How HR Cheats Employees

Harmony Hive Workplace
33 followers
20 Video Views·Jun 28, 2025
This legal video is about how Human Resources cheats their employees out of rights, money, and jobs. You need to be aware of these tricks or else you may fall for one.
Branigan Robertson is an employment lawyer in Orange County, California. His firm exclusively represents employees in lawsuits against their employers.
In this video, I'm going to expose four nasty tricks that human resources uses to cheat their
employees out of money, rights, and their jobs. If you're not aware of these, it's only a matter
of time before you fall for one. My name is Branigan, and I'm an employment lawyer. Oh,
and these tricks get worse as we go on, so keep watching.
Trick number one is the mighty open door policy. If you open up your employee handbook,
there's a 90% chance that somewhere in there, it says that human resources has an open door policy.
Regardless of the language used, most people understand that to mean HR is there. They want
to hear your concerns and complaints, and if you go to HR, they will keep your complaint confidential
and you'll be protected from retaliation. This is absolutely not true. They almost never keep
your complaint confidential. I've talked to hundreds of employees who went to HR in confidence
only to find out shortly thereafter that their complaint was shared with the very person that
they were complaining about, but it gets much worse than that. Most companies actually use
the open door policy as an early warning system so they can get a heads up on the complaints
and quash employee dissent and complaints before they spread. I've talked to hundreds of employees
who have complained about something legitimate, and shortly thereafter, they got written up,
and shortly after that, they were fired for some sort of vague and nebulous reason.
And as a part of this, HR routinely tells people that if you utilize the open door policy,
you will be legally protected from retaliation. But that's untrue. Legally, you are only protected
from retaliation if you've made a complaint protected by law, and I've made several videos
about this subject, and I'll provide links at the end if you want to know more about that.
But most HR people know that you're not protected, and if it suits their objectives, they will tattle
to management, and you'll get fired soon thereafter. Now, don't get me wrong. There
are absolutely times when you should go to human resources and complain in writing,
and I go much deeper into that in my video series on how to complain to HR correctly,
and I'll provide links at the end of this so that you can watch that. But you should not complain
until you fully know why you're doing it, how to do it right, and how to minimize the risks.
While the open door policy is a nasty trick,
it doesn't even come close to the worst on this list, so stay with me.
Trick number two, workplace investigations. Let's say you go to HR to verbally complain
about a coworker who's been harassing you and other female employees. The HR rep will listen
attentively and take notes. You tell her about what happened to you, and you give her the names
of other victims at work. The HR rep then says that she is going to launch an investigation into
the matter. This, unfortunately, is a lie. There are no due process rights within a company. Yes,
she is going to launch an investigation, but not to find out what actually happened.
Her investigation is going to be about how she can best protect the company. You see,
human resources is not your friend. The company pays her paycheck. Her job is to protect the
company from employees like you, and if a potential lawsuit is brewing, her job is to document the
things that help the company, not you. So, she will likely destroy her notes that she took during
your meeting. She will only interview the witnesses that help the company, not the ones that corroborate
your story. Every time she communicates with you going forward, it'll probably be either in person
or on the phone, not in writing. She will start working with your direct supervisor to document
your performance deficiencies so she can write you up in a few minutes to paper your personnel file
so that down the road, if you sue the company, the company can say, look, we wrote her up several
times. She was a bad employee. And the worst part of all of this is that when she finishes her
investigation, I guarantee she will create some kind of investigation report that concludes
there was no evidence of any wrongdoing. Even if the HR rep genuinely believes that you were
harassed, she will never put it in writing because her job is to protect the company, not you. Now,
with all that said, if an investigation is going on at your job, should you refuse to participate
or let this knowledge prevent you from submitting a legitimate complaint to HR? No, absolutely not.
You must play the game and participate. If you don't, down the road in litigation, the jury will
think that you were the problem, not the company. You must always think to yourself, how would a jury
view my actions here? Asking yourself this question is key to doing the right thing in most
employment situations. If you're getting value out of this video, click the subscribe button
down below. I make lots of videos about employee rights, so if you want to stay in the loop,
click the button. Trick number three, they lie. All right, well, in most interactions with HR,
there's no reason for them to lie to you. However, there is no legal requirement that they be
truthful with you. So when things start to get tough, when there is a dispute, you can count on
them protecting their paycheck at your expense. So in addition to what we've already talked about
here today, what are the common situations when HR is going to lie to employees? Well, they routinely
lie in write-ups and performance improvement plans. They can say that you were late all the time for
work when you weren't. They can say that you were insubordinate when you weren't. They can say that
you had a bad attitude when you didn't. And if the cumulative effect of all these small lies
ultimately leads to your termination, they know that they can get away with it because the law
of defamation doesn't have much teeth in employment law. I made a video about defamation, if you want
to know, I'll link below. They also routinely lie during lawsuits. This is super common. I've
questioned a lot of HR reps under oath during depositions. They will say that they gave you
several verbal warnings when they didn't, or they will deny that other people have complained about
the issue that you've complained about. Why do they do this? Well, they do it to protect their job.
Think about it. If they tell the truth, they're probably going to cost their company a whole bunch
of money. So they lie so they don't get fired. The only way to hold them accountable is to have a
really good lawyer who can impeach them properly during the case. But this trick, this line, still
isn't even close to the worst trick on this list. The next one is the worst. It has screwed millions
of Americans out of billions of dollars. And I'm not exaggerating. Before we get to it, I should say
one last important thing. I have a license to practice law in California. A lot of people who
see my videos want to contact me, and that's great. But the free consultation process at my office
is for California workers who got fired from their job, and they believe that they have a
case for harassment, retaliation, discrimination, or wrongful termination. If that applies to you,
and you think I've earned your phone call, don't be afraid to give me a call for a free consultation.
Trick number four, and this is the worst, arbitration. My office gets literally thousands of calls each
year, and just about every single one of those people we ask the following question,
did you sign an arbitration agreement when you started work at the company?
Most people respond by saying, what's arbitration? And therein lies part of the insidious deception
of this trick. Very few people even know what arbitration is and what its implications are
for workers. But don't worry, I will explain. Here is how it works. After you accept the job offer,
HR says congratulations, and then they slide over a bunch of documents for you to sign.
Happy to have a new job, most people quickly sign them without ever reading them. And somewhere
between 20 to 40% of employers have their new employees sign an agreement called arbitration.
Or the arbitration agreement is buried in the employee handbook, and the employee signs an
acknowledgement page that says that they agree to the terms in the employee handbook. Now if you
try to refuse the arbitration agreement, say you refuse to sign it, HR will probably rescind the
job offer. Okay, well what does arbitration actually say? Well an arbitration agreement
says that if there's ever a dispute between you and the company, you can't sue them in the public
court system. You have to sue them through private arbitration. And if valid, that agreement forces
you to fight for your rights in a secretive binding judicial process, where if you lose, you
have no right to appeal. So you can't sue in the public court system. How it works is if you file
for arbitration, an arbitrator, which is usually a retired judge or a former defense attorney,
becomes the judge and jury for the case. This arbitrator is paid hundreds of dollars an hour
by the company to act as a neutral adjudicator. And if you have any common sense at all, you're
asking yourself, if the arbitrator is getting paid thousands upon thousands of dollars by the
company that you're suing, how often do they actually rule in the employee's favor? Well the
answer is, not nearly as often as they rule in favor of the company. So let's say you have a
great case against the company. When your case is forced into arbitration, its settlement value
becomes substantially less than if it were in the regular court system. That's great for the
company and terrible for you. And I've talked to dozens of my employment lawyer colleagues,
and they all say that arbitration dramatically reduces the value of the case. And if you
extrapolate this out on a nationwide basis, billions and billions of dollars of employee
money is lost. But that is not even the worst part. Yes, you can sue them in arbitration,
and you might get something. Sometimes you get something that's pretty much okay. But most
arbitration agreements say that you cannot sue them on a class-wide basis. That means you can't
bring a class action against the company. Why does that matter? Well let's say the company has
failed to pay you $5,000 in unpaid overtime. $5,000 is a lot of money, but that is not nearly
enough to justify hiring a lawyer and pursuing a case against the company. The costs of that case
will quickly overwhelm the value of it. Those smaller claims are just not worth pursuing,
even on a contingency basis. But if you and your lawyer can gather together 100 plus people and
sue on a class-wide basis, then the case becomes economically viable to pursue. So if you're
paying attention, what this means is if there's an arbitration agreement, those smaller claims
just don't get pursued. Period. Ergo, the company gets away with theft. By my estimate, and many
other lawyers I've talked to, without question tens of billions of dollars of employee money across
America is lost each year because of arbitration. Without question, arbitration is the worst trick
that HR and employers use to steal employee wages and minimize the size of harassment,
retaliation, and wrongful termination claims. Okay, Brannigan, how can you avoid this? Well,
that's a big subject in and of itself, and I don't have time, unfortunately, to cover it today.
But if you want me to make a video on arbitration, let me know in the comment section down below.
Believe it or not, this is my third video on human resources. And if you've watched the other two,
you know that I don't really believe that all HR reps are bad people. I just believe that their
incentives are horribly misaligned. There are some good people in the profession, so hopefully
your company has one of them. And the four tricks I've outlined here today are only the tip of the
iceberg. So let me ask you, would you like me to make another video on tricks like this?
Was this helpful?
