'Christina of Denmark, Duchess of Milan' (1538) by Hans Holbein the Younger

Renaissance Art (c.1350–1620)
243 followers
32 Video Views·Dec 30, 2025
Learn how Hans Holbein the Younger's portrait of the 16-year-old widow Christina of Denmark piqued Henry VIII's interest when he was looking for a new bride and the surprising story of how the work came into our collection with Susan Foister, our Deputy Director.
Good afternoon everybody, my name's Susan Foister and I'd like to welcome you to this talk
which is on Holbein's great portrait of Christina of Denmark. So we're going to spend the next half
hour exploring how this painting came to be made by Hans Holbein, one of the most famous
artists of the Renaissance, and there's also quite an exciting coda about how this painting
came to be in the National Gallery's collection today. So Christina of Denmark, who was she?
Well we actually know quite a lot about her and quite a lot too about how Holbein came to
undertake the commission for Henry VIII and paint her, which is quite unusual for the 16th century
so we must make the most of all the letters and documents that we have here. And in those
documents there's quite a lot of talk about Christina and her beauty. Now she was a 16 year
old widow and she'd had quite a hard life. Early on in her life she was born as the daughter to
the King of Denmark in 1521 and when she was a small child the whole family had to flee from
Denmark. Christian was introducing the Protestant Reformation, not everybody agreed with that,
there were some quite brutal things going on, and he fled to the Low Countries, to the court
of Brussels, to the relatives of his wife, taking his three young children with him,
of whom one was Christina. So she was, if you like, a rather grand refugee as a child.
Even in her childhood, living at the court, she was married, age 11, by proxy to the Duke of Milan.
The marriage didn't last very long because when she was 13 already she became a widow
and she is wearing here her black widow's robes. So she was talked about as a beautiful
16 year old widow at the court in Brussels, one of many women, many possible candidates
for marriage to King Henry VIII. So people got quite excited about her.
They talked about the fact that she had dimples which showed when she smiled,
that she had a lisp when she talked, which they said was very attractive, and that she was tall
for the average height at this time, and I think this is more or less a life-size portrait,
and the portrait I think shows off her height and her beauty very well. Her hands are prominent.
She was said to have exceptionally beautiful hands as well. So there was a lot of chatter
and a lot of excitement about this 16-year-old girl. So she's shown before us wearing these
black robes, but they are extremely luxurious widow's weaves, if you like. She's wearing a
most beautiful black satin coat, a full-length coat. It's just falling in folds, sort of rippling
to the floor there and catching the light. This is one of the things that Holbein does so
beautifully. A lot of people wore black at this time, but he really makes the most of the contrasts
and textures of different kinds of black fabrics. So this was a very luxurious coat, made even more
luxurious, as you can see, by the fact that it's all lined with fur. You can see the collar and
then the lining as he follows it all the way down to the floor. So she would have been quite cozy
in this robe. Underneath, she's wearing a plain black dress and this robe is just drawn together
by some black silk ribbons, which you can probably just see there at her waist.
Under the black dress, she's wearing a white chemise, a white shirt with a ruffled neck that
you can see there and ruffled cuffs, which also you may just be able to see have a very fine line
of black embroidery at the edge, just showing off those beautiful hands there. She's holding buff
coloured leather gloves, very fine leather. They would also have been very expensive and she's
wearing one single ring with a red stone and that may be a ring that signifies her mourning as well.
So by this time, she's been wearing mourning for three years. Her hair is virtually hidden
underneath the black cap that she's wearing. You may just be able to see to the left that there's
a bit of a grey lining to it and on the right hand side, you may just be able to see silhouetted,
there are two rows of trimming, which is probably a kind of chenille velvet trimming to the cap.
So she's wearing sumptuous, rich textures to make up her mourning clothes and of course,
those show off all the more the parts of her that we can see, her beautiful hands and her beautiful
face. Can't quite see those dimples but we can imagine those. I'm going to talk about what
happened in 1538 when this painting was commissioned and painted in just a moment
but let me just tell you a bit about Christina's later life. She was always talked about as the
one who got away because I'm maybe not spoiling the story for you entirely by telling you that
she didn't marry Henry VIII although he was very, very interested in her and the story goes
that she said well if she had two heads then she would willingly place one of those at King Henry's
disposal but actually we do have a little bit more information than that and I think we can
probably assume that that was a pretty apocryphal story because it is documented that what she did
say to Henry VIII's ambassadors when she was asked her opinion about marrying Henry is essentially
she didn't have any opinion but she was the Emperor's servant and the Emperor was the Emperor
Charles V, key political figure in this time and she was at the court of his aunt, Mary of Hungary
and she was going to do whatever he wanted. So the feisty reply I think unfortunately we can discount.
So this 16-year-old beauty is represented here and this was a painting made for King Henry VIII.
I'm sure I don't need to tell you that King Henry VIII had six wives. What's key for considering
this painting is that Christina potentially was there to be the fourth wife. So Henry had divorced
Catherine of Aragon, he married Anne Boleyn, that went very badly, that ended in her execution for
adultery and then he married Jane Seymour. Now Jane Seymour was the person who bore him the long
awaited son, the future King Edward VI but unfortunately she died just a few days
after giving birth to him in autumn 1537. So immediately after that Henry was on the lookout
for a fourth wife. So he had his ambassadors scour the courts of Europe. He wanted to know
who was out there and he had some ideas about how to choose between them that seemed pretty
odd to some of the ambassadors. So for example he thought it would be a very good idea to have a
beauty parade of potential candidates at Calais. So Calais was of course at this point under English
rule. He thought it would be very easy for him to come over by boat and enjoy this beauty parade
and you know pick in person who he thought might suit him. Well that went down very very badly with
the French court, they were very scandalized by that idea so that wasn't going to work out. But
of course in this period, this was an age long before photographs, so how was the King of England
going to get a good idea of who was sufficiently attractive, sufficiently beautiful and sufficiently
free of all kinds of possible defects in order to marry the King and perhaps produce another
heir? He had an heir but of course he needed the spare. So a young 16 year old bride seemed as
though she might just be possibly up to the job. So how was he going to get a likeness of her? Well
we know that there was more than one pretty botched portrait that seems to have been sent
over to England. Now the ambassadors had already seen her, they'd given him these very good reports
of her, her lisp, her lovely dimples. She was compared to a Mistress Shelton who was one of the
court beauties. So there was tremendous enthusiasm but they really wanted a good likeness and the
portraits they were being sent they didn't think were going to do the job at all for Henry. So
Henry turned to Hans Holbein who fortunately he had on his payroll at court ready to carry out
the bidding of the King and to be his court portraitist. And in fact through 1538 and 1539
Holbein was kept extremely busy by being sent to Europe to scout out and portray
women who were thought to be the potential brides for Henry. In the spring of 1538
he was sent to Brussels. Now Holbein was perhaps the greatest of all portraitists
in Europe at that moment so Henry was very very fortunate to have him on his staff as it were.
Holbein was a German artist born in Augsburg at the end of the 15th century so he was about 40
at the height of his powers when he was commissioned to paint Christina. He had been
working in England since the 1520s. He came there from Basel in Switzerland where he'd gone to make
his fortune but the prospects for an artist turned really rather negative after the Reformation
started there. So having spent a couple of years in England in the 1520s he came back to England.
He was backed by 1532 and pretty much stayed over here in London until his death in 1543.
Henry VIII paid him a substantial salary, £30 a year. Now it's not set out anywhere exactly what
tasks he was supposed to undertake for that salary but he was multi-talented. He could design
beautiful jewellery and goldsmithsware for the court for example. We have many such drawings
that survive by Holbein. He could paint subject pictures, religious pictures and for Henry at
Whitehall Palace he painted an enormous life-size dynastic portrait of Henry VIII, Henry VII
and their two wives. Henry with Jane Seymour who died just around the time this great commission
was completed. So he could make really magnificent full-length portraits and having a full-length
portrait for a potential bride was really really important. We have documents going back to Henry
VI's time in the middle of the 15th century saying how very important it was when considering a
to be able to see their whole figure, all of their limbs. After all they wanted to make sure
they weren't lacking any of them. So an authentic portrait by a trusted artist was going to bring
back all of that vital information. So a full-length portrait was really important and Holbein by this
time had really shown what he could do. Portraits of Henry, portraits of his family and many
portraits of people at Henry's court. Quite a number of these paintings survive. Of course here
you know we have Holbein's ambassadors just right next to us and there are also many beautiful
drawings that Holbein made of people at the court that survive today, most of them in the Royal
Collection at Windsor Castle and they're always worth a good look. So Holbein was eminently
qualified to carry out this commission and the commission is very very well documented in letters
sent back by Henry's ambassador Sir Philip Hobie. Now Holbein wasn't going to be sent over to
Brussels to take this portrait once it had been agreed all by himself. He had to have a trusted
diplomat with him. We still don't know very much about Holbein's language and skills at this period.
He was born a German, he would have spoken German in Switzerland. We assume by the time he'd spent
several years working in England that his English was quite decent but we really don't know. But we
have some very long letters written by Sir Philip Hobie which tell us exactly what went on. So first
of all of course they had to cross the English Channel in March. That took a few days. They got
to Brussels on the 8th of March and on the 10th of March Holbein was given a sitting with Christina
and this is one of the most interesting pieces of information we have about how Holbein made
portraits because we're told that he had three hours with her. Three hours space they say.
Unfortunately because this commission isn't at all typical we don't know whether it was
usual for him to spend three hours with his sitters when he was making portraits or not.
Neither do we know for certain what exactly he did during those three hours. Now I've referred
to Holbein making drawings of his sitters and the numbers of drawings that survive and we have quite
a few cases in which we've got a drawing and then we've got the portrait so we know that he needed
the drawing in order to make a painted portrait. In the case of Christina it seems really unlikely
I think that Holbein would have crossed the Channel in the March gales in an open boat
with a panel this size. This is a big oak panel. It's surely much more likely that he took several
sheets of paper with him, his coloured chalks, his inks that he liked to work with and that he made
a series of drawings of Christina which were then going to serve him very well in making
the finished portrait. Don't know that for certain. This is surmised but I think that that's
very likely. So what might he have done in his three hours? Well I think he would absolutely
have made a drawing of her face. That was going to be pretty vital and I think it's no accident
that he's showing her full face looking directly at us. Now that's not the case with many of his
other portraits. People are shown slightly to one side, slightly to the other side but I think Henry
wanted to see as much of that face as possible so he wanted a full face drawing there and he
probably would have worked that up on a piece of paper that was coated in a pink watercolour.
So that's the case for most of the drawings that survive that Holbein made in the 1530s.
He would select, we think, a piece of paper covered in a pink shade that would approximate
to his sitter's complexion. That was a way of sort of speeding things up. He had these ready-prepared
sheets so he would say, yep, this light pink perhaps here is the shade that I need. Then he
would have set to work probably with black chalk in the first place and added perhaps some red chalk
for those beautiful red lips and brown for the brown eyes that she has. And in a number of his
portrait drawings he also makes notes in black ink. Notes to himself, notes usually in German,
and they're colour notes usually. So they might be, there's one drawing of a man in which he says
the eyes are a little yellowish. Doesn't sound terribly nice. There are other drawings in which
he talks about the colours and textures. Often he says this bit's to be black velvet, this bit's to
be black satin. The drawings that survive are usually head and shoulders drawings, not much
more. So we can imagine a head and shoulders drawing of Christina, perhaps with some notes on
her eye colour, perhaps with some notes on the black satin robe that she's wearing. But he wouldn't
have worked much of that detail up in a head and shoulders drawing. What he may also have made
is a costume drawing. And we do have one or two very beautiful, quite detailed drawings that he
made of women when he first came to England, perhaps because he was trying to understand the
style of dress which was different from the style in Switzerland. And perhaps with Christina he
would have made a drawing of that type. We have one drawing in which he shows the woman from the
back and from the front, so he can completely understand the style of dress that she's wearing.
So he may have made a costume drawing of Christina. And in one of two cases we have detailed drawings
of hands. And it's my surmise that because Christina's hands are so prominent in this
composition and because she was supposed to have such beautiful hands, that he did make a drawing
of her hands. So I think he would have made these drawings in the three hours that he had allotted
to him, and then he would have taken all of those drawings back with him on the boat back to the
court in London. Now what is really interesting is an ambassador's report from the London court
on Holbein's return, which says that Henry was immediately delighted with what Holbein had
brought back. Now I think that couldn't possibly have been a full-length painted portrait, there
just wouldn't have been time. I think he must have seen some really beautiful drawings. And he was so
overjoyed by what he saw that we're told he set musicians to play all day long. So there was a
tremendous celebration. But of course this could not last because the marriage plans fell through,
Christina did escape with her head, and the next year Henry went on to marry Anne of Cleves,
and we know that didn't work out too well either. But I will say that I don't think that that was
because Holbein misled Henry. If you look into what may have gone wrong, it was more to do with
the clothing that Anne wore, the languages or lack of languages. There were many things about her
that Henry didn't like. Holbein kept his head, it was Thomas Cromwell who lost his over
that marriage. Now Christina went on to have quite a long life. She lived until 1590 and she did
actually marry again. She married the Duke of Lorraine, but unfortunately for her that marriage
didn't last long at all. The second husband died very shortly afterwards, so she was plunged into
mourning again. And although there were plans for her to marry a third time, and in fact she even
came over to England again to pursue those plans, though it wasn't to an Englishman, they fell
through and she spent the rest of her life living quietly in Europe, away from the hurly-burly of
the English court. Now what happened to this painting then I think is very, very interesting.
So Henry was thrilled with whatever Holbein brought back for him, probably drawings.
But he was, we think, particularly pleased with this portrait because he kept it. He kept it in
his collection and that's unusual. There don't seem to be other paintings by Holbein that he
kept, but this one can be identified. And I think that some of the reasons why he was so
entranced and beguiled by this portrait, we can see here just looking at it, Holbein has so
cleverly, I think, given the impression that she's just slightly moving and moving towards us.
And he does it so subtly by the way in which he situates her in space. You can see there's a
shadow on the right-hand side. Is there a doorway somewhere there? We don't know. Holbein often uses
this very ambivalent blue background. Sometimes it suggests the sky rather than the kind of
panelled rooms that you would surely have found indoors in palaces. And then on the other side
you can see her shadow reflected against the wall. So you get a very clear sense of how he
situated her in space. But although, as I've said, it was really important to show her full face so
Henry got a very good view of what she looked like, Holbein has just very, very slightly set
her at an angle to the left. So I think she seems to move, it's suggested, on the diagonal from that
corner of the room, perhaps coming through a doorway over this way where she casts a shadow
on the ground. So to my mind it seems as though she's just about to glide through space towards
us. And I think that's a very beguiling and seductive way of presenting the 16-year-old
widow. So Henry kept this portrait. He hung onto it and it was in his inventories of his possessions
after his death. And then it seems it was really fought over by some quite eminent people in 16th
century England. At one time it was owned by the Earl of Pembroke, then by Lord Lumley who had a
famous collection of paintings including many works by Holbein. Then in the 17th century it
passed into the collection of the Earl of Arundel who confessed his weakness for works by Holbein.
Then it descended in his family for several centuries before ending up in the collection
of the Dukes of Norfolk. And it came on loan to the National Gallery in 1880. It was on loan here
for 28 years and in fact it came as a tremendous shock to many people when in 1908 the Duke of
Norfolk first proposed he was going to sell this painting. Most people assumed the National Gallery
owned it but we didn't. Now the Duke of Norfolk I think sometimes gets a little bit of a bad press
about his motives for selling this painting. There were a lot of aristocratic owners of pictures at
this period, the end of the 19th century, beginning of the 20th century, who were starting to sell off
their paintings and there were some very wealthy collectors in America, particularly at this time,
who were only too pleased to acquire them. Legislation had been passed which made it easier
for aristocrats' assets to be released and many people took advantage of this. Now when the Duke
of Norfolk came to talk to the director of the National Gallery, Charles Holroyd, in 1908,
what he said was that he felt that by selling this painting he could do a great deal of good
with the money. He wasn't after the money for himself but for his own charitable enterprises,
so I think it's worth just noting that. And he gave the Gallery notice that he wanted to sell
the painting. Well, fast forward a year and he told the Gallery that he was selling the painting
in April 1909, that he had a buyer for the painting, that he was selling it to the dealers
for £60,000 and the Gallery had only a couple of weeks to try to match that sum of money,
so ensuing panic. How was the Gallery going to find what was an enormous sum of money to buy this
beautiful painting by Holbein? They didn't quite know. At that time you could call on the government
to give you a grant for the purchase of paintings. I mean I think today our equivalent is the very
generous Heritage Lottery Fund, but we were lucky that the National Art Collections Fund
had been set up six years earlier and they were extremely keen to try to help to raise money.
So there was a public campaign and there was a kind of controversy about acquiring this picture
in the press that we're perhaps familiar with today. Why should we bother to acquire a painting
by a foreign artist? Why should we bother to acquire a painting of a duchess? One newspaper
said we have plenty of English duchesses of our own to look at, we don't need to look at this
one as well. So it was a very public controversy and a public campaign and things moved on very,
very quickly because while money was still being raised, news came in that the painting had been
sold again and the price had gone up. It was now over £70,000 and a deal had been done
so that the painting was going to end up in America and the buyer was going to be the famous
Henry Clay Frick. If you've been to the Frick Collection you'll see his two wonderful Holbeins,
Thomas More and Thomas Cromwell, facing each other across the fireplace and he aimed to add this
painting to them. So everybody was really up against this final deadline and the art fund,
as they're now called, were in there with their public campaign receiving very generous donations
but they were up against a weekend deadline. Now what actually slightly worked in everyone's favour
over here was that there was a bank holiday and they didn't actually realise on the other side
of the Atlantic that there was a bank holiday which just gave us a little bit more time and it
was felt publicly by many people that this painting must be seized from the Americans and there's a
wonderful cartoon in which Uncle Sam is shown dragging Christina out of the frame of this
picture. Henry James wrote a play called The Outcry because there was an outcry about this.
Now at the very, very last minute what happened to save this painting was that an anonymous woman
stepped in and gave £40,000 to contribute to the total that the gallery needed to save this picture.
It was said to be a very large portion of her personal fortune but we do not know to this day
who she was. Her identity has been kept completely secret because she gave the money
on condition that nobody would ever know who she was. Now even today with freedom of information
people have challenged this and asked who was she but we and the art fund have kept absolutely
silent. I don't know her identity. There's been a lot of speculation. It's interesting I think that
she was apparently a woman. She was on holiday at a spa in Germany when she decided to offer
the money but many people who were keen on what later became the cause of women's suffrage
were very enthusiastic about saving this painting so possibly it was a woman who was allied to those
interests. I don't think we shall ever know but we just have to heave a huge sigh of relief and say
a very big thank you to the anonymous benefactor who ensured that we can see this painting today
in the National Gallery. Thank you.
