The Controversial History of Men's Style

Elevate Living
4 followers
5 Video Views·Jan 7, 2026
➡️ Chapters
00:00 — The "polite" lie of classic style.
00:45 — Why U-boat crews wore "Made in the USA."
01:22 — The 1930s redesign that killed flashy fashion.
03:16 — Is your collar actually a piece of armor?
05:30 — The genius 1827 hack for "White Collar" status.
06:48 — Ancient Greece’s version of the "portable bed."
07:55 — The Roman color code for power.
08:58 — What is a "Nuremberg Egg"?
12:47 — 1913: The birth of the world's most popular shirt.
13:59 — The deadly origin of the silk necktie.
15:22 — Why white pants were banned in India.
AI Generated·May contain errors
War, it changes people.
For centuries, the real history of your wardrobe has been hidden behind the word classic.
But when you peel back the layers, the origin of these items is anything but polite.
From mud-dyed chinos to mercenary neckties, your clothes were born from war, riots, and
literal death traps.
The history of your closet is more dangerous than you think.
For those of you that are World War II fans, here's a fact you haven't heard before.
German U-boat crews sank over a million tons of Allied ships wearing cargo pants made in
England and the USA.
Seriously, you had Wolfpack commanders like Wolfgang Luth out there wearing trousers stamped
made in the USA as he sank US merchant marine ships.
So, what's the story here?
How did cargo pants, a relatively new invention made in the USA end up in the hands of a bunch
of German U-boat crews?
Now, the story of the cargo pants begins in the 1930s.
And what we see are militaries around the world are starting to spend a lot more on
their armed forces.
So, they decide, hey, let's spend a little bit on uniforms.
The British in particular, they had not really redesigned their battle dress since 1902.
So, in the early 1930s, the designers hit the board and they said, you know what?
We want to use a little bit less fabric because that's going to be an issue whenever you're
at war, you've got to ration fabric.
And we want something that's got mobility, something that's going to be functional, something
that is more modern that doesn't have to have flashy colors.
In fact, they made sure the buttons were something that, yeah, you never had to shine them.
Before that, you know, everything was about pomp, everything was about bright colors,
everything was about just over the top.
They got away from that very quickly.
They had learned their lessons from World War I.
And so, in 1937, we saw the first look of the new battle dress.
Now, the field service dress, FSD as it would eventually be called, was initially made from
denim.
But they said, you know what?
Let's use a khaki serge.
That is going to actually do a better job of keeping our guys warm.
It's, you know, just simply a better material is going to be more breathable.
But they said, you know what?
Let's adjust a few things.
Everything had to have a place, everything had to have a purpose with British design.
So, the initial cargo pant had three pockets, one on the right back for personal items.
Then, you had a pleated pocket on the front right side for field dressings.
And then, you had one large flat pocket on the left thigh with a hidden button flap that
was specifically made to hold maps.
And down at the bottom of the trousers, they actually had tabs.
This made gathering the material basically wrapping it around the ankle easier.
That was important because with the combat shoe, they would have gaiters that would keep
everything nice and neat down there.
Before that, they had had really high leather boots which were incredibly expensive, so
this was all saving.
You know, these were very utilitarian design.
Now, what's interesting except for a few modifications, we're talking they got rid of the tabs at
the bottom of the cargo pants, they got rid of the belt loops, they adjusted the pocket
on the, you know, for the map pocket, they made it so the button went all the way through,
saved a little bit of fabric there.
The point being is this was used for the next twenty five years.
It was very functional, very useful type of design.
So, the collar has its origins back in the high middle ages.
What we saw were advances in armor and men were now wearing helmets, they were wearing
chain mail to protect themselves.
But there was an issue.
There was a very vulnerable area even if you wore a full face helmet and that was your
neck area.
Thrusting weapons could easily penetrate, so all of a sudden they developed the gorgette.
Now, the gorgette was a solid piece of metal that protected the neck from thrusting weapons.
The issue with it though is it was on a very sensitive part of the body and it was incredibly
uncomfortable especially even if you had chain mail underneath it.
If you didn't have a piece of cloth or material, it would go underneath it.
Now, initially they would wrap clothing, but that could lead to choking and it was incredibly
uncomfortable and that's where they started to develop the collar, a piece of cloth that
could go in right there to separate the skin from the armor.
Now, this may seem like an incidental piece, but, again, it's touching the skin and it's
something that would lead to irritation.
And the men that were commissioning these to be made, everything was handmade, so they
would have it made to their exact measurements.
They would also want to make sure they didn't have any excess cloth because that would lead
to just it being hot that would lead to, you know, fabric wrapping up and getting in the
way or leading to irritation.
So, it was something that all of a sudden you saw men starting to wear these collars,
you know, even when they would take their armor off.
16th century, we saw an interesting thing happen in the Spanish and the English courts.
And that was all of a sudden people started paying attention to these collars and having
fun with them.
Both men and women, it started to become a status symbol, something that, hey, let's
make it a little bit more flamboyant, let's add some ruffles, let's add some lace.
And next thing, you know, these things started getting bigger and larger and drawing more
attention.
What people really liked about this is it did a great job of framing the face.
Most of the clothing at the time was very dark for practical purposes, but here around
the face, you could have a light color which basically would reflect the light would shine
and draw attention to the face.
Now, for over a hundred years, flamboyant collars were the thing.
I mean just look at pictures back from that time period, again, whether it was men, women,
you had Shakespeare even jumping in on this thing.
I mean, yeah, it drew attention to the face, they looked good, but eventually collars started
becoming more practical again, 17th, 18th century.
But then, an interesting thing happened in the year 1827 in the United States.
There was a woman in New York that came up with this really simple idea of detaching
the collar and cuffs by the way from the shirt because here was the deal is white shirts
were prized by people of means.
Why?
Because it was a clear indicator that you didn't work with your hands that you worked
in a very high level or you didn't even have to work and you could wear white.
So, those that did wear whites and a lot of people like to look like they were upper class,
they would have to wash this stuff every single day.
And you imagine washing an entire shirt, the thing would wear out.
But this woman has a genius idea, let's just detach the collar because that gets really
dirty, the cuffs the same and we'll wash those separately.
They even got better on this, they actually used what's known as celluloid.
It was an early form of plastic and they actually created these plastic collars, plastic cuffs
and they were selling them very inexpensively.
Now, if you still had money, you were taking your collars and your cuffs to get washed,
they were made from linen, they had to be starched a lot.
But, again, this was a status symbol.
It was a clear indicator whenever you had that white collar, you were a man of power,
you were a man of money.
Now, getting into the history, how long have men and women been wearing cloaks?
Well, pretty much since they've been wearing any type of clothing.
The idea and the design of a cloak is so simple that we have seen this pop up in cultures
all around the world.
When we look at the earliest clothing that they were wearing, these were pelts that were
shaped basically with room for their head to be able to stick out of and to be able
to protect all around the body.
And another big advantage of a cloak is simply that you can wear it when you're sleeping,
you can wear this when you're walking around.
It's some – basically, yeah, you're wearing your bedwear right here and it was just incredibly
functional and, again, didn't require a whole lot of sewing to be able to get the
job done.
Now, when it comes to recorded history, the first evidence that we see of a cloak or I
was able to find was from about 500 BC and this is on a cup that's over in the Louvre
and it's from ancient Greece and it shows two people hiding under a cloak.
I wonder what they're doing.
But, seriously, the Greeks are given credit I think back to 750 BC for the Hymation which
was a variation of the cloak.
The Romans eventually took it and ran with it and their variation was known as the Pallium.
Now, as it seems like they did with a lot of things, the Romans took the Greek idea
and they actually made it theirs and in some ways improved upon it or actually gave us
the first idea that capes and cloaks could be used as differentiators for us to be able
to see who a person is and their rank in society.
Now, the simplest form of the Roman cloak was known as the Penula and this was worn
by both men and women.
It was just a simple thing that you wore to show that, hey, I'm a part of the community.
Now, higher up the rank structure, we had soldiers and they were actually wearing saggots
and these were larger cloaks a little bit longer and they had specific colors.
So, if you're wearing a red one, you were a regular foot soldier.
If you were wearing one that was scarlet, you were an officer.
If you had a purple saggot, you were a general.
And if you were a general, you wore what was called a lacerna and that was attached to
one shoulder by a brooch on one side and it basically was made in a color that it was
very distinctive.
People knew who you were, they got out of your way, you were in charge, you were the
man.
And this status symbol wasn't confined just to the military.
We also saw Roman senators wearing lacernas in purple as well over their togas.
So, the idea of timekeeping has been pivotal in the advancement of man over the last couple
of thousand years.
We go back to the Egyptians, we go back to any large society thousands of years ago.
What did the Romans use?
They had sundials.
You could tell basically what time it was in general by the position of the sun.
Now, the earliest clock tower we've got on record goes back to Athens and it was called
the Tower of the Winds.
And this actually had eight sundials.
It also had what was known as a water clock.
Wasn't super accurate, but it did a decent job of helping the people be able to tell
the time.
Why was timing important?
Because you need to know when to start work, when to stop work.
And if you're going to be doing processes that require you do them for a set amount
of time, it was important that you were able to track it.
Now, the Chinese as early as 1088, they actually had clock towers using liquid escapement mechanisms.
Again, relatively accurate and you may be wondering, okay, well, if you're not in there,
how can you actually tell the time?
Well, the big thing with clock towers wasn't that you could actually see the time on a
big dial, it was actually you could hear it.
So, they would have bells that would ring every hour.
It wasn't about the minutes, it was about the hours and that right there all of a sudden
everyone within the vicinity could hear the bells ring at a set time and know what time
it is.
Now, as large spring driven clocks became more popular throughout Europe in the 15th
16th century, we started seeing a race to actually make them small.
And I'm talking really small.
All of a sudden, the idea that you could have something that you could hold in your hand
And these were still relatively large, we're talking like 10, 15 pounds.
But, the idea is you could actually hold something that could accurately tell you the time.
This was a big deal and it was expensive.
So, as you could imagine, the only people that were able to afford something like this
would be royalty, you would see maybe really high level noblemen, maybe some merchants
with a lot of money.
These kind of people would be able to afford a timekeeping piece and it was really just
a show of opulence, it was a show that you actually had the money to be able to spend
on this.
And in turn, it eventually started as they became a little bit more common, easier to
manufacture, it became a functional piece.
When I say functional piece, it became a fashion item that a lot of women actually loved to
wear.
They were called Nuremberg eggs and these were actually attached to chains made from
or at least encased in precious metals.
And they pretty much served the purpose of jewelry and they were accentuated your outfits
and they had a small timekeeping device sometimes even hooked up with an alarm.
And, again, it was all about a show that you had the wealth to actually own something like
this.
Now, in the 17th century, there was a big fashion trend.
All of a sudden, men started wearing these smaller pocket watches that would fit in your
pocket, they were that small and it was just a fashion piece.
It was able to pull something like this out around people and show that you had means
that you had money that you basically had something they didn't have.
Now, to better fit in pockets, the shape evolved and the technology, the technicians, everything
at this point was handmade.
Nothing is mass-manufactured.
So, all of a sudden, everything is geared towards, yes, getting it thinner, getting
it smaller, getting it so, yeah, the smaller, the better.
And, again, it was a race to the bottom here.
And we actually know how valuable these watches were because we can go look at old newspaper
clippings.
Stolen watches apparently was a big deal.
People were offering five guineas which is a big amount in that time for just information
on the whereabouts of my stolen watch.
By the end of the 18th century though, you started to see watches just start to reach
the masses.
In fact, a lot of sailors could afford a watch that they would take on their journey, you
know, when you're out on the ocean especially if you're crammed, you know, in bad weather.
It's nice to be able to actually know what time it is when you don't see the sun for
a while.
It happened to me on a boat.
I remember not going up for like three or four days.
I mean, these were huge boats in the, you know, Marine Corps were always riding with
the Navy.
But, yeah, you kind of want to know what time it is.
Now, this next fashion trend was started by a military regulation change in 1913.
Before then, undershirts basically had buttons on them and they – since the 1880s, they
have been using this design.
It wasn't very comfortable and it wasn't very functional.
Well, the military said, you know what?
We need these guys working cleaning, you know, the top of decks and stuff on boats, so let's
give them a piece of gear that is simple and that basically frees up the arms.
The t-shirt was invented, 1913.
The original designs were actually made from wool, they took a long time to dry.
It just wasn't a great design, but eventually within a period of about five to ten years,
we saw that transition to the cotton t-shirt as we know it.
And they went with white because it was incredibly cheap.
Since about 1920, we saw the white t-shirt all of a sudden it was – and this was underwear,
this was not something that was shown.
It wasn't until the 1950s that we saw the white t-shirt all of a sudden being worn under
a leather jacket on the big screen that all of a sudden t-shirts started coming into their
own.
And then, the late 1970s, 1980s, we saw the fashion tee all of a sudden putting, you know,
a little slogan or logo or something, I love New York across the tee all of a sudden made
it something that people would wear every day.
Next up, let's talk about neckwear, specifically ornamental neckwear.
We're talking about the necktie because you think about it, what functional purpose does
a necktie serve?
Well, the answer for over 2,000 years is it brings color, it disrupts pattern.
It actually is a great identifier of what unit you're with.
Going back to 200 BC, we look at the Qin Dynasty, those terracotta soldiers, guess what?
They are wearing silk cords around their neck to identify what units they're with.
Roman legionnaires wore scarves not only for protection, but, again, to identify what unit
you are with and your rank.
In Europe's 30-year war, Croatian mercenaries serving in the French military wore scarves.
They wore these neck pieces that were, yes, decorative and just simply to show who they
were with and what they were about.
And if you think that this is old-fashioned, you ought to do your research on regimental
neckties and the different type of club neckties out there still worn over in England and the
UK.
And this is something that, hey, some people will take an affront if you're wearing their
colors, if you're wearing their unit and you didn't serve, if you didn't go to that club
because it used to be – going back to 1910, pretty much you were only allowed to wear
neckties that you had actually earned.
So, you went to this school, you were part of this club, you had served in these regiments,
you therefore could wear these colors.
If not, well, good luck, you were just wearing something plain.
And let's not forget about khakis, chinos, that tan color that we see on men's trousers
around the world and women have adopted it as well.
This actually comes back 1845.
We had the English over in India and they realized, you know what?
These white pants are not great, they're too bright, we need to go for something a
little bit darker that's going to better fit in.
In fact, it was 1848 that they officially adopted this as a color.
They were using different dyes, it was relatively inexpensive and it really made sense in camouflage.
Now, the United States didn't figure this out until about 1898 in the Spanish-American
War.
All of a sudden, we started adopting khaki.
Again, we saw this pick up and become part of regular uniforms just, you know, office
uniforms with the military throughout World War I, World War II, and it then bled over
into a mere just – just regular college wear in the 1950s.
To this day, khakis, chinos, and the use of the color tan are a staple in men's fashion
and women's fashion around the world.
Gents, what do you think?
What did I miss?
Let me know in the comments below.
And if you want to keep watching, guys, you know I got you covered right here at Real
Men Real Style with another great fine video.
Boom!
Right here.
Go check it out.
Oh, yeah.
