CEO killing sparks revolt: See health insurance whistleblower on why he quit
Jan 6, 2025
There has been pretty serious, pretty intense conversation on that terrible killing of the
UnitedHealth CEO, Brian Thompson, ever since the day it happened. Now, Luigi Mangione has pled not
guilty to 11 charges. That's the update in that court process as of last week. He faces murder
and terrorism charges. But the case, and separate from the actual sort of calls for vigilante style
attacks on people, the case itself has really brought to the fore much deeper, larger concerns
and conversations about growing inequality in America. So that begins with the healthcare
system and doesn't even end there. There are people who've worked in the industry now who are
also using this moment to speak out. A former executive writing in this New York Times piece
that what he saw made him quit a long while back. That's Wendell Potter, who worked at Cigna
in their corporate communications. Looking at this particular case, he says it's reinvigorated
a conversation that they had about suppressing, basically, these very critiques in an industry
that puts, quote, profits above patients. And much of the discussion that began with the sort of
initial debate about, well, murder is wrong and murder is murder and killing someone in broad
daylight is wrong, that piece of it, which goes to law and order and crime, quickly morphed into
larger conversation of, even if that is true, and hopefully most people in a civilized society still
believe in that rule of law and against violence, but if you agree with that, then what happens when
other people are taking actions that lead to avoidable loss of life? And you don't need to
have the lawyerly sort of academic discussion about what you call it. Do you call that
negligence? Do you call that manslaughter? It's certainly different than first-degree murder, but
ethically, what do we do about that? And is that what we want? And is that acceptable with companies
that already make a lot of money claiming they're going to provide you health coverage in the event
that you need it, and when you need it most, they deny you. The rich are also getting richer against
this backdrop. I want to show you just one headline. There are many out there, but when you
look at the hoarding of wealth by a small group of people, Bloomberg, the financial outlet, notes that
the world's 500 richest people are now holding $10 trillion in wealth this year. And if all boats
were rising in this tide, you might have a different dynamic or reaction to that, even though
that is an incredible amount of wealth hoarding that can't possibly be spent in those people's
lifetimes and likely the lifetimes of their children. But when you look at this, the raw
national data, which we have from the federal government, the median wage an American is making
is just over a thousand dollars a week in the first quarter of 24, which doesn't get you very
far, and that's before you run into unplanned health costs, which might be the thing that saves
or doesn't save the life of you or your loved ones. Americans have very few options against
rising inequality and a heck of a lot of understandable rage about the people at the top
doing this. With all that said, I want to bring in the very person I quoted. Wendell Potter worked
as a senior corporate executive in communications at Cigna. He wrote that op-ed for The Times,
and he's written several books and been called upon long before this recent incident to discuss
what is wrong with this health care industry, as well as how other health care reforms like
Obamacare function. He leads the lower out-of-pocket now coalition. You might be the ideal
guest for a non-ideal situation in America. Welcome. Thank you, Ari. Good to be on the show.
Let's start with the point I raised, that if you put aside what I'm calling somewhat legal semantics,
there has to be a regulatory, a societal, and an ethical obligation of these health care
companies to provide that care they promised, rather than deny it to people
who, played by the rules, paid in and are facing life and death situations.
There should be, and there used to be. It's not been so many years ago that that was
kind of the way health insurance worked in this country. But in the mid-1990s,
things changed. Back then, or before then, most of us got our health insurance from non-profit
Blue Cross plans or other non-profit organizations. Since then, the big companies
that dominate the industry are New York Stock Exchange corporations, mega corporations,
that have really put profits over the needs of patients for many, many years now.
This is what happens when you allow Wall Street to run your system of health insurance.
These companies have to show these investors and Wall Street financial analysts,
every three months, that they're meeting those investors' profit expectations.
And they do that in ways that make it more and more difficult for people to get the care that
they need, and to be able to afford that care, even if they have health insurance. That's why
I lead that coalition, because one of the ways that they have been able to penalize us and make
it so difficult for us to get the care that we need is making us pay tens of thousands of dollars,
in many cases, for our care before our insurance policies will kick in these days.
When you look at what they sometimes call medical ethics, there are situations that are
difficult, but where doctors might land on the side of not providing a certain type of care.
Someone who is 90 years old, terminal, and a very complex procedure may or may not add
some months, and the doctors say no. And that still can be heart-wrenching and debatable.
I want to be very clear, a lot of people watching or living in America know this already, right?
Although, Wendell, I don't know if you know, sometimes on the news we tell people things
they already know. That's not the main issue here. The issue are situations where someone
needs life-saving care, the doctors are ready to do it, and as you said, it's the Wall Street-driven
corporation. So I want to read from an example you give where you write that this helped you
decide to leave. 2008, a 17-year-old leukemia patient in California had a scheduled liver
transplant. And then it was, you write, postponed at the last minute when Cigna told her surgeons
that the company, Cigna, would not pay. And then you explain how these things go down. Her family
stirred up so much media attention that Cigna relented, but it was too late. She died a few
hours after Cigna's change of heart. Tell us about that and what it reveals that the company is,
according to that story, literally trying to see what it can get away with, including a situation
that might result in the loss of life that otherwise is saveable. But if there's too much
heat, they back down, which raises the question, why couldn't they have done the thing they're
supposed to do, provide the health coverage, to begin with? You know, what these companies do is
they know that most people take a denial as the final answer, and that most people will not fight
that denial. They will not pursue an appeal that they're entitled to. In this case, Nathalene
Sarkeesian's family did. Cigna still said no. So the company became a, the family became a very
squeaky wheel, and it became a huge PR nightmare for Cigna. And the company eventually relented.
This happens all the time when a case becomes something that the media takes an interest in.
The company, the insurance company in question will usually relent and reverse that denial
because they want that PR problem to go away. But they just are counting on people not knowing
how to even appeal a decision, even if it's life-threatening. And also keep in mind that
most people, when you're sick, you just don't have the energy and sometimes the ability to
advocate for yourself. And it can be a very complicated procedure because these companies
purposely make it very difficult. Only about 10% or fewer people actually appeal these denials.
When they do, the majority are approved. So that just goes to show you that medically necessary
care is being denied day in and day out. And often it's deadly, as it was for Nathalene Sarkeesian.
It happens every single day. And it's only occasionally that a story captures the media's
attention.

