How to Choose the RIGHT Maths Tutor (GCSE & A Level Students Must Watch!)

Maths Tutor Mitchell Dye
83 followers
3 Video Views·Jan 17, 2026
👋 A few spots left for GCSE & A-Level tuition for this term. Book a free trial lesson here: https://www.mitchell-dye.com/
📧 Or email me at [email protected]
Join the Discord!: https://discord.gg/zBD8YYhpPv
PayPal Donations: https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=36HKNDH3GMCTG
💡 Website: educatio.me
💡 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100082943721614
💡 Reddit: /u/MistaMitchell
Hey guys and welcome back. So I know that around this time you've had your second
lot of mocks and you're probably going to, whether in year 10, 11, 12 or 13, you
might be looking for a tutor or you already have a tutor, in which case I
wanted to make this video to kind of go through the common pitfalls that people
encounter when they look for a tutor or when they have a tutor and how you can
avoid them but also what you should expect and also how to find a tutor
yourself that will actually work for you and get a solid grade from. You actually
get the benefit from the tuition. Now before we want to go into this, I want to
preface this, I am a private tutor. This is not going to be a video telling you
why you should go tuition with me or anything like that. My tuition slots are
very much filled usually and I don't really have many more slots so there's
no benefit in me trying to get thousands of new students because I can't teach
all of you, it's just impossible. This is going to be my honest opinion and just
based on, again, as a former tutor at school as well, I have a lot of students
come up to me and they talk to me about having tuition and with a lot of them the
tuition just doesn't work and they think it's their fault, it's not. So here's some
of the kind of pitfalls and here's some things I want to talk about in this
video. The first one is worksheets. Around where I live, which I'm not going to
disclose, around where I live a lot of the tutors will basically just hand out
worksheets and the kids will, or the students will do the worksheets and then
they can ask for help if they need it for an hour and the problem with this is
they're very good for practicing a brand new concept, which is generally speaking
what you do in school. So if you're being homeschooled and someone's teaching you
something for the first time as a tutor, worksheets are totally fine. However, you have
to ask yourself, could I be doing this at home by myself? You see, for me, when I've
tutored homeschooled students, worksheets are something I give as homework. It's
not something we do in lesson. In lesson, we're learning new concepts, which leads
me on to the next point. Tutors should be explaining how to do
problem-solving and how to approach new questions. You shouldn't be sitting there,
working alone for extended periods of time. Again, some of these students will go
there for an hour and I would say, according to them, for 30 to 45 minutes
they're working by themselves. What's the point? You might as well just be at home.
So my recommendation here is, if your tutor's just giving you worksheets and
these worksheets are basically doing the same thing over and over again, if you
want to have a look at the other video that I made on how to study maths, you'll
see what I mean by this, I give some examples, then maybe you want to consider
looking for someone else. Again, you can also find these tutors by asking your
friends and family and if they're just doing basically worksheets, it's not
really that much point. Now, I will say that some tutors will print out their
slides as a worksheet but then work through it with you, so that way the
questions are new. Every single question is brand new, so it'd be something like
they show you a new question, then they give you one to do, then they show you a
new question, give you one to do, like that. That is totally fine, I'm not saying
you should have no paper whatsoever, I'm just saying that doing the same kind of
question a hundred times is kind of pointless. Some tutors as well, what
they'll do is they'll print off the explanation as well, and so it's like
here's your pack of questions, there you go, and then maybe they're teaching a
bunch of other people as well. So that's the first thing I would be very wary of.
The same goes for textbooks at A-level. So worksheets at A-level, sometimes they
give textbooks instead. Again, honestly, you can work through the textbook
yourself. What I'd recommend is if you want to make the most use of your
chooser, is if they are using worksheets, then you want to bring in questions
yourself that you want them to go through, and that'll probably be a much better use of
your time. Because again, doing the same thing over and over again will not make
you better at maths. You have to do new things, you have to do harder things. I liken
it to going to the gym, right? If you lift a really, really light weight a thousand
times, you're not getting stronger. But if you lift heavier and heavier weights for
fewer repetitions, you will get stronger and you will get bigger muscles. Which
one's the better outcome, right? You want to do hard stuff. This is actually
something that's often neglected. Now, as a teacher, one of the teaching standards,
so something that we're trained to follow and what all teachers should be
following, is building relationships with students. Now, this doesn't mean that
you should be, like, gossiping the whole time or anything like that. It just means
that your tutor and your teacher should be aware of what your goals are and, kind
of, how you learn as a person, right? So, for example, I've had students come up to
me before and say, well, I don't need to get higher than a grade five in maths
because I want to be a lawyer, which means I need to do, like, English, history and
some other essay-based subject. And then I've gone, hang on a minute, if you want to
get into a good university and do a law degree, you need a grade six in GCSE
maths. And that's kind of gone, oh, no one's told me that before, now I need to
work on it. The same thing is true for when students want to go to, like, Oxford
or Cambridge and they're not doing too well in maths but they're doing well
enough, like, they're getting a grade six, maybe, or a grade five. But then, on the
University of Oxford and Cambridge's website, they only accept people that get
grades seven, eights and nines and everything. So, these kinds of things is
really important for your tutor as well. They need to understand what you want to
do and provide advice for this thing. They're supposed to be experts. Again,
could you imagine if you wanted to be a lawyer, you get all the way through GCSEs
on a grade five in maths and you don't care, but you get grade nines and everything else,
and then you find out that you can't go to a decent university because you
haven't got a grade six in maths. You know, it's horrible. So, you want to make
sure that your tutor actually knows who you are, what you want to do in the
future, and this goes for year nine, ten, eleven, twelve, thirteen students. For
example, in A-level, chances are, if you want to go to, like, a really good
university, or you want to go for, like, a maths, engineering, medicine, or even a law
degree, or anything like that, you need to do an entrance exam. Are your tutors
going to help you with the entrance exam? Are they preparing that? Have they built
that into the lessons? These are questions that you need to ask. But it
also provides motivation, because if I tell you, actually, you need a grade six,
you're going to be more motivated to do maths, and so outside of lessons, you're
also practicing maths, and that motivation is a really important factor.
I also liken tutoring to, like, being a personal trainer. It's all well
and good to go to the gym for an hour and work out, but if outside of the gym
you're eating really badly and you're not very active, you won't get as many
gains, you won't make as much progress, you won't have as much motivation as if
you're, you know, you go home and you eat really healthily and you do more
exercise outside of the gym as well. And that works for tutoring, that works for
learning in a big part. This is something I really do focus on in my lessons, just
in general, because if you can motivate students like this with telling you what
jobs are out there, how much money you can make, why this is important to you,
it'll make your whole life a lot easier. So, you know, ask yourself, does your
tutor even know your name? Can they tell you what subjects you do? Can they tell
you what you want to do in the future? Are they motivating you? These are all
questions that you need to think about, and do they have knowledge about where
this can lead you? Now, price is a very touchy subject because, again, maybe I'm
biased because, again, I am a private tutor, but the biggest issue is not
overpaying, it's underpaying. So, as a quick anecdote, I had a student come up to me
and mention that she's got a maths tutoring, and then she asked me how much
I charge, and I told her the price that's on my website. She said, what? My tutor
charges £10 an hour. And immediately in my head I thought, what on earth? £10 an hour
for one-on-one tutoring? The reason for this is you can make more money working
an entry-level job in Tesco's. So, as proof, here you go. £12.45 for Tesco's.
Now, I'm not making fun of people that work at Tesco's or anything like that, not
at all, but if your tutor is an academic, they have qualifications, and they're
doing something that's high-level, paying £10 an hour or less is really,
really, really underpaying. And then you have to ask yourself, why are they
charging so little? Is it because they're just starting out and they
want to get students? Fair enough. Or is it because they can't charge anymore
because they don't have the skill set? Again, the thing that I compare it to a
lot of the time is, how much would you pay for being a personal
trainer? Now, I know that as a student, this is very difficult for you to know
because you probably haven't hired anyone before, but maybe your parents can
help you out there. Does £10 an hour sound alright for a personal trainer?
Bearing in mind that tutors, in theory, should be more highly trained than a
personal trainer. That's something you have to consider. But also, on the flip
side, I've heard of people paying unbelievable amounts of money. Now, again,
paying more money generally may get you a better tutor, absolutely, because there's a
reason why they can charge that much. But you have to ask yourself, is what I'm
paying equal to how much I'm getting out of it? So, if you pay £10 an
hour and you're not getting that much, then fair enough. But if you're paying £100
an hour and you're not getting that much, and you don't feel like there's any
improvement, then that's not so good. I'm making this video for students
specifically because I think the biggest problem that students have when they get
tuition is, in school, they're not really learning as much and they don't
enjoy it that much, so then when they get tutoring, they think, oh, it's the same
thing, so yeah, it makes sense. No. You are paying someone, which means that you are
owed a service. It should be enjoyable. And when I say enjoyable, this doesn't
mean it should be easy or we should be laughing and joking. I'm saying it should
be engaging. You shouldn't be bored. You should also be making noticeable
progress. Okay, if you're doing what your tutor's saying and you're actually
learning from your tutor, you should be making progress. If you're at a tutor for a year
and you're not really any better, that is not your fault. Again, you're paying
someone. Now, am I blaming the tutor? Not necessarily, but it just means that you
probably shouldn't be paying for tuition because it's not working for you, and so
you either need to look for a new tutor or not get tuition. Your parents might
not be able to tell if the tuition is worth it, so you have to be the one that
actually says, okay, look, it's not working for me. It's not working. So again, with
the cheap versus expensive, you have to find a middle ground. Obviously, this is
dependent on your budget, how much you're willing to pay, but there are a few
things I'm going to go on to now which will help you get a better price for
what you're looking for, and the first thing I want to talk about is group
versus one-on-one. Now, group tuition gets a bad rap, partly because of COVID. You
know when you did online learning and you didn't learn anything because it was
awful and, yeah, horrible, horrible, horrible, right? But there's also this
idea of anxiety, right? Like, if you're in a group, you might be too nervous to ask
a question or anything like that, which, again, is fair enough. So a lot of people
prefer one-on-one tutoring. The reality is, for a decent tutor, one-on-one
tutoring is going to be a lot more expensive. I would say at least £50 an
hour, going up to £100 an hour is probably what you're looking at for a
decent one-on-one tutor. Again, I'm basing this on London prices. Maybe if you're in
a different part of the world, then obviously that's different. Group tuition can be a
lot cheaper, but again, you need to be aware of the pitfalls here.
The first one is, how many people are in the group? I would argue between 5 and 10
students in a group. Well, I guess between 2 and 10 students in that case, but if
there's 5 to 10 students in the group max, you are going to get a lot of
benefit from that because the teacher will be able to ask you questions
constantly. They will always be within earshot and they're not going to be
helping 30 other people, right? You don't want there to be 20 plus people in there
because then that might be tricky. Now, when I say that, I know that there is a
tuition centre near where I live where they actually have a group of 20 to 30
people, but there's also 3 or 4 teachers. That's completely fine. I'm saying if
there's between 5 and 10 students per adult or per tutor, whatever you want to
call it, that's completely reasonable. That way you can lower the cost
because it should be cheaper than one-on-one while still getting a huge
amount of benefit from it. You want to look out for how many people in the
group, but you also want to look out for how quickly can I get help if I need
help? How quickly can I ask questions? Now, for me, I've moved over to group
tuition a lot more because, again, it's cheaper and I can help more people and
the thing that I do is everyone's constantly interacting. Why? Because I'm
constantly asking questions. Constantly. So, there will not be more than five
minutes before I call your name and I'm asking you a question about something.
That's the kind of interaction that you want. Again, this isn't me just hyping
myself up. Obviously, I do what I think is right because why wouldn't I? But you want
to make sure that you're getting some kind of interaction. One-on-one can be
worse in this regard because, and I've noticed this when I help students after
school sometimes, just people in my class, is if they're doing a
question and they don't want me to help them, I'm just sitting there. There's
not much for me to do because they're busy. If I keep interfering, they're
actually going to be learning less. So, going into a group setting can save you
money while still having the same amount of interaction as one-on-one if
there's like three to five people in there, maybe six or seven people as well.
Because that way, most people are working and you can get the attention of the
tutor far quicker. So, that's why, in my opinion, sometimes group tuition is
actually better value for money because of one-on-one that is going to be
wasted time where the tutor's sitting there not interfering because they
shouldn't be interfering. So, again, that's something to consider and in
terms of anxiety and stuff, obviously that's up to you, right? But one
thing I will say is if you're in a small group, it's far less nerve-wracking than
in a bigger group and if your teacher is building up those relationships, like I
mentioned earlier, you should be very comfortable around them. It shouldn't
necessarily feel like a teacher-student relationship, it should be more
like a debate, more like a discussion, where all of you are trying to figure
out how to do this question. Hopefully that makes a bit of sense. That also
leads me on to online versus in person. Online eliminates the social anxiety
there. So, for me, again, some of my students have their cameras on, some of
them don't. Completely fine. As long as you have a microphone so we can talk,
that's completely fine and the benefit of this is with online students, I might
teach some students from Manchester, from Leeds, from Bristol, etc. all in the same
class. The benefit of that is they will never ever meet each other at all and if
they have their cameras off, no one's even going to see them. So, it makes it far
less nerve-wracking. Again, this anxiety thing, if your teacher or your tutor is
good at building relationships and asking directed questions to people, this
won't be an issue because they'll talk to you one-on-one. They'll ask you, what
do you think this is? Okay, what do you think this is? And that will eliminate it.
So, what are the other benefits of online versus in person? I genuinely
believe that online is better than in person. Now, hear me out, hear me out, hear me out.
Here's, okay, let's imagine this situation. In person, generally speaking, you either
go to the tutor's house, you go to the tuition centre or the tutor comes to you.
In all three of those, if they show up on the day or you show up on the day and
you want to change what you want to do, can't happen, right? If, when I used to go
to people's houses or they came to me, I'd print out the stuff, I'd have it
already. If they want to do something different, I have to then make stuff up
on the spot and it's less efficient. With online tutoring, if the class appears and
they go, oh, you know, we have an exam soon or we covered differentiation or we
covered completing the square and we don't get it or we want to do the hard
questions on this, I can get it open in five seconds. I have got every single
lesson resource ever on my desktop. I can open it in under two minutes and we can
do any lesson you want. That's something that can't happen in person. The other
benefit, with good tutors, if they're in person, they will, generally speaking,
charge you for the time it takes for them to get to your house or the time
for them to get to the centre or whatever. So, let's say you're paying for an hour of
tuition, you might have to end up paying an hour and a half or even two hours.
They also might charge you for all the printing they do. So, for me, again, I can
email PDFs like that and you, there you go, you have all the questions you need.
But, if I have to print out a 40-page document for you with fat loads of
questions and stuff, a lot of tutors charge for that, which, again, is
completely understandable. So, you can save money by doing it online as well
and it also allows you to get in contact with more tutors. Depending on where you
live, the in-person tutors might be bad, they might not be very good at all, they
might have really bad reviews, they might not do what they say, but the reason why
they're in business is because people want in-person tutoring and so that's
what they're going to go to. Online opens you up to being taught by thousands of
more people, which means you get to pick who you want. This also adds a benefit as,
let's say, let's say you're saying that tutoring is not very good to your
parents, but your parents don't believe you or they want you to keep sticking it out.
If it's online, your parents could sit in a lesson and see what you do, right? And
that adds, again, another layer for the tutor to actually be, to make sure the
tutor is doing their job and it also encourages the tutor to do better. If
someone's camera's off, I have no idea who's watching the other side and I've
had parents talk to me afterwards saying, oh, I listened into this lesson, this is
really good. Imagine if I was doing a bad job, boom, that student's gone. But
also, some tutors record the lessons and so they can send it to you and you get
that resource again. So again, with online versus in-person, there are benefits to
both, but honestly, I feel like this is more even than this. So group versus one
on one, there's pros for both. With online versus in-person, I really don't see why
in-person is a big thing. And this, online is also better for you. You don't have to
go out after school. You can stay at home, you can wear whatever you want, and you
can do the lesson in the comfort of your own home with all of your stuff around
you. I mean, imagine you forget your calculator. Well, now your calculator's at
home, you're fine. Qualifications. Very quickly, I want you to go through this. A
lot of the stuff that I see online is, you should be expecting a qualified
teacher with a DBS check and yada yada yada. I'm gonna say no. I don't want to
get a lot of flack for this, but there are lots of teachers that can't teach and
there are a lot of people that aren't qualified teachers that are good at
teaching. So I've had students in year 13 who, as soon as they leave year 13, they
go to university, they start tutoring, and they do a very good job. They prepare
the lessons, they teach the content, everything. I think this is really good
because those people did the exam six months ago, so they're as prepared as
anyone can be. They're very knowledgeable, and yes, they do offer it for cheaper. So
for that, if you're worried about qualifications, I'm gonna say that it
doesn't matter as much as people think it does. Now yes, of course, having a
qualified maths teacher, assuming they're a good maths teacher, is a good
idea for maths tuition, but you should be more focused on how the lessons go
themselves than the qualifications. You don't want people leaning on the
qualifications. I'm also going to point out, when you guys get into university and
then you find these really, really clever people at Oxford or Imperial or
whatever, and they've got PhDs in their subjects and they start teaching and you
realise, oh my god, this person can't teach, qualifications don't matter as
much as people think they do. A person with a PhD in maths doesn't mean they
automatically know how to teach maths. In the same way, that just going through the
teacher training, it makes you more likely to be able to teach maths, but it's
not a guarantee. So instead of focusing on the qualifications and
like DBS and all this other stuff, I would be far more focused on the other
points that I've made. Building relationships, the lessons being
productive, and actually having an impact on your education is far, far more
important. I'm well aware this video is dragging on, so I want to try and speed
through the next few parts. In general, here's what you want to ask yourself
when, if you have tuition already or you've just started, could you be doing
this work by yourself at home? Now, I'm not saying to check your answers right,
but most things have mark schemes, so can you be doing it at home? Do I trust that the
tuition will get me to the grade I want? Now, the reason why I put this here is,
some students will get tuition in like March, the exams in May or June, and they
want to go from a grade 4 to a grade 9, or grade 4 to a grade 5, or grade 4 to a
grade 8. Now, the problem is, as a student, you won't know if that's possible really.
You're relying on other people telling you if it's possible, so students that
have already done that, or teachers. The problem with some tutors is they make
these promises because, I mean think about it right, like if I get six months
of tuition out of you, and you end up not getting the grade, well I've still got
your money. Right, very few tutors offer this like money-back guarantee or
anything like that. The tutor should make very clear what the expectations are, and
if you want to get from a grade 4 to a grade 8 in five months, that is possible,
but here's the work we need to do, here's how many lessons you're going to need,
here's what you need, here's the expectations. If they're just saying, yeah
yeah yeah, that's totally fine, and they're not really laying out a plan, then that's
not really that great, right. It's very suspicious. Again, if they seem overly
enthusiastic, even if you're telling them, hey I want to get from a U to a grade 9
in a month, and they're like yeah yeah yeah, right, keep it within reason. Now again,
this doesn't mean that the tutor has to turn you down, it just means they have to
be open about how much work it's going to take. So how to find a good tutor
really, really quickly, this is the last bit. First thing I'd recommend is whenever
you look to get a tutor, insist on a free trial or a one-off paid lesson. A lot of
tutoring centres, especially the in-person ones, will say you have to pay for the
first month, or even the first year in some cases. The problem is you pay for
that, cancelling and getting your money back is extremely difficult, and so you
probably won't bother doing it, and then it's just a waste of time. Now for me, I
offer free trials. Why? Because that one hour free trial, if you like the tutoring
and you want to go ahead, I will then be paid for the next six months to two,
three, four years. That's a really good deal for me. I'm sacrificing x amount of
money to get that amount of money every single week for the next, potentially for
the next couple months, or for the next few years. So there's no real reason for
a tutor not to give you a free trial, but let's say okay fine they don't do a free
trial, there should be an option for a one-off paid lesson. So you'll pay them
however much money to do the lesson, and if you don't like it, there's no commitment.
That's the first thing you need to do. The next thing you should do, and this is
probably the biggest thing, ask friends or family for recommendations. If your
friend gets tuition and they've started doing really well, ask them for the
tutor's name so you can get tutoring as well. It is the number one top thing that
you should do. Recommendations from people that you trust that actually did well.
Again, you have to be careful here of who you ask, obviously, but if your friends or family
have started doing really well in your subject, again for any subject, that is a really good
recommendation to have. The last thing, and I think this is really really valuable, and this
is one of the reasons I started the channel in the first place, is you want to check if the
tutor has a website or a YouTube channel or something that illustrates them teaching.
Because among all of this, these are all really useful, this bottom thing is the lowest effort
thing on your part. If you look at a lot of YouTubers for maths or GCSEs or A-levels,
most of them will do tutoring because it's the most logical thing. The reason why this is so
useful is if you watch a couple of their videos and you think, oh my god, this guy's boring,
then don't do them. Or, oh wow, this person really explains things well, then that would be a great
tutor for you, because if they explain things well on a video, then they can explain things
really well in person. So these three things are how you pick a really good tutor. Asking your
friends and family, insisting on a one-off paid lesson or a free trial, and checking the tutor's
website or YouTube channel for videos of them teaching so you can see what their style is like.
And the last thing, and this is so important, and this applies to so many things,
I can't tell you how important this is, don't be afraid to jump around for different tutors.
I've started learning languages and for me, trying out many, many tutors was the best thing I could
do. So if I stick with the tutor for a couple lessons, I don't like it, I'll go to another
tutor. You don't owe the tutor anything. If you pay for three lessons, you attend three lessons,
that's it. Don't feel bad about cancelling. The reason why I make that last point so clear is the
number of people I've had say to me, I regret staying in this tuition. It's normally parents
that say this, I regret keeping my son or daughter in this tuition for a year. Then why did you do
it, right? You don't owe the tutors anything, and you should be really, really clear on this.
If the tuition is not working out for you, you're paying for a service that you're not getting,
the tutor's not a bad person, I'm not saying that, but you can leave the tuition and that's it.
And that's probably the most, again, that's one of the most important things. I've had parents come
up to me and even students that say, I've been with a tutor for two or three years and I don't
think it's working. Two or three years. Imagine you went to a dentist for two years and your teeth
were still horrible. Imagine you went to a doctor for two or three years and they didn't fix your
medical condition. Imagine you went to a personal trainer for two or three years and you didn't
change your physique at all. Imagine you went to language lessons for two or three years and you
can't say a word in the language. It would be ridiculous, right? This is the most important
thing. You don't need loyalty to people that haven't learnt it, right? If the tutoring isn't
working for you, move to another tutor, that's fine. If you want to send them a message and
explain why, cool. If you don't, cool. So again, before you actually sign up to a contract or
whatever, insist on a free trial or one-off paid lesson. Before you do that, ask friends and family
for recommendations and check YouTube and websites for videos of people teaching. And lastly, don't
be afraid to jump around tutors. Don't stick with someone. The number of people that stick with the
first tutor they get is ridiculous, especially when that tutor isn't very good for them.
Hopefully you found this video kind of useful. I know it's a bit long-winded because I have a lot
to say about it and again, I encounter this every single year, multiple times a year, whether it's
in September at the start of GCSEs or A-Levels or it's in January after those Christmas marks or
whether it's after the Easter marks or whether it's in June or July to get a head start for A-Levels.
I get this all the time and I see so many parents and so many students in tuition that they don't
think is useful. I know people I've had tuition for three years that have not improved their grade at
all and it's just cost them money. It's pointless. So hopefully you won't fall into that trap. If you
have any questions, do let me know in the comments. If you have tutoring, if you have tuition or you
are thinking of getting it, please leave the questions in the comments. Maybe we can create
some kind of discussion based on it.
