2916 Vs 2915: Milwaukee's biggest SDS+ head to head

Power Machine Tools
2 followers
Here we try out Milwaukee's 2 biggest SDS+ rotary hammers, the 2915 and 2916, Known in places as the M18 FHP and M18FHACOD32 . They look like 2 versions of the same tool, but have different ratings. So what's the deal? which one is Milwaukee's most powerful hammer drill? What are D handle drills for? let's find out!
Use BOLTAH to get 10% off at hownot2.store and it supports what I'm doing, as well as helping climbers all over the world get better hardware on their walls.
#machine #tools
G'day Hammerheads welcome back to the bench and oh bloody thing that is big let me let me move my
camera back a little bit and today we have a very special episode for you we are looking at
Milwaukee's two biggest SDS plus hammers we got the 2916 and the 2915 i'm sorry it's a little
crowd on my bench camera don't don't go any further back all right so let's take a closer
look at them now they both are a standard three mode rotary hammer so they got drill only
they got like an angle adjuster they got hammer only and they got hammer drill
other than that they've got a vibration dampening handle they can fit a dust extractor they got the
one key connectivity if you use that for your tool management and about the only other thing to say
is they both got the auto stop which stops the drill if you're drilling and the bit binds up
all right so let's check out the specs uh firstly long model number on the long guy secondly the
price here in australia the long guy the d handle fair bit more expensive the d handle is also a
little bit heavier now this is where it gets interesting 2915 drop motor is rated 28 mil
or about inch and an eighth whereas the d handle is rated 32 mil inch and a quarter which is weird
because if we look at the rest of the specs they're pretty much the same same very high impact energy
and they reckon the d handle revs 10 rpm faster about one percent faster and hits 50 ipm faster
so a tiny tiny difference there in the specs even though these two tools are rated to different
capacities so based on this rating you'd expect the d handle to be bigger and more powerful but
it is pretty much identical and look at the impact energy 4.9 joules that is a lot this massive
corded ryobi 5 joules the very biggest makita 3.9 the very biggest dewalt 4.5 so historically
milwaukee has overstated their impact a little bit i think but even if it's not 4.9 these guys
still very very big hammers so interesting stuff from the specs there theoretically this guy should
be a little bit more powerful although one percent more powerful pretty weird how they've rated it
like that so that difference in the maximum capacity rating that's super interesting for me
take a look at these two circles one's 28 mil one's 32 doesn't look like much of a difference
but then if you take a look at the surface area of those two the bigger one has 30 percent more
surface area so if you're drilling through concrete that means you've got 30 percent more concrete
you've got to get through and that's why i keep banging on that rating because theoretically
these are very very different tools check this out we take a look at this one from bosch this
is their new 28 millimeter and then this is their 32 bare bit bigger so milwaukee is basically
calling one of these tools with the same specs that size and one that size okay so let's check
those revs 801 swap the batteries over i use this battery in the previous testing for this guy so
just keep it consistent so about half a rev difference and let's check their weight
4.4 kilos i round up and 4.1 so the long one is more expensive heavier but revs the same
same kind of specs and yet milwaukee reckons it's more powerful what is going on there well there's
only one way to find out let's get drilling so 12 by 80 mil into 32 mpa concrete let's see how she
goes all right and the 12 mil speed drill where are they well blow me down these two milwaukees
are the fastest in this test but we've got the bigger rated d handle just a little bit behind
the drop motor still phenomenal performance okay so our next standard test 26 mil or about an inch
same depth same concrete all right for that big one inch drill test where did they end up
kind of cut in the middle a little bit towards the front so once again we've got these two
milwaukees right next to each other d handle slightly slower than the drop motor now out of
all these big guys that did that same sized hole they are way faster than all the one inch rated
drills that's all these guys down here other 28s like that one that one that one that one
they're a bit faster than them so these guys are both performing squarely in the next class
up because we've got the biggest makita we've got the biggest dewalt the biggest bosch so looking
at these results you know it really does seem like these two are actually underrated maybe that's why
milwaukee is able to claim they got the best in class because they're just changing the class
and our last test this is 16 so five eighths by 150 so about six inches and i'm piloting this one
at the moment so not much data here but anyway let's give her a shot all right and in that little
test there same pattern drop motor slightly faster than the d handle still very very fast so the only
two other hammers on this chart are these hikokis they're rated to 28 millimeters so that really
does reinforce that milwaukee is overrating this one if they reckon that's a 28 millimeter
really it's a 32 so it turns out these two are just the same tool in a different shape so what's
with the different rating this one came out about two years ago and maybe they just weren't sure how
well it would go in the field after all it is a new generation tool and even milwaukee get a little
apprehensive this one came out about a year after that one and so by then they've got enough data on
how many warranty claims have happened or whatever to just go nah she can handle a much bigger hole
let's upgrade this one the other reason is maybe milwaukee saw how relatively weak the gen 1 hammers
were compared to the competition so milwaukee has just gone nut we are determined to be best in class
and to do that we're just gonna redefine the class so a little cheeky from milwaukee but hey
you know they make good tools so i guess they can get away with that so the length of these two is
obviously quite different we go from the top of the handle to the top of this handle 120 millimeters
so that is five inches longer so milwaukee obviously wants a very long hammer with this one
and in fact if we take a look at a sort of normal size d handle which is about another two inches
about 50 mil longer than that one so the reason for these guys is usually comfort in certain
positions usually drilling downwards so if you're drilling downwards a lot this one is worth
considering and here am i demonstrating the height difference so i'm 186 centimeters tall that's
using the d handle saves you bending over a fair bit using the drop motor you really don't want to
bend over that much so if you don't want to cough up the extra cash for the long boy you can also
just get some long drill bits you could also get one of these extenders again pretty bloody expensive
won't wear out as fast as a drill bit or you know you could kneel down you could get the apprentice
to do it like whatever i'm gonna leave that up to you to decide if the extra length of this one
is worth the extra money that said i really bloody like this tool it is an absolute monster
and i do appreciate the fact that milwaukee has just gone for something a little different because
this is the only 32 mil d handle i have ever heard of it's pretty cool just to see them trying
something a little bit different now hammerheads if this info has helped you maybe i've saved you
a few hundred bucks from not buying the big guy make sure you like and subscribe this video
because subscriptions make the world go around here now this guy cost me about three months of
ad revenue from this channel so if you want to see more big stuff like this get subscribing and
i'll see what i can do anyway hammerheads i reckon that'll do us so from the big boys and i
thanks very much i'll scratch you later
