“Recycling as a system has become increasingly problematic. The truth of the matter is only a very small percentage of the plastic that's out in the consumer waste stream actually gets recycled at the end of the day. … At the best case scenario, it goes into the landfill. Worst case scenario, it ends up in our water streams, in our ocean, in our environment. … And in fact, so much of it is out there, and so much of it ends up breaking down into micro plastics and ending up in our food stream, in our water stream, and it's ending up in our own bodies,” says California Senator Ben Allen.
Join us as we dive into the challenges the recycling industry is facing, and his efforts in bringing the plastic industry and other producers to the table to solve the recycling problem. We also dive into Allen's personal experience as a senator and what inspired him to go into public service.
*Views expressed in this video/article are opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of California Insider.
Recycling as a system has become increasingly problematic.
The truth of the matter is, only a very small percentage of the plastic
that's out in the consumer waste stream actually gets recycled at the end of the day.
It goes into the landfill, right?
The best case scenario, it goes to the landfill.
Worst case scenario, it ends up ending up in our water streams,
in our ocean, in our environment.
And in fact, so much of it is out there,
and so much of it ends up breaking down into microplastics
and ending up in our food stream, in our water stream,
and it's ending up in our own bodies.
My guest today is California State Senator Ben Allen.
He'll discuss the challenges the recycling industry is facing
and his efforts on bringing the plastic industry
and other producers to the table to solve the recycling problem.
We also dive into Ben's experience as a senator
and his personal motivation for public service.
After you get off of the campaign trail,
and you've heard about all these issues in your constituency,
then you're up there fighting over things
that never came up once during your campaign.
But there are really hot issues there.
Scope of practice battles, right?
I mean, the podiatrists want to be able to work further up the leg,
and the cosmetic surgeons are fighting against the plastic surgeons.
I didn't even know there was a difference between them
before I got into this, but they hate each other.
There's just all these battles that are constantly at play.
I'm Siamak Khorrami. Welcome to California Insider.
Ben, it's great to have you on. Welcome.
Thank you. Thanks for having me. Appreciate it.
You know, recycling is a big topic for Californians,
and a lot of Californians care about the environment.
And we are in the position to do that in California.
A couple of years ago, we covered the fact that
recycling in some cases was not happening,
because China was buying a lot of our recyclable materials.
And then they stopped buying sometime during the pandemic
or right after the pandemic.
Right before, actually.
Right before the pandemic.
And then things were going in the landfill.
What's the status?
Well, we're working on it.
So China implemented this national sword policy,
which said, we don't want your junk anymore, basically.
And so much of our material was going off there.
And in many respects, we were kind of living a lie.
Were they buying it or were they?
They were buying it.
But in the end of the day,
so much of it was not actually getting recycled.
Partly because a lot of it was contaminated.
I mean, we had mixed bales that were very hard to sort.
And partly because there's not a very strong market
for plastics recycling.
If you really stop to think about it,
I mean, the industry has pushed this idea
that recycling is the solution.
But if you really stop to think about it,
it's actually, at least with regards to plastics,
a very time and cost intensive process
to sort the materials,
make sure that they're sorted out
into the right resin types,
and then to go through the process of melting down
and recreating a new product using that material.
Especially when you compare it
to how low plastic prices have been,
virgin plastic, because of lower oil prices.
It's so much easier and so much cheaper
to just take the plastic base
from the oil refining process
and turn it into new product.
And so recycling as a system
has become increasingly problematic.
What we've tried to do with the passage of SB54
and some legislation before that
is to say we're actually going to hold
the industry accountable to its claims.
You claim these products that you keep pushing out
onto the market are recyclable.
Well, you got to actually,
we're going to hold you responsible to that,
to these aggressive rates of recycling.
And if you can't meet those rates,
then you need to transition
toward a new type of product
that's going to be more environmentally friendly.
And that's the core concept
behind this whole idea
of extended producer responsibility,
which is to say to producers,
you know your product the best,
you have the most control over your product,
you know your market the best,
you know your customers the best.
We need you to take an active role
in determining and ensuring
that the products that you keep pushing out
into the market
are not going to end up being a massive burden
on both our environment and on rate payers,
which is what's been happening.
I mean, so much of this stuff ends up
in our waste stream.
It ends up in our rivers and ocean.
It ends up filling up our landfills
and those additional costs
associated with managing all that additional waste
is being borne by regular people.
We've seen rates continue to rise.
And so we, you know,
through this legislation,
we are finally holding these producers responsible
and holding them accountable
for the true costs
associated with their products
and actually inviting them
to be part of the solution
by creating responsibility on their part
and accountability,
which will then encourage them
to move toward more sustainable alternatives.
We are covering California issues, as you know.
If you want us to cover the stories
that are impacting your day-to-day life in California,
reach out to me at siamakcaliforniainsider.com.
You mentioned we were kind of sold a lie.
Can you explain that?
I think over time,
there are a lot of people in the plastics industry,
which is a fossil fuel based,
let's remember plastic is an oil product.
A lot of people don't know this,
but it's an oil product.
And so the oil folks behind the plastics industry
have been promoting the use of plastics
over a long period of time.
Plastics are durable,
it's cheap,
it's strong,
it's easy to use,
it's convenient.
So all of those things have been used
to get plastics into more and more of daily life.
And I remember, I'm not that old.
I remember when they started introducing water bottles.
At the Dodger games.
And I remember thinking to myself,
gosh, why would someone want to pay money?
I was a little kid.
Why would someone want to pay money to pay for water?
Because we used to have drinking fountains.
But of course now it's ubiquitous, right?
Everyone has water bottles and plastic water bottles.
It's just a thing people do.
But it wasn't something that was a common thing back in the day.
But again, that was an example of the plastics industry
pushing this product out on people,
recognizing that folks might find this attractive.
And what they've done throughout all this time
is tell the consumer,
it's up to you to go recycle these products.
Take these plastic products,
feel good about continuing to buy plastics,
put it in the recycling bin,
and we're going to recycle it.
It'll get recycled.
The truth of the matter is,
only a very small percentage of the plastic
that's out in the consumer waste stream
actually gets recycled at the end of the day.
But people think that it's getting recycled.
And they put it into the blue bin.
In fact, in many ways,
it actually makes the recycling system less efficient
because so much plastic is being put
into the recycling waste bins.
And it then creates a whole new cost
associated with sorting out the non-recyclable plastics
or the stuff where there's no market for recycling.
I mean, I do this myself.
I love the newspaper, right?
You're a newspaper guy.
I literally still get the LA Times every day.
And it comes in a plastic bag.
Used to be that little plastic bag had a recycling symbol.
By the way, I don't know why it needs to be in a plastic bag.
It never rains, but there we are.
It used to always have a little recycling symbol
on the plastic bag.
And I would dutifully separate it out,
put it into the recycling bin,
assuming it's got the recycling symbol,
it's getting it recycled.
Come to find out through my job
that actually all of this,
all these bags are gumming up the system.
They're really hard to sort.
They end up actually getting into a lot of the paper bales,
which contaminate the paper bales.
It's part of why China,
one of the many reasons why China
didn't want our stuff anymore
because all of this plastic film was getting stuck
in other bales of other products
and making it much harder.
The little thin plastic film
that would both gum up the machines,
end up in the paper bales,
end up in other bales,
and make it harder for the whole system to work properly.
And it's just one of many examples
of how for most consumers,
they want to do the right thing.
They've been told by the plastics industry
that plastics are not a bad product for the environment.
The more I got into this issue,
the more I came to realize
how much we are all paying,
both environmentally and financially,
to cover up for,
to band-aid over the implications
and the impacts of this massive surge of plastic products
that have been pushed upon us by the plastics industry.
And it's part of why I ended up
getting involved in this issue
and doing the legislation that I've done,
which finally says to them,
look, you gotta be part of the solution.
You gotta be,
we're gonna hold you accountable
to your recyclability claims.
Just because something is technically recyclable,
if it's not actually getting recycled
under real world conditions,
that doesn't help anybody.
And so, if you're gonna claim
these things are recyclable,
you've actually gotta be,
you gotta make sure they're actually getting recycled.
And in fact,
if you're not finding a way to recycle these products,
we gotta transition to more sustainable alternatives.
What percentage of the things
that we put into the bin is getting recycled?
Is there a number on that?
Yeah, most plastics are not recycled.
The one exception-
Even the water bottles?
The water bottles are the one exception.
They are recycled in California
at about a 75% rate.
By the way, it should be 95%
because they are highly recyclable.
Even people put them in the bin?
Most of the stuff that gets in the bin
ends up getting recycled,
of those water bottles.
Most states, by the way,
those water bottles are getting recycled
at about a 35%, 25% rate,
so much lower.
We just happen to have a better system.
People put it into their bin.
Or in other states-
A lot of states,
they don't even have recycling bins
because the recycling market is so weak
that a lot of places
where they don't have
the kind of environmental ethos that we have,
it makes no environmental,
it makes no financial sense
to even encourage people to recycle
because the market is so weak.
Even those plastic water bottles
are typically getting downcycled
in the sense that they are,
yes, they're being turned into something new,
but it's usually something of lesser value.
That's one of the big problems we have
is it's all very good
for something to be technically recyclable.
It's all very good for it to be easily recyclable,
but if the market,
if there's this in a market to buy-
It doesn't make financial sense, right?
Then it doesn't make financial sense.
And then that doesn't help either.
So we shouldn't be continuing
to promote the use of products
on the grounds of recyclability
if there's no real market
for the end product of that item
once it's been recycled.
Now, Ben, was there a time
you figured this out,
that you saw this is-
Because this was shocking to me
when I found out that
a lot of these things
might not be getting recycled.
This all started for me
when I read a newspaper article
about China's national sword policy.
And I remember I sent it to my chief of staff,
my chief environmental staffer.
I said, we got to do something about this.
This is a real problem
because the LA Times was banging the drum
about what a massive challenge
this was going to be for everybody,
especially given what
a big revenue source it was.
I mean, you say we did used to sell.
I think the city of Los Angeles
was making about $5 million a year
off of selling this stuff.
And now, then all of a sudden,
they're losing over $1 million a year
just on trying to deal with the cost
of getting it out, yeah,
of putting in the landfill, et cetera.
So that article sent me down a rabbit hole.
And we ended up,
I've toured so many recycling facilities
and dumps and sorting facilities
and landfills now.
I've met with environmental leaders,
with local governments,
with waste haulers,
with industry folks,
plastics manufacturers,
recyclers and journalists.
And I just started to learn
about how incredibly
dysfunctional the system was.
And that's what led me
toward the eventual passage of these bills
and really digging in deep,
coming up with some systems.
Then that's what launched
this massive negotiation
that I helped to lead
between local government,
who of course are paying
the price of the dysfunction.
Because they are collecting
all the trash.
Local government is sort of the,
they're the ones ultimately
who are held responsible
for waste management.
So that's the thing.
I mean, while people say,
oh, by imposing new costs
on the manufacturers,
you may increase the cost of plastic.
Well, to the extent that may be true,
if that is a real issue,
don't forget,
right now the plastics manufacturers
are pushing the cost associated
with their cheap,
low retail price products
on the rest of us.
There's the rest of us,
it's our local governments
that are picking up the tab.
It's the cities.
And of course, what do they do?
They pass it on to the rate payers, us.
And that's why we've seen
our waste hauling rates
continuing to rise.
And so that's why cities
were such an important part
of the conversation.
And quite frankly,
they were the most important ally
throughout the process
was the League of Cities,
as we were trying to get these bills passed.
Because they're the ones
who are at the front of the line
in terms of the impact.
They're the ones who have been able
to see the problem
up close and personal.
And it was starting
to constrain their budgets.
So what you're saying
is that there are items made
that are at a low cost
because they can be made
at a low cost,
like plastic items,
packaging, all that.
And then they are kind of
promoted as recyclable.
So people buy them,
they use them,
they put them in a recycling bin.
But then to recycle them,
it'll cost a fortune.
Yes.
It doesn't make sense.
So then they don't get recycled.
Why would anyone ever
want to recycle something
when they go through the hassle
of sorting them
and melting them down
and turning them into something
that they can't sell
at a price that justifies
all the expenses associated
with sorting.
So it's partly why
so many states have just given up
on blue bins altogether.
And where does it go?
It goes into the landfill, right?
Goes to the landfill.
The best case scenario
goes to the landfill.
Worst case scenario,
it ends up ending up
in our water streams,
in our ocean,
you know, in our environment.
And of course, we know
that the amount of plastic
out in the environment
is shot up.
And in fact,
so much of it is out there
and so much of it
ends up breaking down
into microplastics
and ending up in our food stream,
in our water stream,
and it's ending up
in our own bodies.
So there's now,
they found plastics in placentas
in our skin, in our blood.
You know, and if you think
about the fact that we now,
this is basically fossil fuel
that is now in our bodies.
Every single one of us,
you have about a credit card worth,
I mean,
there's all sorts of arguments
about the size of a credit card.
Well, who knows, right?
But there's more than that
in your body right now,
in plastic.
Does it come through the food
or does it?
Food and water, typically, yeah.
It's so hard to get rid of, right?
It's not a,
your body isn't designed
to excrete this stuff.
Other states have given up
on this, right?
Yes, because they're not willing
to take,
to do the hard work
of holding the industry accountable
and the market has fallen out
on the materials.
What we're hoping to do
with our legislation, of course,
is by forcing the whole system
to be more responsive
to the realities
that we've just been discussing
and by forcing
the product manufacturers
to actually take into account
true recyclability,
true compostability,
and most importantly,
waste reduction, source reduction,
will both help to spur markets
for circularity
so that those products
that actually really can find an end use
will find an end use
that actually has...
So if they make them,
it is really recyclable
and then there is a financial model
for the recycling.
For the recycling, exactly.
And we'll also create more
of a financial market
for alternatives
that are more environmentally friendly.
And one of the really,
the things I'm most proud of
with this bill having passed
is that I'm now hearing
from some of those young,
exciting California innovators
that have been out there
banging their head against the wall,
trying to get the Walmarts
and the Targets
and the Costco's of the world
to call them back
because they had these really cool,
environmentally friendly alternatives
to plastic.
They're finally getting calls back.
There's a guy out there,
I'll give you one example,
has created an alternative to Styrofoam.
Styrofoam, if you think about it,
what is Styrofoam there for?
It's basically,
in most cases,
it's there to help you get your TV
from Best Buy to your house
without getting cracked or dinged.
It's literally just a padding.
I mean, you could wrap that TV in a blanket.
I mean, it would probably do the same thing,
but it's just this cheap oil-based product
that pads your stuff.
Well, this guy came up with an alternative.
It's made up of shrimp shells
and cornstarch and vinegar,
and it does exactly the same job
of providing padding
to protect appliances.
And unlike Styrofoam,
you could take those natural alternative foam,
that natural alternative foam,
throw it off the Santa Monica Pier,
and it would be completely biodegraded
with no negative environmental impact
within about 15 years.
No toxins.
It's all natural ingredients.
Whereas Styrofoam, as we know,
breaks up into tiny pieces.
It gets into the fish.
It gets into the bloodstream.
Now, all of a sudden,
it's in our bodies
and in our water stream.
And impacting our environment.
So there are really great folks out there
that have been coming up
with the alternatives
to these plastic products.
What's the cost?
Is there a cost model?
That's why they don't accept them.
Is there a big discrepancy?
You know, it's like so many things.
You don't make the change
unless you have to.
I mean, I'll give you one example.
The car companies, for example,
didn't want the California
air quality regulators
to tell them that they had to switch
toward lower polluting
emissions technology
in their automobiles.
But it got to a point
where kids were growing up
with half of the lung capacity
in South LA
versus rural parts of the country.
We couldn't even see the Hollywood sign
because the smog was so bad.
So the regulators said,
you've got to switch
to these lower burning technologies.
They kicked and screamed,
but they did it.
And now we've got much
cleaner burning cars,
even though there's
many more cars on the road
and we can actually see
the Hollywood sign.
Even though there's a lot more traffic
than there was in the 70s.
When you say what's the cost,
you've got to take into account
the total cost, right?
It's so yes, yes,
the imposition of those
that new technology
did lead to a marginal increase
in the cost of automobile purchases.
However, what is the cost associated with
with all the health care impacts
of the pollution
that was caused by those cars?
So what are the costs
that we're currently bearing
as ratepayers or as cities
to handle the influx
of plastic waste?
That's all money that's coming
out of our city coffers.
That means that they have less money
for senior programs
and school programs
and parks and transportation.
I mean, from my perspective,
you've had these plastics manufacturers
that have basically been freeloading
off of the rest of us.
We're all it's not that
there's not a cost
associated with these products.
It's it's it's just that
they're not paying for the cost.
We are.
And it's just not fair.
And so that's ultimately
what this is about.
It's about saying to them,
look, you've got to play
a part in helping us
to come up with solutions here.
You've got to come up with more
environmentally friendly alternatives
and we will all benefit as a result.
If you like California Insider
and you like to know
what's going on in California,
make sure to check out Epoch Times.
This is a newspaper that started
by a group of Chinese Americans
because of human right abuses in China
and now is starting to grow here.
Make sure to go to the Epoch Times
website and check out
the California section
where you can get a lot
of fresh perspectives
on what's going on in California.
Now, let's go back to the interview.
Is there a model for that
where people can do products
that you can actually recycle
and have benefits?
So can that industry,
the ones that are making
plastic bags change in a way
where they can make it degradable?
Well, this is the beauty
of what we did, right?
I mean, we this is actually
a free market model
that said that I had industry
at the table negotiating.
So we they were part of the
they were part of the negotiations.
I mean, ultimately, we say to them,
here are the rules.
You got to meet these rates
for circularity
or you got to find another product
over a runway of time.
And industry,
you know your products better.
You know your market better.
You know the technology the best.
Figure it out.
We all know that
there are alternatives out there.
They will either turn
to those alternatives
or they will find a way
to make their current product
more environmental friendly.
And that process is underway.
And it's part of why
those innovators
that I was telling you about,
like the, you know,
the styrofoam alternatives
are getting is getting the call back
because all of a sudden
these businesses
are actually interested
in checking out their product.
People aren't they don't change
unless they have to.
Most of the time,
especially in business,
because they've got these tight margins
and they have a system
that's always been run
a certain way
and they just don't have
any incentive to change
unless they have to.
I mean, there was an example
of some company
that changed its, you know,
it's it's the resin type
on its detergent bottle.
Just for, I think,
some marginal pricing benefit
and maybe with some aesthetic thing.
And that rendered the item
used to be totally recyclable.
Now it's not recyclable.
But again, they didn't have any.
There was no incentive for them
to even think about recyclability
when they were pushing
these products out.
And that's what we're
that's what we're addressing
with this legislation.
Now, Ben, do you think
this kind of legislation
will have an impact globally?
That is one of the things
that California does.
Sometimes we are doing bigger things,
but then does it have an impact
on the rest of?
I said every step of the way
during the process of this,
this legislation making its way
through the legislature.
If this doesn't influence,
impact national
and indeed global markets,
we won't be doing our job.
I will consider this a failure.
Now, literally today,
I just came.
I was late because I was meeting
with the consul general from Finland
and we were talking
about this very issue.
And there's there's so much interest
in cooperation
between the Nordic countries
in California on this topic
as we as we help,
you know, those businesses
and innovators that are coming up
with better alternatives.
So just like with cars, right?
When when Los Angeles,
when California made that decision
to force the industry
to come up with their mission
to lower emissions
and lower the smog,
that actually sent ripples
around the world
because it created the imperative
for the car companies
to come up with better technologies here.
So then all of a sudden it becomes
it's almost like the solar stuff, right?
I mean, it used to be
so it was very expensive.
We required it.
And so the price plummeted.
So now other countries say,
wait a minute,
you can't tell me anymore
that you can't do this.
You're doing it already
and you're doing it
successfully in California.
So we want to impose
the same emission standards.
Similarly, we prove the model here.
It will give an opportunity
to other parts of the country
and other other parts of the world
to say to the plastics manufacturers,
you know, we want less crap.
We want less waste trash.
That's flooding our landfills.
We know you can do better.
You're doing it there.
We want you to do it here, too.
And then it becomes
kind of a virtuous cycle
where they are able to take advantage
and their environment
is able to take advantage
of the innovation that we've done here.
And hopefully California
businesses and innovators
will be able to profit from that,
quite frankly,
as the front line fighters
and innovators in this space.
Now, for those of us
that may not know about the landfills,
you visited a lot of them, right?
Yeah.
How much volume is coming in
and how much space do they have?
Massive amounts.
I mean, they're just they're dirty.
They are they create
a ton of truck traffic.
There's a lot of waste
that blows off of them.
There's there's air pollutant issues.
I mean, we've got a massive
underground fire that's happening
up in Chiquita Canyon right now.
And people who live nearby
are getting headaches and there's cancer.
I mean, there's all sorts of health impacts.
There was a big battle recently
about the possible creation
of a new landfill
down in San Diego County.
And a lot of people not wanting
one near where they live
or not wanting to see landfills expand.
Landfills are really not
that they're not pleasant places.
They pollute.
We literally we just shove
all this crap into into the ground.
And we keep digging and shoving more.
Exactly.
And literally, I mean, right now,
as we speak, there is an active fire
that is burning its way through
because it's just this mix of of fuel
and plastic and paper and phosphate
and, you know, junk.
I mean, there's everything, everything
and everything you can imagine.
I mean, refrigerators.
I mean, just everything
is thrown together and pushed together
and often heats up
and there's chemicals in there
and there's liquid and there's
it's very hard to manage.
You know, as much as they say
that they do everything they can
to ensure that this stuff
doesn't leach into the ground.
There have been unfortunate examples
where it has, which then implicates
our groundwater system.
And again, right now, I mean, if you know,
I encourage you, your next interview
ought to be with Pilar Schiavo,
who's my colleague in the state assembly,
who represents the northwest
San Fernando Valley,
who just recently stayed
with some of her constituents
who live right by Chiquita Canyon,
this beautiful neighborhood.
And so many of them are now having
all sorts of health problems
because of this fire
that they can't get under control
that's deep within the landfill.
Which is burning all that material
that is underground.
And then it's getting
into everyone's bodies
and there's been cancer
and all sorts of problems.
Now you're working outside of plastic.
You're working on some other items
that are going on the landfill.
How many items are there?
So we're trying to expand
this extended producer responsibility model
to cover lots of other kinds of products,
textiles, food, electric vehicle batteries,
solar panels.
There's work underway
on a whole range of mattresses and carpet.
We need to redo those plans.
So there's a lot of products out there.
I mean, nearly every product, quite frankly,
we could do a better job of managing.
The traditional capitalist model
has just put all of the incentive
on keeping the initial price low
for the sale of a product
without taking into account
the end management, the life cycle.
And so the whole concept
of extended producer responsibility
is to build the total cost
of the life cycle of a product
into the economic model.
First of all, so that our rate payers,
our cities and our citizens
are being treated more fairly
in this grand scheme.
But then also the product manufacturers
do more to take into account
and design a system,
both the actual product design,
but then the distribution chain design
to better ensure
a more responsible management of the product
at the end of life.
Do you think California
with the model
that you guys are introducing,
is this a unique model?
Are we the first?
Well, some aspects of it are unique.
We're the first to require
source reduction, for example,
to force the industry
to just think about
putting less crap out onto the market.
But it's very much inspired by
and in conversation
with other jurisdictions.
British Columbia,
highest among them probably,
but also Ontario and Quebec.
In the United States,
Oregon and Washington and Maine
and several Northeastern states.
Globally, the UK
and the Scandinavian countries,
Japan's got some good programs in place.
So it's definitely a part
of a broader global conversation.
I will say, though,
my friend was at the International Conference
on the Oceans in Portugal
when the announcement was made
that the governor had signed our bill.
And literally everyone
started getting an alert
about it on their phones.
And the whole conference erupted in applause
because there was a recognition
of how important this was globally.
So it is absolutely
part of a global conversation
inspired by other
laws from different parts of the world.
But we also are helping.
We're trying to push forward
the broader conversation
and encourage others to be part of it.
And then, by the way, others will.
I mean, there was, I think,
Vermont and Maine,
we failed to pass the bill,
then they stepped up and passed a bill,
and then our bill passed
and it was better than theirs.
So we're part of, as I say,
it's a virtuous cycle,
a virtuous conversation
between various jurisdictions
as we try to outdo each other,
but in so doing, help each other.
And it's a good thing.
It's a good thing.
I'm proud of it.
Now, one other thing.
You mentioned forcing the industry,
but you, at the same time,
you're saying you're bringing
the industry to the table.
Is there a point that they may not
want to come to the table?
Or do you think the California market
is big enough and the cost
is not that big for them to participate?
Well, look, they will come to the table
if they have to come to the table.
They will also fight us tooth and nail
if they don't believe that
what we're doing is reasonable.
And I guess our job was to find a model
that was going to meet our needs
as a society, as an environment.
As rate payers.
While also not proposing something
that they simply couldn't do,
or they couldn't.
They would leave, like.
Yeah, and it had to be economically viable.
It had to be logistically viable.
And it's part of why,
in the end of the day,
we really focus on giving them,
putting them in the driver's seat.
We don't have some bureaucrat
in Sacramento telling them
exactly what to do.
They create their own producer
responsibility organizations as industry.
Now, they are held accountable
to these ambitious rates and dates
for circularity, for recyclability,
for compostability, for source reduction.
But they ultimately have
both the responsibility,
but also the opportunity to figure it out.
And that's why it is,
as opposed to a command and control system,
where some bureaucrats telling them
what to do and how to do it.
And they appreciated that.
I mean, they appreciated the fact
that they were at the heart of the plan
for finding the solutions.
Ben, do you have any other thoughts for our audience?
Yeah, I just think the more people
can educate themselves
about the way the system works.
I know this is like a crazy idea,
but go visit your local
recycling center or landfill.
I know it sounds like not a fun thing to do,
but actually it's really interesting.
It's really interesting.
And people can visit them?
Is it okay?
You have to make arrangements,
but typically it's not that hard.
And I can certainly help people
with this if they want.
We've helped different political clubs
or organizations plan trips to see.
And I know that our recycling center
in Santa Monica,
they have school groups come and see.
Because I think when you go
to one of these places
and you just see the impact
of our collective consumer behavior
and our throwout behavior,
it leaves an impression on you.
It really helps you grapple
with what role you've helped to play
in this problem that we have.
Because it's so easy to just
put your stuff in these bins
and they magically disappear
and you never have to think about it again.
We've done such a good job
of just taking care of this problem
and pulling it out of your sight,
out of mind.
But these products don't
just magically disappear.
They actually go somewhere.
And there's a lot of problems
associated with it.
And so just the more people
can educate themselves,
even if you don't want to go
to one of these sites,
learn about it, read about it.
There are some wonderful videos
and there's some wonderful documentary films
that have been made on this topic too.
And I can give you a list
that people ought to watch
because it's a difficult
and important topic that merits.
It's not rocket science.
It's not that complicated,
but it's complicated enough
that people need to spend
a few minutes on getting
their head around it.
You have to see it, kind of.
You have to see it to understand.
It really helps.
You are a senator.
You're a state senator in California.
You're serving about
a million people, right?
That's right, yep.
And how did you get into this?
I've been interested in public service
since I was a little kid.
I like the work.
It's meaningful.
It's important.
It's eclectic.
It's diverse, as we were discussing.
One of the things that's really fun
about the job is that every day
I get to work on 15 new things.
I mean, today alone,
I was dealing with
working on an insurance issue,
talking about environmental policy,
talking about higher education.
I mean, every day there's a strange
and wonderful mix of issues
that you get to work on.
I had, I suppose it was a real desire
to get to do this kind of work,
work on policy.
And then, of course,
you have to be willing
to put yourself forward,
which is a scary thing to do.
And I had been serving
on the school board
in Santa Monica, Malibu.
When this position opened up,
I was teaching at UCLA Law School
and working as a lawyer in town.
So I think when the opportunity
presented itself for me
to run for this position,
I guess I'd been thinking about
writing and teaching
state policy issues for some time.
And it was a very short time window
to decide whether to do it or not.
I mean, because our congressman
decided very last minute
to not run for re-election.
So our state senator,
whose job I now have jumped in
for the congressional race
instead of running for re-election.
And maybe if I had more time,
maybe I wouldn't have decided to do it.
But I really had to decide
in a matter of days.
And I figured, you know what?
This will be a few months
till the primary.
If I get past the primary,
that's a good thing.
If not, I get my life back.
I'll go do what I'm doing.
Maybe I'll teach a class
about the experience.
And in one very, very,
very difficult year later,
I emerged victorious
and ultimately won this election.
But it was a really wild experience
running for office at this level.
But very fulfilling.
I met incredible people.
And it's been a great experience ever since.
I've been 10 years in the job,
which is hard to even believe.
It just feels like yesterday
when I was first running.
And it's given me the chance
to work on so many important issues.
We were talking about recycling earlier.
I've delved into environmental policy,
but also education policy
and campaign finance reform,
political reform, elections policy,
health issues, homelessness,
housing, transportation.
I mean, the list goes on and on and on.
And it's been a real,
truly an honor and very fulfilling
to do this work.
You mentioned one year of difficult time.
How was it difficult?
Oh, it's just, it's relentless.
I mean, when you run,
there's just no,
there was no time for a break.
It doesn't matter how well you feel that day.
It doesn't matter how little sleep
you get the night before.
You just have to be,
it's your one opportunity
when you're running in a district
of a million people,
and certainly at a higher level,
it's typically the one chance,
whoever you're meeting with that day,
whatever group you're talking to,
that's going to be their one real-
They're not coming back.
Yeah, just one.
And so it's your one opportunity
to make a good impression upon them,
to hear them,
to make them feel good about you
being their representative,
looking out for them,
looking out for their community
and their interests.
And so you just have to be on.
You have to be on.
And of course,
you're up against really talented people
who want the job just as well,
as much as you do want it.
And it's a truly zero-sum game.
This is not,
it's not like the Olympics
where you get gold,
you get a medal,
even if you come in third.
I mean, if you,
one person wins the position
and everybody else doesn't.
And so it's,
and I was up against
some really talented, excellent people.
I mean, some really good people
who were running for the position as well.
And so I had to differentiate myself.
So it was hard.
It was exhausting,
but it was fun too.
It was fun in its own way.
I mean, I think part of it,
part of how you get through a year like that
is to enjoy aspects of it,
is to make sure you extract
from the experience
all of the excitement
associated with learning new things
and meeting new people
and testing yourself,
testing, putting yourself
in these uncomfortable positions
where you're having to come up
with positions on things
that maybe you hadn't thought about
very much before.
And did you have to come
with positions on the spot
or did you have to just come up?
That's a good question.
I mean, I wouldn't come up with things.
I tried to read as much as I could.
I tried to have
as many informative conversations as I could.
So I tried to prepare as best I could
before every interview
and every debate
and every discussion
and meeting I had.
But sure, I mean, sometimes,
I mean, I would usually say,
here's what I think
about what you've just asked me.
I want a little bit more time
to understand it
and get to know it better,
maybe read a little bit more.
But here's my initial feeling.
And I'll let you know.
And I'd love you to give me your thoughts.
So that was typically what I would do
as opposed to just taking
some kind of rock hard position
on an issue
without...
What was the range of these issues?
Did you have some?
Would you mind sharing some of them
that was difficult to think about?
I mean, everything.
I mean, development politics,
the California, the CEQA,
regulation, taxation,
school finance,
health issues.
How do we structure the health system?
What do we do about homeless?
Civil liberties questions,
policing,
budgetary priorities,
equity and racial issues,
schooling questions,
curricular questions,
labor questions.
And all these things
are things you ultimately have to vote on.
So people,
there's a reason why they're asking you
about your positions
because in the end of the day,
you're going to be casting votes
that really impact
the direction of the state
on all of these different matters.
So they have a right to know
what your feelings and thoughts are.
You don't, as I say,
you don't have to have
a perfectly baked answer,
but they do expect you to grapple
and research and think and read
about these things.
And there's probably about
500 different topics
that you really need to get to know.
And what makes it extra hard
is that they're complicated.
By the way, I didn't even get into energy.
I mean, that's a whole nother subject
that I've gotten to learn a lot about.
So in order to do this job well,
you really have to,
you have to be a voracious
and energetic learner
and thinker and listener.
And so it's part of
what makes the job hard,
but it's part of what
makes it fun and challenging.
Before we continue,
we would like to thank Shen Yun
for sponsoring this channel.
I lived in China for two years
and experienced two different Chinas.
One is the China we know now,
unfortunately with communism.
And the other is ancient Chinese culture
with 5,000 years of history,
strong values,
ethics and morality
that has been lost.
Shen Yun Performing Arts
is reviving this 5,000 years
of Chinese traditional culture.
It takes you back in time
to magical world of ancient China
with a unique blend
of brilliant dancing,
beautiful costumes
and legends coming to life.
Go to ShenYun.com
to find out the schedule
and theater information.
It's a lifetime experience
you don't want to miss.
Just so inspiring.
It makes me want to go dance.
Breathtaking.
I was very impressed.
I'm taking my program
and I'm going to mention it
on the news
because I think it's a great performance
and people should see it.
What I loved about the show
was the authenticity of it.
It was taking me on a journey.
Exceptional.
The technique involved there.
The thousands of hours of training.
People just float.
Everything was exact
and then they worked
to the exact moment
and it was beautiful.
You go away feeling
with a smile in your heart from it.
Have to come.
Life-changing.
Make sure you see it.
Don't wait.
Get your tickets now.
And what was it like
when you got started?
Well, they always say
when you first get up there
it's like drinking out of a firehose.
You've got so many people to meet.
You've got to learn about the culture
and the system up there.
And it doesn't mean you have to accept
everything about the culture
and the system up there
but you have to learn about it at least
so you can navigate
within the system there.
There's a whole world of people in Sacramento
that are different
and it's a whole world of issues.
So after you get off of the campaign trail
and you've heard about all these issues
in your constituency
then you're up there
fighting over things
that never came up once
during your campaign.
But there are really hot issues there.
Scope of practice battles, right?
I mean, the podiatrists
want to be able to work further up the leg
and the cosmetic surgeons
are fighting against the plastic surgeons.
I didn't even know
there was a difference between them
before I got into this
but they hate each other, right?
They're just in massive battles
over licensing
and then you've got
the doctors are fighting against
the hospitals
and the insurance industry
and the nurses.
I mean, everyone's got different,
you know, the optometrists
are fighting against the ophthalmologists
but all of them lock arms
to fight against the trial lawyers, right?
So there's just all these battles
that are constantly at play up there
and you just have to do your best
to listen to everybody,
hear them out,
learn about why
people feel as strongly as they do
and then try to come up
with some wise public policy
and so it's,
yeah, as I say,
drinking out of a firehose
and then over time
you have to build a staff,
you figure out what committees
you want to serve on,
you figure out
what sort of bills you want to run,
what do you want to prioritize,
what do you want to work on,
how do you want to spend your time,
how do you want to craft a schedule,
how do you deal with
just a shock to your system
by now you have to live in two cities
because you have a place in Sacramento
and a place in LA
so that you got that whole dynamic
of back and forth
and over time you get used to it,
you hit your stride,
hopefully you build a good staff
that will help you
both in the district
and also in Sacramento
that help you navigate
all of this stuff
and over time you find your niche
and you find where you're going to
clearly play ball
and where one of the challenges,
you can't possibly work on every issue
so one of the things that you have to do
is figure out
who do I trust on these issues
that I'm not going to spend as much time on,
maybe it's another senator,
another assembly member,
maybe it's an organization
or a staffer
and there are certain topics
that I say,
hey colleague,
I trust you on this topic,
I may have one little,
I may disagree with you on one or two things
but in general
I think you've got a good head
on your shoulders
and so you're going to work on that
and I'll back you up,
I'll ask you some questions
but I'll generally support you
so that's another thing you have to do too,
who do you trust
and then of course
what's interesting is of course
you'll never agree with everybody on everything
so part of it is
even with your closest friends and allies,
you know,
where do you really agree with them,
where do you maybe disagree with them
and understanding all those contours as well.
Is it worth it,
all this,
this is a lot of work?
Yeah, I mean look,
I think a lot of it depends on your personality
and where you find fulfillment,
certainly there's a sacrifice,
there's a toll
and I'll tell you,
I mean I feel really fortunate that
my wife and I got together during the campaign
so we never knew anything different,
something like seven or eight of the people
that entered into the legislature
when I entered into the legislature,
within about four years
their relationships had broken up.
In some cases it was because they were cheating,
but in other cases it was just because
the shock to the system was so hard,
they were living together
and then all of a sudden
they were apart half the time
and they just drew apart
even when they were home
they were working all the time
and they were running out to events.
I talk to politicians all the time who raise kids
or I talk to kids of politicians,
I'm always interested in meeting people
whose parents were in politics
because I want desperately to know
what suggestions do you have for me
to raise two healthy, happy, well-adjusted kids
because I've got two children now
who've been born since I got elected
and how do I craft a life for myself
that does justice to my work
and to my constituents and my job
and also to my family?
As I am trying to balance all of the challenges
of living in two places
and being away a lot
and being at events and all that.
So when I first got in I would go to everything
and I can't be everywhere
in the way that I was when I first started
because I have kids now
and I really care a lot about
making sure I'm there for them.
Of course the good news is
being so involved so early
people got to know me,
people knew who I was
just because I don't necessarily show up
at every single event now
they still know who I am,
they still know they can call me,
they can reach out to me
and we're gonna be able to work well together.
But that's really hard
if you start in office with little kids
because then you're really torn.
And I talked to politicians,
former politicians about how
a lot of regret, quite frankly,
that they have about all the time
they spent outside of the house
away from their families,
critical moments when their kids were
missing those games,
missing those experiences.
So I'm coaching my son's soccer team.
And that causes some consternation
sometimes with my team
because sometimes I gotta cancel things
that I would otherwise go to
because I'm gonna be at practice
or I'm gonna be at the game.
But that's just the commitment
that I've made to myself in some respects
to be there for him
and show him that I'm really present for him
in spite of this very busy job.
You have a lot of people
you guys are serving.
And do people recognize you in the street
or come to you and ask you about things?
Does that happen?
Yeah, sometimes.
I mean, it's funny.
We're not as well known
as people in the federal government.
I like to say that I'm sort of
like a V-level celebrity.
Yes, I do run into people in district.
Now, in Sacramento,
there's a few blocks
right around the Capitol
where I may be a D-level celebrity.
So our reporters know you
when they come through.
Yeah, reporters or other lobbyists
or advocates or other staff.
Then the California Democratic Convention,
that's where I feel more
like a B-plus celebrity.
That's where people really,
there are a lot of political junkies there
who love this stuff
and know all the legislators.
And they'll come up to you
and tell you about some bill
that you voted on
that they either like what you did.
But it's not like being the governor
or being a U.S. senator
or something like that.
Those folks are working
at a different level.
I mean, I do enjoy a certain degree
of privacy in this job
that I would not have
if I were at that level.
And there's something nice about that
because I do think it,
for some of those folks,
it really becomes hard to live your life
because you can't go anywhere
without having folks.
And look, and of course,
nobody forced you to do this, right?
I mean, ultimately you have to,
you know, I mean,
when people recognize me
on the street or in the airport,
I usually like it.
I mean, I like talking
about this stuff with people
unless they want to yell at me,
but even then I kind of find it fun
because, you know,
Does that happen?
Yeah, sometimes.
And look, most of the time,
especially if you kind of,
you go back and forth with them
with a smile and with respect,
they'll appreciate it.
From my perspective,
I mean, I like this stuff.
I like talking about public policy
and I like grappling with these things.
So do they come up to you
with the issues they want to talk to
you about certain issues
or do they talk to you
about your votes or?
Everything, everything.
And usually, usually
they're not expecting to see you.
So, you know, oh, hey, you know,
Senator Allen, you know,
great job or, oh, man,
you got to lower my taxes
or go tell Kamala to do da da da.
You get a lot of that, too.
People kind of give you
their thoughts or advice
about what's happening
at the national level,
as though I have a hotline
to the Nancy Pelosi.
And, you know,
so that's also funny.
Do people mix the national and state?
All the time.
Good and good friends.
They'll say, oh, you know,
are you in Washington this week?
No, I'm not in Washington.
I go to Sacramento.
I go to Washington
every once in a while,
but my job's in Sacramento.
So it's amazing how
I think because I'm
a call to senator,
they sometimes think, yeah,
they sometimes think
I'm going to Washington.
But, you know, again,
it's an it's an opportunity
to have a little conversation
about civics and federalism.
And and it's fun.
I mean, look, I got to say,
in many respects,
I it's a better job
in the legislature
than in Congress.
Congress is so divided,
so partisan.
You know, we were talking earlier
about one of my Republican
colleagues who, you know,
and we're friendly.
We were we've worked well together
on a number of issues.
I like that dynamic in Sacramento.
You know, it just seems like
so much of the world
in Washington is focused on.
Fighting and partisanship
and just seeing something
wild to get yourself on TV,
whereas we're actually able
to get a lot of stuff done
and with real implication.
And we were talking about
plastics earlier
and environmental policy.
We're the fifth largest
economy in the world.
As a state, we've got relative
coherence, cohesion
to our political system.
So when we take action,
on an environmental issue
or in a lot of different things,
it really does have global impact.
And there's something
there's something
really exciting about that,
to be able to get something done
that's meaningful
and know that you've
actually left the mark
that doesn't just have an impact
on your local community
or even just your state,
but it really can move markets
nationally and globally.
And there's something
really fulfilling about that.
In terms of people getting involved
in public service,
do you recommend that
to younger people?
And if you do, why?
Yeah, no, look, absolutely.
I think we need young people
involved in the system,
getting involved.
It's it's fulfilling.
It's interesting.
It's eclectic.
It's meaningful.
I would say, of course,
there's lots of different
ways to get involved.
You don't obviously running
for office is one way
and it's an important
and a very important way.
We need good people
to run for office.
But if that's not for you,
don't think that's the only way
to be involved in the system.
And we have I have a great team
of people that work for me.
So you can work for a politician
at any level.
You can work for an advocacy
organization if there's a topic
that you really care a lot about.
I mean, some of the people
who run the various advocacy
organizations have more power
than the elected officials
because they have the sort
of the base, the money,
the strength of their arguments
on whatever topic they focus on.
So that's another way to get involved.
You can get involved with campaigns
and help to get people
elected that you like.
You can get involved in fundraising
for for people that you like.
You can go work for the government,
not necessarily for a politician,
but for an agency or for
for a department at any level.
If you don't want to work in politics
and government,
you can still get involved
through politicians need help.
They need help fundraising.
They need help with policy ideas.
You know, there's ways
that you can volunteer.
There's ways you can create
organizations and clubs
and get involved with groups
that are out there advocating
from the side or engaged.
There are lots of different ways
to get involved.
And I would just I guess
I would say to younger folks,
a lot of people see the government
as something that's far away,
that's on television,
that's distant from them.
And I would just say that
the government politics
filled with real people.
And don't be afraid of showing up
and asking questions
and getting involved.
And, you know, when I was in college,
I reached out to
the county supervisor,
Zev Yaroslavsky,
who was our supervisor.
You know, when I was
I was going to college
in the East Coast,
I sent him a letter, say,
hey, I'd love to come
intern for you.
I got a job interning
with him for the summer.
That opened up a world to me
as a younger person,
working on health policy
for the county.
And then next thing you know,
he ended up we became good friends.
He became a major supporter of mine.
I mean, I probably his endorsement
when I ran for this
for both the school board
and for this position
became really important for me
in getting elected.
And that was just because
I took the opportunity
to reach out to him
and ask for an internship.
So all those kinds of things
can be really
they can really help to inspire you.
And and and and even
if you don't end up
wanting to be in the public sector,
it's worth it's worth
spending a little bit of time
in the public sector.
I mean, you know, you can intern.
You can I like
when I meet with students,
I tell them
if you go to the university,
most universities,
they'll have the University
of California, for example,
has a center in Sacramento
and in Washington.
You can go take classes there.
You can go, you know,
as you also intern
for elected officials
or government agencies.
It's a great way to get a window
into how our government works.
No matter what you do,
understanding the government,
understanding public policy,
understanding the public sector
can only be helpful to your career
and your and your your philosophy
and outlook on life.
California State Senator Ben Allen,
it was great to have you
on California Insider.
My pleasure.
Thank you.
Thank you so much.