San Francisco is revising how it responds to street homelessness after years of rising costs and uneven results. The city is placing more emphasis on recovery based programs that bring structure and accountability alongside shelter. In this episode, we speak with Steve Adami, executive director of The Way Out, a recovery focused homelessness initiative in San Francisco, and Major Michael Zielinski, division commander of the Golden State Division of The Salvation Army, to examine how this model works day to day and what it changes for people trying to leave the street behind.
00:00 - Intro 01:09 - Improvements in San Francisco's Homelessness Crisis 05:43 - Challenges with Current Approaches 07:26 - Affordable Housing and Accountability 10:11 - The Salvation Army's Approach 26:29 - The Role of Government and Local Leadership 32:12 - The Cost of Homelessness Programs 39:10 - The Impact of Drug Use on Homelessness 45:05 - The Future of Homelessness Programs
San Francisco is changing its approach to homelessness,
and will it work this time?
Today, we sit down with one of the key nonprofits,
one of the good ones in San Francisco,
to find out what's happening on the ground,
and will the city be able to take care of this problem
and get back to what it used to be?
In San Francisco, currently,
eight out of 10 people in the shelter system
return to homelessness.
That's a horrible statistic.
Our behavioral health system has a 12% success rate.
Folks that come through a process
actually develop that ownership
and care for themselves again
to where they want to do better.
When you look at an 82% success rate,
to me, it's worth the investment.
I'm Siamak Khorrami.
Welcome to California Insider.
Steve and Michael, it's great to have you on.
Welcome.
Thank you.
We want to talk to you about homelessness
and what's going on with homelessness.
You guys have a lot of experience in this field,
and we have covered San Francisco
when it had a big crisis.
Some of it is still continuing, but things are changing.
Can you tell us what's happening
in San Francisco right now?
From my own perspective, things are really improving.
Crime is down, encampments are down.
The city, over the last year,
has gone through some real positive transformation.
We had a new mayor elected last year
who really hit the ground running
and put together a really good team
that has a very clear strategy,
and they're relentless about their priorities.
So they've really been prioritizing public safety,
ending public drug use, cleaning up encampments,
cleaning up the streets,
and really making the city business-friendly.
So tourists is coming back.
Companies are moving in.
Just this last holiday season,
San Francisco Airport set a record for the most visitors
visiting San Francisco in any holiday season.
So all indicators of a healthy community
are coming back to San Francisco.
And really, as the newcomer,
I've only been in San Francisco six months,
but you can feel the vibe.
You can feel the goals of the mayor.
You can feel that he really is results-oriented
in what he's doing.
It's not just about saying we'll do something,
but you can see and honestly see
he's putting his money where his mouth is.
He's saying, no, we will be different.
We will be a recovery community.
We're not going to be a lawless community any longer.
And I think he really has established that.
And we have a large center in the Tenderloin,
and you look at how much the Tenderloin has cleaned up.
I was in a visit two years ago
for a review of that particular headquarters
and stayed down near Union Square,
and I walked those neighborhoods.
It's a completely different place.
It's actually a place where you want to be.
It's a place where you're going to feel safe
to walk and be around again.
But more importantly, we see people being helped.
They aren't people just being pushed out or shuttered.
They actually is trying to help.
And that's really where the mayor is at.
His goal is not just to operate shelters
to hide the population,
but his goal really is that we have transitional facilities
for people in San Francisco
so they can become a part of what we call
the normal flow of life again.
In our programs, we might say we're trying to teach people
how to suit up and show up again.
And that's really where I believe the mayor is going,
and he's making an impact, and we're appreciative of that.
California is passing a lot of data privacy laws,
but I'll be honest, sometimes it really hits me.
How much of my life is online?
My name, my address, my birthday, cell phone number,
email address, it's all out there, floating around.
And I've never actually gave anyone permission to use it.
If you're listening to this,
your information is probably out there too.
Think about it, anyone can look us up,
they know where we live, sell our details to strangers,
or worse, potentially steal our identity.
I get a bunch of random phone calls on a regular basis,
and it's scary to know that people can access
my information so easily from across the world.
The internet that's supposed to be a place
for us to connect, it's become a place
that makes us feel scared, less safe.
I'm not accepting that anymore,
and you don't have to either.
That's why I use today's sponsor, Aura.
Aura goes after the data brokers
who profit from selling our personal lives.
They actually scrub our information from those sites
and make sure it stays gone.
I've seen other services out there,
but nothing is as thorough or offers as much
for the same price as Aura.
You can see it for yourself.
Try Aura free for 14 days at aura.com
slash California insider.
Give it two weeks and let Aura do the heavy lifting,
finding and removing your details
from those shady broker sites,
so you can finally take control of your digital life.
I've decided to not leave myself vulnerable on the internet,
and honestly, I don't think you should either.
With Aura, you can finally feel safe,
secure, and back in control.
Now let's watch the rest of the interview.
You mentioned hiding people in the shelters,
and essentially we've talked to a lot of people
from across the state,
and a lot of cities in California are facing this challenge.
And a lot of people have complained to us about shelters
as a way that people are going in.
It's not very clear if it's safe, who's in there,
what's happening, and who comes out, do they recover?
What are your thoughts on the approach
that we have taken in California in general
with homelessness?
I look at it from the standpoint
of you can't warehouse people.
Just because people have an issue
doesn't mean we hide them, we put them in a building.
We were in a shelter the other day
that has 280 residents in a former apartment building.
You had four people in a room, two bunk beds in a room,
plus a dog, plus whatever their possessions were.
It really wasn't a pleasant environment.
People were in bed all day.
It's really trying to give people hope,
and that really felt like hopelessness
because they didn't have an opportunity to move forward.
I know we talk a lot about affordable housing.
People coming into the shelter,
where do they go once they leave the shelter?
So I think it's a two-pronged effort.
I think we have to be able to provide
transitional opportunities for people,
an opportunity for them to get back in the mainstream again.
We chatted earlier about the idea
that people didn't become homeless overnight,
they're not gonna become unhomeless overnight.
So we have to have the steps.
We have a continuum of care
that we've developed in San Francisco
that helps to move people through the cycle,
sort of prepares them to once again,
to move out into the greater community again,
and not to fail, but to be successful.
When we look at the number,
the people that have moved from our shelters,
and it's not just here in San Francisco,
it's in other rehab facilities
that we operate around the country,
where people have been with us a year or more,
they have an 80% chance of making it
once they leave our facility,
as opposed to if people are with us for six months or less,
they have about a 23% chance of making it.
So the idea is how do we provide that long-term stability
so that they continue to learn the skills that they need
in order to function in today's society?
But I still think the missing component
is that concept of what is truly affordable housing.
When we look at the rules and regulations in place,
builders don't wanna build
because there's no money in it for them,
and it becomes too expensive.
We talk about in San Francisco,
it costs a million dollars to build a home,
or a million dollars to build an apartment.
That's not affordable when you try and look at it
from a return on investment.
So people don't wanna invest there.
So we have to figure out
how do we put together affordable housing
so we can transition people, and so that it's safe.
There are other places in the country,
I can think of where I've been
where we have efficiency apartments.
Well, the problem is with those efficiency apartments
is those folks who have just come from the street
and they've said, oh, let's put them in an apartment
and they'll be fine, but they're not fine
because they don't have the skills
or the coping mechanisms yet
to really function and live independently.
They still need accountability.
They still need support in that process.
You know, I think one of the biggest challenges we faced
is the homeless response doesn't really address
the reason why people are homeless in the first place.
And so when we talk about shelters or interim housing
or even permanent supportive housing, what is our goal?
Just to move somebody off the street
so that tourists don't have to see them,
so that people don't have to look at them,
or are we really centered on helping people
reclaim their place in the community?
And I think the challenge that I see daily
is that we put people into housing,
we don't address the root cause
of why they don't have housing,
and we allow them to live the same way
they were living when they were on the streets.
In San Francisco, currently,
eight out of 10 people in the shelter system
return to homelessness.
That's a horrible statistic.
We spend $1.5 billion a year
on behavioral health and homeless services,
and our behavioral health system has a 12% success rate.
And our work really should be centered collectively
on giving people back their lives
so they can reclaim their place in the community
and reestablish the goals that they had
before they became homeless.
And we just currently don't do that.
You walk through the city shelter,
the people are in bed, people all have dogs,
they can't take care of themselves,
their dogs often go uncared for.
It's very chaotic.
In our work in San Francisco,
things are very structured and people are thriving.
Really addressing the root causes of homelessness
is important, and the current housing-first
harm reduction model just does not do that.
What's the difference between when you do that,
where you mentioned you're giving somebody back their life
versus just give them housing?
Can you explain how is it different?
It's really ownership and participation in the process.
When we look at recovery and rehabilitation processes,
the onus is on that individual
to participate in that process,
whether it's through process groups,
whether it's through individual counseling,
whether it's between work they have to do on their own,
they have to own that.
When you just give somebody a house,
they have no ownership.
They take it for granted.
They didn't earn it, they didn't develop it,
they didn't buy it, so why should I care about it?
Versus the folks that come through a process
actually develop that ownership
and care for themselves again
to where they want to do better.
It isn't about, oh, great, somebody gave this to me.
In the Salvation Army, we talk about
we don't wanna just give somebody a handout,
we wanna give them a hand up.
And that's really the difference.
We can give them a handout, but is that sustaining?
Is it, it's the old axiom of give a person a fish
and they'll depend on you for the rest of their life.
Teach that person to fish
and they'll be able to sustain themselves
and support themselves.
And that's where we see the model we're trying to work with
is we're giving people ownership
and responsibility again.
By not giving them responsibility,
they're not gonna take advantage of that.
They're not gonna possess it.
They're not gonna own it.
They're simply going to say, oh, well, thank you.
Sometimes they don't even say thank you.
Sometimes it's, oh, about time you gave this to me.
You know, the current system allows people
to be the worst of themselves
where we ask people to be the best of themselves.
When you look at people on the streets,
people that are homeless,
people that are addicted to drugs,
they've lost all hope.
And simple accomplishments or successes
reinvigorates that inspiration towards life.
And when you ask somebody to be the best of themselves,
they realize the endless possibilities
that they once dreamed of as a child.
Where you compare that to just the housing first
or the harm reduction model
where we expect people to fail
and we expect people to be the worst of themselves.
And then we create mitigating factors
to help them stay the way they are.
I'll give you a perfect example.
You know, we hand out in San Francisco
somewhere close to 200,000 doses a year of naloxone.
I think it's really great to save a life
if somebody overdoses.
But the response to the overdose
is just to save the life.
And then we allow the person just to go back
to doing exactly what they were doing before.
San Francisco is about to open
something called the Reset Center
where people using drugs publicly
or they're under the influence will be arrested
and booked into the Reset Center.
Will be connected to treatment and recovery services
where people will be asked and invited
to participate in programs.
Now we allow people to use drugs,
they overdose, we revive them
only to return them back to the same environment
to overdose again and to revive them again.
Where there's no change at all.
There's no expectation that they should change
or we don't ask them to change.
And it just hasn't worked over the past 15 to 20 years.
In San Francisco or throughout the state.
Throughout my lifetime I think housing first
and harm reduction have been some of the most
regressive policies that have really
destroyed communities and destroyed
people struggling with addiction.
I say that from a perspective of
somebody who spent years of my life
cycling in and out of drug use
and jail and prison and homelessness.
That accountability is the cornerstone of change.
And when you couple accountability with opportunity
that really gives somebody hope
that there is a new life possible.
And I think those are the biggest changes
that have to take place throughout our state
if we're really going to change the dynamic
of people's lives that are struggling
with addiction and homelessness.
You mentioned the $1 million apartment.
It costs a million to give it to someone.
But how much does it cost to get somebody
have that hope to change their trajectory?
Somebody that's homeless that's.
It's $94 a day.
I can give you the cost comparison.
In San Francisco, if you're going to solve
homelessness for a hundred people,
it's a million dollars a unit per person.
So it'd be a hundred million dollars.
And then it's $50,000 a year per person
for their rent for the rest of their lives.
Our model, comparatively speaking,
our model is $31,000 a year.
Lasts anywhere from two to four years
depending on the needs of the people.
Sometimes it's a little bit shorter.
And it's a one-time investment into somebody's lives
where they can then achieve independence
and go out and get their own job,
reunite with their family, raise their children,
retake their place in the community and contribute.
In other words, me just giving you something
for the rest of your life that's very expensive
or helping somebody take over their own life.
And our work is really centered on giving people back hope
and helping them take over their own lives.
And what was the moment for you?
Was there a moment for you
that this model worked?
Because it seems like you have gone through the system
from different angles and now you know this works.
Can you tell us your experience?
It took a long time for me.
I was not a quick learner by any means,
but I will say that this is uncomfortable
for a lot of people to hear,
but being held accountable changed my life.
Prison changed my life, especially the last prison term.
I remember sitting in North Block of San Quentin.
I spent my whole life blaming others for my problems.
And I had this moment of clarity
during my last prison term while sitting in a cell
that at the center of all my problems was me
and that if I caused all those problems,
then I could also solve them.
And that was really,
it was like a very freeing moment in my mind,
a pivotal moment in my life
that I could do something differently.
And when I got out of prison,
I became part of a community of people
that were coming home from jail,
coming home from prison,
trying to stay clean and sober.
And we helped each other,
the old principle of each one teach one.
And you don't see that often today in these medical models.
The relationship is between an individual and their doctor
or individual and clinician,
where I was part of a community of people
and we were all helping each other
kind of go up the mountain together.
And I think that's another thing that's been lost
in these new models of harm reduction, housing first,
and really medical driven models of recovery,
lose this sense of community.
If you get people to see what their challenges are,
to understand that they,
how long does it take?
How does it work?
Can you tell us about the process?
It's really a part of our continuum of care.
For a person that comes into our program initially
through what we call our Harbor Light,
and they may go through detox.
And then typically they go through
a six month recovery program,
whether it's in our Harbor Light
or one of our adult rehabilitation centers,
which helps them to reconnect
a lot of those neural synapses to,
because you have a curfew.
You have to get up in the morning.
There are classes you have to go through.
So it's beginning,
that's beginning of that retraining for an individual.
And then once they finish that six months,
the next step is then finding work.
And a part of then finding work
is moving into transitional housing
and moving into transitional.
You still are continuing to employ
and use the basics that you learned
in that first six months,
whether it's going to your meetings,
whether it's working with a sponsor,
whether it's being a part of a process group,
whether it's working with the case manager.
And then you're saving money
so that you can stay with us at that point
up to 24 months and have saved money,
continue to work the process
until you're now ready to move out onto your own again.
But it costs money to do that.
But at the same time,
we believe that the return is so large.
When you look at an 82% success rate,
to me, it's worth the investment.
So 82% success rate,
meaning that when people get out of your program,
they're on their own.
Yeah.
It's defined as, in the final phase,
people that exit employed, housed, and clean and sober.
But if we take a step back,
in 2023, the Salvation Army San Francisco
launched a homeless initiative called The Way Out.
And the initiative focused solely
on the intersection of drug addiction and homelessness.
And what we've been able to build in San Francisco
is a continuum of care,
which we call a recovery system of care,
that spans 10 programs, 600 beds,
with four ultimate goals.
We want to get people off the streets in real time.
We want to get them off of drugs
and teach them how to live.
We want to give them a few years after treatment
in housing that's focused on recovery,
where they can learn marketable job skills,
get jobs, and save money,
with the ultimate goal
that they can then reunite with their family
and reclaim their place in the community.
And it's really sequenced,
compared to the current homeless response system
that is just, you have a person that's homeless,
and the solution is just to give them a house.
It skips all the sequencing
of getting people off of drugs,
addressing mental illness,
getting people stable,
getting people healthy,
teaching people how to live,
and then giving them time to practice.
And what we see is when you take somebody off the streets
and just stick them in an apartment,
most of the time, it doesn't work out.
Most of the time, they return back to the streets.
So it's been amazing to see the work
that we've done in San Francisco.
It's had a lot of support locally.
I think the way out, the initiative itself,
is about 85% of it is funded by the local government.
15% of it is funded by our donors and other grants.
But cost comparatively,
it's much less expensive than the Housing First model.
And the success, as Major Zielinski said,
is like eight times higher
than either the Shelter System Housing First model
or the Medi-Cal funded treatment model.
I think I mentioned earlier
that there was an article published a year ago December
in the Chronicle where people had gone
to a drug treatment center in San Francisco
and they ended up overdosing and dying.
And this story had data in it
that was taken from the state
that showed San Francisco's Medi-Cal funded
drug treatment programs had a 12% success rate,
meaning for the $800 million we spend,
88 out of 100 people failed.
I mean, I think anybody that was rational would say,
we're obviously doing something wrong.
Are, is the model bad?
Are the providers bad?
Do we not hold people to the same standard
that we'd hold our children to?
And I don't think anybody took a deep dive into the problem.
When Mayor Lurie got elected,
what he did was is he changed the director
of the Department of Public Health.
And the new director has got a very clear vision
aligned with the mayor's.
And they're really funding programs now
that prioritize recovery and prioritize abstinence.
And I think the abstinence movement
has really come a long way just in the last
two and a half years in San Francisco.
And there's been a collection of people
that have really worked hard.
There's been advocates, there's been people in recovery,
and there's been city leaders that have all come together
to promote recovery and to promote abstinence
from drug use.
The interesting aspect of all of this is,
is this is new for the Army to do.
The Army was founded in 1865 in London, England.
Our founder, William Booth, actually wrote a book
back in those early days called
The Way Out and In Darkest England.
And it was essentially what we're doing today.
It was taking a man and you look at the graphic of it,
it's a photo of people awash in the ocean
and there are people around that.
And as you look at the picture,
you see the different steps that people can get to.
Now this went a little farther.
Actually, the Army was thinking of farm colonies
at that point in time,
where people could participate in the process.
But the concept was always been,
it takes steps to get people from here to here.
We joked that the Army was founded by accident.
William Booth was a Methodist preacher
and was doing revival meetings
in the East End of London, Miles End Waste.
And his goal was to see people are converted
and then go into the church.
Well, the problem became is,
in that point in time in the church,
it was more about what was going into the offering plate
than it was that was going into your soul.
And so the churches were not accepting all these people
that were from the street, et cetera, that had no means.
And so he began, at that point in time,
it was called the Christian Mission,
several years later,
it then became what we now know as the Salvation Army
because it was a movement.
And he talked about it moving like an army.
Well, he wrote this book
because he saw how do we get people
from this point to this point?
And really, in many ways,
what we're doing today isn't anything new,
but we're taking what we've known and applying it
and saying, folks, this is what works.
We know what works.
We know these other models don't work.
We can do it for less money
and we can see more lives changed.
Now, the piece that we haven't talked about is it's God.
It's our faith base, which helps us and powers us to do this.
It's not something that happens by accident
or because we just have goodwill,
but we know that it takes a radical change
in a person's life.
Otherwise, they're gonna continue
to do what their own self-will is and continue to fail.
So we provide them with that opportunity
to see how they can change, not just physically,
but emotionally and spiritually as well
so they can continue to have success in their life.
Unfortunately, there's a lot of negativity
and anxiety right now.
Even in a beautiful place like California,
I'm constantly running to people that are facing depression.
Even they have a lot of things materially.
No matter what you and your family are going through
right now, there is still hope.
Imagine surrounding yourself for two hours
with pure beauty, amazing music,
colors that we don't see in this world anymore,
and a message of hope and inspiration.
Shen Yun is coming back to California.
I've been going to the show for the last 14 years
and every time I go, I see smiles on the people's faces
when they're leaving the theater
and the expressions are in a way
that is hard to explain,
but there is this joy coming from inside
and I want you guys to experience that.
If you want to take a break from all the negativity
and anxiety that's out there,
make sure to give yourself this experience.
It will really lift your soul.
Shen Yun is currently performing in Northern California
and soon will come to LA area and Southern California.
Make sure to get your tickets right now
before they sell out.
A performance that truly matters,
each and every one of us,
is what you've been waiting for, Shen Yun.
Get tickets now at ShenYun.com.
Is it possible to roll this out to the rest of the state
and how are each regions in California responding to it?
In California, in the Salvation Army,
we have what are called three different divisions
and each of those divisions has what's called
a divisional commander.
In our instance, we're the Golden State Division.
We take the 18 counties in Central California.
I am the divisional commander for that area,
for the Golden State Division.
Within that division, we have a number of shelters.
At this point in time,
San Francisco has been our focal point
because of funding and opportunity
and a willingness to work with us to effect change.
We have other communities that have operated shelters
which are having the same exact problems
that San Francisco was.
I spent a day in Modesto before I came down here
and we're looking at changing our shelters
from being that low barrier shelter
to something of a transitional level
so that people are actually able to move out.
We have people that have stayed
in these low barrier shelters for two years.
I don't think it's intended that you're to live
in that type of an instance for two years or more.
The observation is if it's transitional,
then we need to move on to something else.
And so we're trying to go back now and look at,
we're gonna downsize the number of beds we have,
but we also are saying,
we're gonna be able to move people in and out.
They're not just gonna be there forever.
And I think that's the model
that we're beginning to roll out in other areas.
If we're gonna do shelter,
this is how we want to do shelter
because this is where we see results.
How much the local government's policy matter?
We're seeing that in San Francisco right now.
There is a change in thinking.
There's a shift in thinking, shift in leadership.
And it doesn't have to be shift in leadership,
but there's a change in thinking.
And now you're seeing the results.
Does that matter a lot?
Is there a lot of fund available?
It makes all the difference.
In the situation I described just down the street,
city of Anaheim is a huge part of that
and is largely involved what's going on there.
That's what makes it successful.
In San Francisco, prior to Mayor Lurie,
I don't think it would have been possible,
but it is possible now
because he truly wants to make change.
In Modesto, working with the city and county there,
they want to make change.
They want to see something different
because they've realized that their other efforts
have been flailing.
So we have to do something.
We have to do something different.
We can't continue that definition of insanity,
doing the same thing over and over again,
expecting a different result.
And that's where I see the change.
And it takes government leadership
wanting to make that change.
We can make a certain amount of change on our own,
but really it does take a village to get it done.
I can think of many times I would get called and said,
your people are down here tearing this up
or your people are doing this.
And it's like, they're not my people.
They're your citizens.
They're all of our people.
And now we're not,
we don't hear from the mayor's office saying,
your people are doing this.
We hear from the mayor's office.
How can we work together?
Give us your input, your ideas.
What are the outcomes that you believe can take place?
So it's not just a,
it isn't just us.
It isn't just them.
It's all of us working together as a team to make it happen.
Something that comes up often is funding for programs.
And I think in 2013,
the Obama administration launched the Housing First Model
as a one-size-fits-all policy to end homelessness.
We were told we would end homelessness in 10 years.
Obviously that didn't happen.
In 2016, Governor Newsom was the only governor
in the first state, California,
to launch the Housing First Model
with the same promise that we would end homelessness.
And what we've seen is spending on homeless services
has gone up.
And so has homelessness,
because that response doesn't address
why people are on the streets in the first place.
I think it takes a combination.
I know the federal government now is moving
in that direction where it's really a recovery-first model
and local governments.
Where we're fortunate in San Francisco
is that we are a resource-rich community.
We have some budget problems now that were inherited
because the business community was negatively impacted
by open-air drug markets and crime at one point,
but we're on the rebound now.
So we're able to work with local government
who has a different vision than the state
to really address why people are on the streets.
Just yesterday in Mayor Lurie's State of the City speech,
he was very clear that do not come to San Francisco
and use drugs, you will be arrested.
Do not come to San Francisco and sell drugs,
you will be arrested.
That we are a recovery-first city,
and that's where he's putting his resources.
That if you invest in people
and give people the ability to change,
it makes a healthier, stronger community
than just giving somebody a shelter bed or a house.
And I think our continuum in San Francisco,
which spans 10 programs,
really addresses the needs of people on the streets
where we sequence them through a collection of programs
that each plays a different role
in helping them rebuild their lives.
Something that doesn't happen outside the standard model.
There's been billions of dollars
going towards homelessness.
If you guys are the experts,
you're in this field, you know it well.
If this money was not going to Housing First,
or if it was coming to models like yours,
would we be able to solve this problem?
Would we be able to not have significant debt
in the number of people that are homeless?
I think there's one element
that's the constant in all of this.
That's people.
And people have to want to change.
If people want to change, then they won't change.
There are some folks, back in the day,
we used to call them the winos, the bums.
There are some people that don't ever want to change.
Our goal is for those that want to change,
we'll be that resource.
So can we bring it to zero?
No, I don't believe that we'll ever bring it to zero.
That may sound pessimistic.
All of us have our own interests, but it's realistic.
But for those that want to change,
gosh, I'm going to be a part of that change agent
and help them to change.
I'm willing to do whatever it takes
for someone that wants to change.
For someone who doesn't want to change,
I'm going to let them wait until they're ready.
But for the individual, the family, et cetera,
that wants to change, man, I'll be their champion.
And that's where I want to invest my money.
With my finance background, man, I'm looking,
what's the return on investment here?
And if somebody wants to change,
I'm willing to invest in them
because I know in the long run,
they're going to do great.
And it's a lot less expensive on us as a culture and society.
But the most important part is that they're successful
and they feel successful in what they're doing,
which breeds then the next generation
that has that same feeling of success.
When we look at the drug situation,
it's really helping people understand
that there are other alternatives to that.
That's not where you bury your fears.
That's not where you bury your hurt.
That's not where you find excitement.
Where you find excitement in life
is by living it with other people
and enjoying that life together.
From this conversation and from what we have learned,
it looks like the money is going now to the right place
or right solutions.
I mean, California has squandered billions of dollars
on solutions that didn't work.
I don't know if we're going to fully come back
from those episodes,
but I do think what's missing in the whole system
from a provider standpoint
and from a person that is struggling standpoint
is there's just no accountability in the system.
That we spend money in the vein
that we're going to improve things
and then things don't improve
and there's never any course correction.
And I think that had we invested
those government funds differently,
I think we would have made a greater impact
on the homeless crisis in California.
I actually think there is a housing crisis to some degree,
but I think what you're really seeing play out
on the streets is a drug crisis.
And the drug crisis then morphs
into this criminal justice episode
where nobody's being held accountable.
People are breaking the law, people are using drugs
and people are just running around
saying if they just had housing, things would change.
And that's just the farthest thing from the truth.
They would just have a different place to maybe set up shop.
They would not change their lives
because they would continue in the same lifestyle.
I think we have to hold people accountable
and it's through that accountability
that often is the impetus for people to change their lives.
I think the vast majority of people
that are living in these housing first models
struggle with addiction.
California Policy Lab published a paper in 2019
that said 75% of the homeless population
struggled with addiction.
Yet the housing first law in California
doesn't require anybody to stop using drugs
or even participate in any services.
It's merely we're gonna give you a house,
we're gonna pay your rent and everything else is optional.
So I mentioned this earlier that in our model,
we are asking people to be the best of themselves,
knowing that they will make mistakes from time to time.
In the current model, we just allow people
to be the worst of themselves
and everybody else is just paying the bill.
And I think that investing in people
is what we should be investing,
not investing in just paying people's rent
and giving them a place to live for the rest of their lives.
To build is a million dollars,
but then for each individual, it's $50,000.
It's a maintenance cost of $50,000 a year
on top of the million, yeah.
And it's for the rest of their lives.
It's for perpetuity.
Yeah, it's a permanent subsidy
compared to a shallow subsidy.
So it's very expensive.
It's incredibly expensive.
And one of the questions we're saying.
I mean, that's why when we ask, is it enough money?
I don't think it's about whether it's enough money.
I think it's about how are we spending the money?
The other question is, is who's on the hook
for this rent for the person's the rest of their life?
Is it the federal government?
Is it the state?
Is it the local municipality?
In this recent federal continuum of care NOFO,
the federal government was gonna reduce
the permanent supportive housing guarantees to like 30%.
So a lot of the models would have been cut or unfunded.
So we have people in these units.
Who is supposed to pay that rent
if the federal government cut the funding?
Is it gonna be the local government, philanthropists?
Again, the system is centered on moving the problem
from the street into a place
where we don't have to look at them.
And then you throw another element into this
that we're dealing with in one of our own facilities.
It's a permanent supportive housing facility is.
Who pays for all the damage
that the person who's living in there does?
You know, they break off sprinkler heads,
fire sprinkler heads, floods apartments.
Doesn't just flood one apartment,
it floods down the other apartments.
You're on the hook for a million dollars.
Because they wanna smoke?
Is that what they wanna do?
Yeah, yeah, they wanna smoke.
Or they think that's some place to hang things.
Or they think there's a camera in there,
so they're gonna destroy the spy camera
that's hiding in the sprinkler.
I mean, we're in the process,
we're getting ready to do a $4.5 million remodel project
to one of our permissive housing projects
so that we can add the ability,
if somebody knocks a sprinkler off in their room,
it's only gonna impact their room.
It's gonna drain somewhere else
as opposed to draining through several buildings.
But who pays for that?
Well, we're gonna pay for that of our own insurance captive
in order to make that happen.
But it's $4.5 million that could have been spent.
For other homeless.
For other homeless, as opposed to trying to fix
because the people that are in there
have went right from the street into that situation
and haven't done all the work in between to be ready for it.
Prop 36 passed, and a lot of people hope
that this will bring back the drug court
or actually make it.
Have you guys seen anything from this proposition?
You know, it's challenging in San Francisco
because nobody has any priors.
And so it's really predicated,
36 is really predicated on priors.
Because they don't, they just get the ticket.
Because they get a ticket and it's a misdemeanor,
so it doesn't show up.
It doesn't show up.
Yeah, I know there hasn't been many Prop 36 cases
in San Francisco since the law passed,
really the implementation.
It's not the fault of our district attorney
who's done an incredible job.
It's the system itself.
Nobody just has any priors.
When you look back on people's criminal history
between judicial diversion, mental health diversion,
and other justice reform over the years,
things just haven't happened.
Also, the bench in San Francisco.
It's another issue we could spend a whole show on
talking about the accountability of judges in the city.
But I think that that used to be the intervention
that got most people clean.
It just doesn't happen.
The intersection between living on the streets.
I mean, just think about it.
People come to San Francisco, did.
I mean, things are changing.
So I'm talking two, three, four, five years ago,
since 2020.
People could come to San Francisco and sell drugs.
People came from all over the state or country
to use drugs.
They lived on the streets.
They committed crimes to support their habits,
and no one was held accountable.
What happened was is we have a beautiful mall
in downtown San Francisco.
Every business moved out.
You would walk downtown.
Every other door was boarded up.
They destroyed downtown.
Downtown is no longer for drug users in San Francisco.
Downtown is for tourists, businesses, families,
children, and residents.
And the city, our mayor is taking back the city
and making it a place for everybody.
I mean, drug use has so negatively impacted communities
and people that were struggling with addiction.
It's incredible.
And it's just gone on way too long.
I would be speaking at an event and people would say like,
wow, you've accomplished a great deal in your life.
And I'd be like, I am an average.
I'm just average.
I know people that are brilliant.
I'm average.
What happened for me was,
is there was an intervention that saved my life.
And what it was called was prison, right?
I got a wake up call that helped me get clean,
that gave me a pathway to a new way of life.
Two and a half months ago,
we launched the city's first abstinence-based shelter.
It is-
It's actually been four months ago now.
Four months.
So it's called Hope House.
Our shelter has a curfew, 9 p.m.
Anytime you leave, you have to have a pass.
We are drug testing people
when they're out on passes randomly.
We are also breathalyzing people
when they come in and out of the building.
And we just did a satisfaction survey
of the participants in the program.
And the overwhelming sense was,
this was the greatest opportunity they've had in years.
That unlike other city shelters
that are chaotic and loud and drug use,
you could walk in there, you could hear a pin drop.
People are in bed at night.
People are getting up in the morning.
We require everyone to go to a morning meeting.
Every day, if they're not employed,
they have to participate in two activities,
either onsite or offsite.
That includes like AA meetings, NA meetings,
process groups, yoga, health and wellness activities,
going to the gym.
So we tried to create an environment
that replicates real life for people.
The ultimate goal of the shelter was to stabilize people
and get them to go to treatment.
So we've had a significant number of people
that have gone on to drug treatment.
But one thing that was really shocking
was there's a lot of people on the streets
that are just severely mentally ill
that don't even use drugs.
And they're living there now.
And they're connected to mental health services
in the community and they're on medication.
And these folks are thriving.
And they're in a safe, protected environment
where they can make mistakes
and not become homeless again, which is great.
And it's a real exciting thing to see in San Francisco.
And we're hoping to expand that model
and to get more beds to help more people.
There's another element in the homelessness situation
is the cost of living.
There are people that are having really the issue
of they're living paycheck to paycheck
and then the costs go up higher, they fall behind.
How much of that do you guys see
and how is it a lot easier to solve that?
I firmly believe that government costs
for building housing are an impediment
to people actually building housing.
When we're looking at what does it cost
to build affordable housing?
Man, it's not, we try and blame the materials.
Materials isn't, yeah, there's been an increase
of cost of materials, but it's the labor
and more importantly, it's the government costs
that get piled on top of it that make it difficult.
Then you think about if it's a for-profit entity.
So they've had to pay all those fees.
Now they're gonna pay property taxes
based on that appraised value.
And that can go up or down.
They're gonna find other ways to charge fees onto that.
So what do they have to do?
They have to charge more for people
to actually be in their facility.
Well, then those people can't afford it.
They move, have to move somewhere else.
So it's a vicious circle.
And I think until we try and figure out a way,
how do we lower the cost of building?
How do we lower that cost of living for sheltering?
It's only at that point that we actually will be able
to people who work at a lower wage job
would be able to get in and get going.
So you are seeing a change in San Francisco,
despite all the challenges that you're seeing
with the legal system, but there's still a change
because from what you're seeing, the community was fed up
and the new mayor is taking action.
Do you think the rest of California can do the same?
Yes, it's about creating hope.
And I think that's really what the mayor's been able to do.
His messaging has been creating hope.
Now, they may not articulate it that way,
but that's the way I articulate it
because people see there's opportunity.
They see there's something on the other side.
They're not just seeing what's been going on.
They're seeing that there's a better way.
They're seeing that somebody cares.
And so in turn, I think that that's where they see hope.
This is the first administration I've seen in San Francisco
where it's not about politics, it's about results.
And they've been committed to results.
And the accountability from our mayor and his team,
he's made mistakes and he's been very clear
about the mistakes he's made
and what he's learned from his mistakes.
And it's refreshing.
Like, you know, he is on social media
as his way to communicate with San Franciscans.
It feels like you're part of this momentum
and it actually feels good.
But it is hope.
And that's what it's, it's created that culture
of what we would call solutions.
You have to be solution-based.
And I think that's really the direction that he's pushing.
It isn't about, let's just do the same old thing.
And I believe that other communities,
if they embrace that mindset of looking for solutions
rather than just trying to keep doing the same thing
over and over again, that will breed hope
and in turn will breed success.
And people will say, this is the life I want to live.
Steve Adami and Major Michael Zielinski
with Salvation Army.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
Well, thank you.
It was great being here.
We appreciate the opportunity to share.
What do you think about the situation in San Francisco?
And if you live there,
do you see major changes right now happening there?
Let us know in the comments
or you can always email us at siamakacaliforniasider.com.
We read all of your comments and emails.
I'm Siamak Korami.
This is California Insider.
We'll see you next time.