agilex is often hailed as a leader in the space, but Gaia has called its
efficiency into question, reporting that only one-tenth of the waste that
Agilex processed in 2018 was actually turned into styrene, a figure that
the company disputes.
So, yes, they were significantly off on the yield numbers.
And if our yields were in a 10 to 20 percent range, we would not have an
economic plastic recycling pathway that the top companies in polystyrene
have embraced.
While Gaia says the company has not proven that it's capable of recycling
plastic on a commercial scale, Agilex is planning to expand its capacity
across the U.S., Europe and Asia, in conjunction with a number of
petrochemical partners such as America's Styrenex and Ineos.
The facility in Chicago that we're developing with Ineos Styrolution
will be 100 tons per day, 10 times the size of our Tigard, Oregon facility.
And as we replicate those, the scale of our recycled styrene will begin
to have a significant impact on the market.
Cooper says the company hasn't run a lifecycle analysis to see how its
recycled polystyrene compares to virgin polystyrene, but estimates the
process to be between 40 to 70 percent cleaner.
This number, too, is up for debate, but it's more than just a
disagreement over statistics.
Fundamentally, it's a disagreement over priorities.
Basically, there's not a consensus on whether chemical recycling will
represent an important part of the plastic waste solution or an expensive
distraction from what many believe ought to be the real priority, making
less plastic. There are people who embrace chemical recycling as an
emerging technology with an evolution path.
There are others more focused on reducing the amount of plastics that
we use as a country and as a world.
Not surprisingly, there's big policy disagreements as well.
For example, the fact that plastic industry groups enthusiastically
support chemical recycling while opposing policies like single-use
plastic bans or plastic taxes leaves many skeptical that the industry
would ever pursue eco-friendliness over profits.
The industry is investing so much money in chemical recycling because
they really want to convince us that they can continue to churn out
ever-large quantities of plastic and solve the problem downstream.
Tangri and many other environmentalists believe that instead of pursuing
chemical recycling, the plastic waste problem is best addressed through
legislation, in particular, extended producer responsibility laws that
force plastic producers to bear the cost for the environmental impacts of
their products. There are proposals that would impose a tax on plastic
producers proportional to the environmental and health harm that they
cause. The idea is that this would lead to less plastics production
overall, drive growth in the market for plastic alternatives and
incentivize consumers to turn to reusable materials instead.
But many champions of chemical recycling support a more free market
approach. If virgin plastics cost more because there's a tax on them, that
helps us out. But I think that open market competition is really the true
way in the long run to foster the innovation and the efficiency to drive
higher recycling rates across all plastic types.
Cooper's position is shared by industry groups like the American
Chemistry Council and the Plastics Industry Association, who say that
consumer demand and corporate pledges will make recycled plastic an
attractive option, even if virgin plastic remains cheaper.
Others, though, say legislation and chemical recycling both have a role to
play. Regulatory and governmental frameworks have really driven us
to where we're at the point now where there is an absolute demand to
deal with the issues of post-use plastics in the future.
Maybe there won't be a need for plastics and we find a better way of
doing things. But for the foreseeable, we are going to have plastics in
the environment. And so what we do is already environmentally better.
It will ultimately get even better as time goes on.
But for now, serious doubts about chemical recycling's efficacy,
environmental footprint and scalability remain, leading many to withhold
support in favor of starting with simpler solutions.
Overall, I always like to start with the easiest, most obvious solutions.
And I think there are many, many places where we could just use less
plastic without compromising our quality of life.
I think it'll take a lot more than just coming up with a handful of
amazing technologies to fix this.
