Why was it so STUCK? Brazing Repair & Critical Analysis - Victorian Radial Drill Restoration PART 11

Screw Driver
87 followers
#machinery #motorbikes #occupations #career
A breakdown on why the Radial arm drill spindle was so stuck inside its bearing. Ill also carry out some urgent repairs to damage sustained while I was trying to free it off!
Cheers!
Follow me -
/ iron_jonsey
https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?...
This is the spindle from my Victorian drill press which had taken ages to remove from its bearing
Today's video aims to reinstall it properly hopefully in a way that works as the manufacturers originally intended all those years ago
Before we can proceed we must overcome a few obstacles as unfortunately it has sustained some damage
There's a rather unsightly crack around the lower end of the bearing that opened up when the top of the spindle burst at the end
I didn’t realize it until I got up off the floor so fixing that repair is my top priority
But before doing any of that let's take a step back and examine why he was stuck in the first place
Typically when you have pieces that are tightly stuck it's difficult to get them moving at first but once they start shifting the process becomes progressively easier and everything begins to move smoothly again
You might even be able to push the piece slightly backward or make it turn
These actions help circulate the oil through the clogged area and dislodge any dirt or rust that might be causing the issue
But in their case it was the exact opposite
It began to move then hardened and remained rigid until the bitter end
Why on earth was that
Well I've been thinking about it and I have a few suspicions
To confirm those suspicions we'll need to take some measurements
The first measurement I want to take is this end
of the screw shaft up here It's free of rust
In fact it's still slightly oily
So I'll measure it
It's just over two and a quarter in 1026
I don't know why it's 10 000 over 2 and a quarter but that's what they decided to do
This end is heavily encrusted with hard glass-like rust that is flaky and brittle
And that is 2.27
That's 2.65
And right here above 2.65
And there's the thickest point measuring 2.271 which is 11 000 units thicker than the unoxidized end
Why Well let's take
the same measurements on the bearing
That is 2 269
Let's do it again
A bit deeper and in a spot that isn't damaged or has a rusted groove
That's 2.266 and 2.66 again 2.266
That's 5 000 less than the larger end over there and 6 000 greater than that original surface
I'm not surprised Probably it's just tolerance But
that explains why getting through that
lower extreme was so difficult
But that still doesn't explain how it became thicker
If it had been contained within this sphere all along it would be physically impossible
It doesn't matter how rusty it might be it could still swell up that much
So let's measure the other end
And it's quite a bit larger now
The next one is 2 315 because that's where a larger board ends for the open space
This opening ends here and then higher up it's quite wide
This is where it's been all along
This end has been protruding
That’s why he’s so irritable
And here it’s nice and clean
The area where that cluster of empty space begins aligns with where this starts becoming much thicker
and also with oxidation in the groove due to the large clearance between this diameter and the one located there
The water has been able to stay there and carry
out its unpleasant task thanks to the way it's arranged
When this is inserted inside and the feed screw slides
over it much of the feed screw is exposed to the elements
Thus any water that struck the feed screw has spiraled down the screw and reached this area
And this has remained almost constantly damp and filled with water throughout the 40 years the machine was outdoors
Therefore it's no surprise that it was so difficult to remove him as he was essentially
what we had between these two figures was a 5000 interference fit
This is why it only moved when there was a significant temperature difference
I should add that this interference adjustment was definitely a contributing factor to the crack at the end
Maybe if I had heated this end at the same time as pushing it out it might have been avoided
Yet the crack was most likely already there perhaps caused by my blows or perhaps present from the very first day
Nevertheless we're where we are and it's time to move forward with the repair
Prior to that the parts are thoroughly cleaned and soaked in a chemical desoxidant
I'm using a brand I've never tried before It's called Viltan Verde
Ox and oddly enough it's a powder designed to dissolve in water
I quickly realized the water needed to be quite hot and since I don't have a hot water supply in the workshop
It took me quite a while to get it to dissolve properly but in the end we managed it with a few teapots
Some pieces didn't receive the molasses treatment because they were still attached to something at the time
The key component is this conical pulley on the headstock side which drives the feed shaft via the worm gear fitted into the cast piece
It came out very easily and I decided it wasn't worth the trouble to pull it out
You can paint around it and perform in-situ descaling this way
I found a box that comfortably fits the spindle bearing
And a piece of sealed drainage pipe is ideal for the screw itself
In the remaining part of the cube I'll also degrease the top lid of the column
It also serves as the vertical shaft bearing as well as the feed pulley which I addressed in part 7
It's time to let him do his job
After rinsing and cleaning it some rust still remained deep within the holes so I returned it to the solution for a second treatment
Let's see how that conical pulley works
Well this is the second time
That looks really good
It has definitely fulfilled its purpose and now we can properly assess that damage
It's nearly come loose
It's fully cracked in annoying way plus that small crack right in the center
so it probably wants to come out straight away
There it is
Looking inside this brake we can see the grain structure of the cast iron
We can also see the dark area in the lower right portion of the
brake indicating that a fracture was likely present here from day one
All I did was finish the job properly
Confirmed suspicion
It's definitely cast iron
So we'll continue with some preparation work on this and see if we can weld it
I want to weld the original broken piece so I decided to temporarily reinstall the spindle to serve as a guide ensuring the broken piece stays properly supported during welding
The top end of the screw needed a bit of adjustment at first but once those high spots in the milled area were smoothed out it slid in with a little persuasion
A few additional tweaks will be made later when it's time to work on the spindle but this adjustment will do for now
I'll begin by preheating the entire area generally before focusing the heat on the joint
This is high-temperature soldering
I decided to weld this joint primarily because it's a supporting surface running inside a conical bronze bearing
With strong brazing there is significantly less risk of creating hard spots or inclusions in the weld area that could damage the bronze bearing later on
The repair will also be concealed so the visible contrast between bronze and iron isn't such a significant issue
I don't have much experience with brazing but I think this turned out pretty well and I definitely enjoyed making it
It's quite therapeutic once you get used to it
Once I was satisfied with the repair I wrapped it up to allow for a slow cooling process
Once cooled and with the excess material around the repair smoothed down it's time to head to the lathe and see if I can do some machining
And here's where things got strange
Initially I mounted the part on the lathe using the central section of the bearing as a reference on the steady rest
g that would give me good access to repair the machine both inside and out and possibly polish both surfaces of the bearing again
After securing the chuck's end it was immediately obvious something was wrong—the bearing piece exhibited a severe eccentricity at its end
I pushed the window down as far as it would go all the way to the tapered end
It wasn't ideal but it was unavoidable at this stage so I scanned the various surfaces with the DTI
This first surface is where the bevel gear which drives the entire bearing and lead screw inside is mounted
That was fine at 5000 I can live with that
The teeth of the 150-year-old bevel gears aren't even machined so they can withstand only a few thousandths of eccentricity
Then if we move up to the upper conical bearing stub you can see it's smoother but wears down slightly more around 6000
Moving into the middle zone it's quite severe with nearly 15 000 people displaced
A little higher up it's even worse with over 15 000
Then descending to the lower stump it returns to about 6 in the middle section and around 8 at the top
When measuring the section that runs along the lunette we can see that the inner diameter is quite accurate ignoring that protrusion
Likely just a bit of flux or some residue from the brazing material
On the outside they're just a few thousand
The lack of smoothness is likely due to rust
When viewing these numbers with the reading displayed in the middle it appears to bend at that point and further research is needed
For now I'll use this setup to clean the repaired inner diameter enough so we don't touch any iron
And I can always finish the rest by hand when it's time to install the spindle
Heat
It definitely slides much more easily than before
Despite what the strange DTI readings suggest the fact that I can turn this proves one thing
The issue is that the internal hole isn't bent
And the imperfections we previously observed in the DTI are present on these surfaces
What am I going to do about it I'm still not sure
I guess I'll have to machine it a bit on the lathe especially to get those two bearing stubs aligned with each other again
After all I want this drill to work properly Therefore any
misalignment between those two stubs will only cause issues
I'm fairly confident there's enough material available to do it but additional measurements are needed to confirm that
The more perceptive among you are probably horrified by the mess at the back end
Don't worry I'll take care of that soon enough
But thank you so much for watching the video and see you next time
