MLB's Own Official Top 10 Players List Is a Mess

Chicago Cubs Fans
23 followers
MLB.com released their list of the top 100 players in Major League Baseball recently,
and for the most part, I thought it was fine, particularly on the front end,
as I don't know if there'd be any rearranging I personally would make of Shohei Otani being first,
Aaron Judge being second, Bobby Witt Jr. being third, and Cal Raleigh being fourth.
All of these guys showed enough, both in 2025 and in the previous couple seasons,
to own their respective spots. No, it was more so on the back half of the top 10 that I thought
that there were some downright incomprehensible decisions, born perhaps of some narrative ball
was worth pointing out. I also do want to acknowledge before we go any further that
some people will say that there's no real tangible difference between a player being ranked
7th instead of 10th, but I would disagree. When we get to the top, top rankings in the sport,
each spot becomes more and more indicative of how someone is viewed, and perhaps even more
relevantly, how they're viewed over other players. And these marginal differences certainly count for
something to me. I'm going to go in the order of which these confusing choices appear, starting
with Jose Ramirez at 5th, and Juan Soto at 6th. Now, this is in no way meant to disparage J-Ram,
who is going to more than likely be a first ballot hall of famer when he retires. And the
third baseman had another absolutely outstanding season in 2025, one that ended up netting him
another top 5 MVP ranking, finishing 3rd. Soto, however, also finished in the same spot for his
league, setting career highs in a multitude of categories, the most surprising of which being
a National League-leading stolen base total. It's only when you examine their numbers side by side,
both in this past season and in the prior 3 years combined, that things start to look a little
funky. In the prior campaign, Soto had a notable edge in every major statistical category, besides
hits and batting average, while being comparable in stolen bases. The biggest tangible differences
could be found in home runs, where he had a lead of 13, OPS with an edge of almost 60, and OPS Plus
with over 20. But, again, let's go back over the prior 3 years if you think this is just recency
bias. Since the start of 2023, Soto has dominated in pretty much the exact same fashion, only giving
up ground in one additional category, being RBIs. Add in the fact that Soto is over 6 years younger,
and I just can't understand placing him behind Cleveland's switch-hitting superstar. I think
this might be a classic example of overcorrection from the baseball media, with J-Ram being called
underrated for so long that he actually ended up, this season, being slightly overrated.
The next puzzling decision was certainly less confusing than the previous, with Paul Skeens
being ranked 7th and Tarek Skubal being ranked 8th. As you can see from their comparison chart,
this looks a little bit odd, considering the only category that Skeens has the edge in is war,
which isn't really reliable for pitchers, ERA and ERA Plus. I'm not going to say this was a horrible
decision, but it is a bit strange to see a pitcher who's won back-to-back Cy Young Awards, thrown
over 60 more innings over the past 2 years with almost 100 more strikeouts, and superior rate
stats in almost every way, finish behind a guy who's going to be in his 3rd season in the league.
Again, not downright offensive or anything, just a little off in my opinion. It is, however,
the next two choices on this list that inspired the making of this video, with Corbin Carroll and
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. being ranked 9th and 10th in the sport overall. I do think both of these guys
should be in the top 20, maybe even top 15 players, but I'm going to throw a chart out there
right now that includes 3 separate guys who I think all could have been ranked in front of them
depending on what you value. Guerrero and Carroll, in this exercise, only led the overall group in
batting average, stolen bases, and slugging percentage, meaning that if you value advanced
contributions, you probably would have picked Julio Rodriguez. And if you value rate stats,
and what they could be predictive of in 2026, you probably would have picked Acuna Jr., who,
mind you, has won an MVP in the recent past. Additionally, if you wanted a player who is as
steady as they come with elite defense at one of the most important positions on the field,
you could have selected Lindor. But it actually gets even crazier when you zoom out back to 2023,
when Carroll first started getting major playing time. Since then, him and Vladimir only merge on
top in three categories, being stolen bases, hits, and RBI. If you're looking at it through
this lens, Francisco would seem to be an obvious inclusion, as he's tallied over 4 wins above
replacement more than Carroll in this window, and over 6 more than Vladi. And again, if you wanted
to go by rate stats, Acuna Jr. would seemingly hop to the front, and J-Rod honestly wouldn't be bad
either considering he's second overall in value and plays one of the hardest positions himself
in center field, and does so to an elite level. No matter how you slice it, it just doesn't really
make sense to include those two guys at the end of the list over these other players. In terms of
it's probably because Corbin is one of the most electric players in the sport when it comes to his
combination of raw power and speed, outshining the better metric performance of players like
Rodriguez and Lindor, who post good but not great offensive numbers year in and year out. Acuna is
probably just being dinged for his injury history over the past couple years, which I do understand,
but don't necessarily agree with to this level, keeping him out of the top 10. Vladi, meanwhile,
got a tremendous boost from his postseason performance, which I always personally dislike
for a list like this. He's a first baseman with poor fielding stats, and not even dramatically
better hitting stats than the guys around him in this graphic. An impressive October sample size
does little in my mind to offset this when the list itself is regarding the top players in the
game for the regular season. It just doesn't seem to be very relevant. Anyway, you guys be sure to
let me know what you think of these decisions in the comments, and who you would've liked to
have seen be included in the top 10. Alright everybody, if you made it this far, I appreciate
you watching, and if you did, consider checking out any of these other videos on your screen right
now for other content just like this. Also, if you ever see anything you'd like to see me detail
in the video, feel free to reach out to my email basebpoet at gmail dot com, and if I end up using
your idea, I'll give you a shoutout. Thanks for watching, have a great rest of your day.
