Birdman of Alcatraz Was Not Who You Think Forgotten History YouTube

Artifact Archives
9 followers
2 Video Views·Feb 5, 2026
Alcatraz has been back in the headlines recently with talk of repurposing the island prison
for modern illegal immigrant detention, pending hearings, and deportations. But long before it
became a political symbol, it was home to some of the most infamous criminals in American history,
the most famous probably being Chicago mobster Al Capone. Alcatraz is located on Alcatraz Island
in San Francisco Bay, some 1.5 miles off the coast of California. First used as a jail during the
American Civil War, Alcatraz became a federal penitentiary in 1934. But there was another
inmate who became a legend and the subject of the feature film The Birdman of Alcatraz,
which hit theaters in 1962. It was a fictionalized, almost sterile version of the life of a very
interesting man. Who was Robert Stroud? How did he get to Alcatraz? What made him famous?
Hello, I'm Colin Heaton, former history professor, Army and Marine Corps veteran,
and welcome to this episode of Forgotten History.
Robert Stroud was born on January 28, 1890 in Seattle, Washington, where he endured a troubled
childhood under a very abusive father. At 13, he ran away from home and landed in Alaska. By the
time he was 18 years of age, he had a relationship with a dance hall girl named Kitty O'Brien,
who was rumored to be a prostitute and Stroud may have been her pimp. In 1909, O'Brien was
allegedly beaten by an acquaintance, possibly a customer or even a jealous suitor, and Stroud
shot and killed the man. It was also rumored that Stroud killed the man for refusing to pay.
He was later convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to 12 years at McNeil Island
Penitentiary in Washington State, beginning his 54 years behind bars. Stroud developed a reputation
of being a very violent and disruptive prisoner, to include homosexual assaults against other
inmates. He once assaulted a hospital orderly and stabbed a fellow prisoner, receiving an additional
six months to his sentence. In 1912, Stroud was transferred to Leavenworth Federal Penitentiary
in Kansas as inmate number 8154. On May 25, 1916, his younger brother came for a visit but was not
allowed to see him due to a disciplinary action, after a corrections officer named Turner took
Stroud's name and inmate number for an infraction. Later, Stroud entered the cafeteria the next day,
on March 26, 1916, where Turner was posted and he asked permission to speak with him.
Stroud asked Turner if he had reported him to the warden, as Officer Turner had taken his
name and number the previous day. Officer Turner told Stroud that he had not yet reported him,
but Stroud still stabbed Turner in the heart, killing him using a sharpened case knife,
with about 1,500 other inmates in the dining area being witnesses. Stroud had three separate trials
for the murder, two being hung juries in 1918, with a verdict of guilty announced in the third
and final trial, and Stroud was sentenced to be hanged. Stroud apparently showed no remorse for
the killing, writing, the guard took ill and died all of a sudden, he had a heart condition,
puncture of the heart, there was a knife hole in it. One amazing outcome was that, due to Turner
being very popular with the inmates, as he was perceived as being fair in his treatment,
the inmates requested permission from the warden to donate $400 to Turner's family.
Stroud's mother then appealed to President Woodrow Wilson, who commuted his sentence
to life imprisonment, but Leavenworth's warden at the time, T.W. Morgan, strongly opposed the
decision, citing Stroud's reputation for violence. President Wilson's attorney general, Alexander
Mitchell Palmer, saw to it that Stroud would spend the rest of his life in solitary confinement and
not be executed. During a break in the prison yard in 1920, Stroud came upon a fallen nest
with three baby sparrows. He took the birds back to his cell, sparking his longtime fascination with
ornithology, and was allowed to keep the birds as a hobby. He developed his interest in ornithology
at Leavenworth, which would create his legend. Despite having had no formal education after 13,
Stroud became self-educated. Stroud enrolled in several university extension courses in mechanical
drawing, engineering, music, theology, and mathematics, but he never abandoned his violent
methods. Stroud began reading every book he could acquire on the subject of birds and science and
recorded his own observations on behavior and illnesses that the books failed to cover. He was
granted permission to raise and breed canaries and reached a point to where he had 300 of them
living in cigar boxes in an adjoining cell. He became self-taught as a scientist and built a
makeshift laboratory to develop homemade medicines for them, which he sold via mail order. His research
into diseases and creating remedies were later considered groundbreaking. The other prisoners
were sometimes allowed to buy the canaries that Stroud raised, which he sold for supplies and
to help support his mother. Stroud himself said that he used a razor blade and nail for tools
and made his first birdcage out of wooden crates. Not long after this, William Biddle took over as
the warden of Leavenworth. Biddle was determined to turn Leavenworth into a model federal prison,
creating what he saw as a progressive rehabilitation penitentiary. He saw Stroud as the tool to start
his project. Biddle was impressed with Stroud's raising of the birds and his using fellow prisoners
in his research, as he kept detailed notes on all of his avian activities, and he furnished Stroud
with cages, chemicals, and stationery to conduct his ornithological activities. Visitors to the
prison were shown Stroud's aviary, and many people purchased his canaries. Over the years, he raised
nearly 300 canaries in his cells. He also wrote two full books, the 60,000-word treatise Diseases
of Canaries in 1933, which managed to be smuggled out of Leavenworth, and then submitting a later
edition titled Stroud's Digest on the Diseases of Birds in 1943, with updated specific information
containing many of his own personal drawings. Stroud also made several important scientific
contributions to aviation pathology, most notably developing a cure for the hemorrhagic septicemia
family of diseases within certain bird species, thereby gaining recognition and immense respect
from the international scientific, zoological, biological, and ornithological communities.
But Stroud's growing popularity actually created serious problems for the prison
staff due to the amount of fan mail and professional inquiries he received,
since, per regulations, each letter sent or received in or out of the prison had to be read,
copied, and approved. Stroud's correspondences soon required a full-time prison secretary.
But there was also another problem, since most of the time his birds were permitted to fly
freely within his cells. Because of the great number of birds he kept, his cell was filthy,
creating a possible health issue. As a result, in 1931 there was an attempt to terminate his
business and get rid of the birds. But Stroud got lucky, as one of his mail correspondents,
a bird researcher from Indiana named Della Mae Jones, made his story known to newspapers and
magazines around the nation, and even in Europe. What followed was a massive letter campaign and
a 50,000 signature petition being sent to President Herbert Hoover, which resulted in Stroud being
permitted to keep his birds. And, despite prison overcrowding, he was even given a second cell
to house them. However, feeling defeated, the prison officials restricted his letter-writing
privileges. But, despite this, Jones and Stroud became close, and she relocated to Kansas in 1931
and started a business with him, selling his bird medicines. The prison officials were finally fed
up with Stroud's activities and the unwanted publicity, so they intensified their efforts
to transfer him from Leavenworth. However, Stroud discovered a Kansas law that forbade the transfer
of prisoners who were married in Kansas, and he married Jones by proxy, which infuriated the
prison's administrators, who would not allow him to correspond with his wife. But the prison
officials were not alone in their anger. His own mother, Elizabeth Stroud, strongly disapproved of
the marriage, believing women were nothing but trouble for her son. Whereas, previously, she had
been a strong advocate for her son, helping him with legal battles, she now argued against his
application for parole and became a major obstacle in his attempts to be released from the prison
system. After moving away from Leavenworth, she had no further contact with him, and she died in 1938.
In 1933, Stroud advertised in a publication that he had not received any royalties from the sales
of his book Diseases of Canaries. In retaliation, the publisher, who did not want to pay Stroud,
complained to the new warden and, as a result, proceedings were then initiated to transfer
Stroud to Alcatraz, where he would not be permitted to keep his birds. But Stroud's luck
ran out when it was discovered that some of the equipment he had been using for his lab
was, in fact, being used as a homemade distillery to manufacture alcohol. The officials finally had
the wedge they needed to drive Stroud out. Citing his dangerous tendencies and long-standing concerns
about the sanitary conditions of his cells, they initiated proceedings to send him to Alcatraz.
In late 1942, Stroud was given 10 minutes to prepare for his transfer to the U.S. Penitentiary
on Alcatraz Island, becoming inmate number 594. He was not allowed to have his birds in Alcatraz,
so the birds, along with his research equipment, were sent to his brother.
Upon arrival at Alcatraz, Stroud was still in isolation, but he continued writing, producing
manuscripts on the history of the U.S. prison system and an autobiography, though he was denied
permission to release them. He would spend six years in segregation and another 11 confined to
the hospital wing at the penitentiary. In 1943, he was assessed by psychiatrist Dr. Romney M. Ritchie,
who diagnosed him as a psychopath with an IQ of 112, which contradicted the initial Leavenworth
assessment of his IQ in 1942, which stated that he had an IQ of 116. Rumors of Stroud's
homosexuality were noted at Alcatraz. According to Donald Hurley, whose father was a guard at
Alcatraz, whenever Stroud was around anyone, which was seldom, he was closely watched as prison
officials were very aware of his overt homosexual tendencies. In an interview with Hurley for his
book, a former inmate heard Stroud was always in dog block, which is what they called solitary
confinement, or later in the hospital because he was a wolf, meaning an aggressive homosexual
who had a bad temper. In 1955, Stroud was the subject of author Thomas E. Gaddis' well-received
biography titled Birdman of Alcatraz. While detailing the prisoner's violent behavior,
the book also painted him as a man fighting to maintain his dignity within exceedingly difficult
conditions. Prison staff and fellow inmates described him as a manipulative and dangerous
person. During his 17-year term at Alcatraz, Stroud was allowed access to the prison library
and began studying law. Occasionally, he was permitted to play chess with one of the guards.
Stroud began petitioning the government that his long prison term amounted to cruel and unusual
punishment. While in Alcatraz, he wrote two more manuscripts, Bobby, an autobiography and Looking
Outward, a history of the U.S. prison system from colonial times to the formation of the Bureau of
Prisons. A judge ruled that Stroud had the right to write and keep such manuscripts, but upheld the
warden's decision to ban their publication. After Stroud's death, the transcripts were delivered to
his lawyer, Richard English. In 1959, with his health failing, Stroud left Alcatraz and was
transferred to the Medical Center for Federal Prisoners in Springfield, Missouri, but he was
never released. In 1962, the feature film Birdman of Alcatraz, loosely taken from Gaddis' book,
was released in theaters, featuring Burt Lancaster in an Academy Award-nominated role
as a mild-mannered, reformed version of Stroud. The film was a commercial success,
but it was not well-received by those who knew Stroud. Some former inmates of Alcatraz say that
the real Stroud was a far more sinister, dangerous, and unpleasant person than the fictionalized
version portrayed in the book and film. One inmate said Stroud was a vicious killer. I think
Burt Lancaster owes us all an apology. In February 1963, Stroud met and talked with actor Burt
Lancaster, who portrayed him in the film. Stroud never saw the film or read the book it was based
on, but he did share one of the problems that prevented parole, that he was an admitted
homosexual. Lancaster quoted Stroud as saying, Let's face it, I'm 73 years old. Does that answer
your question about whether I would be a dangerous homosexual? It was at Springfield where Stroud
finally earned a reprieve from his long stay in solitary confinement, taking a job in the prison
print shop. Stroud remained in the public eye and became even more famous after the book and film
came out, but he had little time left. Despite the increased attention, Stroud was unsuccessful
in his attempts to attain parole. He had been incarcerated for the last 54 years of his life,
of which 42 were spent in solitary confinement. However, by his last years, Stroud's behavior had
markedly improved and he was viewed more favorably. Judge Becker considered Stroud to be modest,
no longer a danger to society, and as having a genuine love for birds. Given his level of notoriety,
the crimes he committed were unremarkable, especially as the assaults he committed had a
clear cause. Carl Sefakis considers Stroud to have been a brilliant self-taught expert on birds,
and possibly the best known example of self-improvement and rehabilitation in the U.S.
prison system. Because of Stroud's contributions to the field of ornithology, he gained a large
following of thousands of bird breeders and poultry raisers who demanded his release,
and, for many years, a committee to release Robert F. Stroud campaigned
to have Stroud released from prison. However, because Stroud had killed a federal officer,
his punishment in solitary confinement remained intact. In 1963, Richard M. English, a young
lawyer who had campaigned for John F. Kennedy in California, took the cause of securing Stroud's
release. He also met with former President Harry S. Truman to enlist support, but Truman declined.
He also met with senior Kennedy administration officials who were studying the subject.
English actually took the last photograph of Stroud, in which he is shown with a green visor.
The prison warden attempted to have English prosecuted for bringing something into the
prison he did not take out, unexposed film, but the authorities declined to take any further action.
Stroud also filed a lawsuit to have his manuscripts released, and the decision was still
pending when he was discovered dead in his cell from natural causes on November 21, 1963, at age
73. Stroud was interred in the Old Masonic Cemetery near Metropolis, Illinois, after a private funeral
ceremony at Aitken's Farmer Funeral Home on November 25. His common-law wife had died earlier
in February 1963. After Stroud's death, his personal property, including original manuscripts,
were turned over to English, who was his last legal representative. English later donated some
of the possessions to the Audubon Society. The manuscripts themselves went into probate,
but his lawyer Dudley Martin sought to acquire them as administrator of the deceased inmate's
will. He finally obtained the manuscripts in 1984 and tried to have them published,
but publishing houses were very wary of potential lawsuits from former Alcatraz officers, who may
not be placed in a very good light in the book. After the statute of limitations passed, Looking
Outward, A Voice from the Grave finally appeared in e-book form in February 2014. Among other
details, the book reveals Stroud's homosexuality and the corruption rife among prison guards and
wardens. With the movie rights sold and the promise of additional volumes on the way,
it seemed likely the Birdman story would remain popular in the public's imagination. In fact,
actor Art Carney portrayed Stroud in the 1980 TV movie Alcatraz, The Whole Shocking Story,
and Dennis Farina played Stroud in the TV movie Six Against the Rock in 1987,
a dramatization of the 1946 Battle of Alcatraz. Robert Stroud remains a controversial figure,
a man whose intellectual pursuits and contributions to ornithology are juxtaposed
against a backdrop of violence and lifelong incarceration. His story continues to provoke
discussions about rehabilitation, the nature of criminality, and the complexities of human
behavior. However, despite all of this, Stroud is still considered to be one of the most notorious
criminals in American history. Robert Neamey states that Stroud had a superior intellect
and became a first-rate ornithologist and author, but was an extremely dangerous and menacing
psychopath, disliked and distrusted by his jailers and fellow inmates. Robert Stroud lives
on in the legend of Alcatraz as an enigmatic and chimeric figure. Thank you for watching this
episode of Forgotten History. If you liked what you saw, please click like, share, and subscribe,
and if you would like to assist with the ever-increasing cost of production,
please consider becoming a channel member and joining our Patreon page.
Please check out our merchandise store, and thanks for watching!
