A CEO Wanted to Run Healthcare Like Taco Bell. Here’s How His Patients Are Doing

Entrepreneurial Edge
21 followers
Two dialysis giants control the industry — and they're gaming the healthcare system.
DaVita and Fresenius are pushing out and intimidating patients, and sometimes refusing to send them to the hospital.
It's all done to boost profits and make more off the dialysis business.
-----
#business #entrepreneur #marketing #success #smallbusiness #motivation #money #businessowner #entrepreneurship #digitalmarketing #startup #branding #mindset #investment
This is the future of healthcare.
Oh, I'm sorry.
This is the future of healthcare.
If I was confused, it's because, according to the former CEO, they have the same business model.
If I had 1,400 Taco Bells and 32,000 people who worked in them,
I would be doing all the same stuff.
You may not have heard of DaVita, but they're everywhere,
along with their biggest competitor, Fresenius.
They're the biggest players in the dialysis market,
which you may not know or particularly care about.
But you should, because more than likely, you have a kidney inside of you right now.
And nearly 750,000 people a year experience kidney failure,
while over half a million Americans are currently receiving
the only treatment for kidney failure besides a transplant, dialysis.
But taking a look at how the free market ran wild on just this one organ,
the human body, can give us some insight into the future of American healthcare.
They're doing a lot of things that you might encourage a fast food restaurant to do,
like get a lot of patients through the facility each day, cut back on wages, cut back on costs.
Turns out the kidneys are a little different than a Crunchwrap Supreme.
I was scared because at that point was when I realized I can die on the chair.
And I won't even know it.
This is Carmen.
Because Carmen's kidneys didn't work properly,
she needed to show up to dialysis several times a week just to stay alive.
For over a decade, Carmen showed up week after week
so a machine could do what her kidneys couldn't, clean her blood.
And for most of that time, the clinic performing that life-saving service was a DaVita.
Over time, Carmen had witnessed the kind of cost-cutting and decline in quality
many of us have witnessed in retail, food, and furniture.
In 14 years, the quality of care diminished to the point where
patients were having to suffer needlessly.
They cut back on cleaning costs, leaving bloodstains on the floor and chairs.
They took away the numbing medication Carmen used.
The needle sticks are incredibly painful.
But one of the most alarming trends is short staffing,
asking nurses and dialysis technicians to do more and more.
You may think of dialysis as something like a gentle blood draw,
but it's more like an all-out assault on the body.
Patients describe passing out, losing dangerous amounts of blood,
nausea, vomiting, blood pressure spikes.
Is this just a normal part of dialysis?
High-speed, short treatment time, high ultrafiltration rate dialysis
causes cardiac disease, plummeting blood pressure, horrible quality of life.
This is journalist Tom Mohler, who spent five years talking to over 100 patients,
workers, and kidney doctors to blow the lid on this industry.
It is, and I'm not exaggerating,
the most horrifying thing I've read in years.
And I asked him,
what happens when you do this kind of high-speed dialysis with not enough staff?
I've talked with Magellan Hanford,
who is a former LAPD officer who retrained as a dialysis nurse.
He said that at times, as a nurse, he had 17 patients that he was responsible for.
And his description of the day at the office
was like working in a mass unit in a war zone.
It was, you know, someone's cramping here, someone's coding here,
running from place to place.
More than once, he described having to
put a deceased patient under a sheet and continue treating everyone else
because there was just no other option.
You're just sitting there waiting to see what emergency is going to happen.
I've bled out.
And while I'm bleeding out, there's a person across from me
that is alarming.
Who are they going to help first?
And it's not just DeVita.
For this story, I spoke to Fresenius workers across California
who all described the same kind of nightmare scenarios Carmen experienced at DeVita.
Over the years, I believe it went from, you know,
care over profit to very quickly profit over care
to get as many patients as they can with the least amount of staffing
and hoping that nothing happens.
On a bad day, you can get up to seven, eight, nine patients with one technician.
A manager told one of my co-workers,
we were complaining because we were short-staffed that weekend
and nobody came to help.
And, oh, well, nobody died.
That was the response.
One of the nightmare scenarios of dialysis is
the patient is hooked to the machine,
they go to sleep, the needle dislodges,
and the alarm doesn't sound and they bled out.
That is something that I've heard in my reporting numerous times.
My worst experience on dialysis
was one of the times when I passed out.
When I came to, I had no idea that that had happened to me.
And I was scared.
At that point was when I realized I can die on the chair
and I won't even know it.
If they're understaffed, you don't have someone watching every minute.
So bad things happen in a short time.
One of the ladies that I used to ride transport with,
I saw her walking to the scale really wobbly and shaking.
Nobody was around to help her or able to help her
because they were running short-staffed that day like usual.
So while normally they will escort you to the scale,
that was not the case that day.
At the scale, she fell.
And then next thing you know, the ambulance people are rushing in
and they're putting her in
and they covered her head when they took her out.
If I had 1,400 Taco Bells, I would be doing all the same stuff.
You have patients on an assembly line
crammed in as rapidly as possible
and as many shifts as possible to make the facility more profitable.
But even when you're trying to run dialysis like an assembly line,
things happen.
A patient's ride drops them off late.
An emergency happens.
And to catch up, somebody has to cut their dialysis time short.
But here's the problem.
The doctor has prescribed a certain amount of time
for each patient to sit in a chair
with a certain amount of blood being pushed in and out of their system.
If I need five hours of dialysis and I'm only getting four,
it's not cleaning my blood as much as it should.
Toxins can build up in my bloodstream, making me sick.
One of the most unambiguous findings of medical research
and dialysis over the last 30 years
is that shortened treatment times shorten lives.
It's very straightforward.
Now, if a patient wants to cut their dialysis time short,
they need to sign something called an AMA,
a document basically saying you want to do this against medical advice.
But at DaVita and Fresenius, it's not always willing.
We would ask the patient to sign an AMA,
even though it's not the patient's fault.
But we have a schedule to keep with the next patient.
That's the fast food model of healthcare,
where the chains want patients on that machine for three to four hours.
This is economist Ryan McDevitt,
who studied the business of dialysis extensively.
If a patient needs to be on the machine longer today,
they have another patient supposed to come in for their session
where they're going to get another reimbursement.
They don't want to adjust the schedule
to accommodate that patient needs a more personalized type of care.
But here's the problem.
If you want one of the limited kidneys available for transplant,
disregarding a doctor's order looks really bad.
One DaVita patient I spoke to
claimed she was turned down for a kidney transplant
in part because of these AMAs on her medical record.
A kidney transplant means not being trapped in a chair for hours a week,
means living longer.
But transplant organizations don't want to give kidneys
to people that they feel won't follow a doctor's orders.
Another problem in the dialysis industry
is that the very system designed by Medicare
to keep clinics accountable
has been gamed by DaVita and Fresenius.
They have an incentive to push out patients
who are going to harm their scores.
And so most glaring aspect of this
is when a patient is kicked out of the facility
and they'll find different nefarious ways to do that.
We've heard anecdotes where they'll trump up charges on a patient
saying they've been disruptive or they threatened staff.
But what it does is help them look better on the report cards.
And that's important because if they fall short,
they will lose 2% of their Medicare reimbursements.
Another glaring example of juicing their scores involves ambulances.
When a patient gets sent to the hospital from the clinic,
it's a sign something has gone wrong.
And so it hurts your score.
My blood pressure shot sky high.
I mean, really high.
I'm like, shouldn't we be calling the ambulance?
They're like, no, we're going to get it down.
We'll get it down. We'll get it down.
I'm thinking if you don't get me to the hospital,
I'm going to have a damn stroke.
I never got an ambulance
until I put my foot down.
And I said, either you call an ambulance or I will
because I really don't give a damn about DeVita's numbers.
I've actually heard an incredibly similar story
from another patient at an entirely different DeVita location.
Allegedly, a man was repeatedly fainting
while another patient pleaded with staff to call an ambulance.
Whenever there's a dollar at stake,
the for-profit chains do everything they can to chase that dollar,
even if it comes at the expense of patient care.
Now, if you're wondering why these patients
just can't go to another company for dialysis
instead of the emergency room,
well, DeVita and Fresenius have been on a buying spree.
And Ryan McDevitt studied what happens when they buy up other clinics.
We use this quirk in Medicare data
where we could look at the same facility, same patients,
before and after DeVita and Fresenius took over.
Hospitalization rates went up by about 6%.
Death rates go up 3%.
And most alarming, transplant rates for the patients
during their first year of dialysis fell by almost 10%.
Now you think, well, why would that be?
It seems to me that if you want to maintain your cash flow,
you don't let people off dialysis.
That sounds a bit sinister, but it just is a matter of incentives.
More alarming is that when patients do push back and advocate for themselves,
the consequences are sometimes dire.
In my experience as a reporter,
patients who speak out about their rights,
patients who are a little bit difficult,
patients who don't agree immediately to be passive subjects of care,
are quite often targeted for intimidation
and sometimes pushed out of their clinics.
When you're pushed out of a clinic as a dialysis patient,
your lifeline is cut.
This fear has been a consistent through line in the history of dialysis.
In fact, 25 years ago, Republican Senator Chuck Grassley
held a hearing on dialysis
and couldn't find many patients willing to go public.
He expressed his frustration by saying,
they must dialyze to live.
That fact alone has discouraged many patients
interviewed by this committee
from coming forward today to publicly testify.
Quite often because you've been discharged,
you're not accepted to other clinics.
You're blackballed in the area where you live.
So your last resort is the emergency room,
but emergency rooms aren't set up for chronic care.
So they don't actually treat you until your blood is so toxic.
Your whole physiology is so messed up that you're about to die.
Of course, this yo-yo effect on the human body is disastrous
and leads to, you know, rapid demise.
DeVita and Fresenius collectively today
own about 80% of facilities across the country.
They systematically got and bought up
over a thousand independent clinics.
One way they've maintained this duopoly,
Ryan alleges, is by bribing kidney doctors.
They're paying kickbacks to nephrologists
to get them to refer more patients to the facility.
So DeVita and Fresenius have collectively paid
over a billion dollars in settlements and fines
over the past decade or so.
They view it as a cost of doing business.
For them, it's like paying the rent or paying employees.
With their duopoly cemented,
DeVita and Fresenius have been able to aggressively
insidify dialysis with no repercussions.
Sam and Manny have been organizing
with UnitedHealthcare workers to fight for better pay
and more staffing at Fresenius and DeVita.
Manny alleges Fresenius has been retaliating
against workers involved in unionizing.
Carmen is lucky.
She got a kidney transplant.
But she is still fighting for better working conditions
for the dialysis workers that kept her alive.
They take care of us.
They're responsible for my kidney.
My brand new kidney is going to be two years old tomorrow.
If you have kidney failure in the United States,
you're worse off than almost anywhere in the developed world.
Patients in America die sooner
than anywhere else in the developed world.
They have a 20% annual mortality rate.
Compare that to Europe, which is 12 to 15.
Compare that to Japan, which is 6%.
It's radically, radically different.
So American patients die two to three times faster.
The dialysis industry strongly objects
to the way Tom characterized their business in his book.
They did so through lawyers.
I sent some of the stronger statements
to the major dialysis companies.
And some didn't answer, but others, via their lawyers,
wrote back and said, basically, I was full of ----.
I was completely wrong about everything.
And to me and to my publisher,
that was an attempt to block publication of the book.
They didn't say it in so many words,
but they suggested this was libelous.
In 2019, before Ryan McDevitt's damning publication
about dialysis chains, the editors of that journal
received a lengthy email from a DaVita executive.
It includes a laundry list of complaints that,
if true, would likely have gotten the paper retracted,
according to McDevitt.
After he and his co-authors responded,
an editor called the complaints silly and confused.
The DaVita and Fresenius model are not unique to dialysis.
They just have the perfect set of customers,
people who need to show up three times a week
or die in short order.
But hospitals, doctors' offices, pharmacies,
even veterinary clinics,
are being consolidated in similar ways.
That's one of the few things that everybody can agree on,
right, left, and center,
is that our healthcare system is broken.
And dialysis is just sort of the worst case scenario
of what can happen when you totally focus on profits
and on Wall Street and turn the other cheek to human harm.
The model is the same.
Buy up local businesses and aggressively cut costs.
It doesn't have to be this way.
Nearly every other country in the world
has figured this out.
