Billy The Kid- The Truth BehindTthe Legend - Forgotten History Clips

Artifact Archives
9 followers
1 Video View·May 2, 2026
Watch the full video here: • TRUTH about Billy The Kid - Forgotten History
=================================================================================
Billy the Kid remains one of the most famous and mysterious figures of the American Old West. Born Henry McC …
Here's another fascinating fact. Although often accused of being Billie the Kid,
William Henry Roberts, better known as Brushy Bill, finally later admitted to being Billie the Kid,
which created quite a stir given the historically accepted story that Billie the Kid was shot
by Sheriff Pat Garrett. Naturally, there were skeptics, but here are some interesting things
about Roberts, who got the nickname Brushy Bill as a scout for a stagecoach line in the Black Hills
of Idaho. Roberts matched Billie the Kid in every physical and possible way, including his voice,
laughter, and eye color. Photos of Roberts and Billie the Kid were scientifically compared by
the University of Texas at Austin and validated by the FBI, showing Roberts and Billie the Kid
to be the same person. Also, adding credibility was that when Roberts was interviewed about his
background, it was evident that he knew explicit details about the people, places, events, and
little-known details of Billie the Kid. More than anyone else alive, even historians back then.
Most of what was known to historians was from Pat Garrett's own book,
Ghost Written by Marshall Ashman Ash Upson, The Authentic Life of Billie the Kid, which became
gospel on the subject. Deputies John Poe and Thomas Kidd McKinney also testified afterward
that Garrett killed Billie the Kid. However, in later years, both Poe and McKinney stated
that Sheriff Garrett did not kill Billie the Kid, and Poe's account during his original testimony
contradicted Garrett's on several important and relevant points.
According to writer Frederick Nolan, Garrett's book was a farrago of nonsense that has been
responsible for every single one of the myths perpetuated about Billie the Kid, and for many
inaccuracies, evasions, and even untruths. Most serious historians today do not give Pat Garrett's
book much credibility, as Garrett was well known to fabricating his own life and embellishing many
events. However, Roberts's credibility is only increased as more is learned. Another factor
supporting the cause for Roberts was the family bible found after his death that recorded the
names of his family members such as Bonnie, McCarty, and Antrim, all the aliases used by
Billie the Kid. Of course, some detractors state that Roberts was not Billie the Kid because Billie
Kid was right-handed while Roberts was supposedly left-handed. Billie spoke Spanish and they claimed
Roberts did not. They also claimed that William Henry Roberts was actually Oliver P. Roberts,
who his documented past did not coincide with the life of the Kid. But in fact, Roberts was
ambidextrous and spoke Spanish fluently and he knew every detail one would expect if he were
in fact Billie the Kid. William Henry Roberts claimed that the man who was killed by Garrett
was a friend of his named Billy Barlow, who was half Mexican and looked a lot like Billie the Kid
except for his dark beard and dark skin. A few months later, before the shooting in Fort Sumner,
the editor of the Las Vegas Gazette, J. H. Kugler, interviewed Billie the Kid in person while he was
in town waiting to be transported to Mesilla for his murder trial. Kugler's description was
different than the man Garrett shot, quoting his report. There was nothing very mannish about him
in appearance, for he looked and acted a mere boy. He is about five feet eight or nine inches tall,
slightly built and lithe, weighing about 140, a frank open countenance, looking like a school
boy with the traditional silky fuzz on his upper lip, clear blue eyes with a roguish snap about
them, light hair and complexion. Roberts recited that actual interview, even describing Kugler.
