At first glance, this painting might seem like an innocent winter scene. But in typical Pieter Bruegel the Elder fashion, this painting is full of hidden symbols. Here’s what I found.
Beneath this serene winter wonderland, Pieter Bruegel the Elder’s “The Hunters in the Snow” unveils a much darker, more perilous reality. At first glance, Bruegel captures the charm of winter: ice skating, fishing, and sledding. But upon closer inspection, you’ll find bird traps, burning houses, and a few ominous crows perched overhead.
But don’t be fooled, this is not just a simple genre scene. We can’t view this painting without considering what life was like during the 1560s. Between the historic climate event, “The Little Ice Age”, and the religious upheaval of the Protestant Reformation, this painting becomes a reflection of the harsh, uncertain world of the 1560s.
Music: Epidemic Sound
Thanks for watching and let me know what you think in the comments!
Alla Prima is a series of video essays that explore the history behind some of our favorite works of art. My mission is to make art history accessible, engaging, and inspiring.
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
At first glance, this painting might seem like just another simple, innocent winter scene.
Wait, what's that? And who are they?
This is Hunters in the Snow by Peter Bruegel the Elder,
an artist famous for sneaking secret messages and hidden symbols into his work.
So I hate to break it to you, but this scene is not nearly as innocent as it looks.
So buckle up, buttercup.
The story begins with these guys, the hunters who give this painting its name.
But where are they going?
And why do they look like they just had the worst day ever?
Because at first, this painting is buzzing with life.
It has over 60 people ice skating, curling, fishing, sledding, and playing ice hockey.
And throughout the painting, there's a strong sense of community.
I mean, just look at these people.
They make me want to join in on the fun too.
The artist of this piece, Peter Bruegel the Elder,
was one of the most significant artists of the 16th century Dutch Renaissance
and was known for his landscapes and genre paintings of everyday people doing everyday things.
And in this case, playing and hunting during the winter of 1565.
So why does this hunting party in the foreground stand in such
stark contrast to the vitality depicted elsewhere in the scene?
Well, their body language says it all.
Heads hanging low, shoulders slumped, and every step through the snow
feels heavier than the last as they make their way back home.
They look exhausted.
Only one carries a fox, but not for food.
It was likely hunted for its fur or to keep the poultry safe back at home.
And as for the others, the bags hanging on their belts indicate that they're filled with
something.
Maybe a partridge, maybe a quail, but hardly a feast.
And yet, the hunters are holding spears, the kind used for hunting deer.
And even their dogs look embarrassed.
A pack of 13, including greyhounds and bloodhounds,
hang their heads low with their ears drooping forward.
Their disappointment is palpable.
They set out for deer, but returned with a fox, and if they were lucky, a couple of quail.
And to make matters worse, look down at their feet.
Fresh bunny tracks cutting right across their path.
As if the little guy had just outrun them and yelled,
Better luck next time, peasants!
And that's not a diss, because they actually are peasants.
In fact, Bruegel focused on painting the lives of common Flemish people so much
that he earned the nickname Peasant Bruegel.
But Bruegel was an educated townsman, and he often socialized with wealthy scholars and merchants.
So to observe his subjects more closely, Bruegel would often dress up as a peasant
to blend in at village festivals and weddings.
And I think that's part of what makes Bruegel's paintings feel so real.
His figures aren't frozen in stiff, manufactured poses,
but captured in motion, moving naturally, just like real people.
And he was also a master at composition,
because if you follow the hunter's path along with the descending rooftops,
Bruegel leads your eye to a village teeming with life,
a stark contrast to the hunter's failure.
And since we're on the topic of a lively village,
let's see what's happening down there, where it looks like everyone's enjoying winter.
Well, unless you live in that house.
So, what's with the burning house?
At first glance, you can barely see it.
It's just a tiny blip of orange amongst a sea of blue, green, and white.
But look closer, and you'll also find villagers scrambling with ladders,
trying to put out the blaze.
In a scene filled with cheerful skaters and snow-covered rooftops,
this house fire feels out of place.
But remember when I said that Bruegel loved to sneak in symbols?
Yeah, well, this is one of them.
And if we look even closer, more of his hidden symbols begin to reveal themselves.
Like this bird trap that's smack dab in the center of the painting.
And these crows perched in the trees.
And even the magpies circling above.
At first glance, each one seems ordinary,
until we remember what they meant to Bruegel's audience.
In the 16th century, birds generally represented the human soul,
but specifically crows were omens of death,
and magpies symbolized the devil.
Now look at this crooked sign hanging in front of the inn.
It depicts Saint Hubertus, the patron saint of hunters.
So to understand how this links back to these hunters,
you need a little bit of context.
The story goes Saint Hubertus converted to Christianity
after seeing a crucifix between a stag's antlers while hunting on Good Friday.
So then why is the sign off balance and hanging by a single hook?
Well, the crooked sign seems to confirm their failed hunt.
And remember those spears, the ones meant to hunt deer?
Well, it's ironic because the very animal that inspired Saint Hubertus' conversion
eludes the hunters entirely.
The crooked sign hints at the hunters' misfortune before we even notice their empty hands.
Suddenly, all of these details begin to take on new meaning.
The crooked sign, the unsuccessful hunters, the escaped bunny, the burning house,
the bird trap, the circling crows and magpies,
and to top it all off, the frozen lake that could crack at any moment
all contribute to the tense narrative that danger is everywhere.
And this atmosphere of unease aligns with the historic climate of the era too.
Because from the 16th to the 19th century,
northern Flanders, the region depicted in the painting,
experienced what is known as the Little Ice Age.
This period had severe temperatures that froze water reserves
and caused disruption to food supply, resulting in riots, illness, famine, and death.
So together, these details invite the viewer to reflect on the precarity of life,
with themes of survival emerging, not overtly,
but from the hidden symbolism that Bruegel carefully weaves throughout his painting.
But the fear and suffering of the time weren't blamed on climate alone.
Many believed these hardships were punishments from God,
and that belief wasn't that far-fetched given the unstable religious landscape
during the 16th century where the Protestant Reformation
directly challenged the authority and doctrine of the Catholic Church.
So now with this context in mind, we have to ask,
what else might Bruegel be asking us to see?
Turns out, a lot.
So let's go back to that bird trap and take a closer look.
During Bruegel's time, the bird trap was a common stand-in for the devil,
while the unsuspecting birds, that symbolize human souls,
are easily lured into the trap with deceitful pleasures.
Now let's go back to the sign above the inn, dangling precariously from the building
as if it might drop into the open fire down below at any moment.
Once depicting Saint Hubertus, the patron saint of hunters,
its broken and off-balance state may not only represent the hunter's failure,
but a symbolic deterioration of the old faith amid the chaos of religious reform.
During the Protestant Reformation, both sides believed that they were on the side of God
and that their enemies were in league with the devil,
with the Catholic Church viewing the reformers as being
tempted away from the true faith by demonic influence
and the Protestant leaders viewing the Catholic Church
as a corrupt antichrist system and a tool of the devil.
Suddenly, these details begin to evolve the narrative.
It's no longer that danger is everywhere,
but that the devil's traps are everywhere.
So why did Bruegel hide so many hidden symbols into what looks like a simple winter scene?
Because at first, Hunters in the Snow appears to be just that,
a group of hunters returning home.
But then we notice the details.
A crooked sign, a bird trap, and a burning house in the distance.
This is a painting created during a time of deep religious instability,
when expressing the wrong belief could get you silenced, exiled, or worse.
So how did Bruegel, living under the reign of King Philip II of Spain,
a fierce defender of Catholicism, navigate such a dangerous landscape?
Well, he embedded religious allegories into scenes of everyday life.
Instead of overt iconography, he used symbols,
traps, signs, and birds to tell a more subtle story.
That way, whether you are Protestant or Catholic,
you couldn't accuse his work of being openly oppositional.
But this was also a strategic business move for him,
because as the Protestant Reformation spread, it fundamentally changed the art market.
Churches commissioned less art,
so artists like Bruegel were forced to adapt to a new clientele of wealthy merchants.
But Bruegel loved to hide symbols in his work.
So what did he do?
He masked theological commentary inside seemingly secular genre scenes,
like in Hunters in the Snow.
This piece is considered the final painting in a series of six
that represent the seasons of the year,
commissioned by an Antwerp banker and merchant.
But today, only five survive.
The Gloomy Day, the Hay Harvest, the Harvesters,
the Return of the Herd, and this one, Hunters in the Snow.
This series of work is part of a long tradition in Northern European art
of portraying the months of the year and the activities available during each season.
Let me know in the comments if you'd like to see me analyze any of these other paintings.
Oh, and one last thing.
See that dramatic mountain in the back?
Don't worry, it's not a hidden symbol and it doesn't hold any secret meaning.
It's actually totally made up.
Yeah, completely fake.
You won't find mountains like that anywhere in Flanders.
It's actually a combination of the mountains Bruegel saw while traveling in the Alps
and a little bit of his imagination.
Okay, maybe it's mostly his imagination, but hey,
if Bruegel wants to take a few artistic liberties every now and then,
I'm not gonna hold it against him.