Why good GCSE Students Fall Behind in Year 12 Maths

Maths Tutor Mitchell Dye
83 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 4, 2026
Free Lesson: https://calendly.com/mitchell-dye/1-to-1-free-lesson
This video is for students starting Year 12 and want to get an A* Predicted grade for UCAS in Year 13
Website: https://www.mitchell-dye.com/
Every September, students arrive in A-Level Maths with grades 7, 8 and 9.
Some of them fly, others are confused within a few weeks and start wondering whether they were good at maths in the first place.
And some of them are just kind of like, they meander and they slowly decay over time in terms of their results.
And the surprising part is that GCSE grades really don't predict A-Level outcomes all that well.
So, a strong GCSE grade proves that you achieved a strong result in GCSE.
It does not prove that you are able or possible to get a very high grade in A-Level.
So here are five reasons why capable GCSE students fall behind.
And I'm going to also tell you how to stop each and every single one of them.
Reason one, they rely on recognition. This is a really big one.
So at GCSE, a lot of the questions are very easy to identify.
But also when you have like a revision worksheet, it normally tells you what the topic is in the title.
And so then you can just select the method.
So you see like quadratic equations, okay, completing the square or okay, quadratic formula.
And then you know that you need to use that every single time.
With A-Level maths, all of the topics are so interlinked and mixed up and messy that it's actually shocking.
The discriminant is like the first big one that comes to mind.
When we learn that in class, students are like, oh, this is easy.
But then they don't recognise it when it comes up in every single other chapter after that.
So discriminant in chapter two comes up in all of the rest.
So how do you train this? We need to train this by mixing topics.
So before calculating anything, you need to read the question and in your head or verbally out loud say what the question is telling you.
So what can you gain from this sentence? Why have they said it has one solution?
Why have they said it's a tangent? What does it mean?
You can also, and this is why I recommend doing exam questions on PMT,
after every topic, go to those exam questions because it's not immediately obvious what the topic is.
They are grouped together and they also mix them up, which is very, very nice.
Reason two, again, a really big one in the first couple of chapters, actually, is that algebra is accurate, but it's slow.
So a student can earn a grade eight, maybe even a grade nine,
whilst being very slow at doing things like completing the square or factorising quadratic,
because you normally get two or three marks for those questions.
In A-Level, factorising completing the square might not even be worth a mark at all,
or it's worth just a single mark, which means they expect you to do it very, very, very quickly.
And the problem, again, is that in A-Level maths,
we don't deal with things like percentages and fractions and things like that that often.
Instead, almost all of it is to do with algebra.
So this one weakness here applies to literally the entirety of A-Level maths, including stats and mechanics.
So this can also cause students to sit in lessons and feel like everything's going by really,
really quickly because their teacher's factorising immediately,
their teacher's skipping steps in completing the square and getting it right.
And again, this really impacts in chapter two with modelling of quadratics,
especially where you expect to do fairly hard factorising completing the square very, very quickly.
So how do we actually fix this? Well, essentially, it's frequent fluency practice.
So really, really practising those factorising and completing the square.
A big problem that students have is their calculators will actually often do the factorising for them.
But then when questions say you can't use a calculator, they slow right down.
And that's a really big problem. Or it says show that it can be written in this form,
in which case your calculator is not really going to help you.
Or the factorising doesn't have any numbers in it, and so your calculator can't do it.
This is why in the first couple of weeks I set so much homework on just doing things like indices,
factorising, expanding and completing the square, and surds as well,
because those five topics come up so much.
But a lot of students will see that in the textbook, say that's easy GCSE grade five,
skip it, and then they are suddenly very, very slow in the later chapters,
and they struggle to keep up with it.
I have year 13 students making mistakes on indices in an integration question
that cost them two of the six marks or three of the six marks, which is a real big shame.
So make sure you're doing all of that work to make sure to just get yourself to that really, really high standard.
Reason number three, they're copying worked examples.
This is a real problem with students that use the textbook,
but also depending on how your teachers teach as well.
So a worked example can create the illusion of understanding,
because you see the steps logically laid out step by step,
and what happens when the next question comes up?
Well, what you do is you look at the numbers and you try and put them in place for that worked example, right?
And I get a lot of students say this to me as well,
because when I give them a question, I mainly just change the numbers,
and they'll say, well, can't I just swap the numbers here?
The point is you need to understand why you're doing each step.
The understanding is far more important for a few reasons.
One, you cannot memorise every single type of question in A-level maths.
There are thousands.
You just don't have the memory capacity to do that.
Secondly, if you don't understand,
you are not going to be able to do questions that bury the question slightly.
So instead here, you're going to study an example.
Once you understand these steps, you ask yourself, why did they do this?
Why did they do this? Why did they do this?
Once you understand that, you're going to close the example
and try a question of the same type and see if you get it right.
So you can mark yourself, see how far you get,
and that way you can recognise the method and you can actually learn it as well,
which is really, really important.
Reason number four, they avoid mistakes.
So if you're a high-attaining student, especially a grade A online student,
you're used to being correct.
At A-level maths, a lot of the stuff that you've done in GCSE is mostly correct.
So a good example of this is when you square root numbers
and you get a plus or minus.
Students will say, well, I'm still correct. I said the plus one.
But you need all of the solutions.
So you need to be really careful with this
because if you get to a difficult question and you get stuck,
if you're used to being correct, you're not going to like being stuck
and you're not going to like being wrong.
So what I find with a lot of students is they look at a question and say,
I don't know how to do that, and they won't even attempt
because then they're not wrong.
They just haven't even bothered.
The problem with this is fairly obvious.
You're not learning anything.
A-level maths, the best way to learn maths in general, actually,
but especially in A-level maths, is to find hard questions and attempt them.
So even me as a maths teacher that's done this for 10-plus years,
there are questions where I don't know immediately what to do.
So I read the question, look at what the question is telling me,
and I build up statements from there.
So again, like I said before, if something's a tangent,
it means it should have one solution,
which means b squared minus 4ac equals 0.
Again, I can't do all of that in my head.
I have to write it out.
So the best way to avoid this, of course, is a bit tricky,
but I would recommend having kind of a productive struggle window,
so an amount of time that you agree with yourself to struggle with a question
before you give up in air quotes.
So for example, you might work independently for, let's say, 8 minutes,
write down what you know, try something or a simpler question,
and then seek a hint.
Because again, with a lot of these high-level students,
what they're very tempted to do is,
okay, I looked at that, oh, I'm not sure, look at solution bank,
oh, I was going to do that anyway, and then continue.
Pointless.
Give yourself 8 minutes per question to try and,
and again, in that 8 minutes, you're writing out everything you know,
and you're trying stuff.
That way, at least you're getting the first few steps,
which are often the hardest ones.
Reason 5 is, again, a really big one,
and it's why a lot of students come to me for tuition in year 13 instead of year 12.
They wait for the first bad test.
Now, bad is so subjective.
For example, is it, I get 90%, 80%, 70%, 60%, 50%, how much percent?
The problem is, in September, and even October and November,
is I mostly understand it.
Mostly is not good enough when every topic builds on the previous topics.
These small gaps will accumulate over time.
If there's a couple small gaps in Chapter 1,
and in Chapters 2 and 3 and 4,
suddenly you've got 10, 15, 20 small gaps,
which is really, really big.
And by the time we give you a proper assessment,
which is normally once a half term, so once every 6 to 8 weeks,
it might, you know, you might be two chapters ahead of those mistakes.
So you've kind of fallen behind a little bit, which is a big shame.
So what I would do is have weekly self-tests.
Every time you learn something,
pick a few questions from the exercise book or from the PMT questions,
and see if you can get 100%.
And you should be aiming for 100%,
because why not, right?
Try and aim for 100%.
If you're getting 60% or 70%,
okay, that's a B, but that's 70% in each chapter,
which very quickly accumulates to less than 50% in a real exam,
which is really, really bad.
Anything that you cannot fit in that first week that you're doing,
you put that as a priority for the next week.
But you should be testing yourself on every single topic,
even if your school doesn't do it.
And remember, ChatGPT can make tests for you.
Or you can just select questions from the textbook or from PMT.
So, good GCSE students do not fall behind
because A-Level Maths is only for geniuses
that got grade 9 pluses in GCSE Maths.
They fall behind when they, you know,
when they rely on recognition, when their algebra is slow,
when they're passively copying
instead of actually really trying to understand something,
when they have a fear of making mistakes,
and when they have delayed feedback,
causing them to have this knock-on effect
of losing more and more marks in every single chapter.
So, again, I have that diagnostic that I've linked in the description.
It's completely free, of course,
where you can kind of give yourself an idea
of how well you've understood the first couple of chapters.
But I'll see you in the next one.
