We pushed the Milwaukee M18 Fuel Surge and the DeWalt Quiet Hydraulic Impact Driver to their absolute breaking points in the most requested comparison test we've ever done. Viewers wanted to know: Which tool has the best longevity?
The results were dramatic! We set up a hydraulic impact driver torture test running 50 six-inch lag fasteners and 50 one-inch self-feeding holes in wood. One tool hit a staggering 204°F and was literally smoking but refused to die. The other tool, however, repeatedly shut down and quit when the work got hard.
The difference in performance led us to the "inconsistent employee" analogy: "Managing inconsistency [in a tool] works when it wants to work is impossible to deal with". See the full tool test raw to find out which is the marathon runner and which is the sprinter that can't finish the job.
If you're looking for the best hydraulic impact driver for professional use, you need to see this full impact driver durability test before you buy!
0:00 The Shocking Preview: Cooked vs. Quit 0:20 The Longevity Challenge: Why We Did This Test 0:39 Milwaukee Surge vs. DeWalt Quiet Hydraulic Specs 1:13 Test Parameters: Lags, Holes, and the 'Nemesis' 6:21 Mid-Test Temperature Check & Audio Update 10:04 The Milwaukee Surge Shuts Down (The Inconsistency) 14:20 The DeWalt Meltdown: 204°F and SMOKING 16:40 Can Milwaukee Surge complete the test? 20:34 The Final Verdict: "Inconsistent Employee" Analogy 21:29 Conclusion and Final Thoughts 22:05 Subscribe & What's the Next Tool to Destroy?
We're going to go through 50 lag fasteners,
then we're going to go through 50 holes.
This thing's on fire.
Yeah, it's got to be.
You see the smoke come off of it?
Yeah.
You're saying that we don't make it to the second 50 fasteners?
One of these is going to die in drilling the first 50 holes.
Is that what I heard?
That would be my prediction, yeah.
This has been the most requested comparison test
that I've actually ever received.
So this is the Waltz Quiet Hydraulic Impact Driver.
It's much quieter than a traditional.
It's two speeds.
It's, you know, it's quiet.
It's fast. It's got great lights.
You know, I love it.
This is Milwaukee's Generation 2
M18 Fuel Surge Impact Driver.
Three speeds, not two speeds, three speeds.
The performance on this impact driver is so astonishing.
People actually believe that this was the straight M18 fuel.
It's so fast.
Not the surge.
They didn't believe it was a surge
because it is so powerful.
A lot of the viewers said to us, yes,
but will that surge actually last?
Longevity was the question.
Here's the deal.
We're going to be running 50 quarter inch
by six inch lag fasteners.
We'll then move into drilling one inch holes
through this two by lumber with a one inch spade bed.
Self-feeding, just so everybody knows.
Number one, batteries are fully charged.
You can see, here's the other thing.
Maybe you could go out there
and give them a little look, a look-see.
Temperature wise, these are room temperature.
They're both starting out room temperature.
Yeah, you can see here, 67 degrees.
And then on the Milwaukee, 68 degrees,
67 degrees, 63, 64 down by the battery.
So 65, more than cool enough.
Perfect.
We have our audio meter here.
Is that the decibel meter?
We have our decibel meter up here.
We're going to drive one.
So we have a baseline of how loud these actually are.
And will these tools become louder as they're abused?
As they're used?
We need sounds on the set.
We're going to drive one at a time.
Next up, the Milwaukee.
Can you give us a run?
Milwaukee looked to be around the 88 decibel mark.
The Walt looked to be 87.
We're going to run 47, more fasteners.
We'll get to number 48
and we'll take another decibel reading.
See you in a couple minutes.
Okay, I'm going to drive my 48 fastener.
We're going to be as quiet as possible.
We're going to get a reading.
Is it any louder now that we've driven
a whole bunch of lags?
The Walt?
Yep.
They both peaked around 90 decibel,
which makes them slightly louder
than when we started out.
Does it have something to do
with the hydraulic mechanism inside?
Potentially.
As it heats up, the tool could become louder.
Can we get a temperature on each tool
now that we see which one's louder or warmer?
While I fill these up,
we're going to get ready for the second portion
of this test.
So up in here, by the motor,
we're at 98, 102, 104, 105, 107.
Go back here, 97.
Down in the handle, in the 70s.
So obviously, much warmer than it was.
Down at the battery.
The battery's still running at only 69, 70 degrees though,
which is interesting.
Pretty cool.
Take a look at the Milwaukee.
Up here by the front, 99, 105.
Back here by the motor, 109, 111, I saw up there.
So significantly hotter again.
Down in the handle, 83, 84.
And then down by the battery.
Again, cool battery, 68.
So obviously the tools are heating up,
but the batteries are staying pretty cool.
Now, after all those lags,
we still have a full battery on the Milwaukee.
That's pretty doggone impressive.
Yeah, I was expecting a little bit of a dip,
but no, still, same for me too.
Can you give us your initial impression
of driving those with a hydraulic?
I mean, I gotta be honest.
Previously, if I had that many lags to drive, that size,
it wouldn't have been generation one surge.
Definitely not.
Generation two has me second guessing that now.
I would consider this.
Yeah, getting through it, getting through it quieter.
My arm wasn't beat up as I was running through the fasteners
like I felt like I could still keep going.
So I was impressed by the tool.
I was impressed by the battery and the capability of it.
Will we be surprised with the drilling portion?
We have one inch self-feeding spade pits.
Maybe this is a new era of impact drivers
and maybe the lines have been blurred.
We're gonna find out.
We're about to find out, yeah.
So you're marked off number one through 50.
So am I.
I will say this.
What will?
That's grease.
Grease.
That's grease.
You seeing that?
You're gonna have to keep an eye here.
Let's see.
Go.
I got a full battery.
Tool won't start.
Yo, actually three bars.
It's not a full battery.
Tool won't start.
Let me take it off.
You can keep going, I suppose.
I'll reset it on there.
It's ready to go again.
It's timed out.
Battery change.
The tool.
Keep going.
I'm gonna try a battery swap.
Tool's done.
Done.
Okay, by the motor.
Switch gear's running pretty cool still at 85.
120, 134, 141.
142.
Oh my God.
This is the battery we were running.
And you can see, you're in the 71 degree range.
Like, it's not 72, 74.
Like, the battery's operating pretty cool, actually.
All right, what do we do here?
I mean, we have a clear winner.
Where are you at battery-wise?
I got two bars left still on this battery.
I mean, I'm getting a little bit of a smell,
but I think it'll plow through this.
I'm thoroughly impressed.
Okay, where is, here's your 50 mark.
Go to town.
Will it make to the first 50?
I feel like I hear an audible difference.
Yeah, I'm down to one bar.
Give it a battle.
Here you go.
Thank you.
All right, pull it out.
I don't even wanna touch this thing.
This thing's on fire.
Yeah, it's gotta be.
I mean, we're up at 160, 180, 195, 192, 200.
We crashed at 200 up here by the front.
I saw it as high as 204.
Come back here to the motor a little bit.
We're in the 130s.
Oh, that rubber overmold, 202.
Let's get in the handle here.
I was feeling it in the handle a little bit.
We're at 89, 90 in the handle, not terrible.
This is a newer battery,
so I'm not expecting anything out of that.
64, 65.
Can you grab that other battery?
I'm just curious.
Guess what?
That other battery's still only at 75.
That's the 21700 tablet cells.
Yeah.
So here, get ahead on.
See if there's anything crazy going on there.
Right in the cone, I'm at 200.
Whoa.
If I go right through the center cone into the back,
I saw 250.
You see that, or no?
You see the smoke come off of it?
Yeah.
Let me see if I can get right in there.
You guys can see it better than I can
because I'm at a weird angle here,
but I'm in the 200s, 220s.
It's bouncing all over the 200s at the front there.
Quiet on the set.
We were at 88 on the first sound test,
90 on the second sound test, 91.
So three decibel points,
which would be, what, 30% higher, or?
It is a substantial increase in sound
after running it through what we see here.
Any perceptions?
I mean, we've done these tests in the past
with one-inch battle bits,
and we've caught multiple Dewalt impact drivers on fire.
The fact that we were able to run through
50 six-inch lag fasters and then drill 50 holes
with a one-inch bait bit, I mean.
I feel like this is a redemption for Dewalt.
Redemption?
I feel like I could do another 50 before.
I think the plastic will catch on fire
before the actual gear does, the motor does.
I mean, it's still running.
And I'm not hearing,
even though it sounds a little bit louder,
I'm not hearing any whining or.
Do I, so it came back to life.
I think we gotta see if it can finish the job.
So it seems after a break period.
Had a lunch break.
Took lunch break, it's back.
Speed three, maybe it just needed to cool down.
Do we try to finish the, I mean, this is tool test raw.
I guess we're gonna try to finish those other holes.
I mean, listen, Dewalt's in the truck
waiting for Milwaukee to finish up for the day.
It's done again.
Smoke break.
Had its lunch break, now it's on smoke break.
Got a little aroma coming from it too.
But that's more Dewalt smell again.
What's the conclusion here though?
If you need work done now, you go with the Dewalt.
Will this actually come back to life
and operate at full capacity again?
I don't know.
What is it that's shutting it down?
Is it a temperature distinction
that says once it hits this?
How do I know?
I have no clue.
That's the thing.
Is it electronics that are built into it
that are shutting it down?
Until, you know, I don't know.
Like, where are we at?
Are we even as warm as we were, you know, a while ago?
So, we're at 125.
I feel like we're not even at the temperatures.
We're at 127.
It's not the battery.
I mean, even straight through the collet.
It's not even that, it's not even that hot.
Is it the electronics in there that are shutting it down?
Now it's coming, it's back on again.
It's funny, I pulled the.
You know, here's the thing.
There's a famous saying by a very wise human being,
person I know.
You're at like 129.
What do you say about when you can't depend on someone
as an employee?
Like, when you, you know,
you can expect a bad employee to be bad.
You can expect a good employee to be good.
But when you have a what?
What kind of employee?
An inconsistent.
Tell us about it.
It's hard to manage inconsistent.
I'd rather manage bad or good.
Managing inconsistency works when it wants to work
is impossible to deal with.
Check the temperature of the DeWalt too,
because the DeWalt's still pretty hot.
I mean, we're, I saw some 137s in here.
This thing's not that hot.
The DeWalt's in the 200s, 221, 218, 222.
The word I would use to describe the surge
when it comes to endurance, disappointing.
Here's your marathon runner.
Here's your sprint.
Here's the thing.
Good on all of you for requesting this video.
A lot of you said in the comments,
it's not about how quickly the job can get done.
It's about how many times can you do that job?
We answered some questions here today, I believe.
Leave it down in the comments section below.
What's the next tool test raw?
You want to see which burning desire do you have?
What do you want to see proved till it's destroyed?
Pretty much, yeah.
We want to know.
Leave it all below.
With that, I want to say I appreciate each and everyone
for being here.
Thank you for helping us out today, Jimmy.
My pleasure.
We hope to see you all on the next one.