This video explores the complex role of fathers, encouragement, and adversity in shaping personal growth and greatness. From a psychological perspective, it examines how the desire for parental approval—especially from a demanding or emotionally distant father—can become a powerful motivator. The discussion highlights the importance of having at least one encouraging role model, whether a parent, another adult, or even figures found in books and stories.
Using examples such as Angela’s Ashes, the conversation shows how individuals can selectively reject destructive influences while amplifying positive ones, even within the same person. It also delves into the idea of the “beneficial adversary,” questioning how struggle, high standards, and conditional approval can drive development without becoming arbitrary or damaging.
Ultimately, the video argues that real love is not just acceptance, but a balance of encouragement, high expectations, and firm boundaries—pushing someone to become what they are capable of being, without breaking the relationship that makes growth possible.
Tell me if I'm wrong, but it feels like
the engine of greatness, at least on the male side of things, has often been trying to prove the
father wrong or trying to gain the acceptance of the father.
So that tension, where the parent is not encouraging, like you mentioned, but is
basically
saying, no, you won't be able to do this.
My observation as a psychologist has been that it's very, very difficult for someone to get their act together
unless they have at least one figure in their life that's encouraging and shows them the pathway forward.
So you can have a lot of adversity in your life, and if you have one person around who's a good model and you're
neurologically intact, you can latch on to that model. Now, you can also find that model in books, and
people do that sometimes. Like, I've interviewed people who had pretty fragmented childhoods who turned to books and
found the pattern that guided them in, like, let's say, the
adventures of the heroes of the past, because that's a good way of thinking about it.
And I read a book called Angela's Ashes that was written by an Irish author, Frank McCourt.
Fantastic book, beautiful book. And his father was an alcoholic of gargantuan proportions.
He was just an Irish drinker who drank every scent that came into the family, and many of whose children died in
poverty. And
what Frank did,
it's a testament to the human spirit, is he sort of divided his father conceptually into two elements. There was sober morning father
who was encouraging and with whom he had a relationship, and then there was drunk and useless later afternoon and evening father, and he
rejected the negative, and he
amplified his relationship with the positive. Now, like, he had other
he had other things going for him, but he, you know, he did a very good job of discriminating.
And, I mean, partly the question that you're
raising is, to what degree is it useful to have a beneficial adversary?
Yeah, and, I mean, struggle-free progress is not possible, and
I think there are situations under which where, you know, you might be
motivated to prove someone in your
immediate circle wrong.
But then that also implies that at some level, for some reason, you actually care about their judgment.
You know, you just didn't write them off completely.
Well, I mean, that's why I say there's an archetype of a young man trying to gain the approval of
his father, and I think that repeats itself in a bunch of
biographies that I've read. I don't know, there must have been an engine somewhere that they found of approval, of
encouragement. Maybe in books, maybe in the mother, or maybe the role of the parents is flipped.
Well, my father was hard to please. Very. Did you ever succeed?
Yes, but it wasn't easy, ever. When was the moment when you
succeeded?
Late, pretty late, like
40,
maybe later. Was it a
gradual or a definitive moment when a shift happened?
My father always was always willing to approve of the things I did that were good, although he was
not effusive by any stretch of the imagination, and the standards were very high. Now, I was probably fortunate for me,
you know, and it does bear on the question you're asking. It's like, if you want someone to motivate you
optimally, God, it's complicated, because there has to be a temperamental dance between the two people.
What you really want is for someone to apply the highest possible standards to you
that you're capable of reaching,
right? And that's a vicious dance, because
you have to have a relationship with your child to do that properly, you know, because you want to, if you want to be
optimally motivating as a father, you keep your children on the edge. It's like,
you might not reward something in your child that you would think would be good in someone else, because you think they could do better.
And so my father was pretty clear about the idea that he always expected me to do better. And
was that
troublesome? It was like, I felt often
when I was young, that there was no pleasing him.
But I also knew that that wasn't... I knew that that wasn't right. See, I actually knew that wasn't right.
Because I could remember, especially, I think, when I was very young, that I did things that he was pleased about.
I knew that was possible. So it wasn't
unpredictable and arbitrary. It was just difficult.
It sounds like he's hit a pretty good optimal.
But it's for each individual human, that optimal differs. Well, that's why you have to have a relationship
with your children. You have to know them.
And, well, with yourself too. And with your wife.
You can't hit that optimal.
That optimal is probably love.
Because love isn't just acceptance. Love is acceptance and encouragement. And it's not just that either.
It's also, no, don't do that. That's beneath you.
You're capable of more. And how harsh should that be? It's like, that's a really hard question.
You know, like, if you really love someone, you're not gonna put up with their stupidity. Don't do that.
You know, one of the rules I had with my little kids was,
don't do anything that makes you look like an idiot in public. Why? Because I don't want you disgracing yourself.
Why not? Because I like you.
I think you're great. And you're not gonna act like a bloody fool in public, so that people get the wrong idea about you.
No!